Grundymustallowhimlicence。Wherehisownpurseandcreditarenotthreatened,hewilldothehonoursofhisvillagegenerously。
Anyartistismadewelcome,throughwhatevermediumhemayseekexpression;scienceisrespected;eventheidler,ifheprove,ashesorarelydoes,agentleman,willsoonbegintofindhimselfathome。Andwhenthatessentiallymoderncreature,theEnglishorAmericangirl-student,begantowalkcalmlyintohisfavouriteinnsasifintoadrawing-roomathome,theFrenchpainterownedhimselfdefenceless;hesubmittedorhefled。HisFrenchrespectability,quiteaspreciseasours,thoughcoveringdifferentprovincesoflife,recoiledaghastbeforetheinnovation。Butthegirlswerepainters;therewasnothingtobedone;andBarbizon,whenIlastsawitandforthetimeatleast,waspracticallycededtothefairinvader。Paterfamilias,ontheotherhand,thecommontourist,theholidayshopman,andthecheapyounggentlemanuponthespree,hehoundedfromhisvillageswitheverycircumstanceofcontumely。
Thispurelyartisticsocietyisexcellentfortheyoungartist。
Theladsaremostlyfools;theyholdthelatestorthodoxyinitscrudeness;theyareatthatstageofeducation,forthemostpart,whenamanistoomuchoccupiedwithstyletobeawareofthenecessityforanymatter;andthis,aboveallfortheEnglishman,isexcellent。Toworkgrosslyatthetrade,toforgetsentiment,tothinkofhismaterialandnothingelse,is,forawhileatleast,theking'shighwayofprogress。Here,inEngland,toomanypaintersandwritersdwelldispersed,unshielded,amongtheintelligentbourgeois。These,whentheyarenotmerelyindifferent,pratetohimabouttheloftyaimsandmoralinfluenceofart。Andthisisthelad'sruin。Forartis,firstofallandlastofall,atrade。Theloveofwordsandnotadesiretopublishnewdiscoveries,theloveofformandnotanovelreadingofhistoricalevents,markthevocationofthewriterandthepainter。Thearabesque,properlyspeaking,andeveninliterature,isthefirstfancyoftheartist;hefirstplayswithhismaterialasachildplayswithakaleidoscope;andheisalreadyinasecondstagewhenhebeginstousehisprettycountersfortheendofrepresentation。Inthat,hemustpauselongandtoilfaithfully;
thatishisapprenticeship;anditisonlythefewwhowillreallygrowbeyondit,andgoforward,fullyequipped,todothebusinessofrealart-togivelifetoabstractionsandsignificanceandcharmtofacts。Inthemeanwhile,lethimdwellmuchamonghisfellow-craftsmen。Theyalonecantakeaseriousinterestinthechildishtasksandpitifulsuccessesoftheseyears。Theyalonecanbeholdwithequanimitythisfingeringofthedumbkeyboard,thispolishingofemptysentences,thisdullandliteralpaintingofdullandinsignificantsubjects。Outsiderswillspurhimon。
Theywillsay,"Whydoyounotwriteagreatbook?paintagreatpicture?"Ifhisguardianangelfailhim,theymayevenpersuadehimtotheattempt,and,tentoone,hishandiscoarsenedandhisstylefalsifiedforlife。
Andthisbringsmetoawarning。Thelifeoftheapprenticetoanyartisbothunstrainedandpleasing;itisstrewnwithsmallsuccessesinthemidstofacareeroffailure,patientlysupported;
theheaviestscholarisconsciousofacertainprogress;andifhecomenotappreciablynearertotheartofShakespeare,growsletter-perfectinthedomainofA-B,ab。Butthetimecomeswhenamanshouldceaseprelusorygymnastic,standup,putaviolenceuponhiswill,and,forbetterorworse,beginthebusinessofcreation。
Thisevildaythereisatendencycontinuallytopostpone:aboveallwithpainters。Theyhavemadesomanystudiesthatithasbecomeahabit;theymakemore,thewallsofexhibitionsblushwiththem;anddeathfindstheseagedstudentsstillbusywiththeirhorn-book。Thisclassofmanfindsacongenialhomeinartistvillages;intheslangoftheEnglishcolonyatBarbizonweusedtocallthem"Snoozers。"Continualreturnstothecity,thesocietyofmenfartheradvanced,thestudyofgreatworks,asenseofhumouror,ifsuchathingistobehad,alittlereligionorphilosophy,arethemeansoftreatment。Itwillbetimeenoughtothinkofcuringthemaladyafterithasbeencaught;fortocatchitistheverythingforwhichyouseekthatdream-landofthepainters'village。"Snoozing"isapartoftheartisticeducation;
andtherudimentsmustbelearnedstupidly,allelsebeingforgotten,asiftheywereanobjectinthemselves。
Lastly,thereissomething,orthereseemstobesomething,intheveryairofFrancethatcommunicatestheloveofstyle。Precision,clarity,thecleanlyandcraftyemploymentofmaterial,agraceinthehandling,apartfromanyvalueinthethought,seemtobeacquiredbythemereresidence;orifnotacquired,becomeatleastthemoreappreciated。TheairofParisisalivewiththistechnicalinspiration。Andtoleavethatairycityandawakenextdayuponthebordersoftheforestisbuttochangeexternals。Thesamespiritofdexterityandfinishbreathesfromthelongalleysandtheloftygroves,fromthewildernessesthatarestillprettyintheirconfusion,andthegreatplainthatcontrivestobedecorativeinitsemptiness。
II
Inspiteofitsreallyconsiderableextent,theforestofFontainebleauishardlyanywheretedious。Iknowthewholewesternsideofitwithwhat,Isuppose,Imaycallthoroughness;wellenoughatleasttotestifythatthereisnosquaremilewithoutsomespecialcharacterandcharm。Suchquarters,forinstance,astheLongRocher,theBas-Breau,andtheReineBlanche,mightbeahundredmilesapart;theyhavescarceapointincommonbeyondthesilenceofthebirds。Thetwolastarereallyconterminous;andinbotharetallandancienttreesthathaveoutlivedathousandpoliticalvicissitudes。Butintheonethegreatoaksprosperplacidlyuponanevenfloor;theybeshadowagreatfield;andtheairandthelightareveryfreebelowtheirstretchingboughs。Intheotherthetreesfinddifficultfooting;castlesofwhiterocklietumbledoneuponanother,thefootslips,thecrookedviperslumbers,themossclingsinthecrevice;andaboveitallthegreatbeechgoesspiringandcastingforthherarms,and,withagracebeyondchurcharchitecture,canopiesthisruggedchaos。
Meanwhile,dividingthetwocantons,thebroadwhitecausewayoftheParisroadrunsinanavenue:aroadconceivedforpageantryandfortriumphalmarches,anavenueforanarmy;but,itsdaysofgloryover,itnowliesgrillinginthesunbetweencoolgroves,andonlyatintervalsthevehicleofthecruisingtouristisseenfarawayandfaintlyaudiblealongitsamplesweep。Alittleupononeside,andyoufindadistrictofsandandbirchandboulder;alittleupontheotherliesthevalleyofApremont,alljuniperandheather;andclosebeyondthatyoumaywalkintoazoneofpinetrees。Soartfullyaretheingredientsmingled。Normustitbeforgottenthat,inallthispart,youcomecontinuallyforthuponahill-top,andbeholdtheplain,northwardandwestward,likeanunrefulgentsea;northatalldaylongtheshadowskeepchanging;
andatlast,totheredfiresofsunset,nightsucceeds,andwiththenightanewforest,fullofwhisper,gloom,andfragrance。
TherearefewthingsmorerenovatingthantoleaveParis,thelamplitarchesoftheCarrousel,andthelongalignmentoftheglitteringstreets,andtobathethesensesinthisfragrantdarknessofthewood。
Inthiscontinualvarietythemindiskeptvividlyalive。Itisachangefulplacetopaint,astirringplacetolivein。Asfastasyourfootcarriesyou,youpassfromscenetoscene,eachvigorouslypaintedinthecoloursofthesun,eachendearedbythathereditaryspellofforestsonthemindofmanwhostillremembersandsalutestheancientrefugeofhisrace。
Andyettheforesthasbeencivilisedthroughout。Themostsavagecornersbearaname,andhavebeencherishedlikeantiquities;inthemostremote,Naturehaspreparedandbalancedhereffectsasifwithconsciousart;andman,withhisguidingarrowsofbluepaint,hascountersignedthepicture。Afteryourfarthestwandering,youareneversurprisedtocomeforthuponthevastavenueofhighway,tostrikethecentrepointofbranchingalleys,ortofindtheaqueducttrailing,thousand-footed,throughthebrush。Itisnotawilderness;itisratherapreserve。And,fitlyenough,thecentreofthemazeisnotahermit'scavern。Inthemidst,alittlemirthfultownliessunlit,hummingwiththebusinessofpleasure;
andthepalace,breathingdistinctionandpeopledbyhistoricnames,standssmokelessamonggardens。
Perhapsthelastattemptatsavagelifewasthatoftheharmlesshumbugwhocalledhimselfthehermit。Inagreattree,closebythehighroad,hehadbuilthimselfalittlecabinafterthemanneroftheSwissFamilyRobinson;thitherhemountedatnight,bytheromanticaidofaropeladder;andifdirtbeanyproofofsincerity,themanwassavageasaSioux。Ihadthepleasureofhisacquaintance;heappearedgrosslystupid,notinhisperfectwits,andinterestedinnothingbutsmallchange;forthathehadagreatavidity。Inthecourseoftimeheprovedtobeachicken-
stealer,andvanishedfromhisperch;andperhapsfromthefirsthewasnotruevotaryofforestfreedom,butaningenious,theatrically-mindedbeggar,andhiscabininthetreewasonlystock-in-tradetobegwithal。Thechoiceofhispositionwouldseemtoindicatesomuch;forifintheforesttherearenoplacesstilltobediscovered,therearemanythathavebeenforgotten,andthatlieunvisited。There,tobesure,arethebluearrowswaitingtoreconductyou,nowblazeduponatree,nowpostedinthecornerofarock。Butyoursecurityfrominterruptioniscomplete;
youmightcampforweeks,iftherewereonlywater,andnotasoulsuspectyourpresence;andifImaysupposethereadertohavecommittedsomegreatcrimeandcometomeforaid,IthinkIcouldstillfindmywaytoasmallcavern,fittedwithahearthandchimney,wherehemightlieperfectlyconcealed。Aconfederatelandscape-paintermightdailysupplyhimwithfood;forwater,hewouldhavetomakeanightlytrampasfarastothenearestpond;
andatlast,whenthehueandcrybegantoblowover,hemightgetgentlyonthetrainatsomesidestation,workroundbyaseriesofjunctions,andbequietlycapturedatthefrontier。
ThusFontainebleau,althoughitistrulybutapleasure-ground,andalthough,infavourableweather,andinthemorecelebratedquarters,itliterallybuzzeswiththetourist,yethassomeoftheimmunitiesandofferssomeofthereposeofnaturalforests。Andthesolitary,althoughhemustreturnatnighttohisfrequentedinn,mayyetpassthedaywithhisownthoughtsinthecompanionablesilenceofthetrees。Thedemandsoftheimaginationvary;somecanbealoneinabackgardenlookeduponbywindows;
others,liketheostrich,arecontentwithasolitudethatmeetstheeye;andothers,again,expandinfancytotheverybordersoftheirdesert,andareirritablyconsciousofahunter'scampinanadjacentcounty。Totheselast,ofcourse,Fontainebleauwillseembutanextendedtea-garden:aRoshervilleonaby-day。Buttotheplainmanitofferssolitude:anexcellentthinginitself,andagoodwhetforcompany。
III
IwasforsometimeaconsistentBarbizonian;ETEGOINARCADIA
VIXI,itwasapleasantseason;andthatnoiselesshamletlyingcloseamongthebordersofthewoodisforme,asforsomanyothers,agreenspotinmemory。ThegreatMilletwasjustdead,thegreenshuttersofhismodesthousewereclosed;hisdaughterswereinmourning。Thedateofmyfirstvisitwasthusanepochinthehistoryofart:inalesserway,itwasanepochinthehistoryoftheLatinQuarter。ThePETITCENACLEwasdeadandburied;Murgerandhiscrewofspongingvagabondswereallatrestfromtheirexpedients;thetraditionoftheirreallifewasnearlylost;andthepetrifiedlegendoftheVIEDEBOHEMEhadbecomeasortofgospel,andstillgavethecuetozealousimitators。Butifthebookbewritteninrose-water,theimitationwasstillfartherexpurgated;honestywastherule;theinnkeepersgave,asI
havesaid,almostunlimitedcredit;theysufferedtheseediestpaintertodepart,totakeallhisbelongings,andtoleavehisbillunpaid;andiftheysometimeslost,itwasbyEnglishandAmericansalone。Atthesametime,thegreatinfluxofAnglo-
Saxonshadbeguntoaffectthelifeofthestudious。Therehadbeendisputes;and,inoneinstanceatleast,theEnglishandtheAmericanshadmadecommoncausetopreventacruelpleasantry。Itwouldbewellifnationsandracescouldcommunicatetheirqualities;butinpracticewhentheylookuponeachother,theyhaveaneyetonothingbutdefects。TheAnglo-Saxonisessentiallydishonest;theFrenchisdevoidbynatureoftheprinciplethatwecall"FairPlay。"TheFrenchmanmarvelledatthescruplesofhisguest,and,whenthatdefenderofinnocenceretiredover-seasandlefthisbillsunpaid,hemarvelledonceagain;thegoodandevilwere,inhiseyes,partandparcelofthesameeccentricity;ashrugexpressedhisjudgmentuponboth。
AtBarbizontherewasnomaster,nopontiffinthearts。PalizziboreruleatGretz-urbane,superiorrule-hismemoryrichinanecdotesofthegreatmenofyore,hismindfertileintheories;
sceptical,composed,andvenerabletotheeye;andyetbeneaththeseoutworks,alltwitteringwithItaliansuperstition,hiseyescoutingforomens,andthewholefabricofhismannersgivingwayontheappearanceofahunchback。CernayhadPelouse,theadmirable,placidPelouse,smilinglycriticalofyouth,who,whenafull-blowncommercialtraveller,suddenlythrewdownhissamples,boughtacolour-box,andbecamethemasterwhomwehavealladmired。Marlotte,foracentralfigure,boastedOlivierdePenne。
OnlyBarbizon,sincethedeathofMillet,wasaheadlesscommonwealth。Evenitssecondarylights,andthosewhoinmydaymadethestrangerwelcome,havesincedesertedit。ThegoodLachevrehasdeparted,carryinghishouseholdgods;andlongbeforethatGastonLafenestrewastakenfromourmidstbyanuntimelydeath。Hediedbeforehehaddeservedsuccess;itmaybe,hewouldneverhavedeservedit;buthiskind,comely,modestcountenancestillhauntsthememoryofallwhoknewhim。Another-whomIwillnotname-hasmovedfartheron,pursuingthestrangeOdysseyofhisdecadence。Hisdaysofroyalfavourhaddepartedeventhen;
buthestillretained,inhisnarrowerlifeatBarbizon,acertainstampofconsciousimportance,hearty,friendly,fillingtheroom,theoccupantofseveralchairs;norhadheyetceasedhislosingbattle,stilllabouringupongreatcanvasesthatnonewouldbuy,stillwaitingthereturnoffortune。Butthesedaysalsoweretoogoodtolast;andtheformerfavouriteoftwosovereignsfled,ifI
heardthetruth,bynight。Therewasatimewhenhewascountedagreatman,andMilletbutadauber;behold,howthewhirligigoftimebringsinhisrevenges!TopityMilletisapieceofarrogance;iflifebehardforsuchresoluteandpiousspirits,itisharderstillforus,hadwethewittounderstandit;butwemaypityhisunhappierrival,who,fornoapparentmerit,wasraisedtoopulenceandmomentaryfame,and,throughnoapparentfaultwassufferedstepbysteptosinkagaintonothing。Nomisfortunecanexceedthebitternessofsuchback-foremostprogress,evenbravelysupportedasitwas;buttothosealsowhoweretakenearlyfromtheeasel,aregretisdue。Fromalltheyoungmenofthisperiod,onestoodoutbythevigourofhispromise;hewasintheageoffermentation,enamouredofeccentricities。"Ilfautfairedelapeinturenouvelle,"washiswatchword;butiftimeandexperiencehadcontinuedhiseducation,ifhehadbeengrantedhealthtoreturnfromtheseexcursionstothesteadyandthecentral,ImustbelievethatthenameofHillshadbecomefamous。
Siron'sinn,thatexcellentartists'barrack,wasmanageduponeasyprinciples。Atanyhourofthenight,whenyoureturnedfromwanderingintheforest,youwenttothebilliard-roomandhelpedyourselftoliquors,ordescendedtothecellarandreturnedladenwithbeerorwine。TheSironswerealllockedinslumber;therewasnonetocheckyourinroads;onlyattheweek'sendacomputationwasmade,thegrosssumwasdivided,andavaryingsharesetdowntoeverylodger'snameundertherubric:ESTRATS。
Uponthemorelong-sufferingthelargertaxwaslevied;andyourbilllengthenedinadirectproportiontotheeasinessofyourdisposition。Atanyhourofthemorning,again,youcouldgetyourcoffeeorcoldmilk,andsetforthintotheforest。Thedoveshadperhapswakenedyou,flutteringintoyourchamber;andonthethresholdoftheinnyouweremetbythearomaoftheforest。
Closebywerethegreataisles,themossyboulders,theinterminablefieldofforestshadow。Thereyouwerefreetodreamandwander。Andatnoon,andagainatsixo'clock,agoodmealawaitedyouonSiron'stable。Thewholeofyouraccommodation,setasidethatvaryingitemoftheESTRALS,costyoufivefrancsaday;
yourbillwasneverofferedyouuntilyouaskedit;andifyouwereoutofluck'sway,youmightdepartforwhereyoupleasedandleaveitpending。
IV
Theoretically,thehousewasopentoallcorners;practically,itwasakindofclub。Theguestsprotectedthemselves,and,insodoing,theyprotectedSiron。Formalmannersbeinglaidaside,essentialcourtesywasthemorerigidlyexacted;thenewarrivalhadtofeelthepulseofthesociety;andabreachofitsundefinedobservanceswaspromptlypunished。Amanmightbeasplain,asdull,asslovenly,asfreeofspeechashedesired;buttoatouchofpresumptionorawordofhectoringthesefreeBarbizonianswereassensitiveasatea-partyofmaidenladies。IhaveseenpeopledrivenforthfromBarbizon;itwouldbedifficulttosayinwordswhattheyhaddone,buttheydeservedtheirfate。Theyhadshownthemselvesunworthytoenjoythesecorporatefreedoms;theyhadpushedthemselves;theyhad"madetheirhead";theywantedtacttoappreciatethe"fineshades"ofBarbizonianetiquette。Andoncetheywerecondemned,theprocessofextrusionwasruthlessinitscruelty;afteroneeveningwiththeformidableBodmer,theBailyofourcommonwealth,theerringstrangerwasbeheldnomore;heroseexceedingearlythenextday,andthefirstcoachconveyedhimfromthesceneofhisdiscomfiture。Thesesentencesofbanishmentwerenever,inmyknowledge,deliveredagainstanartist;suchwould,I
believe,havebeenillegal;buttheoddandpleasantfactisthis,thattheywereneverneeded。Painters,sculptors,writers,singers,IhaveseenalloftheseinBarbizon;andsomeweresulky,andsomeblatantandinane;butoneandallenteredatonceintothespiritoftheassociation。ThissingularsocietyispurelyFrench,acreatureofFrenchvirtues,andpossiblyofFrenchdefects。ItcannotbeimitatedbytheEnglish。Theroughness,theimpatience,themoreobviousselfishness,andeventhemoreardentfriendshipsoftheAnglo-Saxon,speedilydismembersuchacommonwealth。ButthisrandomgatheringofyoungFrenchpainters,withneitherapparatusnorparadeofgovernment,yetkeptthelifeoftheplaceuponacertainfooting,insensiblyimposedtheiretiquetteuponthedocile,andbycausticspeechenforcedtheiredictsagainsttheunwelcome。Tothinkofitistowonderthemoreatthestrangefailureoftheirraceuponthelargertheatre。Thisinbredcivility-tousethewordinitscompletestmeaning-thisnaturalandfacileadjustmentofcontendingliberties,seemsallthatisrequiredtomakeagovernablenationandajustandprosperouscountry。
Oursociety,thuspurgedandguarded,wasfullofhighspirits,oflaughter,andoftheinitiativeofyouth。Thefeweldermenwhojoineduswerestillyoungatheart,andtookthekeyfromtheircompanions。Wereturnedfromlongstationsinthefortifyingair,ourbloodrenewedbythesunshine,ourspiritsrefreshedbythesilenceoftheforest;theBabelofloudvoicessoundedgood;wefelltoeatandplaylikethenaturalman;andinthehighinnchamber,panelledwithindifferentpicturesandlitbycandlesgutteringinthenightair,thetalkandlaughtersoundedfarintothenight。Itwasagoodplaceandagoodlifeforanynaturally-
mindedyouth;betteryetforthestudentofpainting,andperhapsbestofallforthestudentofletters。He,too,wassaturatedinthisatmosphereofstyle;hewasshutoutfromthedisturbingcurrentsoftheworld,hemightforgetthatthereexistedotherandmorepressingintereststhanthatofart。But,insuchaplace,itwashardlypossibletowrite;hecouldnotdrughisconscience,likethepainter,bytheproductionoflistlessstudies;hesawhimselfidleamongmanywhowereapparently,andsomewhowerereally,employed;andwhatwiththeimpulseofincreasinghealthandthecontinualprovocationofromanticscenes,hebecametormentedwiththedesiretowork。Heenjoyedastrenuousidlenessfullofvisions,heartymeals,long,swelteringwalks,mirthamongcompanions;andstillfloatinglikemusicthroughhisbrain,foresightsofgreatworksthatShakespearemightbeproudtohaveconceived,headlessepics,glorioustorsosofdramas,andwordsthatwerealivewithimport。Soinyouth,likeMosesfromthemountain,wehavesightsofthatHouseBeautifulofartwhichweshallneverenter。Theyaredreamsandunsubstantial;visionsofstylethatreposeuponnobaseofhumanmeaning;thelastheart-
throbsofthatexcitedamateurwhohastodieinallofusbeforetheartistcanbeborn。Buttheycometousinsucharainbowofglorythatallsubsequentachievementappearsdullandearthlyincomparison。Wewereallartists;almostallintheageofillusion,cultivatinganimaginarygenius,andwalkingtothestrainsofsomedeceivingAriel;smallwonder,indeed,ifwewerehappy!Butart,ofwhatevernature,isakindmistress;andthoughthesedreamsofyouthfallbytheirownbaselessness,otherssucceed,graverandmoresubstantial;thesymptomschange,theamiablemaladyendures;andstill,atanequaldistance,theHouseBeautifulshinesuponitshill-top。
V
Gretzliesoutoftheforest,downbythebrightriver。Itboastsamill,anancientchurch,acastle,andabridgeofmanysterlings。Andthebridgeisapieceofpublicproperty;
anonymouslyfamous;beamingontheincuriousdilettantefromthewallsofahundredexhibitions。IhaveseenitintheSalon;I