Butthecaseistotallydifferentwithrespecttotheinstitutionofcivilgovernment,organizedonthesystemofrepresentation。Suchagovernmenthascognizanceofeverything,andofeverymanasamemberofthenationalsociety,whetherhehaspropertyornot;and,therefore,theprinciplerequiresthateveryman,andeverykindofright,berepresented,ofwhichtherighttoacquireandtoholdpropertyisbutone,andthatnotofthemostessentialkind。
  Theprotectionofaman'spersonismoresacredthantheprotectionofproperty;andbesidesthis,thefacultyofperforminganykindofworkorservicesbywhichheacquiresalivelihood,ormaintaininghisfamily,isofthenatureofproperty。Itispropertytohim;hehasacquiredit;
  anditisasmuchtheobjectofhisprotectionasexteriorproperty,possessedwithoutthatfaculty,canbetheobjectofprotectioninanotherperson。
  Ihavealwaysbelievedthatthebestsecurityforproperty,beitmuchorlittle,istoremovefromeverypartofthecommunity,asfarascanpossiblybedone,everycauseofcomplaint,andeverymotivetoviolence;
  andthiscanonlybedonebyanequalityofrights。Whenrightsaresecure,propertyissecureinconsequence。Butwhenpropertyismadeapretenseforunequalorexclusiverights,itweakenstherighttoholdtheproperty,andprovokesindignationandtumult;foritisunnaturaltobelievethatpropertycanbesecureundertheguaranteeofasocietyinjuredinitsrightsbytheinfluenceofthatproperty。
  Nexttotheinjusticeandill-policyofmakingpropertyapretenseforexclusiverights,istheunaccountableabsurdityofgivingtomeresoundtheideaofproperty,andannexingtoitcertainrights;forwhatelseisatitlebutsound?Natureisoftengivingtotheworldsomeextraordinarymenwhoarriveatfamebymeritanduniversalconsent,suchasAristotle,Socrates,Plato,etc。Theyweretrulygreatornoble。Butwhengovernmentsetsupamanufactoryofnobles,itisasabsurdasifsheundertooktomanufacturewisemen。Hernoblesareallcounterfeits。
  Thiswax-workorderhasassumedthenameofaristocracy;andthedisgraceofitwouldbelessenedifitcouldbeconsideredonlyaschildishimbecility。
  Wepardonfopperybecauseofitsinsignificance,andonthesamegroundwemightpardonthefopperyoftitles。Buttheoriginofaristocracywasworsethanfoppery。Itwasrobbery。Thefirstaristocratsinallcountrieswerebrigands。Thoseoflatertimes,sycophants。
  ItisverywellknownthatinEngland(andthesamewillbefoundinothercountries),thegreatlandedestatesnowheldindescentwereplunderedfromthequietinhabitantsattheConquest。Thepossibilitydidnotexistofacquiringsuchestateshonestly。Ifitbeaskedhowtheycouldhavebeenacquired,noanswerbutthatofrobberycanbegiven。Thattheywerenotacquiredbytrade,bycommerce,bymanufactures,byagriculture,orbyanyreputableemployment,iscertain。
  Howthenweretheyacquired?Blush,aristocracy,tohearyourorigin,foryourprogenitorswerethieves。TheyweretheRobespierresandtheJacobinsofthatday。Whentheyhadcommittedtherobbery,theyendeavoredtolosethedisgraceofitbysinkingtheirrealnamesunderfictitiousones,whichtheycalledtitles。Itiseverthepractiseoffelonstoactinthismanner。
  Theyneverpassbytheirrealnames。
  Asproperty,honestlyobtained,isbestsecuredbyanequalityofrights,soill-gottenpropertydependsforprotectiononamonopolyofrights。
  Hewhohasrobbedanotherofhisproperty,willnextendeavortodisarmhimofhisrights,tosecurethatproperty;forwhentherobberbecomesthelegislatorhebelieveshimselfsecure。ThatpartoftheGovernmentofEnglandthatiscalledtheHouseofLords,wasoriginallycomposedofpersonswhohadcommittedtherobberiesofwhichIhavebeenspeaking。
  Itwasanassociationfortheprotectionofthepropertytheyhadstolen。
  Butbesidesthecriminalityoftheoriginofaristocracy,ithasaninjuriouseffectonthemoralandphysicalcharacterofman。Likeslaveryitdebilitatesthehumanfaculties;forasthemindboweddownbyslaverylosesinsilenceitselasticpowers,so,inthecontraryextreme,whenitisbuoyedupbyfolly,itbecomesincapableofexertingthem,anddwindlesintoimbecility。Itisimpossiblethatamindemployeduponribandsandtitlescaneverbegreat。Thechildishnessoftheobjectsconsumestheman。
  Itisatalltimesnecessary,andmoreparticularlysoduringtheprogressofarevolution,anduntilrightideasconfirmthemselvesbyhabit,thatwefrequentlyrefreshourpatriotismbyreferencetofirstprinciples。
  Itisbytracingthingstotheiroriginthatwelearntounderstandthem:
  anditisbykeepingthatlineandthatoriginalwaysinviewthatweneverforgetthem。
  Aninquiryintotheoriginofrightswilldemonstratetousthatrightsarenotgiftsfromonemantoanother,norfromoneclassofmentoanother;
  forwhoishewhocouldbethefirstgiver,orbywhatprinciple,oronwhatauthority,couldhepossesstherightofgiving?
  Adeclarationofrightsisnotacreationofthem,noradonationofthem。Itisamanifestoftheprinciplebywhichtheyexist,followedbyadetailofwhattherightsare;foreverycivilrighthasanaturalrightforitsfoundation,anditincludestheprincipleofareciprocalguaranteeofthoserightsfrommantoman。As,therefore,itisimpossibletodiscoveranyoriginofrightsotherwisethanintheoriginofman,itconsequentlyfollows,thatrightsappertaintomaninrightofhisexistenceonly,andmustthereforebeequaltoeveryman。
  Theprincipleofanequalityofrightsisclearandsimple。Everymancanunderstandit,anditisbyunderstandinghisrightsthathelearnshisduties;forwheretherightsofmenareequal,everymanmustfinallyseethenecessityofprotectingtherightsofothersasthemosteffectualsecurityforhisown。
  Butif,intheformationofaconstitution,wedepartfromtheprincipleofequalrights,orattemptanymodificationofit,weplungeintoalabyrinthofdifficultiesfromwhichthereisnowayoutbutbyretreating。Wherearewetostop?Orbywhatprinciplearewetofindoutthepointtostopat,thatshalldiscriminatebetweenmenofthesamecountry,partofwhomshallbefree,andtherestnot?
  Ifpropertyistobemadethecriterion,itisatotaldeparturefromeverymoralprincipleofliberty,becauseitisattachingrightstomerematter,andmakingmantheagentofthatmatter。Itis,moreover,holdinguppropertyasanappleofdiscord,andnotonlyexcitingbutjustifyingwaragainstit;forImaintaintheprinciple,thatwhenpropertyisusedasaninstrumenttotakeawaytherightsofthosewhomayhappennottopossessproperty,itisusedtoanunlawfulpurpose,asfire-armswouldbeinasimilarcase。
  Inastateofnatureallmenareequalinrights,buttheyarenotequalinpower;theweakcannotprotectthemselvesagainstthestrong。Thisbeingthecase,theinstitutionofcivilsocietyisforthepurposeofmakinganequalizationofpowersthatshallbeparallelto,andaguaranteeof,theequalityofrights。Thelawsofacountry,whenproperlyconstructed,applytothispurpose。
  Everymantakesthearmofthelawforhisprotectionasmoreeffectualthanhisown;andthereforeeverymanhasanequalrightintheformationofthegovernment,andofthelawsbywhichheistobegovernedandjudged。