Noteverybodycanperusealloftheseverydiverseauthorswithpleasure。HebeganhispoemontheRomangladiatorialcombats;
indeedhisyears,fourscoreandone,lefthisintellectualeagernessasunimpairedasthatofGoethe。"Acrookedshare,"hesaidtothePrincessLouise,"maymakeastraightfurrow。""OneafternoonhehadalongwaltzwithM-intheballroom。"Speakingof"AllthecharmofalltheMusesOftenfloweringinalonelyword"
inVirgil,headduced,ratherstrangely,thecunctantemramum,saidoftheGoldenBough,intheSixthAEneid。Thechoiceisodd,becausetheSibylhasjusttoldAEneasthat,ifhebedestinedtopluckthebranchofgold,ipsevolensfacilisquesequetur,"itwillcomeoffofitsownaccord,"likethesacredtibranchesoftheFijians,whichbenddowntobepluckedfortheFirerite。Yet,whenthepredestinedAEneastriestoplucktheboughofgold,ityieldsreluctantlycunctantem,contrarytowhattheSibylhasforetold。MrConington,therefore,thoughtthephraseasliponthepartofVirgil。"PeopleaccusedVirgilofplagiarising,"hesaid,"butifamanmadeithisowntherewasnoharminthatlookatthegreatpoets,Shakespeareincluded。"Tennyson,likeVirgil,mademuchthatwasancienthisown;hisversesareoften,andpurposefully,amosaicofclassicalreminiscences。Buthewasvexedbythehuntersafterremoteandunconsciousresemblances,andfar-fetchedanalogiesbetweenhislinesandthoseofothers。Hecomplainedthat,ifhesaidthatthesunwentdown,aparallelwasatoncecitedfromHomer,oranybodyelse,andheusedaverypowerfulphrasetocondemncriticswhodetectedsuchrepetitions。"Themoaningsofthehomelesssea,"——"moanings"
fromHorace,"homeless"fromShelley。"AsifnooneelsehadeverheardtheseamoanexceptHorace!"Tennyson'smixtureofmemoryandforgetfulnesswasnotsostrangeasthatofScott,andwhenheadaptedfromtheGreek,Latin,orItalian,itwasofsetpurpose,justasitwaswithVirgil。Thebeautifullinescomparingagirl'seyestobottomagatesthatseemto"WaveandfloatIncrystalcurrentsofclearrunningseas,"
heinventedwhilebathinginWales。Itwashishabit,tonotedowninversesuchsimilesfromnature,andtousethemwhenhefoundoccasion。Butthehighercriticism,analysingthesimile,detectedelementsfromShakespeareandfromBeaumontandFletcher。
InJune1891thepoetwentonatourinDevonshire,andbeganhisAkbar,andprobablywroteJuneBrackenandHeather;orperhapsitwascomposedwhen"weoftensatonthetopofBlackdowntowatchthesunset。"HewrotetoMrKipling-
"TheoldesttotheyoungestsingerThatEnglandbore"
toalterMrSwinburne'slinestoLandor,praisinghisFlagofEngland。MrKiplingrepliedas"theprivatetothegeneral。"
Earlyin1892TheForesterswassuccessfullyproducedatNewYorkbyMissAdaRehan,themusicbySirArthurSullivan,andthesceneryfromwoodlanddesignsbyWhymper。RobinHoodaswelearnfromMarkTwainisafavouriteherowiththeyouthofAmerica。MrTomSawyerhimselftook,inMarkTwain'stale,thepartoftheboldoutlaw。
TheDeathofOEnonewaspublishedin1892,withthededicationtotheMasterofBalliol-
"ReadaGreciantaleretoldWhich,castinlaterGrecianmould,QuintusCalaberSomewhatlazilyhandledofold。"
QuintusCalaber,moreusuallycalledQuintusSmyrnaeus,isawriterofperhapsthefourthcenturyofourera。Abouthimnothing,ornexttonothing,isknown。Hetold,insolateanage,theconclusionoftheTaleofTroy,andinthewriter'sopinionhasbeenundulyneglectedanddisdained。Hismanner,Iventuretothink,ismoreHomericthanthatofthemorefamousanddoubtlessgreaterAlexandrianpoetoftheArgonauticcycle,ApolloniusRhodius,hisseniorbyfivecenturies。HismaterialswereprobablytheancientandlostpoemsoftheEpicCycle,andthestoryofthedeathofOEnonemaybefromtheLittleIliadofLesches。PossiblypartsofhisworkmaybetextuallyderivedfromtheCyclics,butthetopicisveryobscure。InQuintus,Paris,afterencounteringevilomensonhisway,makesalongspeech,imploringthepardonofthedesertedOEnone。Shereplies,notwiththeTennysonianbrevity;shesendshimbacktothehelplessarmsofherrival,Helen。Parisdiesonthehills;neverdidHelenseehimreturning。Thewood-nymphsbewailParis,andaherdsmanbringsthebitternewstoHelen,whochantsherlament。ButremorsefallsonOEnone。Shedoesnotgo"SlowlydownBythelongtorrent'sever-deepenedroar,"
butrushes"swiftasthewindtoseekandspringuponthepyreofherlord。"FateandAphroditedriveherheadlong,andinheavenSelene,rememberingEndymion,bewailsthelotofhersisterinsorrow。
OEnonereachesthefuneralflame,andwithoutawordoracryleapsintoherhusband'sarms,thewildNymphswondering。Theloversaremingledinoneheapofashes,andthesearebestowedinonevesselofgoldandburiedinahowe。Thisisthestorywhichthepoetrehandledinhisoldage,completingtheworkofhishappyyouthwhenhewalkedwithHallaminthePyreneanhills,thatweretohimasIda。
TheromanceofOEnoneandherdeathcondone,asevenHomerwasapttocondone,thesinsofbeautifulParis,whomthenymphslament,despitetheevilthathehaswrought。ThesilenceoftheveiledOEnone,asshespringsintoherlover'slastembrace,isperhapsmoreaffectingandmorenaturalthanTennyson's"SheliftedupavoiceOfshrillcommand,'Whoburnsuponthepyre?'"
TheStTelemachushastheoldsplendourandvigourofverse,and,thoughwrittensolateinlife,isworthyofthepoet'sprime:-
"EveafterevethathaggardanchoriteWouldhauntthedesolatedfane,andthereGazeattheruin,oftenmutterlow'VicistiGalilaee';louderagain,Spurningashatter'dfragmentoftheGod,'VicistiGalilaee!'but——whennowBathedinthatluridcrimson——ask'd'IsearthOnfiretotheWest?oristheDemon-godWrothathisfall?'andheardananswer'WakeThoudeedlessdreamer,lazyingoutalifeOfself-suppression,notofselflesslove。'
AndonceaflightofshadowyfighterscrostThedisk,andonce,hethought,ashapewithwingsCamesweepingbyhim,andpointedtotheWest,Andathisearheheardawhisper'Rome,'
Andinhishearthecried'ThecallofGod!'
Andcall'darose,and,slowlyplungingdownThro'thatdisastrousglory,sethisfaceBywasteandfieldandtownofalientongue,Followingahundredsunsets,andthesphereOfwestward-wheelingstars;andeverydawnStruckfromhimhisownshadowontoRome。
Foot-sore,way-worn,atlengthhetouch'dhisgoal,TheChristiancity。"
Akbar'sDreammaybetaken,moreorless,torepresentthepoet'sowntheologyofaraceseekingafterGod,ifperchancetheymayfindHim,andtheclosingHymnwasafavouritewithTennyson。Hesaid,"Itisamagnificentmetre":-
"HYMN。
I。
Onceagainthouflamestheavenward,onceagainweseetheerise。
Everymorningisthybirthdaygladdeninghumanheartsandeyes。
Everymorningherewegreetit,bowinglowlydownbeforethee,TheetheGodlike,theethechangelessinthineever-changingskies。
II。
Shadow-maker,shadow-slayer,arrowinglightfromclimetoclime,Hearthymyriadlaureateshailtheemonarchintheirwoodlandrhyme。
Warblebird,andopenflower,and,men,belowthedomeofazureKneeladoringHimtheTimelessintheflamethatmeasuresTime!"
InthisfinalvolumethepoetcasthishandfulofincenseonthealtarofScott,versifyingthetaleofIlBizarro,whichthedyingSirWalterrecordsinhisJournalinItaly。TheChurchwardenandtheCurateisnotinferiortotheearlierpeasantpoemsinitsexpressionofshrewdness,humour,andsuperstition。AverseofPoetsandCriticsmaybetakenasthepoet'slastwordontheoldfutilequarrel:-
"Thisthing,thatthingistherage,Helter-skelterrunstheage;
MindsonthisroundearthofoursVaryliketheleavesandflowers,Fashion'daftercertainlaws;
Singthouloworloudorsweet,Allatallpointsthoucanstnotmeet,Somewillpassandsomewillpause。
Whatistrueatlastwilltell:
Fewatfirstwillplacetheewell;
Sometoolowwouldhavetheeshine,Sometoohigh——nofaultofthine-
Holdthineown,andworkthywill!
Yearwillgrazetheheelofyear,Butseldomcomesthepoethere,AndtheCritic'srarerstill。"
Stillthelinesholdgood-
"Sometoolowwouldhavetheeshine,Sometoohigh——nofaultofthine。"
Theendwasnowathand。AsenseofweaknesswasfeltbythepoetonSeptember3,1892:onthe28thhisfamilysentforSirAndrewClark;
butthepatientgraduallyfadedoutoflife,andexpiredonThursday,October6,at1。35A。M。TotheverylasthehadShakespearebyhim,andhiswindowswereopentothesun;onthelastnighttheywerefloodedbythemoonlight。ThedescriptionofthefinalscenesmustbereadintheBiographybythepoet'sson。"Hispatienceandquietstrengthhadpoweruponthosewhowerenearestanddearesttohim;wefeltthankfulfortheloveandtheutterpeaceofitall。""Thelifeafterdeath,"Tennysonhadsaidjustbeforehisfatalillness,"isthecardinalpointofChristianity。IbelievethatGodrevealsHimselfineveryindividualsoul;andmyideaofHeavenistheperpetualministryofonesoultoanother。"Hehadlivedthelifeofheavenuponearth,beinginallhisworkaministerofthingshonourable,lovely,consoling,andennoblingtothesoulsofothers,withaministrywhichcannotdie。Hisbodysleepsnexttothatofhisfriendandfellow-poet,RobertBrowning,infrontofChaucer'smonumentintheAbbey。
CHAPTERXI——LASTCHAPTER。
"O,thatPresswillgetholdofmenow,"Tennysonsaidwhenheknewthathislasthourwasathand。Hehadahorrorofpersonaltattle,asevenhisearlypoemsdeclare-
"FornowthePoetcannotdie,Norleavehismusicasofold,ButroundhimerehescarcebecoldBeginsthescandalandthecry。"
Butno"carrion-vulture"haswaited"Totearhisheartbeforethecrowd。"
AboutTennyson,doubtless,thereismuchanecdotage:mostoftheanecdotesturnonhisshyness,hisreallyexaggeratedhatredofpersonalnotoriety,andtheoddandbrusquethingswhichhewouldsaywhenalarmedbyeffusivestrangers。Ithasnotseemedworthwhiletorepeatmorethanoneortwooftheselegends,norhaveIsoughtoutsidetheBiographybyhissonformorethanthebiographerchosetotell。Thereaderswhoareleastinterestedinpoetryaremostinterestedintattleaboutthepoet。Itistheprivilegeofgeniustoretainthefreshnessandsimplicity,withsomeofthefoibles,ofthechild。WhenTennysonreadhispoemsaloudhewasapttobemovedbythem,andtoexpressfranklyhisapprobationwherehethoughtitdeserved。Onlyveryrudimentarypsychologistsrecognisedconceitinthisfreedom;andonlythesamesetofpersonsmistookshynessforarrogance。EffusivenessofpraiseorcuriosityinastrangerisapttoproducebluntnessofreplyinaBriton。"Don'ttalkd-dnonsense,sir,"saidtheDukeofWellingtontothegushingpersonwhopilotedhim,inhisoldage,acrossPiccadilly。OfTennysonMrPalgravesays,"Ihaveknownhimsilenced,almostfrozen,beforetheeagerunintentionaleyesofagirloffifteen。Andunderthestressofthisnervousimpulsecompelledtocontradicthisinnerselfespeciallywhenundertheterrorofleonisation……,hewasdoubtlessattimesbetrayedintoanabruptphrase,acoldunsympatheticexterior;amoment's'defectoftherose。'"Hadhenotbeensensitiveinallthings,hewouldhavebeenlessofapoet。ThechiefcriticismdirectedagainsthismodeoflifeisthatheWAS
sensitiveandreserved,buthecouldanddidmakehimselfpleasantinthesocietyoflespauvresd'esprit。Curiosityalarmedhim,anddrovehimintohisshell:strangerswhomethiminthatmoodcarriedawayfalseimpressions,whichdevelopedintomyths。AstheMasterofBalliolhasrecorded,despitehisshyness"hewasextremelyhospitable,ofteninvitingnotonlyhisfriends,butthefriendsofhisfriends,andgivingthemaheartywelcome。Forunderneathasensitiveexteriorhewasthoroughlygenialifhewasunderstood。"
Inthesepointshewasunlikehisgreatcontemporary,Browning;forinstance,TennysonneverIthinkwastheMaster'sguestatBalliol,mingling,likeBrowning,withtheundergraduates,towhomtheMaster'shospitalitywasfreelyextended。Yet,wherehewasfamiliar,Tennysonwasagaycompanion,notshunningjestorevenparadox。"AsDrJohnsonsays,everymanmaybejudgedofbyhislaughter":butnoBoswellhaschronicledthelaughtersofTennyson。
"Henever,orhardlyever,madepunsorwitticisms"thoughonepun,atleast,enduresintradition,"butalwayslivedinanattitudeofhumour。"MrJowettwritesandnodescriptionofthepoetisbetterthanhis-
IfIweretodescribehisoutwardappearance,IshouldsaythathewascertainlyunlikeanyoneelsewhomIeversaw。AglanceatsomeofWatts'portraitsofhimwillgive,betterthananydescriptionwhichcanbeexpressedinwords,aconceptionofhisnoblemienandlook。Hewasamagnificentman,whostoodbeforeyouinhisnativerefinementandstrength。Theunconventionalityofhismannerswasinkeepingwiththeoriginalityofhisfigure。Hewouldsometimessaynothing,orawordortwoonly,tothestrangerwhoapproachedhim,outofshyness。Hewouldsometimescomeintothedrawing-roomreadingabook。Atothertimes,especiallytoladies,hewassingularlygraciousandbenevolent。Hewouldtalkabouttheaccidentsofhisownlifewithanextraordinaryfreedom,asatthemomenttheyappearedtopresentthemselvestohismind,thedaysofhisboyhoodthatwerepassedatSomersby,andtheoldschoolofmannerswhichhecameacrossinhisownneighbourhood:thedaysofthe"apostles"atCambridge:theyearswhichhespentinLondon;theeveningsenjoyedattheCockTavern,andelsewhere,whenhesawanothersideoflife,notwithoutakindlyandhumoroussenseoftheridiculousinhisfellow-creatures。Hisrepertoryofstorieswasperfectlyinexhaustible;theywereoftenaboutslightmattersthatwouldscarcelybearrepetition,butweretoldwithsuchlifelikereality,thattheyconvulsedhishearerswithlaughter。Likemoststory-tellers,heoftenrepeatedhisfavourites;but,likechildren,hisaudiencelikedhearingthemagainandagain,andheenjoyedtellingthem。Itmightbesaidofhimthathetoldmorestoriesthananyone,butwasbynomeanstheregularstory-teller。Inthecommonestconversationheshowedhimselfamanofgenius。
TothisdescriptionmaybeaddedanotherbyMrF。T。Palgrave:-
Everyonewillhaveseenmen,distinguishedinsomelineofwork,whoseconversationtotaketheoldfigureeither"smelttoostronglyofthelamp,"orlayquiteapartfromtheirartorcraft。
What,throughalltheseyears,struckmeaboutTennyson,wasthatwhilstheneverdeviatedintopoeticallanguageassuch,whetherinrhetoricorhighlycolouredphrase,yetthroughoutthesubstanceofhistalkthesamemodeofthought,thesameimaginativegraspofnature,thesamefinenessandgentlenessinhisviewofcharacter,thesameforbearanceandtoleration,theaureamediocritasdespisedbyfoolsandfanatics,whicharestampedonhispoetry,wereconstantlyperceptible:whilstintheeasyandasitwereunsoughtchoiceness,theconscientiousandtruth-lovingprecisionofhiswords,thesamepersonalidentityrevealeditself。Whatastrangecharmlayhere,howdeeplyilluminatingthewholecharacter,asinprolongedintercourseitgraduallyrevealeditself!Artistandman,Tennysonwasinvariablytruetohimself,orrather,inWordsworth'sphrase,he"movedaltogether";hisnatureandhispoetrybeingharmoniousaspectsofthesamesoul;asbotaniststellusthatflowerandfruitarebuttransformationsofrootandstemandleafage。Wereadhow,inmediaevaldays,conduitsweremadetoflowwithclaret。
Butthiswasongreatoccasionsonly。Tennyson'sfountainalwaysranwine。
Oncemore:InMme。Recamier'ssalon,Ihaveread,atthetimewhenconversationwasyetafineartinParis,guestsfamousforespritwouldsitinthetwilightroundthestove,whilsteachinturnletflysomesparklinganecdoteorbon-mot,whichroseandshoneanddiedoutintosilence,tillthenextoftheelectpyrotechnistswasready。
Goodthingsofthiskind,asIhavesaid,wereplentifulinTennyson'srepertory。Butwhat,topassfromthematerialstothemethodofhisconversation,eminentlymarkeditwasthecontinuityoftheelectriccurrent。Hespoke,andwassilent,andspokeagain:
butthecircuitwasunbroken;therewasnoeffortintakingupthethread,nosenseofdisjunction。OftenIthought,hadheneverwrittenalineofthepoemssodeartous,hisconversationalonewouldhavemadehimthemostinterestingcompanionknowntome。Fromthisgreatandgraciousstudentofhumanity,whatless,indeed,couldbeexpected?Andif,asaconverser,IweretocomparehimwithSocrates,asfiguredforusinthedialoguesofhisgreatdisciple,I
thinkthatIshouldhavetheassentofthateminentlyvaluedfriendofTennyson's,whoselonglabouroflovehasconferredEnglishcitizenshipuponPlato。
Wehavecalledhimshyandsensitiveindailyintercoursewithstrangers,andastocriticism,hefreelyconfessedthatamidgeofdispraisecouldsting,whileapplausegavehimlittlepleasure。Yetnopoetalteredhisversessomuchinobediencetocensureunjustlyorirritatinglystated,yetinessencejust。Hereadilyrejectedsomeofhis"Juvenilia"onMrPalgrave'ssuggestion。Thesamefriendtellshowwellhetookaratherfierceattackonanunpublishedpiece,whenMrPalgrave"ownedthathecouldnotfindonegoodlineinit。"Veryfewpoets,orevenversifiersfiercertheythanpoetsare,wouldhavecontinuedtoshowtheirvirginnumberstoafriendsocandid,asTennysondid。Perhapsmostofthegenusirritabilewillgrantthatspokencriticism,ifunfavourable,somehowannoysandstirsoppositioninanauthor;probablybecauseitconfirmshisownsuspicionsabouthiswork。Suchcriticismisalmostinvariablyjust。
ButCampbell,whenRogersofferedacorrection,"bouncedoutoftheroom,witha'Hangit!Ishouldliketoseethemanwhowoulddaretocorrectme。'"
MrJowettjustlyrecognisedinthelifeofTennysontwocircumstanceswhichmadehimotherthan,butforthese,hewouldhavebeen。HehadintendedtodowiththeArthuriansubjectwhatheneverdid,"insomewayorothertohaverepresentedinitthegreatreligionsoftheworld……ItisaproofofTennyson'sgeniusthatheshouldhavethusearlygraspedthegreathistoricalaspectofreligion。"Hisintentionwasfoiled,hisearlydreamwasbroken,bythedeathofArthurHallam,andbythecoldnessandcontemptwithwhich,atthesameperiod,hisearlypoemswerereceived。
MrJowettwhohadafirmbeliefinthe"greatwork"regrettedthechangeofplanastotheArthuriantopic,regretteditthemorefromhisowninterestintheHistoryofReligion。Butweneednotsharetheregrets。TheearlyplanfortheArthurwhichMrJowettneversawhasbeenpublished,andcertainlytheschemecouldnothavebeenexecutedontheselines。{18}Moreover,astheMasterobserved,theworkwouldhavebeenprematureinTennyson'syouth,and,indeed,itwouldstillbepremature。Thecomparativescienceofreligiousevolutionisevennowverytentative,anddoesnotyieldmaterialsofsufficientstabilityforanepic,evenifsuchanepiccouldbeforcedintothemouldoftheArthurlegends,afeatperhapsimpossible,andcertainlyundesirable。Atrulyfantasticallegorymusthavebeentheresult,anditisfortunatethatthepoetabandonedtheideainfavourofmorehumanthemes。Moreover,herecognisedveryearlythathiswasnotaMusedelonguehaleine;thathemustbe"short。"Wemaythereforefeelcertainthathisearlysorrowanddiscouragementweresalutarytohimasapoet,andasaman。Hebecamemoresympathetic,moretender,andwasobligedtoputforththatstoicalself-control,andstrenuouscourageandendurance,throughwhichalonehispoeticcareerwasrenderedpossible。"Hehadthesusceptibilityofachildorawoman,"sayshisfriend;"hehadalso"itwasastrangecombination"thestrengthofagiantorofagod。"Withoutthesequalitieshemusthavebrokendownbetween1833
and1842intoahypochondriac,oramorose,ifmajestic,failure。
Poor,obscure,andunhappy,heovercametheworld,andpassedfromdarknessintolight。The"poetictemperament"inanothernotgiftedwithhisenduranceandpersistentstrengthwouldhaveachievedruin。
MostofusrememberTaine'sparallelbetweenTennysonandAlfreddeMusset。TheFrenchcritichasnohighapprovalofTennyson's"respectability"andlongpeacefullife,ascomparedwiththewreckedlifeandgeniusofMusset,l'enfantperduoflove,wine,andsong。
Thisisatheorylikeanother,andisperhapsattractivetotheyoung。Thepoetmusthavestrongpassions,orhowcanhesingofthem:hemustbetossedandwhirledinthestressofthings,likeShelley'sautumnleaves;-
"Ghostsfromanenchanterfleeing。"
LookingatBurns,Byron,Musset,orevenatShelley'searlieryears,youthseesinthemthetruepoets,"sacredthings,"butalso"light,"
asPlatosays,inspiredtobreaktheirwingsagainstthenatureofexistence,andtheflammantiamaeniamundi。Butthisisalmostaboyishidea,thisideathatthetruepoetistheslaveofthepassions,andthatthepoetwhodominatesthemhasnone,andisbutastaiddomesticanimal,anassbrowsingthecommon,assomebodyhaswrittenaboutWordsworth。CertainlyTennyson'swasno"passionlessperfection。"He,likeothers,wastemptedtobeatwithineffectualwingsagainsttheinscrutablenatureoflife。He,too,hadhisdarkhour,andwasassubjecttotemptationastheywhoyieldedtothestressanddied,orbecameunhappywaifs,"youngmenwithasplendidpast。"Hemusthaveknown,nolessthanMusset,theattractionsofmanyaparadisartificiel,withitsbrightvisions,itshouris,itsoffersofoblivionofpain。"Hehadthelookofonewhohadsufferedgreatly,"MrPalgravewritesinhisrecordoftheirfirstmeetingin1842。Buthe,likeGoethe,Scott,andVictorHugo,hadstrengthaswellaspassionandemotion;hecameunscorchedthroughthefirethathasburnedawaythewingsofsomanyothergreatpoets。Thiswasnolessfortunatefortheworldthanforhimself。Ofhisprolongeddarkhourweknowlittleindetail,butwehaveseenthatfromthefirstheresistedtheTempter;UlyssesishisRetroSathanas!
About"themechanismofgenius"inTennysonMrPalgravehastoldusalittle;moreappearsincidentallyinhisbiography。"Itwashiswaythatwhenwehadenteredonsomesceneofspecialbeautyorgrandeur,afterenjoyingittogether,heshouldalwayswithdrawwhollyfromsight,andstudytheview,asitwere,inalittleartificialsolitude。"
Tennyson'spoems,MrPalgravesays,oftenaroseinakindofpointdereperelikethoseformsandlandscapeswhichseemtospringfromafloatingpointoflight,beheldwithclosedeyesjustbeforewesleep。"Morethanoncehesaidthathispoemssprangoftenfroma'nucleus,'someoneword,maybe,orbriefmelodiousphrase,whichhadfloatedthroughthebrain,asitwere,unbidden。Andperhapsatoncewhilewalkingtheywerepresentlywroughtintoalittlesong。Butifhedidnotwriteitdownatoncethelyricfledfromhimirrecoverably。"Hebelievedhimselfthustohavelostpoemsasgoodashisbest。Itseemsprobablethatthisisacommongenesisofverses,goodorbad,amongallwhowrite。LikeDickens,andlikemostmenofgeniusprobably,hesawallthescenesofhispoems"inhismind'seye。"Manyauthorsdothis,withoutthepowerofmakingtheirreaderssharethevision;butprobablyfewcanimpartthevisionwhodonotthemselves"visualise"withdistinctness。Wehaveseen,inthecasesofTheHolyGrailandotherpieces,thatTennyson,afterlongmeditatingasubject,oftenwroteveryrapidly,andwithlittleneedofcorrection。Hewasbornwith"style";itwasagiftofhisgeniusratherthantheresultofconsciouselaboration。Yethediduse"thefile,"ofwhichmuchisnowwritten,especiallyforthepurposeofpolishingawaythesibilants,socommoninourlanguage。Inthenineyearsofsilencewhichfollowedthelittlebookof1833hispoemsmatured,andhenceforthitisprobablethathealteredhisverseslittle,ifweexceptthemodificationsinThePrincess。Manyslightverbaltouchesweremade,oroldreadingswererestored,butimportantchanges,inthewayofomissionoraddition,becamerare。
OfnatureTennysonwasscrupulouslyobservanttillhisverylatestdays,eagerlynoting,notonly"effects,"asapainterdoes,buttheircauses,botanicalorgeological。Hadmanbeenscientificfromthebeginninghewouldprobablyhaveevolvednopoetryatall;
materialthingswouldnothavebeenendowedbyhimwithlifeandpassion;hewouldhavetoldhimselfnostoriesoftheoriginsofstarsandflowers,cloudsandfire,windsandrainbows。Modernpoetshaveresented,likeKeatsandWordsworth,thedestructionoftheoldprehistoricdreamsbythegeologistandbyotherscientificcharacters。ButitwaspartofTennyson'spoeticoriginalitytoseethebeautifulthingsofnatureatoncewiththevisionofearlypoeticmen,andofmodernsaccustomedtothemicroscope,telescope,spectrumanalysis,andsoforth。ThusTennysonreceivedadoubledelightfromthesensibleuniverse,anditisadoubledelightthathecommunicatestohisreaders。Hisintellectwasthusalwaysactive,eveninapparentrepose。Hiseyesrestednotfromobserving,orhismindfromrecordingandcomparing,thebeautifulfamiliarphenomenaofearthandsky。InthematterofthestudyofbookswehaveseenhowdeeplyversedhewasincertainoftheGreek,Roman,andItalianclassics。MrJowettwrites:"Hewaswhatmightbecalledagoodscholarintheuniversityorpublic-schoolsenseoftheterm,……yetIseemtorememberthathehadhisfavouriteclassics,suchasHomer,andPindar,andTheocritus……HewasalsoaloverofGreekfragments。ButIamnotsurewhether,inlaterlife,heeversatdowntoreadconsecutivelythegreatestworksofAEschylusandSophocles,althoughheusedoccasionallytodipintothem。"TheGreekdramatists,infact,seemtohaveaffectedTennyson'sworkbutslightly,whileheconstantlyremindsusofVirgil,Homer,Theocritus,andevenPersiusandHorace。MediaevalFrench,whetherinpoetryorprose,andthepoetryofthe"Pleiad"
seemstohaveoccupiedlittleofhisattention。Intotheorientalliteratureshedipped——prettydeeplyforhisAkbar;andevenhisLocksleyHallowedsomethingtoSirWilliamJones'sversionof"theoldArabianMoallakat。"Thedebtappearstobeinfinitesimal。HeseemstohavebeenlesscloselyfamiliarwithElizabethanpoetrythanmighthavebeenexpected:anumberofhisobiterdictaonallkindsofliterarypointsarerecordedintheLifebyMrPalgrave。"SirWalterScott'sshorttale,MyAuntMargaret'sMirrorhowlittleknown!,heoncespokeofasthefinestofallghostormagicalstories。"LordTennysonadds,"TheTapestriedChamberalsohegreatlyadmired。"BotharelostfrommodernviewamongtheshortpiecesofthelastvolumesoftheWaverleynovels。Ofthepoet'sinterestinandattitudetowardsthemoreobscurepyschologicalandpsychicalproblems——topopularsciencefoolishness——enoughhasbeensaid,buttheremarksofProfessorTyndallhavenotbeencited:-
Myspecialpurposeinintroducingthispoem,however,wastocallyourattentiontoapassagefurtheronwhichgreatlyinterestedme。
Thepoemis,throughout,adiscussionbetweenabelieverinimmortalityandonewhoisunabletobelieve。Themethodpursuedisthis。TheSagereadsaportionofthescroll,whichhehastakenfromthehandsofhisfollower,andthenbringshisownargumentstobearuponthatportion,withaviewtoneutralisingthescepticismoftheyoungerman。LetmehereremarkthatIreadthewholeseriesofpoemspublishedunderthetitle"Tiresias,"fullofadmirationfortheirfreshnessandvigour。SevenyearsafterIhadfirstreadthemyourfatherdied,andyou,hisson,askedmetocontributeachaptertothebookwhichyoucontemplatepublishing。IknewthatIhadsomesmallstoreofreferencestomyinterviewwithyourfathercarefullywritteninancientjournals。Onthereceiptofyourrequest,I
lookeduptheaccountofmyfirstvisittoFarringford,andthere,tomyprofoundastonishment,Ifounddescribedthatexperienceofyourfather'swhich,inthemouthoftheAncientSage,wasmadethegroundofanimportantargumentagainstmaterialismandinfavourofpersonalimmortalityeight-and-twentyyearsafterwards。Innootherpoemduringalltheseyearsis,tomyknowledge,thisexperienceoncealludedto。Ihadcompletelyforgottenit,buthereitwasrecordedinblackandwhite。Ifyouturntoyourfather'saccountofthewonderfulstateofconsciousnesssuperinducedbythinkingofhisownname,andcompareitwiththeargumentoftheAncientSage,youwillseethattheyrefertooneandthesamephenomenon。
Andmore,myson!formorethanoncewhenI
Satallalone,revolvinginmyselfThewordthatisthesymbolofmyself,ThemortallimitoftheSelfwasloosed,AndpastintotheNameless,asacloudMeltsintoheaven。Itouch'dmylimbs,thelimbsWerestrange,notmine——andyetnoshadeofdoubt,Bututterclearness,andthro'lossofSelfThegainofsuchlargelifeasmatch'dwithoursWereSuntospark——unshadowableinwords,Themselvesbutshadowsofashadow-world。
AnywordsaboutTennysonasapoliticianareapttoexcitethesleeplessprejudicewhichhauntsthepoliticalfield。Heprobably,ifforcedto"putanametoit,"wouldhavecalledhimselfaLiberal。
Buthewasnotasocialagitator。Heneversetarickonfire。"Heheldaloof,inasomewhatdetachedposition,fromthegreatsocialseethingsofhisage"MrFredericHarrison。Butinyouthhehelpedtoextinguishsomeflamingricks。Hespokeofthe"many-headedbeast"thereadingpublicintermsborrowedfromPlato。HehadnohigheresteemformobsthanShakespeareorJohnKnoxprofessed,whilehistheoryoftyrantsinthecaseofNapoleonIII。about1852wasthatofLiberalslikeMrSwinburneandVictorHugo。ThoughtomodernenlightenmentTennysonmayseemasgreataToryasDrJohnson,yethehadspokenhiswordin1852forthefreedomofFrance,andforsecuringEnglandagainstthesupposeddesignsofausurpernowfallen。Hereallybelieved,obsoleteasthefaithmaybe,inguardingourown,bothonlandandsea。PerhapsnoContinentalorAmericancritichaseveryetdispraisedapoeticalfellow-countrymanmerelyforurgingthedutiesofnationalunionandnationaldefence。
Acritic,however,writesthusofTennyson:"Whenourpoetdescendsintothearenaofpartypolemics,insuchthingsasRiflemen,Form!
HandsallRound,……TheFleet,andothertopicalpiecesdeartotheJingosoul,itisnotpoetrybutjournalism。"IdoubtwhetherthedesirablenessoftheexistenceofavolunteerforceandofafleetreallyiswithinthearenaofPARTYpolemics。Ifanypartythinksthatweoughttohavenovolunteers,andthatitisourdutytostarvethefleet,whatisthatparty'sname?Whocries,"DownwiththeFleet!DownwithNationalDefence!HoorayfortheDisintegrationoftheEmpire!"?
Tennysonwasnotapartyman,buthecertainlywouldhaveopposedanysuchparty。IftodefendourhomesandthisEnglandbe"Jingoism,"
Tennyson,likeShakespeare,wasaJingo。But,alas!IdonotknowthenameofthepartywhichopposesTennyson,andwhichwishestheinvadertotrampledownEngland——anyinvaderwilldoforsophilanthropicapurpose。Exceptwhenresistingthisunnamedparty,thepoetseldomorneverentered"thearenaofpartypolemics。"
Tennysoncouldnothaveexclaimed,likeSquireWestern,"HurrahforoldEngland!TwentythousandhonestFrenchmenhavelandedinKent!"
Heundeniablydidwriteverseswhetherpoetryorjournalismtendingtomakereaderstakeanunfavourableviewofhonestinvaders。Iftodothatistobea"Jingo,"andifsuchconducthurtsthefeelingsofanygreatEnglishparty,thenTennysonwasaJingoandapartisan,andwas,sofar,arhymester,likeMrKipling。IndeedweknowthatTennysonapplaudedMrKipling'sTheEnglishFlag。Sotheworstisout,asweinEnglandcounttheworst。InAmericaandonthecontinentofEurope,however,apoetmaybeproudofhiscountry'sflagwithoutincurringrebukefromhiscountrymen。Tennysondidnotreckonhimselfapartyman;hebelievedmoreinpoliticalevolutionthaninpoliticalrevolution,withcataclysms。HewasneitheranAnarchistnoraHomeRuler,norapoliticiansogenerousastowishEnglandtobelaiddefencelessatthefeetofherfoes。
Ifthesesentimentsdeservecensure,inTennyson,atleast,theyclaimourtolerance。HewasnotborninagenerationlateenoughtobetrulyLiberal。Oldprejudicesabout"thisEngland,"oldwordsfromHenryV。andKingJohn,hauntedhismemoryanddarkenedhisvisionofthetrueproportionsofthings。Wedrawinprejudicewithourmother'smilk。ThemotherofTennysonhadnotbeenanAgnosticoraComtist;hisfatherhadnotbeenastaunchtrue-blueanti-
Englander。Thusheinheritedacertainbiasinfavouroffaithandfatherland,abiasfromwhichhecouldneveremancipatehimself。Buttoutcomprendrec'esttoutpardonner。HadTennyson'sbirthbeenlater,wemightfindinhimamorecompleterealisationofourpoeticideal——mighthavedetectedlesstoblameortoforgive。
WiththatapologywemustleavethefameofTennysonasapoliticiantotheclementconsiderationofanenlightenedposterity。Idonotdefendhisnarrowinsularities,hisJingoism,ortheappreciablepercentageoffaithwhichblushinganalysismaydetectinhishonestdoubt:thesethingsImayregretorcondemn,butweoughtnottoletthemobscureourviewofthePoet。Hewasledawaybybadexamples。
OfallJingoesShakespeareisthemostunashamed,andnexttohimareDrayton,Scott,andWordsworth,withhis"Oh,foronehourofthatDundee!"
IntheyearswhichfollowedtheuntowardaffairofWaterlooyoungTennysonfellmuchundertheinfluenceofShakespeare,Wordsworth,andtheotheroffenders,andtheseareextenuatingcircumstances。Byacuriouspracticalparadox,wheretherealmsofpoetryandpoliticsmeet,theTorycriticsseemmilderofmoodandmoreLiberalthantheLiberalcritics。ThusMrWilliamMorriswascertainlyaveryadvancedpoliticaltheorist;andintheologyMrSwinburnehaswrittenthingsnoteasilyreconcilablewithorthodoxy。YetwefindDivine-
RightTories,whoinliteratureareferventadmirersofthesetwopoets,andleavetheirheterodoxiesoutofaccount。ButmanyLiberalcriticsappearunablequitetoforgiveTennysonbecausehedidnotwishtostarvethefleet,andbecauseheheldcertainveryancient,ifobsolete,beliefs。Perhapsageneralamnestyoughttobepassed,asfaraspoetsareconcerned,andtheirpoliticsandcreedsshouldbelefttosilence,where"beyondthesevoicesthereispeace。"
Oneremark,Ihope,canexcitenoprejudice。ThegreatestoftheGordonswasasoldier,andlivedinreligion。ButthepointatwhichTennyson'smemoryisblendedwiththatofGordonisthepointofsympathywiththeneglectedpoor。Itistohiswiseadvice,andtoaffectionforGordon,thatweowetheGordontrainingschoolforpoorboys,——agoodschool,andgoodboyscomeoutofthatacademy。
ThequestionastoTennyson'spreciserankinthegloriousrollofthePoetsofEnglandcanneverbedeterminedbyus,ifinanycaseoratanytimesuchdeterminationscanbemade。Wedonot,orshouldnot,askwhetherVirgilorLucretius,whetherAEschylusorSophocles,isthegreaterpoet。TheconsentofmankindseemstoplaceHomerandShakespeareandDantehighaboveall。Fortherestnoprize-listcanbesettled。Ifinfluenceamongaliensisthetest,Byronprobablytakes,amongourpoets,thenextrankafterShakespeare。Butprobablythereisnopossibletest。IncertainrespectsShelley,inmanyrespectsMilton,insomeColeridge,insomeBurns,intheopinionofanumberofpersonsBrowning,aregreaterpoetsthanTennyson。ButforexquisitevarietyandvariedexquisitenessTennysonisnotreadilytobesurpassed。Atonemomenthepleasestheuncriticalmassofreaders,inanothermoodhewinstheverdictoftheraffine。ItisasuccesswhichscarceanyEnglishpoetbutShakespearehasexcelled。Hisfaultshaverarely,ifever,beenthoseofflat-footed,"thick-ankled"dulness;ofrhetoric,ofcommon-
place;ratherhavehisdefectsbeentheexcessofhisqualities。A
kindofJohnBullishnessmayalsobenoted,especiallyinderogatoryreferencestoFrance,which,trueoruntrue,areoutoftasteandkeeping。Buttheseerrorscouldberemovedbytheexcisionofhalf-
a-dozenlines。HislaterworkastheVoyageofMaelduneshowsajustappreciationofancientCelticliterature。Agreatcritic,F。
T。Palgrave,hasexpressedperhapsthesoundestappreciationofTennyson:-
Itisfor"thedaysthatremain"tobearwitnesstohisrealplaceinthegreathierarchy,amongstwhomDanteboldlyyetjustlyrankedhimself。ButifwelookatTennyson'sworkinatwofoldaspect,——
HERE,ontheexquisiteartinwhich,throughout,hisverseisclothed,thelucidbeautyoftheform,themelodyalmostaudibleasmusic,themysteriousskillbywhichthewordsusedconstantlystrikeastheINEVITABLEwordsandhence,unforgettable,thesubtleallusivetouches,bywhichasecondaryimageissuggestedtoenrichtheleadingthought,astheharmonic"partials"giverichnesstothenotestruckuponthestring;THERE,whenwethinkofthevastfertilityinsubjectandtreatment,unitedwithhappyselectionofmotive,thewiderangeofcharacter,thedramaticforceofimpersonation,thepathosineveryvariety,themasteryoverthecomicandthetragicalike,aboveall,perhaps,thosephrasesofluminousinsightwhichspringdirectfromimaginativeobservationofHumanity,trueforalltime,comingfromthehearttotheheart,——hisworkwillprobablybefoundtoliesomewherebetweenthatofVirgilandShakespeare:havingitsportion,ifImayventureonthephrase,intheinspirationofboth。
AprofessedenthusiastforTennysoncanaddnothingto,andtakenothingfrom,thesewordsofonewho,thoughhisfriend,wastootrulyacritictoentertaintheadmirationthatgoesbeyondidolatry。