ThusI,forone,regretthatifyouaregoingtohaveanaristocracyitdidnotremainalogicalonefoundedonthescienceofheraldry;athingassertinganddefendingthequitedefensibletheorythatphysicalgenealogyisthetest;insteadofbeing,asitisnow,ameremachineofEtonandOxfordforvarnishinganybodyrichenoughwithonemonotonousvarnish。
Anditissupremelysointhecaseofreligion。Aslongasyouhaveacreed,whicheveryoneinacertaingroupbelievesorissupposedtobelieve,thenthatgroupwillconsistoftheoldrecurringfiguresofreligioushistory,whocanbeappealedtobythecreedandjudgedbyit;
thesaint,thehypocrite,thebrawler,theweakbrother。Thesepeopledoeachothergood;ortheyalljointogethertodothehypocritegood,withheavyandrepeatedblows。Butoncebreakthebondofdoctrinewhichaloneholdsthesepeopletogetherandeachwillgravitatetohisownkindoutsidethegroup。Thehypocriteswillallgettogetherandcalleachothersaints;thesaintswillgetlostinadesertandcallthemselvesweakbrethren;theweakbrethrenwillgetweakerandweakerinageneralatmosphereofimbecility;andthebrawlerwillgoofflookingforsomebodyelsewithwhomtobrawl。
ThishasverylargelyhappenedtomodernEnglishreligion;Ihavebeeninmanychurches,chapels,andhallswhereaconfidentprideinhavinggotbeyondcreedswascoupledwithquiteaparalysedincapacitytogetbeyondcatchwords。Butwhereverthefalsityappearsitcomesfromneglectofthesametruth:thatmenshouldagreeonaprinciple,thattheymaydifferoneverythingelse;thatGodgavemenalawthattheymightturnitintoliberties。
Therewashugelymoresenseintheoldpeoplewhosaidthatawifeandhusbandoughttohavethesamereligionthanthereisinallthecontemporarygushingaboutsistersoulsandkindredspiritsandaurasofidenticalcolour。Asamatteroffact,themorethesexesareinviolentcontrastthelesslikelytheyaretobeinviolentcollision。Themoreincompatibletheirtempersarethebetter。Obviouslyawife'ssoulcannotpossiblybeasistersoul。Itisveryseldomsomuchasafirstcousin。
Thereareveryfewmarriagesofidenticaltasteandtemperament;theyaregenerallyunhappy。Buttohavethesamefundamentaltheory,tothinkthesamethingavirtue,whetheryoupractiseorneglectit,tothinkthesamethingasin,whetheryoupunishorpardonorlaughatit,inthelastextremitytocallthesamethingdutyandthesamethingdisgrace——
thisreallyisnecessarytoatolerablyhappymarriage;anditismuchbetterrepresentedbyacommonreligionthanitisbyaffinitiesandauras。Andwhatappliestothefamilyappliestothenation。Anationwitharootreligionwillbetolerant。Anationwithnoreligionwillbebigoted。Lastly,theworsteffectofallisthis:thatwhenmencometogethertoprofessacreed,theycomecourageously,thoughitistohideincatacombsandcaves。Butwhentheycometogetherinacliquetheycomesneakishly,eschewingallchangeordisagreement,thoughitistodinetoabrassbandinabigLondonhotel。Forbirdsofafeatherflocktogether,butbirdsofthewhitefeathermostofall。
THEFOOL
FormanyyearsIhadsoughthim,andatlastIfoundhiminaclub。I
hadbeentoldthathewaseverywhere;butIhadalmostbeguntothinkthathewasnowhere。Ihadbeenassuredthatthereweremillionsofhim;
butbeforemylatediscoveryIinclinedtothinkthattherewerenoneofhim。AftermylatediscoveryIamsurethatthereisone;andIinclinetothinkthatthereareseveral,say,afewhundreds;butunfortunatelymostofthemoccupyingimportantpositions。WhenIsay"him,"Imeantheentireidiot。
Ihaveneverbeenabletodiscoverthat"stupidpublic"ofwhichsomanyliterarymencomplain。Thepeopleoneactuallymeetsintrainsorattea-
partiesseemtomequitebrightandinteresting;certainlyquiteenoughsotocallforthefullexertionofone'sownwits。AndevenwhenIhaveheardbrilliant"conversationalists"conversingwithotherpeople,theconversationhadmuchmoreequalityandgiveandtakethanthisageofintellectualsnobswilladmit。Ihavesometimesfelttired,likeotherpeople;butrathertiredwithmen'stalkandvarietythanwiththeirstolidityorsameness;thereforeitwasthatIsometimeslongedtofindtherefreshmentofasinglefool。
Butitwasdeniedme。TurnwhereIwouldIfoundthismonotonousbrilliancyofthegeneralintelligence,thisruthless,ceaselesssparkleofhumourandgoodsense。The"mostlyfools"theoryhasbeenusedinananti-democraticsense;butwhenIfoundatlastmypricelessass,Ididnotfindhiminwhatiscommonlycalledthedemocracy;norinthearistocracyeither。Themanofthedemocracygenerallytalksquiterationally,sometimesontheanti-democraticside,butalwayswithanideaofgivingreasonsforwhathesaysandreferringtotherealitiesofhisexperience。Norisitthearistocracythatisstupid;atleast,notthatsectionofthearistocracywhichrepresentsitinpolitics。Theyareoftencynical,especiallyaboutmoney,buteventheirboredomtendstomakethemalittleeagerforanyrealinformationororiginality。IfamanlikeMr。WinstonChurchillorMr。WyndhammadeuphismindforanyreasontoattackSyndicalismhewouldfindoutwhatitwasfirst。
NotsothemanIfoundintheclub。
Hewasverywelldressed;hehadaheavybuthandsomeface;hisblackclothessuggestedtheCityandhisgraymoustachestheArmy;butthewholesuggestedthathedidnotreallybelongtoeither,butwasoneofthosewhodabbleinsharesandwhoplayatsoldiers。Therewassomethirdelementabouthimthatwasneithermercantilenormilitary。Hismannerswereashadetoogentlemanlytobequitethoseofagentleman。
Theyinvolvedanunctionandover-emphasisoftheclub-man:thenI
suddenlyrememberedfeelingthesamethinginsomeoldactorsoroldplaygoerswhohadmodelledthemselvesonactors。AsIcameinhesaid,"IfIwastheGovernment,"andthenputacigarinhismouthwhichhelitcarefullywithlongintakesofbreath。Thenhetookthecigaroutofhismouthagainandsaid,"I'dgiveit'em,"asifitwerequiteaseparatesentence。Butevenwhilehismouthwasstoppedwiththecigarhiscompanionorinterlocutorleapedtohisfeetandsaidwithgreatheartiness,snatchingupahat,"Well,Imustbeoff。Tuesday!"。I
dislikethesedarksuspicions,butIcertainlyfanciedIrecognisedthesuddengenialitywithwhichonetakesleaveofabore。
When,therefore,heremovedthenarcoticstopperfromhismouthitwastomethatheaddressedthebelatedepigram。"I'dgiveit'em。”
"Whatwouldyougivethem,"Iasked,"theminimumwage?"
"I'dgivethembeans,"hesaid。"I'dshoot'emdownshoot'emdown,everymanJackofthem。Ilostmybesttrainyesterday,andhere'sthewholecountryparalysed,andhere'sahandfulofobstinatefellowsstandingbetweenthecountryandcoal。I'dshoot'emdown!"
"Thatwouldsurelybealittleharsh,"Ipleaded。"Afterall,theyarenotundermartiallaw,thoughIsupposetwoorthreeofthemhavecommissionsintheYeomanry。”
"CommissionsintheYeomanry!"herepeated,andhiseyesandface,whichbecamestartlingandseparate,likethoseofaboiledlobster,mademefeelsurethathehadsomethingofthekindhimself。
"Besides,"Icontinued,"wouldn'titbequiteenoughtoconfiscatetheirmoney?"
"Well,I'dsendthemalltopenalservitude,anyhow,"hesaid,"andI'dconfiscatetheirfundsaswell。”
"Thepolicyisdaringandfullofdifficulty,"Ireplied,"butIdonotsaythatitiswhollyoutsidetheextremerightsoftherepublic。Butyoumustrememberthatthoughthefactsofpropertyhavebecomequitefantastic,yetthesentimentofpropertystillexists。Thesecoal-owners,thoughtheyhavenotearnedthemines,thoughtheycouldnotworkthemines,doquitehonestlyfeelthattheyownthemines。Henceyoursuggestionofshootingthemdown,orevenofconfiscatingtheirproperty,raisesvery——"
"Whatdoyoumean?"askedthemanwiththecigar,withabullyingeye。
"Whoyertalkingabout?"
"I'mtalkingaboutwhatyouweretalkingabout,"Ireplied;"asyouputitsoperfectly,aboutthehandfulofobstinatefellowswhoarestandingbetweenthecountryandthecoal。Imeanthemenwhoaresellingtheirowncoalforfancyprices,andwho,aslongastheycangetthoseprices,careaslittlefornationalstarvationasmostmerchantprincesandpirateshaveearedfortheprovincesthatwerewastedorthepeoplesthatwereenslavedjustbeforetheirshipscamehome。ButthoughIamabitofarevolutionistmyself,Icannotquitegowithyouintheextremeviolenceyousuggest。Yousay——"
"Isay,"hecried,burstingthroughmyspeechwithareallysplendidenergylikethatofsomenoblebeast,"IsayI'dtakealltheseblastedminersand——"
Ihadrisenslowlytomyfeet,forIwasprofoundlymoved;andIstoodstaringatthatmentalmonster。
"Oh,"Isaid,"soitistheminerswhoarealltobesenttopenalservitude,sothatwemaygetmorecoal。Itistheminerswhoaretobeshotdead,everymanJackofthem;forifoncetheyareallshotdeadtheywillstartminingagain……Youmustforgiveme,sir;IknowIseemsomewhatmoved……Thefactis,Ihavejustfoundsomething。somethingI
havebeenlookingforforyears。”
"Well,"heasked,withnounfriendlystare,"andwhathaveyoufound?"
"No,"Ianswered,shakingmyheadsadly,"IdonotthinkitwouldbequitekindtotellyouwhatIhavefound。”
Hehadahundredvirtues,includingthecapitalvirtueofgoodhumour,andwehadnodifficultyinchangingthesubjectandforgettingthedisagreement。Hetalkedaboutsociety,histownfriendsandhiscountrysports,andIdiscoveredinthecourseofitthathewasacountymagistrate,aMemberofParliament,andadirectorofseveralimportantcompanies。Hewasalsothatotherthing,whichIdidnottellhim。
Themoralisthatacertainsortofpersondoesexist,towhoseglorythisarticleisdedicated。Heisnottheordinaryman。Heisnottheminer,whoissharpenoughtoaskforthenecessitiesofexistence。Heisnotthemine-owner,whoissharpenoughtogetagreatdealmore,bysellinghiscoalatthebestpossiblemoment。Heisnotthearistocraticpolitician,whohasacynicalbutafairsympathywithbotheconomicopportunities。Butheisthemanwhoappearsinscoresofpublicplacesopentotheuppermiddleclassorthatlessknownbutmorepowerfulsectionthelowerupperclass。Menlikethisalloverthecountryarereallysayingwhatevercomesintotheirheadsintheircapacitiesofjusticeofthepeace,candidateforParliament,ColoneloftheYeomanry,oldfamilydoctor,PoorLawguardian,coroner,oraboveall,arbiterintradedisputes。Hesuffers,intheliteralsense,fromsofteningofthebrain;hehassofteneditbyalwaystakingtheviewofeverythingmostcomfortableforhiscountry,hisclass,andhisprivatepersonality。Heisadeadlypublicdanger。ButasIhavegivenhimhisnameatthebeginningofthisarticlethereisnoneedformetorepeatitattheend。
THECONSCRIPTANDTHECRISIS
Veryfewofuseverseethehistoryofourowntimehappening。AndI
thinkthebestserviceamodernjournalistcandotosocietyistorecordasplainlyaseverhecanexactlywhatimpressionwasproducedonhismindbyanythinghehasactuallyseenandheardontheoutskirtsofanymodernproblemorcampaign。ThoughallhesawofarailwaystrikewasaflatmeadowinEssexinwhichatrainwasbecalmedforanhourortwo,hewillprobablythrowmorelightonthestrikebydescribingthiswhichhehasseenthanbydescribingthesteelykingsofcommerceandthebloodyleadersofthemobwhomhehasneverseen——noranyoneelseeither。IfhecomesadaytoolateforthebattleofWaterlooashappenedtoafriendofmygrandfatherheshouldstillrememberthatatrueaccountofthedayafterWaterloowouldbeamostvaluablethingtohave。ThoughhewasonthewrongsideofthedoorwhenRizziowasbeingmurdered,weshouldstillliketohavethewrongsidedescribedintherightway。
UponthisprincipleI,whoknownothingofdiplomacyormilitaryarrangements,andhaveonlyheldmybreathliketherestoftheworldwhileFranceandGermanywerebargaining,willtellquitetruthfullyofasmallsceneIsaw,oneofthethousandscenesthatwere,sotospeak,theanteroomsofthatinmostchamberofdebate。
InthecourseofacertainmorningIcameintooneofthequietsquaresofasmallFrenchtownandfounditscathedral。ItwasoneofthosegrayandrainydayswhichrathersuittheGothic。Thecloudswereleaden,likethesolidblue-grayleadofthespiresandthejewelledwindows;theslopingroofsandhigh-shoulderedarcheslookedlikecloaksdroopingwithdamp;andthestiffgargoylesthatstoodoutroundthewallswerescouredwitholdrainsandnew。Iwentintotheround,deepporchwithmanydoorsandfoundtwogrubbychildrenplayingthereoutoftherain。I
alsofoundanoticeofservices,etc。,andamongtheseIfoundtheannouncementthatat11。30thatisabouthalfanhourlatertherewouldbeaspecialservicefortheConscripts,thatistosay,thedraftofyoungmenwhowerebeingtakenfromtheirhomesinthatlittletownandsenttoserveintheFrenchArmy;sentasithappenedatanawfulmoment,whentheFrenchArmywasencampedatapartingoftheways。TherewerealreadyagreatmanypeopletherewhenIentered,notonlyofallkinds,butinallattitudes,kneeling,sitting,orstandingabout。AndtherewasthatgeneralsensethatstrikeseverymanfromaProtestantcountry,whetherhedislikestheCatholicatmosphereorlikesit;Imean,thegeneralsensethatthethingwas"goingonallthetime";thatitwasnotanoccasion,butaperpetualprocess,asifitwereasortofmysticalinn。
Severaltricolourswerehungquiteneartothealtar,andtheyoungmen,whentheycamein,filedupthechurchandsatrightatthefront。Theywere,ofcourse,ofeveryimaginablesocialgrade;fortheFrenchconscriptionisreallystrictanduniversal。Somelookedlikeyoungcriminals,somelikeyoungpriests,somelikeboth。Someweresoobviouslyprosperousandpolishedthatabarrack-roommustseemtothemlikehell;othersbythelookofthemhadhardlyeverbeeninsodecentaplace。ButitwasnotsomuchthemereclassvarietythatmostsharplycaughtanEnglishman'seye。Itwasthepresenceofjustthoseoneortwokindsofmenwhowouldneverhavebecomesoldiersinanyotherway。
Therearemanyreasonsforbecomingasoldier。Itmaybeamatterofhereditaryluckorabjecthungerorheroicvirtueorfugitivevice;itmaybeaninterestintheworkoralackofinterestinanyotherwork。
Buttherewouldalwaysbetwoorthreekindsofpeoplewhowouldnevertendtosoldiering;allthosekindsofpeoplewerethere。Aladwithredhair,largeears,andverycarefulclothing,somehowconveyedacrossthechurchthathehadalwaystakencareofhishealth,notevenfromthinkingaboutit,butsimplybecausehewastold,andthathewasoneofthosewhopassfromchildhoodtomanhoodwithoutanyshockofbeingaman。
IntherowinfrontofhimtherewasaveryslightandvividlittleJew,ofthesortthatisatailorandaSocialist。Byoneofthoseaccidentsthatmakereallifesounlikeanythingelse,hewastheoneofthecompanywhoseemedespeciallydevout。Behindthesestifforsensitiveboyswererangedtheranksoftheirmothersandfathers,withknotsandbunchesoftheirlittlebrothersandsisters。
Thechildrenkickedtheirlittlelegs,wriggledabouttheseats,andgapedatthearchedroofwhiletheirmotherswereontheirkneesprayingtheirownprayers,andhereandtherecrying。Thegraycloudsofrainoutsidegathered,Isuppose,moreandmore;forthedeepchurchcontinuouslydarkened。Theladsinfrontbegantosingamilitaryhymninodd,ratherstrainedvoices;Icouldnotdisentanglethewords,butonlyoneperpetualrefrain;sothatitsoundedlikeSacrarterumbrrarpourlapatrie,Valdarkararumppourlapatrie。
Thenthisceased;andsilencecontinued,thecolouredwindowsgrowinggloomierandgloomierwiththeclouds。Inthedeadstillnessachildstartedcryingsuddenlyandincoherently。InacityfartothenorthaFrenchdiplomatistandaGermanaristocratweretalking。
Iwillnotmakeanycommentaryonthethingthatcouldblurtheoutlineofitsalmostcruelactuality。Iwillnottalknorallowanyoneelsetotalkabout"clericalism"and"militarism。”Thosewhotalklikethataremadeofthesamemudasthosewhocallalltheangersoftheunfortunate"Socialism。”ThewomenwhowerecallinginthegloomaroundmeonGodandtheMotherofGodwerenot"clericalists";or,iftheywere,theyhadforgottenit。AndIwillbetmybootstheyoungmenwerenot"militarists"——quitetheotherwayjustthen。Thepriestmadeashortspeech;hedidnotutteranypriestlydogmaswhatevertheyare,heutteredplatitudes。Insuchcircumstancesplatitudesaretheonlypossiblethingstosay;becausetheyaretrue。Hebeganbysayingthathesupposedalargenumberofthemwouldbeuncommonlygladnottogo。
Theyseemedtoassenttothisparticularpriestlydogmawithevenmorethantheirallegedsuperstitiouscredulity。Hesaidthatwarwashateful,andthatweallhatedit;butthat"inallthingsreasonable"thelawofone'sowncommonwealthwasthevoiceofGod。HespokeaboutJoanofArc;
andhowshehadmanagedtobeaboldandsuccessfulsoldierwhilestillpreservinghervirtueandpractisingherreligion;thenhegavethemeachalittlepaperbook。Towhichtheyrepliedafterabriefintervalforreflection:
Pongprongperesklangpourlapatrie,Tambraugtararroncpourlapatrie。
whichIfeelsurewasthebestandmostpointedreply。
Whileallthiswashappeningfeelingsquiteindescribablecrowdedaboutmyowndarkeningbrain,asthecloudscrowdedabovethedarkeningchurch。
TheyweresoentirelyoftheelementsandthepassionsthatIcannotuttertheminanidea,butonlyinanimage。Itseemedtomethatwewerebarricadedinthischurch,butwecouldnottellwhatwashappeningoutsidethechurch。Themonstrousandterriblejewelsofthewindowsdarkenedorglistenedundermovingshadoworlight,butthenatureofthatlightandtheshapesofthoseshadowswedidnotknowandhardlydaredtoguess。Thedreambegan,Ithink,withadimfancythatenemieswerealreadyinthetown,andthattheenormousoakendoorsweregroaningundertheirhammers。ThenIseemedtosupposethatthetownitselfhadbeendestroyedbyfire,andeffaced,asitmaybethousandsofyearshence,andthatifIopenedthedoorIshouldcomeoutonawildernessasflatandsterileasthesea。Thenthevisionbehindtheveilofstoneandslategrewwilderwithearthquakes。Iseemedtoseechasmscloventothefoundationsofallthings,andlettingupaninfernaldawn。Hugethingshappilyhiddenfromushadclimbedoutoftheabyss,andwerestridingabouttallerthantheclouds。AndwhenthedarknesscreptfromthesapphiresofMarytothesanguinegarmentsofSt。JohnIfanciedthatsomehideousgiantwaswalkingroundthechurchandlookinginateachwindowinturn。
Sometimes,again,Ithoughtofthatchurchwithcolouredwindowsasashipcarryingmanylanternsstrugglinginahighseaatnight。SometimesIthoughtofitasagreatcolouredlanternitself,hungonanironchainoutofheavenandtossedandswungtoandfrobystrongwings,thewingsoftheprincesoftheair。ButIneverthoughtofitortheyoungmeninsideitsaveassomethingpreciousandinperil,orofthethingsoutsidebutassomethingbarbaricandenormous。
Iknowtherearesomewhocannotsympathisewithsuchsentimentsoflimitation;Iknowtherearesomewhowouldfeelnotouchoftheheroictendernessifsomedayayoungman,withredhair,largeears,andhismother'slozengesinhispocket,werefounddeadinuniforminthepassesoftheVosges。ButonthissubjectIhaveheardmanyphilosophiesandthoughtagooddealformyself;andtheconclusionIhavecometoisSacrarterumbrrarpourlaPattie,anditisnotlikelythatIshallalteritnow。
ButwhenIcameoutofthechurchtherewerenoneofthesethings,butonlyalotofShops,includingapaper-shop,onwhichthepostersannouncedthatthenegotiationswereproceedingsatisfactorily。
THEMISERANDHISFRIENDS
Itisasignofsharpsicknessinasocietywhenitisactuallyledbysomespecialsortoflunatic。Amildtouchofmadnessmayevenkeepamansane;foritmaykeephimmodest。SosomeexaggerationsintheStatemayreminditofitsownnormal。Butitisbadwhentheheadiscracked;
whentheroofofthecommonwealthhasatileloose。
Thetwoorthreecasesofthisthatoccurinhistoryhavealwaysbeengibbetedgigantically。ThusNerohasbecomeablackproverb,notmerelybecausehewasanoppressor,butbecausehewasalsoanaesthete——thatis,anerotomaniac。Henotonlytorturedotherpeople'sbodies;hetorturedhisownsoulintothesameredrevoltingshapes。ThoughhecamequiteearlyinRomanImperialhistoryandwasfollowedbymanyaustereandnobleemperors,yetforustheRomanEmpirewasneverquitecleansedofthatmemoryofthesexualmadman。Thepopulaceorbarbariansfromwhomwecomecouldnotforgetthehourwhentheycametothehighestplaceoftheearth,sawthehugepedestaloftheearthlyomnipotence,readonitDivusCaesar,andlookedupandsawastatuewithoutahead。
ItisthesamewiththatuglyentanglementbeforetheRenaissance,fromwhich,alas,mostmemoriesoftheMiddleAgesarederived。LouisXIwasaverypatientandpracticalmanoftheworld;butlikemanygoodbusinessmenhewasmad。Themorbidityoftheintriguerandthetorturerclungabouteverythinghedid,evenwhenitwasright。AndjustasthegreatEmpireofAntoninusandAureliusneverwipedoutNero,soeventhesilversplendourofthelattersaints,suchasVincentdePaul,hasneverpaintedoutfortheBritishpublicthecrookedshadowofLouisXI。Whenevertheunhealthymanhasbeenontop,hehasleftahorriblesavourthathumanityfindsstillinitsnostrils。Nowinourtimetheunhealthymanisontop;butheisnotthemanmadonsex,likeNero;ormadonstatecraft,likeLouisXI;heissimplythemanmadonmoney。Ourtyrantisnotthesatyrorthetorturer;butthemiser。
Themodernmiserhaschangedmuchfromthemiseroflegendandanecdote;
butonlybecausehehasgrownyetmoreinsane。Theoldmiserhadsometouchofthehumanartistabouthiminsofarthathecollectedgold——asubstancethatcanreallybeadmiredforitself,likeivoryoroldoak。
Anoldmanwhopickedupyellowpieceshadsomethingofthesimpleardour,somethingofthemysticalmaterialism,ofachildwhopicksoutyellowflowers。Goldisbutonekindofcolouredclay,butcolouredclaycanbeverybeautiful。Themodernidolaterofrichesiscontentwithfarlessgenuinethings。Theglitterofguineasisliketheglitterofbuttercups,thechinkofpelfislikethechimeofbells,comparedwiththedrearypapersanddeadcalculationswhichmakethehobbyofthemodernmiser。
Themodernmillionairelovesnothingsolovableasacoin。Heiscontentsometimeswiththedeadcrackleofnotes;butfarmoreoftenwiththemererepetitionofnoughtsinaledger,allaslikeeachotheraseggstoeggs。Andasforcomfort,theoldmisercouldbecomfortable,asmanytrampsandsavagesare,whenhewasonceusedtobeingunclean。Amancouldfindsomecomfortinanunsweptatticoranunwashedshirt。ButtheYankeemillionairecanfindnocomfortwithfivetelephonesathisbed-headandtenminutesforhislunch。Theroundcoinsinthemiser'sstockingweresafeinsomesense。Theroundnoughtsinthemillionaire'sledgeraresafeinnosense;thesamefluctuationwhichexciteshimwiththeirincreasedepresseshimwiththeirdiminution。Themiseratleastcollectscoins;hishobbyisnumismatics。Themanwhocollectsnoughtscollectsnothings。
Itmaybeadmittedthatthemanamassingmillionsisabitofanidiot;
butitmaybeaskedinwhatsensedoesherulethemodernworld。Theanswertothisisveryimportantandrathercurious。Theevilenigmaforushereisnottherich,buttheVeryRich。Thedistinctionisimportant;
becausethisspecialproblemisseparatefromtheoldgeneralquarrelaboutrichandpoorthatrunsthroughtheBibleandallstrongbooks,oldandnew。Thespecialproblemto-dayisthatcertainpowersandprivilegeshavegrownsoworld-wideandunwieldythattheyareoutofthepowerofthemoderatelyrichaswellasofthemoderatelypoor。Theyareoutofthepowerofeverybodyexceptafewmillionaires——thatis,misers。
IntheoldnormalfrictionofnormalwealthandpovertyIammyselfontheRadicalside。IthinkthataBerkshiresquirehastoomuchpoweroverhistenants;thataBromptonbuilderhastoomuchpoweroverhisworkmen;thataWestLondondoctorhastoomuchpoweroverthepoorpatientsintheWestLondonHospital。