ThefameofAdamSmithrestssodeservedlyonhisgreatwork,theWealthofNations,thatthefactisapttobelostsightof,thatlongbeforehedistinguishedhimselfasapoliticaleconomisthehadgainedareputation,notconfinedtohisowncountry,byhisspeculationsinmoralphilosophy。
TheTheoryofMoralSentimentswasfirstpublishedin1759,whenitsauthorwasthirty-six;theWealthofNationsin1776,whenhewasfifty-three。Thesuccessofthelattersooneclipsedthatofhisfirstwork,butthewidecelebritywhichsoonattendedtheformerisattestedbythefactofthesortofcompetitionthatensuedfortranslatingitintoFrench。Rochefoucauld,grandsonofthefamousauthoroftheMaxims,gotsofarinatranslationofitastheendofthefirstPart,whenacompletetranslationbytheAbbé;Blavetcompelledhimtorenouncethecontinuanceofhiswork。TheAbbé;MorelletsoconspicuousafigureintheFrenchliteratureofthatperiodspeaksofhimselfinhisMemoirsashavingbeenimpressedbyAdamSmith'sTheorywithagreatideaofitsauthor'swisdomanddepthofthought。
Thepublicationofthesetwobooks,theonlywritingspublishedbytheirauthorinhislifetime,arestrictlyspeakingtheonlyepisodeswhichformanythinglikelandmarksinAdamSmith'scareer。Thesixty-sevenyearsofhislife1723-90wereinotherrespectsstrangelydestituteofwhatarecalled"events;"andbeyondtheadventureofhischildhood,whenhewascarriedawaybygipsiesbutsoonrescued,nothingextraordinaryeveroccurredtoruffletheevensurfaceofhisexistence。
If,therefore,thehappinessofanindividual,likethatofanation,maybetakentovaryinverselywiththematerialsaffordedbythemtothebiographerorthehistorian,AdamSmithmaybeconsideredtohaveattainednomeandegreeofhumanfelicity。Fromhisidealoflife,politicalambitionandgreatnesswerealtogetherexcluded;itwashiscreedthathappinesswasequalineverylot,andthatcontentmentalonewasnecessarytoensureit。"What,"heasks,"canbeaddedtothehappinessofthemanwhoisinhealth,whoisoutofdebt,andhasaclearconscience?"
Tothissimplestandard,circumstancesassistedhimtomouldhislife。
Hishealth,delicateinhisearlyyears,becamestrongerwithage;necessitynevercompelledhimtoseekacompetenceinuncongenialpursuits;nordidatranquillifeoflearningevertempthimintopathsatvariancewiththelawsofhismoralbeingorhiscountry。InseveralpassagesofhisMoralSentiments,itwillappearthathetooknopainstoconcealhispreferencefortheoldEpicureantheoryoflife,thatineaseofbodyandpeaceofmindconsistshappiness,thegoalofalldesire。
Butthecharmofsuchaformulaoflifeisperhapsmoreobviousthanitsrenderingintoanactualstateofexistence。Easeofbodydoesnotalwayscomeforthewishing;andpeaceofmindoftenliesstillfurtherfromcommand。Theadvantageoftheformulais,thatitsetsbeforeusadefiniteaim,andaffordsusatanytimeameasureofthehappinessweenjoyorofthatweseearoundus。Judgedbythisstandard,however,theconclusionmustbeanditisaconclusionfromwhichAdamSmithdoesnotshrinkthatthelotofabeggarmaybeequalinpointofhappinesstothatofaking。
TheresultofthisEpicureantheoryoflifeonAdamSmithwas,fortunatelyfortheworld,astrongpreferenceforthelifeoflearningandliteratureovertheprofessionalorpoliticallife。Heabjuredfromthefirstallanxietyfortheprizesheldoutbythevariousprofessionstocandidatesforwealthorreputation。ThoughsenttoBalliolatseventeenasaSnellexhibitioner,forthepurposeoffittinghimselfforserviceintheChurchofEngland,hepreferredsomuchthepeaceofhisownmindtothewishesofhisfriendsandrelations,that,whenheleftOxfordafteraresidenceofsevenyears,hedeclinedtoenterintotheecclesiasticalprofessionatall,andhereturnedtoScotlandwiththesoleandsimplehopeofobtainingthroughliteraturesomepostofmoderateprefermentmoresuitabletohisinclinations。
Fortuneseemstohavefavouredhiminmakingsuchacoursepossible,forafterleavingOxfordhespenttwoyearsathomewithhismotheratKirkaldy。HehadnottoencounterthedifficultieswhichcompelledHumetopractisefrugalityabroad,inordertopreservehisindependence。Hisfather,whohaddiedafewmonthsbeforehisbirth,hadbeenprivatesecretarytothePrincipalSecretaryofStateforScotland,andafterthatComptrolleroftheCustomsatKirkaldy。AdamSmithwas,moreover,anonlychild,andiftherewasnotwealthathome,therewasthecompetencewhichwasallhedesired。
Bythecircumstancesofhisbirth,hiseducation,likethatofDavidHume,devolvedinhisearlyyearsuponhismother,ofwhomonewouldgladlyknowmorethanhasbeenvouchsafedbyherson'sbiographer。Sheissaidtohavebeenblamedforspoilinghim,butitispossiblethatwhatseemedtoherScotchneighboursexcessiveindulgencemeantnoveryexceptionaldegreeofkindness。Atallevents,thetreatmentsucceeded,norhadeveramotheramoredevotedson。Herdeath,whichdidnotlongprecedehisown,closedalifeofunremittedaffectiononbothsides,andwasthefirstandgreatestbereavementthatAdamSmitheverhadtomourn。Thesocietyofhismotherandherniece,MissDouglas,wholivedwiththem,wasallthatheeverknewoffamilylife;andwhenthesmallcirclebrokeup,asitdidatlastspeedilyandwithshortintervalsofsurvivalforthosewhoexperiencedthegriefofthefirstseparation,AdamSmithwaswell-advancedinyears。Hesurvivedhismotheronlysixyears,hiscousinabouttwo;
andhehadpassedsixtywhentheformerdied。
Itissaid,thatafteradisappointmentinearlylife,AdamSmithgaveupallthoughtsofmarriage;butifhethusfailedofthehappiestconditionoflife,itisequallytruethathewassparedthegreatestsorrowsofhumanexistence,andanumberofminortroublesandanxieties。Thedomesticeconomywasentirelyconductedbyhiscousin,andtothephilosopherisattributedwithmorethanusualjusticeallthatincapacityforthecommondetailsoflifewithwhichthepopularconceptionalwaysclothesascholar。
ItissaidthateventhefancyofaLaBruyè;rehasscarcelyimaginedinstancesofamorestrikingabsenceofmindthanmightbeactuallyquotedofhim;2andfromboyhoodupwardshehadthehabitoflaughingandtalkingtohimselfwhichsometimesledcasualobserverstoinferencesnottohiscredit。
DugaldStewart,whosesomewhatmeagrememoironAdamSmithisthechiefauthorityforallthatisknownofhislife,describeshimas"certainlynotfittedforthegeneralcommerceoftheworldorforthebusinessofactivelife。"Thesubjectofhisstudiesrenderedhim"habituallyinattentivetofamiliarobjectsandtocommonoccurrences。"Evenincompany,hewasapttobeengrossedwithhisstudies,andwouldseem,bythemotionofhislipsaswellasbyhislooksandgestures,tobeinallthefervourofcomposition。Inconversation"hewasscarcelyeverknowntostartatopichimself,"andifhedidsucceedinfallinginwiththecommondialogueofconversation,"hewassomewhatapttoconveyhisownideasintheformofalecture。"Notwithstandingthesedefects,wearetoldof"thesplendourofhisconversation,"andoftheinexhaustiblenoveltyandvarietywhichbelongedtoit,byreasonofhisreadyadaptationoffancifultheoriestoallthecommontopicsofdiscourse。
Ofhisearlyyearsoftenthemostinterestingofany,asindicativeoffuturecharactersingularlylittleremainsknown。SomeofthosewhowerethecompanionsofhisfirstschoolyearsatKirkaldy,andwhoremainedhisfriendsforlife,haveattestedthepassionheeventhenhadforbooksand"theextraordinarypowersofhismemory。"
AttheageoffourteenhewassenttotheUniversityofGlasgow,wherehisfavouritestudiesweremathematicsandnaturalsciences,andwhereheattendedthelecturesofDr。Hutcheson,whohasbeencalled"thefatherofspeculativephilosophyinScotlandinmoderntimes,"andwhosetheoryoftheMoralSensehadsomuchinfluenceonAdamSmith'sownlaterethicalspeculations。
Beyondthisreferencetohisstudies,nothingistoldofAdamSmith'sthreeyearsatGlasgow。Hiswholeyouthisinfactablankforhisbiographer。
Wehearofnoprizes,nodistinctions,nofriendships,noadventures,noeccentricitiesofanykind。NorisitmuchbetterwithregardtohiscareeratOxford,towhichhewassentbytheUniversityofGlasgowattheageofseventeen。Onlyoneanecdoteremains,ofverydoubtfultruth,andnotmentionedbyDugaldStewart,totheeffectthatheonceincurredrebukefromthecollegeauthoritiesofBalliolforhavingbeendetectedinhisroomsreadingHume'sTreatiseonHumanNature。Thestoryisworthmentioning,ifonlyasanindicationoftheprevalentideaofAdamSmith'sbentofmindinhisundergraduatedays;andthosewho,inspiteofexperience,stillholdtothetheory,thatatthebottomofeverystorysometruthmustlie,maygatherfromthisone,thatevenatcollegethefuturefriendofthehistorianwasattractedbytheboldscepticismwhichdistinguishedhisphilosophy。
ItwasperhapsbyreasonofthisattractionthatattheendofsevenyearsatOxfordAdamSmithdeclinedtotakeorders。LeavingOxford,whichformostmenmeansanentirechangeoflife,meantforhimsimplyachangeinthesceneofhisstudies;atransferofthemfromoneplacetoanother。
Languages,literature,andhistory,could,hefound,bestudiedaswellatKirkaldyasatthechiefseatoflearninginEngland。ToOxford,sodifferentinmostcollegesnowfromwhatitwasinthosedays,heseemsnevertohaveexpressedorfeltthegratitudewhichthroughlifeattachedhimtoGlasgow;andhisimpressionsoftheEnglishuniversityhavebeenimmortalizedbyhiminnoflatteringtermsinwhathehassaidofitinhisWealthofNations。
Afternearlytwoyearsspentathome,AdamSmithremovedtoEdinburgh,where,underthepatronageofLordKames,sowellknowninconnexionwiththeScotchliteratureofthelastcentury,hedeliveredlecturesonrhetoricandbelleslettres;andthesamesubjectformedthegreaterpartofhislecturesasProfessorofLogicatGlasgow,towhichposthewaselectedin1751,attheageoftwenty-eight。ThenextyearhewaschosenProfessorofMoralPhilosophyatthesameuniversity;andtheperiodofthirteenyears,duringwhichheheldthissituation,heeverregardedasthemostusefulandhappyofhislife。
OfhislecturesatGlasgowonlysomuchhasbeenpreservedashepublishedintheMoralSentimentsandWealthofNationsrespectively。
Hedividedhiscourseintofourparts,thefirstrelatingtoNaturalTheology,thesecondtoEthics,thethirdtothesubjectofJusticeandthegrowthofJurisprudence,thefourthtoPolitics。UnderthelatterheadhedealtwiththepoliticalinstitutionsrelatingtocommerceandallthesubjectswhichenterintohismaturerworkontheNatureandCausesoftheWealthofNations;whilstunderthesecondhead,heexpoundedthedoctrineswhichheafterwardspublishedintheMoralSentiments。OnthesubjectofJustice,itwashisintentiontowriteasystemofnaturaljurisprudence,"oratheoryofthegeneralprincipleswhichoughttorunthroughandbethefoundationofthelawsofallnations。"ItwastohavebeenanimprovementontheworkofGrotiusonthesamesubject,andtheTheoryofMoralSentimentsconcludeswithapromisewhich,unfortunately,wasneverfulfilled。"Ishall,"hesays,"inanotherdiscourse,endeavourtogiveanaccountofthegeneralprinciplesoflawandgovernment,andofthedifferentrevolutionstheyhaveundergoneinthe
differentagesandperiodsofsociety,notonlyinwhatconcernsjustice,butinwhatconcernspolice,revenue,andarms,andwhateverelseistheobjectoflaw。Ishallnot,therefore,atpresent,enterintoanyfurtherdetailsconcerningthehistoryofjurisprudence。3
OneofAdamSmith'sownpupils,andafterwardsforlifeoneofhismostintimatefriends,Dr。Millar,professoroflawatGlasgow,andauthorofanexcellentworkontheOriginofRanks,hasleftagraphicdescriptionofthegreatsuccesswhichattendedtheselecturesatGlasgow。"TherewasnosituationinwhichtheabilitiesofMr。Smithappearedtogreateradvantagethanasaprofessor……hisreputationasaprofessorwasaccordinglyraisedvcryhigh,andamultitudeofstudentsfromagreatdistanceresortedtotheUniversity,merelyuponhisaccount。Thosebranchesofsciencewhichhetaughtbecamefashionableatthisplace,andhisopinionswerethechieftopicofdiscussioninclubsandliterarysocieties。Eventhesmallpeculiaritiesinhispronunciationormannerofspeaking,becamefrequentlytheobjectsofimitation。"
ItseemstohavebeenduringtheearlyyearsofhisprofessorshipatGlasgowthatAdamSmithformedthatfriendshipwithDavidHumewhichformssopleasingafeatureinthelifeofbothofthem,andissomemorableinthehistoryofliteraryattachments。Therewassufficientsamenessinthefundamentalcharacteristicsandopinionsofeachofthem,togetherwithsufficientdifferencesonminorpoints,toensurethepermanenceoftheirmutualaffection。Bothtookthesameinterestinquestionsofmoralphilosophyandpoliticaleconomy;bothhadacertainsimplicityandgentlenessofcharacter;bothheldthesameideasoftherelationofnaturaltorevealedreligion。
AletterwrittenbyHumetohisfriendin1759,ontheoccasionofthepublicationofhisMoralSentiments,isofinterest,notonlyascharacteristicofthefriendshipbetweenthem,butasindicativeofthegoodreceptionwhichthebookimmediatelymetwithfromallpersonscompetenttojudgeofit。TheletterisdatedApril12,1759。
"IgiveyouthanksfortheagreeablepresentofyourTheory。
WedderburneandImadepresentsofourcopiestosuchofouracquaintancesaswethoughtgoodjudges,andpropertospreadthereputationofthebook。
IsentonetotheDukeofArgyll,toLordLyttleton,HoraceWalpole,SoameJennyns,andBurke,anIrishgentleman,whowrotelatelyaveryprettytreatiseontheSublime。MillardesiredmypermissiontosendoneinyournametoDr。Warburton。IhavedelayedwritingtillIcouldtellyousomethingofthesuccessofthebook,andcouldprognosticate,withsomeprobability,whetheritshouldbefinallydamnedtooblivion,orshouldberegisteredinthetempleofimmortality。Thoughithasbeenpublishedonlyafewweeks,Ithinkthereappearalreadysuchstrongsymptoms,thatIcanalmostventuretoforetellitsfate……IamafraidofLordKames'sLawTracts。
AmanmightaswellthinkofmakingafinesaucebyamixtureofwormwoodandaloesasanagreeablecompositionbyjoiningmetaphysicsandScotchlaw……IbelieveIhavementionedtoyoualreadyHelvetius'sbookdel'Esprit。Itisworthyourreading,notforitsphilosophy,whichI
donothighlyvalue,butforitsagreeablecomposition。Ihadaletterfromhimafewdaysagowhereinhetellsmethatmynamewasmuchoftenerinthemanuscript,butthatthecensorofbooksatParisobligedhimtostrikeitout……Butwhatisallthistomybook?sayyou。MydearMr。
Smith,havepatience:composeyourselftotranquillity;showyourselfaphilosopherinpracticeaswellasprofession;thinkontheemptiness,andrashness,andfutilityofthecommonjudgmentofmen;howlittletheyareregulatedbyreasoninanysubject,muchmoreinphilosophicalsubjects,whichsofarexceedthecomprehensionofthevulgar……Awiseman'skingdomishisownbreast;or,ifheeverlooksfarther,itwillonlybetothejudgmentofaselectfew,whoarefreefromprejudicesandcapableofexamininghiswork。Nothingindeedcanbeastrongerpresumptionoffalsehoodthantheapprobationofthemultitude;andPhocion,youknow,alwayssuspectedhimselfofsomeblunderwhenhewasattendedwiththeapplausesofthepopulace。
"Supposing,therefore,thatyouhavedulypreparedyourselffortheworstbyallthesereflections,Iproceedtotellyouthemelancholynews,thatyourbookhasbeenveryunfortunate,forthepublicseemdisposedtoapplauditextremely。Itwaslookedforbythefoolishpeoplewithsomeimpatience;andthemobofliteratiarebeginningalreadytobeveryloudinitspraises。ThreebishopscalledyesterdayatMillar'sshopinordertobuycopiesandtoaskquestionsaboutitsauthor。TheBishopofPeterboroughsaidhehadpassedtheeveninginacompanywherehehearditextolledaboveallbooksintheworld。TheDukeofArgyllismoredecisivethanheusestobeinitsfavour。IsupposeheeitherconsidersitanexoticorthinkstheauthorwillbeserviceabletohimintheGlasgowelections。
LordLyttletonsaysthatRobertson,andSmith,andBowerarethegloriesofEnglishliterature。Oswaldprotestshedoesnotknowwhetherhehasreapedmoreinstructionorentertainmentfromit。Butyoumayeasilyjudgewhatreliancecanbeplacedonhisjudgmentwhohasbeenengagedallhislifeinpublicbusiness,andwhoneverseesanyfaultsinhisfriends。
Millarexultsandbragsthattwo-thirdsoftheeditionarealreadysold,andthatitissureofsuccess。Youseewhatasonofearththatis,tovaluebooksonlybytheprofittheybringhim。Inthatview,Ibelieve,itmayproveaverygoodbook。
"CharlesTownsend,whopassesforthecleverestfellowinEngland,issotakenwiththeperformancethathesaidtoOswaldhewouldputtheDukeofBuccleuchundertheauthor'scare,andwouldmakeitworthhiswhiletoacceptofthatcharge。AssoonasIheardthisIcalledonhimtwice,withaviewoftalkingwithhimaboutthematter,andofconvincinghimoftheproprietyofsendingthatyoungnoblemantoGlasgow;forIcouldnothopethathecouldofferyouanytermswhichwouldtemptyoutorenounceyourprofessorship。ButImissedhim……
"Inrecompenseforsomanymortifyingthings,whichnothingbuttruthcouldhaveextortedfromme,andwhichIcouldeasilyhavemultipliedtoagreaternumber,IdoubtnotbutyouaresogoodaChristianastoreturngoodforevil;andtoflattermyvanitybytellingmethatallthegodlyinScotlandabusemeformyaccountofJohnKnoxandtheReformation,"
etc。
TheinvitationreferredtobyHumeinthislettertotravelwiththeDukeofBuecleuchcameinaboutfouryearstime;andtheliberaltermsinwhichtheproposalwasmade,togetherwiththestrongtemptationtotravel,ledtoafinalresignationoftheGlasgowprofessorship。
Buthereagaincuriosityisdoomedtodisappointment;forAdamSmithwrotenojournalofhistravelsabroad,andhehadsuchanaversiontoletter-writingthatnorecordsofthissortpreservehisimpressionsofforeignlife。4Scarcelymorethanthebareoutlineofhisrouteisknown。SometwoweeksatPariswerefollowedbyeighteenmonthsatToulouse。ThenatourintheSouthofFrancewasfollowedbytwomonthsatGeneva;andfromChristmas,1765,tothefollowingOctoberthetravellerswereinParis,thislatterperiodbeingtheonlyoneofanygeneralinterest,onaccountoftheillustriousacquaintanceswhichtheintroductionsofHumeenabledAdamSmithtomakeintheFrenchcapital。
DuringthisperiodAdamSmithbecameacquaintedwiththechiefmenoflettersandphilosophersofParis,suchasD'Alemhert,Helvetius,Marmontel,Morellet;anditistoberegrettedthatMorellet,whomentionsthefactofconversationsbetweenhimself,Turgot,andAdamSmith,onsubjectsofpoliticaleconomyandonseveralpointsconnectedwiththegreatworkthencontemplatedbythelatter,shouldhavegivenusnocluetotheinfluenceTurgotmayhavehadinsuggestingorconfirmingtheideaoffreetrade。
Thattheintercoursebetweenthembecameintimatemayatleastbeinferredfromtheunverifiedstoryoftheirsubsequentliterarycorrespondence;
andtoQuesnai,theeconomist,itisknownthatAdamSmithintended,butforthedeathoftheformer,tohavededicatedhisWealthofNations。
`WithMorellet,too,AdamSmithseemstohavebeenintimate。Theabbé;
recordsinhisMemoirsthathekeptfortwentyyearsapocket-bookpresentedtohimasakeepsakebyAdamSmith。ThelattersenthimalsoacopyoftheWealthofNationstenyearslater,whichMorellet,withhisusualzealfortranslating,settoworkuponatonce。TheAbbé;Blavet,however,wasagainthefirstinthefield,sothatMorelletcouldnotfindapublisher。ItisworthnoticingthatMorelletmentionsthefactthatAdamSmithspokeFrenchverybadly,whichisnottheleastinconsistentwithhisbiographer'sclaimforhimofan"uncommonlyextensiveandaccurateknowledge"ofmodernlanguages。
Thedukeandthephilosopher,havinglaidintheircompanionshipabroadthefoundationofafriendshipwhichlastedtillthedeathofthelatter,returnedtoLondoninOctober,1766。ThenexttenyearsofhislifeAdamSmithspent
athomewithhismotherandcousin,preparingtheworkonwhichhisfamenowchieflyrests。Itwasaperiodofquietuneventfulstudy,andalmostsolitude。WritingtoHume,hesaysthathischiefamusementsarelongandsolitarywalksbythesea,andthatheneverfeltmorehappy,comfortable,orcontented,inhislife。HumemadevainendeavourstotempthimtoEdinburghfromhisretirement。"Iwant,"hesaid,"toknowwhatyouhavebeendoing,andproposetoexactarigorousaccountofthemethodinwhichyouhaveemployedyourselfduringyourretreat。Iampositiveyouarewronginmanyofyourspeculations,especiallywhereyouhavethemisfortunetodifferfromme。Allthesearereasonsforourmeeting。"
Thiswasin1769。Sevenyearslater,1776,theWealthofNationsappeared,andHume,whowasthendying,againwrotehisfriendacongratulatoryletter。"Euge!Belle!Iammuchpleasedwithyourperformance,andtheperusalofithastakenmefromagreatstateofanxiety。Itwasaworkofsomuchexpectation,byyourself,byyourfriends,andbythepublic,thatItrembledforitsappearance;butamnowmuchrelieved。Notbutthatthereadingofitnecessarilyrequiressomuchattention,thatIshallstilldoubtforsometimeofitsbeingatfirstverypopular。Butithasdepthandsolidity,andacuteness,andissomuchillustratedbycuriousfacts,thatitmust,atlast,takethepublicattention。ItisprobablymuchimprovedbyyourlastabodeinLondon。Ifyouwerehere,atmyfireside,Ishoulddisputesomeofyourprinciples……Butthese,andahundredotherpoints,arefitonlytobediscussedinconversation。
Ihopeitwillbesoon,forIaminaverybadstateofhealth,andcannotaffordalongdelay。"
Thisletterseemstohaveledtoameetingbetweenthetwofriends,thelastbeforethesadfinalseparation。OfthecheerfulnesswithwhichHumemethisdeath,AdamSmithwroteanaccountinaletteraddressedtoStrahan,thepublisher,andappendedtoHume'sautobiography,tellinghowHume,inreferencetohisapproachingdeparture,imaginedaconversationbetweenhimselfandCharon,andhowhecontinuedtocorrecthisworksforanewedition,toreadbooksofamusement,toconverse,orsometimesplayatwhistwithhisfriends。Healsoextolled"Hume'sextremegentlenessofnature,whichneverweakenedthefirmnessofhismindnorthesteadinessofhisresolutions;hisconstantpleasantryandgoodhumour;hissevereapplicationtostudy,hisextensivelearning,hisdepthofThought。"Hethoughtthathistemperwasmoreevenlybalancedthaninanyothermanheeverknew;andthat,howevermuchdifferenceofopiniontheremightbeamongmenastohisphilosophicalideas,accordingastheyhappenedornottocoincidewiththeirown,therecouldscarcelybeanyconcerninghis
characterandconduct。"Uponthewhole,"heconcluded,"Ihavealwaysconsideredhim,bothinhislifetimeandsincehisdeath,asapproachingasnearlytotheideaofaperfectlywiseandvirtuousmanasperhapsthenatureofhumanfrailtywillpermit。"
ConsideringthatHumecountedamonghisfriendssuchchurchmenasRobertsonthehistorian,andBlair,authoroftheSermons,AdamSmith'sconfidentbeliefintheuniformityofjudgmentabouthisfriend'scharacterneednotappearunreasonable;but,unfortunately,adignitaryoftheChurch,authorofaCommentaryonthePsalms,andafterwardsBishopofNorwich,chosetoconsiderthelettertoStrahanamanifestoagainstChristianity,andaccordinglypublishedanonymouslyalettertoAdamSmith,purportingtobewritten"byoneofthepeoplecalledChristians。"Thewriterclaimedtohaveinhiscompositionalargeproportionofthemilkofhumankindness;
tobenobigotnorenemytohumanlearning;andnevertohaveknownthemeaningofenvyorhatred。Strangethenthat,attheageofforty-six,Dr。Homeshouldhavebeenguiltyofaletter,whichitwouldbedifficulttomatchforinjusticeofinference,orcontemptibilityofstyle,andwhichheeventhoughtfittoleavetoposterityamonghisotherpublishedworks。
Hebegins:"Youhavebeenlatelyemployedinembalmingaphilosopher;hisbody,IbelieveImustsay,forconcerningtheotherpartofhisnatureneitheryounorheseemtohaveentertainedanidea,sleepingorwaking。Elseitsurelymighthaveclaimedalittleofyourcareandattention;
andonewouldthinkthebeliefofthesoul'sexistenceandimmortalitycoulddonoharm,ifitdidnogood,inaTheoryofMoralSentiments。