CharlesV。wasamanofsoundjudgmentandliberalviews,ofgreatenergyandprudence,asskilfulinwarashewasintheartsofdiplomacy,andimmenselysuperiorinnearlyeveryrespecttohiscontemporaries,FrancisI。ofFranceandHenryVIII。ofEngland。Yetinspiteofallhisadmittedqualifications,andnotwithstandingthefactthathewastherulerofthree-fourthsofWesternEurope,helivedtowitnesstheoverthrowofhisdearestprojectsandthecompletefailureofhisgeneralpolicy。Buthiswantofsuccesswasnotduetopersonalimprudenceorinactivity。Itistobeattributedtothecircumstancesofthetimes,therebellioninSpain,theopenrevoltofsomeandthedistrustofothersinGermany,therapidadvanceoftheTurkstowardsthewest,and,aboveall,thestrugglewithFrance。DespitehismanyquarrelswiththeHolySee,andinfaceofthemanytemptationsheldouttohimtoarriveattheworldwidedictatorshiptowhichhewassuspectedofaspiring,byputtinghimselfattheheadofthenewreligiousmovement,heneverwaveredforamomentinhisallegiancetotheCatholicChurch——
[1]Grisar,/Luther/Eng。Trans。,i。,p。4。
[2]/Id。/p。8。
[3]Grisar,/Luther/Eng。Trans。,i。,p。14。
[4]Id。chap。iv。
[5]Keller,/JohannvonStaupitzunddieAnfangederReformation/,1888。
[6]Grisar,op。cit。Eng。Trans。,i。,34,323。
[7]Id。i。,34,Bd。iii。,957-8。
[8]Paulus,/JohannTetzel,derAblassprediger/,1899。/DieDeutschenDominikanerimKampfegegenLuther/,1903。
[9]Grisar,op。cit。Eng。Trans。,i。,pp。341-55。
[10]Kidd,/DocumentsoftheContinentalReformation/,pp。20-6。
[11]Specially,Nos。43,45,59,86。
[12]/Dialogus……inpresumptuosasM。LuthericonclusionesdepotestatePapae。/
[13]Greving,/JohannEck/,etc。,1906。
[14]"/BeatissimePater,prostratummepedibustuaebeatitudinisofferocumomnibusquaesumethabeo。Vivifica,occide,voca,revoca,approba,reproba,utplacuerit。VocemtuamvocemChristiintepraesidentisetloquentisagnoscam。Simortemmerui,morinonrecusabo。/"
[15]Pastor,op。cit。,iv。,177-9。
[16]Creutzberg,/KarlvonMiltitz/,1907。
[17]"/CoramDeoettotacreaturasuatestor,menequevoluissenequehodievelleEcclesiaeRomanaeacBeatitudinisTuaepotestemullomodotangereautquacunqueversutiademoliri;quinplenissimeconfiteorhuiusecclesiaepotestatemessesuperomnia,neceipraeferendumquidquidsiveincoelosiveinterrapraeterunumJesumChristumDominumomnium/"3rdMarch,1519。Kidd,op。cit。,p。43。
[18]Grisar,op。cit。Eng。Trans。,i。,359。
[19]/CambridgeModernHistory/,ii。,chaps。ii。,iii。
[20]/ImperatorumnationisGermanicaegravaminaadSademRomanam/,1725。
[21]DeWeldige-Kremer,/DeJoannisCochlaeiVitaetScriptis/,1865。
HewasoneofthemostenergeticopponentsoftheReformationparty。
[22]Schwane,/Dogmengeschichtederneurenzeit/,1890,pp。131-51,210-240,251-92。
[23]Grisar,op。cit。,Bd。iii。,228。
[24]/DeLiberoArbitrio/,etc。,1524。
[25]Grisar,op。cit。,Bd。i。,pp。483-502。
[26]Raynaldus,/Ann。Eccl。/ann。1522。
[27]Pastor,op。cit。,Bd。iv。,pp。212-393。
[28]"OfsuchslenderdimensionswastheoriginalProtestantChurch;
smallasitwas,itwasonlyheldtogetherbythenegativecharacterofitsprotest。"——/Camb。Mod。Hist。/,ii。,p。205。
[29]Negwer,/Wimpina/,1909。
[30]Hergenrother-Kirsch,op。cit。,Bd。iii。,p。80。
[31]Pastor,op。cit。,Bd。iv。,473-5。
[32]Hergenrother-Kirsch,op。cit。,iii。,pp。102-8。
[33]ForLuther'sownviewsontheresultsofhispreaching,cf。
Dollinger,/DieReformation/,Bd。ii。,pp。426-52。
[34]Grisar,op。cit。,Bd。ii。,382-436。
[35]Grisar,op。cit。,Bd。iii。,211-30。
[36]ThattherecanbenoquestionofsuicideisadmittedPaulus/LuthersLebensende/,1898。
[37]/Tischreden//TableTalk/,cf。Grisar,ii。,178sqq。Smith,/Luther'sTableTalk/,1907。/Am。Ecc。Review/1906,pp。1-18。
[38]/PersonalCharacterofLuther//Ir。Theol。Quart。/,viii。,p。
77-85。
bZwingliinSwitzerland:HisattitudetowardsLutheranism。
SeeworksmentionedaboveII。a。Dandliker,/GeschichtederSchweiz/,3Bde,1904。Dandliker-Salisbury,/AShortHistoryofSwitzerland/,1899。DeHaller,/HistoiredelarevolutionreligieuseoudelareformeprotestantedanslaSuisseoccidentale/,1837。Gelpke,/KirchengeschichtederSchweiz/,1856-
61。Schuler-Schulthess,/OperaHuldriciZwinglii/,8vols。,1828-
42。Jackson,/HuldreichZwingli/,1901。
TheterritorynowknownasSwitzerlandformedportionoftheHolyRomanEmpire。In1291,however,duringthereignofRudolphofHabsburg,thethreestatesorcantonsofUri,Schweiz,andUnterwalden,formedaconfederationtodefendtheirrightsandprivileges,thuslayingthefoundationfortheexistenceofSwitzerlandasanindependentnation。Othercantonsjoinedthealliance,moreespeciallyafterthevictoryatMorgartenin1315,whentheAustrianforcesdespatchedagainsttheSwisswerealmostannihilated。AustriamadevariousattemptstowinbacktheSwisstotheirallegiancebutwithoutsuccess,andin1394theindependenceofthealliedcantonswaspracticallyrecognised。
AboutthetimeoftheReformationinGermanySwitzerlandconsistedofthirteencantonsandseveralsmaller"allied"or"friendly"statesnotadmittedtofullcantonalrights。Thoughboundtogetherbyaloosekindofconfederationforpurposesofdefenceagainstaggression,thevariousstatesenjoyedalargemeasureofindependence,andeachwasruledaccordingtoitsownpeculiarconstitution。TheFederalDietorGeneralAssemblywascomposedofrepresentativesappointedbythecantons,anditsdecisionsweredeterminedbythevotesofthestates,thelargestandmostpopulouspossessingnogreaterpowersthantheleastinfluentialmemberoftheconfederation。Someofthestateswerenominallydemocraticintheirformofgovernment,but,asinmostcountriesduringthisperiod,thepeasantshadmanygroundsforreasonablecomplaint,particularlyinregardtotaxation,treasurypensions,andtheenlistingandemploymentoftheSwissmercenarytroops,thenthebestsoldiersinEurope。
AsinGermany,manycauseswereatworktopreparethegroundforthenewreligiousteaching。OnaccountofthefreecharacterofitsinstitutionsrefugeesofallkindsfledtoSwitzerlandforasylum,andwereallowedgreatlibertyinpropagatingtheirviews。Again,theSwissmercenaries,returningfromtheircampaignsandservice,duringwhichtheywerebroughtintocontactwithvariousclassesandnations,servedmuchthesamepurposeasdoesthemodernnewspaper。InboththesewaysthepeasantsofSwitzerlandwerekeptintouchwiththesocial,political,andreligiousconditionoftherestofEurope,andwiththehopesandplansoftheirownclassinotherkingdoms。
Humanismhadnot,indeed,madeverystrikingprogressinSwitzerland,thoughthepresenceofErasmusatBasle,andtheattacksthathedirectedagainstthemonksandtheclergy,couldnotfailtoproducesomeeffectonapeoplewhosemindswerealreadypreparedforsuchmethodsbytheiracquaintancewithmoderndevelopments。
If,however,theChurchinSwitzerlandhadbeenfreefromabusesnotallthewitandeloquenceofErasmusandhisfollowerscouldhaveproducedarevolt,butunfortunately,theinfluencesthatledtothedownfallofreligioninothercountrieswerealsoatworkintheSwisscantons。Thecathedralchapterswerecomposedforthegreaterpartofmenwhohadnovocationtothepriesthood,andwhoadoptedtheclericalprofessionbecausetheywishedtoenrichthemselvesfromtherevenuesoftheChurch,andwereensuredofgoodpositionsthroughtheinfluenceoftheirrelativesandpatrons。Manyoftheclergywerefarfrombeingperfect,norwereallthereligiousinstitutionsmindfulofthespiritorevenoftheletteroftheirconstitutions。
Unfortunately,too,owingtothepeculiarpoliticaldevelopmentoftheircountry,thebishopsofSwitzerlandweresubjecttoforeignmetropolitans,twoofthembeingunderthejurisdictionoftheArchbishopofMainz,twounderBesancon,oneunderAquileia,andonesubjectimmediatelytoRome。Partlyforthisreason,partly,also,owingtotheincreasingencroachmentsofthecivilpower,disputesandconflictsbetweentheecclesiasticalandtemporaljurisdictionswerenotunfrequent。ButitwouldbeamistaketosupposethattherewerenogoodecclesiasticsinSwitzerlandatthistime。Thereweremanyexcellentpriests,bothsecularandregular,whorecognisedthesadconditionofaffairs,andwhosupportedmeasuressuchasthoseundertakenbytheBishopofBaslein1503withalltheirpower。ThegreatbodyofteachersknownastheFriendsofGodwereatworkinSwitzerlandasintheNetherlands,andweredoingsplendidserviceforeducation,bothsecularandreligious。
Theman,whoplayedinSwitzerlandthepartplayedsosuccessfullybyLutherinGermany,wasUlrichZwingli。Hewasthesonofrichparents,bornatWildhaus,inthecantonofSaintGall1484,educatedattheUniversitiesofBerne,Basle,andVienna,andafterhisordinationtothepriesthood,appointedtotheparishofGlarus。Hewasayoungmanofremarkableabilitybothasastudentandasapreacher,andwasfortunateenoughtoattractthenoticeofapapallegate,throughwhoseinfluenceapensionwasassignedtohimtoenablehimtoprosecutehisstudies。HewasagoodclassicalscholarwithamorethanaverageknowledgeofHebrew,andwellversedintheScripturesandinthewritingsoftheFathers。ForatimeheactedaschaplaintosomeSwissregimentsfightinginItalyforthePopeagainstFrance,andonhisreturntohisnativecountryhewasappointedpreacheratthefamousshrineofOurLadyatEinsiedeln。[1]Herehisoratoricalpowersstoodhimingoodstead,buthisjudgmentandlevel-headednesswerenotonthesamehighplaneashisdeclamatorypowers,norwashisownprivatelifeinkeepingwiththesanctityoftheplaceorwiththedenunciationsthathehurledsorecklesslyagainsthisclericalbrethren。HebegantoattackpilgrimagesanddevotionstotheBlessedVirgin,butitwasnotsomuchforthisasforhisunlawfulrelationswithawomanofbadcharacterthathewasrelievedofhisoffice。[2]
HeretiredtoZurichwherehewasappointedpreacherinthecathedral。
HerehedenouncedthelivesoftheclergyandtheabusesintheChurch,relying,ashestated,uponwhathehadseenhimselfinItalyduringhisresidencethereaschaplaintotheSwissmercenaries。LikeLuther,hewellknewhowtowintheattentionandsympathyofthemobbyhisappealstothenationalfeelingsofhiscountrymen,andlikeLutherheinsistedthattheScriptureswerethesoleruleoffaith。Hedenouncedinthestrongestlanguagetheimmoralityandvicesoftheclergy,celibacy,vowsofchastity,pilgrimagesandthevenerationofthesaints,butforsofarhehadnotbrokenentirelywiththeChurch。
ThepreachingoftheIndulgencespromulgatedbyLeoX。inConstancewasentrustedtotheFranciscans。TheirworkwasadifficultoneespeciallyastheGrandCouncilofZurichforbadethemtopersist,as,indeed,didalsotheableandzealousHugovonHohenlandenberg,BishopofConstance,inwhosedioceseZurichwassituated。Zwingli,confidentofthesupportofthecityauthorities,attackedthedoctrineofIndulgencesandwasbackedbytheGrandCouncil,whichordered,athisinstigation,thattheWordofGodshouldbepreachedaccordingtotheScriptures,regardlessoftraditionortheinterpretationoftheChurch。Lateronhedirectedhisattacksagainstthemeritoriousnessofgoodworksandthepracticeoffastandabstinence1522,andaboutthesametimeheaddressedapetitiontotheBishopofConstancedemandingthatheshouldnotinterferewiththepreachingofthepureWordofGodnorsetanyobstacletothemarriageofhispriests。Headmittedpubliclythathisrelationswithwomenhadbeendisgraceful,thathehadlearnedfromhisownpersonalexperiencehowimpossibleoffulfilmentwasthevowofchastity,andthatmarriagewastheonlyremedythatwouldenablehimtoovercometheemotionsofcarnallustreferredtobySt。PaulinhisepistletotheCorinthiansI。7,9。
Thebishoprefusedtoyieldtothisdemandinsistingonthestrictobservanceofcelibacy,andappealedtotheGrandCounciltosupporthimwiththefullweightoftheirauthorityApril1522。
IncensedbythisrefusalZwinglishookofftheyokeofecclesiasticalauthority,rejectedtheprimacyofthePope,andtheinfallibilityofGeneralCouncils,denouncedcelibacyandvowsofchastityasinventionsofthedevil,andcalledupontheSwisspeopletosupporthiminhisfightforreligiousfreedom。Oncebefore,in1520,LeoX。
hadsummonedZwinglitoRometoanswerforhisteaching,butthesummonshadbeenunheeded。AdrianVI。madeanotherattempttowinhimfromhisdangerouscoursebyaletterfullofkindnessandsympathy,buthisremonstranceproducednoeffect1523。TheGrandCouncilofZurich,hopefulofsecuringapreponderatinginfluenceinSwitzerlandbytakingtheleadinthenewmovement,favouredZwingli。InsteadofrespondingtotheappealoftheBishopofConstanceitannouncedagreatreligiousdisputationtobeheldinJanuary1523,towhichbothZwingliandhisopponentsweresummonedfortheexplanationanddefenceoftheirviews。Zwingliputforwardsixty-seventheses,theprincipalofwhichwerethattheBibleisthesoleruleoffaith,thattheChurchisnotavisiblesocietybutonlyanassemblyoftheelect,ofwhichbodyChrististheonlytruehead,thatconsequentlythejurisdictionofthePopeandofthebishopsisausurpationdevoidofscripturalauthority,thattheMass,Confession,Purgatory,andIntercessionoftheSaintsaretoberejectedasderogatorytothemeritsofChrist,andfinally,thatclericalcelibacyandmonasticvows,insteadofbeingcounselsofperfection,areonlycloaksforsinandhypocrisy。TheBishopofConstancerefusedtotakepartinsuchadisputation。Hisvicar-general,JohannFaberofConstance,however,attendedthemeeting,notindeedtotakepartinthediscussionbutmerelytoprotestagainstitasopposedtotheauthorityoftheChurchandofthecouncils。Ashisprotestswereunheeded,heundertooktodefendthedoctrinesattacked,butintheendtheGrandCouncildeclaredthatthevictoryrestedwithZwingli。
FlushedwithhistriumphZwinglinowproceededtoputhistheoriesintopractice。SupportedbyamobheendeavouredtopreventthecelebrationofMass,religiousprocessions,theuseofpicturesandstatues,andthesolemnceremonialassociatedwithExtremeUnctionandtheViaticum。HecompiledanintroductiontotheNewTestamentfortheuseoftheclergy,calleduponthemtoabandontheirobligationsofcelibacy,andsetthemanexamplebytakingashiswifeawomanwhohadbeenforyearshisconcubine。Heandhisfollowers,supportedbythemajorityoftheGrandCouncil,wentthroughthecitydestroyingaltars,pictures,statues,organs,andconfessionals,anderectinginplaceofthealtarsplaintableswithaplateforbreadandavesselforwine。TheCatholicmembersoftheGrandCouncilweredrivenfromtheirposition,andCatholicworshipforbiddeninZurich1523-5。
ThesystemofZwingliwasmuchmorerationalisticand,inacertainsense,muchmorelogicalthanthatofLuther。Imbuedwiththeprinciplesofpantheisticmysticism,hemaintainedthatGodisinHimselfallbeing,createdaswellasuncreated,andallactivity。
Henceitwasasabsurdtospeakofindividuallibertyorindividualactionastospeakofamultiplicityofgods。Whetheritwasacaseofdoinggoodordoingevilmanwasbutamachinelikeabrushinthehandsofapainter。InregardtosinhecontendedmanmaybepunishedforviolatingthelawlaiddownbyGodeventhoughtheviolationisunavoidable,butGod,beingabovealllaw,isnowisetoblame。
Concupiscenceorself-loveis,accordingtohim,attherootofallmisdeeds。Itisinitselftherealoriginalsin,andisnotblottedoutbyBaptism。HisteachingontheScriptures,individualjudgment,ecclesiasticalauthorityasrepresentedbythebishops,councils,andPope,goodworks,indulgences,purgatory,invocationofthesaints,andvowsofchastitydifferedbutslightlyfromwhatLutherhadputforward。OnthequestionofJustification,andparticularlyonthedoctrineoftheEucharist,thetworeformersfoundthemselvesinhopelessconflict。[3]
Zwingli'steachingdidnotatfirstfindmuchfavourinotherportionsofGermanSwitzerland。Lucernedeclaredagainstitin1524。Thecityauthoritiesforbadetheintroductionofthenewteaching,andofferedanasylumtothoseCatholicswhohadbeenforcedtofleefromZurich。
OthercantonsassociatedthemselveswithLucerne,andadeputationwassenttoZurichtorequestthecityauthoritiestoabandonZwingliandtotakepartinageneralmovementforarealandconstitutionalreform。ButtheGrandCouncil,mindfulofthepoliticaladvantageswhichwouldaccruetoZurichfromitsleadershipinthenewreligiousrevolt,declinedtorecedefromtheirposition。
WhileZwingliwasatworkinZurich,Oecolampadius1482-1531sethimselftostirupreligiousdivisionsinBasle。HewasbornatWeisnberg,studiedlawatBolognaandtheologysubsequentlyatHeidelberg,wasordainedpriest,andappointedtoaparishinBasle1512。WithErasmushewasontermsoftheclosestintimacy,and,asBaslewasthenoneofthegreatliterarycentresoftheworld,hesoonbecameacquaintedwithLuther'spamphletsandteaching。SomeoftheclergyinBasle,notablyWolfgangCapito,awarmfriendofZwingli,werealreadyshowingsignsofrestlessnessespeciallyinregardtotheMass,purgatory,andinvocationofthesaints,andOecolampadiuswasnotslowtoimbibethenewideas。In1518hewasappointedpreacherintheCathedralofAugsburg,but,havingresignedthisofficeonaccountoffailinghealth,hewithdrewtotheconventofAltmunster,where,forsometime,helivedaretiredlife。Subsequentlyheactedaschaplaintothewell-knownGermanknight,FranzvonSickingen,andfinally,in1524,heacceptedtheparishofSt。Martin'sinBasle。
HenowproclaimedhimselfopenlyasupporterofZwingli,advocatedthenewteachingonjustificationandgoodworks,andattackedseveralCatholicdoctrinesandpractices。Forhim,asindeedformostoftheotherreformers,clericalcelibacywasthegreatstumblingblock。Heencouragedhisfollowersbytakingashiswifeayoungwidow,whowassubsequentlyinturnthewifeofthetworenownedLutheranpreachers,ButzerandCapito。Atfirstthecityauthoritiesandalargebodyoftheuniversityprofessorswereagainsthim,butowingtothedisturbancescreatedbyhispartisansfulllibertyofworshipwasgrantedtothenewsect1527。Notcontentwiththisconcession,theydemandedthattheMassshouldbesuppressed。In1529thefollowersofOecolampadiusroseinrevolt,seizedthearsenalofthecity,directedthecannonontheprincipalsquares,andattackedthechurches,destroyingaltars,statues,andpictures。Erasmus,disgustedwithsuchmethodsofpropagatingreligion,leftBasleandsoughtahomeinFreiburg。TheCatholicswereexpelledfromthecitycouncil,theirreligionwasproscribed,andBaslejoinedhandswithZurichinitsrebellionagainsttheChurch。
TherevoltsoonspreadintoothercantonsofSwitzerland。InBerneandSchaffhausenbothpartieswerestronganddetermined,andforatimetheissueoftheconflictwasuncertain,butin1528thepartyofZwingliandOecolampadiussecuredtheupperhand。SimilarlyinSt。
Gall,Glarus,etc。,victoryrestedwiththenewteaching。Othercantons,asforexample,Solothurn,waveredastowhichsidetheyshouldtake,butthethreeoldestcantonsofSwitzerland,Uri,SchweizandUnterwalden,togetherwithZug,FreiburgandLucerne,refusedtobeseparatedfromtheChurch。
Apartaltogetherfromthequestionofreligion,therewasanaturaloppositionbetweenpopulousandmanufacturingcentreslikeBerneandBasle,andtheruralcantons,devotedalmostentirelytoagriculturalandpastoralpursuits。Whenreligiousdifferencessupervenedtoaccentuatetherivalryalreadyinexistence,theyledalmostinevitablytothedivisionofSwitzerlandintotwohostilecamps。
Zurich,Basle,Berne,Schaffhausen,andSt。Gall,thoughtheywerethemostimportantcities,soonfoundthemselvesunabletoforcetheirviewsontherestofthecountry,astheywerewithstoodbythefederalcouncil,themajorityofwhichwasstillCatholic。Thelatterinsistedthataconferenceshouldbeheldtosettlethereligiousdisputes。TheconferencewasarrangedtotakeplaceatBadenin1526。
Eck,assistedbytwootherCatholictheologians,FaberandMurner,undertooktodefendtheCatholicposition。Zurichrefusedtosendrepresentatives,butthereformingpartywererepresentedbyOecolampadius,Haller,andothersoftheirleaders。Theconferencewasattendedbydelegatesfromtwelvecantons,andwasapprovedofbytheSwissbishops。AfteradiscussionlastingfifteendaysduringwhichEckdefendedtheCatholicdoctrineregardingtheMass,Eucharist,Purgatory,andtheIntercessionoftheSaints,themajorityofthecantonsdecidedinhisfavour,andaresolutionwaspassedforbiddingreligiouschangesinSwitzerlandandprohibitingthesaleoftheworksofLutherandZwingli。
Itwassoonevident,however,thatpeacecouldnotbesecuredbysuchmeasures。TheruralandCatholiccantonswereinthemajority,muchtothedisgustofflourishingcitieslikeBerneandZurich。Thesestates,believingthattheywereentitledtoacontrollingvoiceinthefederalcouncil,determinedtousethereligiousquestiontobringaboutacompletechangeintheconstitutionofthecountrybyassigningthecantonalrepresentationinthefederalcouncilonthebasisofpopulation。TheyformedanalliancewiththeotherProtestantcantonsandwithConstancetoforwardtheirclaims1527-8,buttheCatholiccantonsimitatedtheirexamplebyorganisingaCatholicfederationtowhichtheArchduke,FerdinandofAustria,promisedhissupport1529。
Zwingliwasmosteagerforwar,andathisinstigationthearmyofZurich,backedbyBerne,tookthefieldin1529。TheCatholicstates,however,madeitclearthattheywerebothableandwillingtodefendtheconstitution,butthebondofnationalunityandthedislikeofcivilwarexercisedsuchaninfluenceonbothpartiesthataconflictwasavertedbytheconclusionofthePeaceofKappel1529。TheconcessionssecuredforhispartybythisPeacedidnotsatisfyZwingli,whodesirednothinglessthanthecompletesubjugationoftheCatholiccantons。NegotiationswereopenedupwithPhilipofHesse,withtheGermanLutherans,andwithFrancisI。ofFrance,andwhenthenewsoftheformationoftheLeagueofSchmalkaldreachedtheProtestantsofSwitzerland,itwasthoughtthatthetimehadcomewhenthetriumphofZurichandBerne,whichmeantalsothetriumphofthenewteaching,shouldbesecured。Zwinglibesoughthisfollowerstoissueadeclarationofwar,butitwassuggestedthatthereductionoftheCatholiccantonscouldbesecuredjustaseffectivelybyablockade。InthismovementZurichtookthelead。Theresult,however,didnotcoincidewiththeanticipationsofZwingli。TheCatholiccantonsflewtoarmsatonce,andastheirterritoriesformedacompactunit,theywereabletoputtheirunitedarmyintothefieldbeforetheforcesofZurichandBernecouldeffectajunction。ThedecisivebattletookplaceatKappelinOctober1531,whentheZwinglianssufferedacompletedefeat,ZwinglihimselfandfivehundredofthebestmenofZurichbeingleftdeadonthefield。ThearmyofBerneadvancedtoolatetosavetheiralliesortochangetheresultofthewar。TheCatholiccantonsusedtheirvictorywithgreatmoderation。Insteadofcrushingtheiropponents,astheymighthavedone,theyconcludedwiththemthesecondPeaceofKappel1531。
Accordingtothetermsofthistreaty,nocantonwastoforceanothertochangeitsreligion,andlibertyofworshipwasguaranteedinthecantonaldomains。SeveralofthedistrictsthathadbeenwaveringreturnedtotheCatholicfaith,andtheabbotofSt。Gallwasrestoredtotheabbeyfromwhichhehadbeenexpelled。
OecolampadiusfollowedZwinglitothegraveinashorttime,havingbeencarriedoffbyafeveraboutamonthafterthedefeatofKappel,andtheleadershipofthemovementdevolvedupontheirsuccessors,BullingerandMyconius。
WithregardtotheSacramentsLutherandZwingliagreedthattheywereonlysignsofgrace,thoughintheexplanationofthisviewZwingliwasmuchmoreextreme,becausemuchmorelogical,thanLuther。
Believingashedidthatjustificationdependeduponfaithalone,hecontendedthattheSacramentsweremereceremoniesbywhichamanbecameorshowedhimselftobeafollowerofChrist。Theyweredevoidofanyobjectivevirtue,andwereefficaciousonlyinsofarastheyguaranteedthattheindividualreceivingthempossessedthefaithnecessaryforjustification。ButitwasprincipallyinregardtotheEucharistthatthetworeformersfoundthemselvesinhopelessdisagreement。HadLutherwishedtobeconsistentheshouldhavethrownovertheRealPresenceaswellasTransubstantiation,buttheforceoftradition,thefearthatanysuchteachingwouldarousetheoppositionofthepeople,andtheplainmeaningofthetextsofScriptureforcedhimtoadoptacompromise。"HadDoctorCarlstadt,"hewrote,"oranyoneelsebeenabletopersuademefiveyearsagothatthesacramentofthealtarisbutbreadandwinehewould,indeed,havedonemeagreatservice,andrenderedmeverymaterialaidinmyeffortstomakeabreachinthePapacy。Butitisallinvain。Themeaningofthetextsissoevidentthateveryartificeoflanguagewillbepowerlesstoexplainitaway。"Hecontendedthatthewords"ThisisMybodyandThisisMyblood"couldbearonlyonemeaning,namely,thatChristwasreallypresent,butwhileagreeingwithCatholicsabouttheRealPresenceofChristintheEucharist,herejectedthedoctrineofTransubstantiation,maintaininginitsplaceConsubstantiationorImpanation。
ThoughLutherinsistedsostronglyontheRealPresence,itisnotclearthatinthebeginninghehadanyveryfixedviewsonthesubject,orthathewouldhavebeenunwillingtochangeanyviewshehadformed,wereitnotthatoneofhislieutenants,Carlstadt,begantoexercisehisprivilegeofjudgmentbyrejectingtheRealPresence。
SuchanactofinsubordinationarousedtheimplacableireofLuther,whodenouncedhisformercolleagueasaheretic,andpursuedhimfromWittenbergandJena,wherehehadfledforrefuge。IntheendCarlstadtwasobligedtoretiretoSwitzerland,wherehisdoctrinefoundfavourwiththeSwissreformers。
FromthebeginningofhiscampaignZwinglirealisedthattheRealPresencewasnotinharmonywithhistheoryofjustification,andhencehewasinclinedtoholdthattheEucharistwasameresigninstitutedasareminderofChrist'sdeath。ButinviewofthecleartestimonyoftheHolyScripturehewasatalosshowtojustifyhisposition。Atlastbyponderingonotherpassagesthatheconsideredsimilartothetext"ThisisMybody,"wheretheword"is"shouldbeinterpreted"signifies,"hecontendedthatthetruemeaningofChrist'swordsattheLastSupperis,"ThissignifiesMybody。"
Oecolampadiusagreedwiththisinterpretation,thoughforadifferentreason,comparingtheBlessedEucharisttoaringthatahusbandgoingawayonalongjourneymightgivetohiswifeasapledgeandreminderofhisaffection。[4]
Lutherresentedbitterlysuchatheoryasanattackuponhisauthority,especiallyasZwinglirefusedtoallowhimselftobebrow-
beatenintoretractinghisdoctrine。Insteadofsubmittingtothenewreligiousdictator,ZwinglisoughttojustifyhimselfbytheveryprinciplebywhichLutherjustifiedhisownrevoltagainsttheCatholicChurch。HecontendedthatLuther'stheoryofjustificationinvolvedlogicallytherejectionoftheEucharistaswellasoftheotherSacraments,thattheScripturaltextscouldbeinterpretedashehadinterpretedthem,andthathewasnotboundtotakeanycognisanceoftheChristiantraditionoroftheauthorityofthecouncils。HecomplainedthatLuthertreatedhimselfandhisfollowersashereticswithwhomitwasnotrighttoholdcommunion,thatheproscribedtheirwritingsanddenouncedthemtothemagistrates,andthathedidpreciselytowardsthemwhatheblamedthePopefordoingtohimself。
Lutherfounditdifficulttomeetthislineofargument。MuchagainsthiswillhewasobligedtosupporthisopinionsbyappealingtothetraditionoftheChurchandthewritingsoftheFathers,whichlatterhehaddenouncedas"fetidpoolswhenceChristianshavebeendrinkingunwholesomedraughtsinsteadofslakingtheirthirstfromthepurefountainofHolyScripture。"[5]"ThisarticleTheEucharist,"hewrote,"isneitherunscripturalnoradogmaofhumaninvention。ItisbasedupontheclearandirrefragablewordsofHolyWrit。IthasbeenuniformlyheldandbelievedthroughoutthewholeChristianworldfromthefoundationoftheChurchtothepresenttime。ThatsuchhasbeenthefactisattestedbythewritingsoftheHolyFathers,bothGreekandLatin,bydailyusageandbytheuninterruptedpracticeoftheChurch……Todoubtit,therefore,istodisbelievetheChristianChurchandtobrandherasheretical,andwithhertheprophets,apostles,andChristHimself,who,inestablishingtheChurchsaid:
'BeholdIamwithyoualldayseventotheconsummationoftheworld。'"[6]
TheoppositionofLutherdidnotputanendtothecontroversy。TheZwingliantheoriesspreadrapidlyinSwitzerland,whencetheywerecarriedintoGermany,muchtotheannoyanceofLutherandoftheProtestantprincesforwhomreligiousunitywasnecessaryatalmostanycost。Lutherwouldlistentonoschemesofcompromise。HedenouncedtheZwingliansinthemostviolentterms,asservantsofthedevil,liars,andhereticsforwhosesalvationnomanshouldpray。
HavingrejectedTransubstantiationinordertoridhimselfofthesacrificialideaandofthedoctrineofaChristianpriesthood,hefoughtstronglyfortheRealPresenceonthegroundthatGod'sbody,beingunitedtothedivinity,enjoyedthedivineattributeofubiquity。TothisZwinglimadetheveryeffectiverejoinderthatifthewordsofScripture"ThisisMybodyandthisisMyblood"aretobeinterpretedliterallytheycouldbearonlythesenseputuponthembytheCatholics,becauseChristdidnotsay"Mybodyisinorunderthisbread,"butrather"ThisthebreadisMybody。"Furthermore,hepointedoutthatLuther'sexplanationconcerningtheubiquityofChrist'sbodyledclearlytoaconfusionofthedivineandhumannatureofChrist,andwasinconsequenceonlyarenewaloftheMonophysiteheresy,condemnedbythewholeChristianChurch。
ThisunseemlydisputebetweenthetwoleadersofthenewmovementdidnotpleasetheProtestantprincesofGermany,forwhomdivisionoftheirforcesmightmeanpoliticalextinction。TheElectorofSaxonysupportedLutherwarmly,whilePhilipofHessewasmoreorlessinclinedtosidewithZwingli。AconferencewasarrangedbetweenthetwopartiesatMarburg1529,atwhichLutherandOecolampadiuswerepresenttodefendtheirviews。Onafewsecondarymattersanagreementwasarrivedat,butonthemainquestion,theRealPresence,Lutherwouldyieldnothing,andsotheReformersweredividedintotwoparties,GermanLutheransandSwissReformed——
[1]/PrecisHistoriquedel'AbbayeetduPelerinagedeNotre-Dame-des-
Ermites/,1870。
[2]/Realencycl。furProtestantischeTheol。/,xxi。,p。778。
[3]Schwane,op。cit。,p。141。
[4]Schwane,op。cit。,p。349。
[5]Dollinger,/DieReformation/,i。,pp。430-51。
[6]Alzog,iii。,256-7。
cNorthernEurope。
Seebibliography,chap。ii。a。Karup,/GeschichtederKatholischenKircheinDanemark/,1863。Munter,/KirchengeschichtevonDanemarkundNorwegen/,1823。Theiner-Cohen,/LaSuedeetlaSaint-SiegesouslesroisJeanIII。,SigismondIII。,etCharlesIX。/,1842。Butler,/TheReformationinSweden/,1884。DeFlaux,/LaSuedeauXVImesiecle/,1861。Englestoft,/ReformantesetCatholicitempore,quosacraemendatasunt,inDaniaconcertantes/,1836。Schmitt,/DieVerteidigungderKathol。KircheinDanemarkgegendieReligionsneuerungim16enJahr/,1899。
/ConfutatioLutheranismiDanici/,etc。written1530,ed。1902。
AtthebeginningofthesixteenthcenturypoliticalpowerinDenmarkwasvestedtoagreatextentinthehandsofthebishopsandnobles。
Itwasbythesetwopartiesthatthekingwaselected,andsogreatwastheirinfluencethat,asarule,thecandidatechosenbytheirvoteswasobligedtoacceptanyconditionstheycaredtoimpose。Thebishops,asinmostcountriesatthetime,heldenormousestates,grantedtotheirpredecessorsbythecrownorbequeathedbygenerousbenefactorsforthemaintenanceofreligion。Unfortunately,withsomeexceptions,theywerenotmenzealousforreligiousinterests,orcapableofunderstandingthataseriouscrisiswasathand。Ineverydirectiontheneedofreformwasonlytooapparent,and,assuchasworkhadnotbeenundertakenbythosewhoshouldhaveundertakenit,asplendidopportunitywasaffordedtothemenwhodesirednotthewelfareofreligionbutrathertheoverthrowoftheChurch。
ChristianII。1513-23wishedtoputanendtothesupremacyofthebishopsandnoblesandtoassertforhimselfandhissuccessorsabsolutecontrol。Hewasamanofgreatabilityanddetermination,wellacquaintedwiththetendenciesoftheage,andnotparticularlyscrupulousaboutthemeansbywhichthesuccessofhispolicymightbeassured。TosuchamanLuther'sattackonthebishopsofGermanyseemedtobealmostprovidential。Herealisedthatbyembracingthenewreligioussystem,whichenabledhimtoseizethewealthoftheChurchandtoconcentrateinhisownhandsfullecclesiasticalpower,hecouldridhimselfofoneofthegreatestobstaclestoabsolutism,andsecureforhimselfandhissuccessorsundisputedswayinDenmark。
Thoughhisownlifewasscandalouslyimmoralhedeterminedtobecomethechampionofareligiousreformation,andagainstthewishesofthenobles,clergy,andpeopleheinvitedadiscipleofLuther'stoCopenhagen,andplacedathisdisposaloneofthecity'schurches。
Thissteparousedthestrongestopposition,butChristian,confidentthatboldnessmeantsuccess,adoptedsternmeasurestoovercomehisopponents。Heproclaimedhimselfthepatronofthosepriestswhowerewillingtodisregardtheirvowsofcelibacy,issuedregulationsagainsttheunmarriedclergy,andappealedtothepeopleagainstthebishopsandthenobles。AstheArchbishop-electofLundwasunwillingtoshowhimselftobecoercedintobetrayingtheinterestsconfidedtohischarge,thekingcommandedthatheshouldbeputtodeath。
Bytheseviolentmethodshehadhopedtofrightenhissubjectsintocompliancewithhiswishes,buthewasdoomedtospeedyandcompletedisappointment。Thebishopsandbarons,thoughdividedonmanyquestions,wereatoneintheirresistancetosuchdespotism,andtheyhadbehindthemthegreatbodyofthepeople,whohadlittleifanydesireforareligiousrevolution。ChristianII。wasdeposed,andinhisplacehisuncle,FrederickI。1523-33,becamekingofDenmark。
AthiscoronationthenewmonarchpledgedhimselftodefendtheCatholicreligionandtosuppressheresy。Soon,however,motivessimilartothosethathadinfluencedhispredecessorinducedhimalsotoleantowardsLutheranism。Atfirsthiseffortsforthespreadofthenewteachingwerecarriedoutsecretly,butoncehefelthimselfsecureonthethrone,heproclaimedhimselfpubliclyaLutheran1526
andinvitedLutheranpreacherstothecapital。ADietwascalledin1527atOdenseetoconsiderthereligiouscontroversythathadarisen。
Inthisassemblytheking,basinghisdefenceonthegroundthatthoughhehadpledgedhimselftoprotecttheCatholicChurchhewasundernoobligationtotolerateabuses,contendedthatthesuppressionofabusesandthepurifyingofreligionweretheonlyobjectshehadatheartinthemeasuresthathehadtaken。Owingmainlytohisownstubbornnessandthecowardlyandwaveringattitudeofthebishops,itwasagreedbytheDietthattillaGeneralCouncilcouldbeconvokedfulltolerationshouldbegiventotheLutheranpreachers,thatinthemeantimenocivildisabilitiesshouldbeinflictedonsupportersofthenewreligion,thatthoseoftheclergywhowishedtomarryshouldbeallowedtodoso,thatthearchbishopshouldapplynolongertoRomeforhispallium,andfinallythattheconfirmationoftheappointmentofbishopsshouldbetransferredfromthePopetotheking。
Bythesemeasures,towhichthebishopsofferedonlyafaintopposition,DenmarkwasseparatedpracticallyfromtheHolySee,andthefirststepwastakenontheroadthatwastoleadtonationalapostasy。ThenextimportantmeasurewasthedisputationarrangedbythekingtotakeplaceatCopenhagenin1529。TheveryfactthatatthismeetingnoDanishecclesiasticcapableofdefendingtheCatholicfaithwastobefound,andthatitwasnecessarytohaverecoursetoGermanyforchampionsoforthodoxy,isinitselfasufficientindicationofthecharacterofthebishopswhothenruledinDenmark,andofthestateoflearningamongsttheDanishclergyoftheperiod。
EckandCochlaeuswereinvitedtocometoCopenhagen,butastheyhadsufficientworktoengagetheirattentionathome,thedutyofupholdingCatholicdoctrinedevolveduponStagefyr,atheologianofCologne。[1]HecouldnotspeakDanish,norwouldtheLutheranpartyconsenttocarryontheconferenceinLatin。Furthermore,heclaimedthattheauthorityoftheFathersandthedecreesofpreviousGeneralCouncilsshouldberecognised,buttheLutheransinsistedthattheBiblewastheonlysourcefromwhichChristiansshouldreceivetheirdoctrines。Inthesecircumstances,sinceadisputationwasimpossible,bothpartiesagreedtosubmitafullstatementoftheirviewsinwritingtothekingandcouncil,who,asmighthavebeenanticipated,decidedinfavourofLutheranism。
Duringtheremainderofhisreign,FrederickI。sparednopainstosecurethevictoryforthenewteachinginhisdominions。Thenobleswerewonovertotheking'sviewsbypromisesofashareinthepartitionofecclesiasticalproperty,andthosewhowishedtostandwellwiththesovereignwerenotslowinhavingrecoursetoviolenceasaffordingproofthattheirzealforLutheranismwassincere。
ConsequentlytheLutheranpartyfoundthemselvesinamajorityintheDietof1530,andwerepowerfulenoughtodoastheypleased。InaccordancewiththeexamplesetinGermanyandSwitzerlandattackswerebegunonchurches,pictures,andstatues,butinmanyplacesthepeoplewerenotpreparedforsuchchanges,andbitterconflictstookplacebetweentherivalparties。Intheconfusionthatresultedthesupportersofthedeposedkingroseinarmsagainsthissuccessfulrival,andthecountrywassubjectedtothehorrorsofcivilwar。
FrederickI。founditnecessarytoabandontheviolentpropagationofLutheranismandtooffertolerationtotheCatholics。
Onhisdeathin1533thebishopsofDenmarkprotestedagainstthesuccessionofhissonChristianIII。1533-51whowasapersonalfriendofLuther,andwhohadalreadyintroducedProtestantismintohisownstateofHolstein;butasthenobles,wonoverbypromisesofashareinthespoliationoftheChurch,refusedtomakecommoncausewiththebishops,theirprotestwasunheeded。Confidentthathecouldrelyonthesupportofthenobles,thekinggavesecretinstructionstohisofficialsthatonacertaindaynamedbyhimallthebishopsofDenmarkshouldbearrestedandlodgedinprison。Hisorderswerecarriedouttotheletter1536,andsorejoicedwasLutherbythisstepthathehastenedtosendthekinghiswarmestcongratulations。
ThebishopswereofferedreleaseonconditionthattheyshouldresigntheirSeesandpledgethemselvestooffernofurtheroppositiontothereligiouschange。Totheirshamebeitsaidthatonlyoneoftheirnumber,Ronnow,BishopofRoskilde,refusedtoacceptlibertyonsuchdisgracefulterms,preferringtoremainaprisoneruntilhewasreleasedbydeath1544。Thepriestswhorefusedtoacceptthenewreligionweredrivenfromtheirparishes,andseveralmonasteriesandconventsweresuppressed。
TocompletetheworkofreformandtogivetheChurchinDenmarkanewconstitutionBugenhagen,adiscipleofLuther,wasinvitedtothecapital1539。HebeganbycrowningthekingaccordingtoLutheranritual,andbydrawingupaformofecclesiasticalgovernmentthatplacedfullspiritualpowerinthehandsofthecivilruler。AsinGermany,superintendentswereappointedinroomofthebishopswhohadresigned。WhentheworkofdrawingupthenewecclesiasticalorganisationhadbeenfinisheditwassubmittedtoandapprovedofbytheDietheldatOdenseein1539。InanotherDietheldin1546theCatholicChurchinDenmarkwascompletelyoverthrown,herpossessionswereconfiscated,herclergywereforbiddentoremaininthecountryunderpenaltyofdeath,andalllayCatholicsweredeclaredincapableofholdinganyofficeinthestateoroftransmittingtheirpropertytotheirCatholicheirs。BythosemeasuresCatholicismwassuppressed,andvictorywassecuredfortheLutheranparty。
Norway,whichwasunitedwithDenmarkatthisperiod,wasforcedintosubmissiontothenewcreedbytheviolenceoftheDanishkings,aidedastheywerebythegreedynoblesanxioustoshareintheplunderoftheChurch。SimilarlyIceland,whichwassubjecttoDenmark,wasseparatedfromRome,thoughatfirstthepeopleofferedthestrongestresistancetothereformers。Theexecution,however,oftheirbishop,JohnAresen,theexampleofDenmarkandNorway,andthewantofcapablereligiousleadersproducedtheireffects,andintheendIcelandwasinducedtoacceptthenewreligion1551。ForaconsiderabletimeCatholicismretaineditsholdonalargepercentageofthepeoplebothinNorwayandIceland,buttheseveremeasurestakenbythegovernmenttoensurethecompleteextirpationoftheCatholichierarchyandpriesthoodledalmostofnecessitytothetriumphofLutheranism。
BytheUnionofKalmar1397Sweden,Norway,andDenmarkwereunitedundertheruleoftheKingofDenmark。TheUniondidnot,however,bringaboutpeace。ThepeopleofSwedendislikedtheruleofaforeigner,andmorethanoncetheyroseinrebellionagainstDenmark。
Intheabsenceofastrongcentralauthoritytheclergyandnoblesbecamethedominantfactorsinthestate,especiallyastheytooktheleadinthenationalagitationsagainstKingErikandhissuccessors。
Asinmostothercountriesatthetime,theChurchwasexceedinglywealthy,thebishopricsandabbaciesbeingendowedverygenerously,butunfortunately,aselsewhere,theprogressofreligionwasnotinproportiontotheworldlypossessionsofitsministers。Endowmenthaddestroyedthelibertyofelectionsoessentialforgoodadministration,withtheresultthatthebishopsandotherecclesiasticaldignitarieswereselectedwithoutmuchregardfortheirqualificationsasspiritualguides。Yetitmustbesaidthatingeneraltheadministratorsoftheecclesiasticalpropertywerenothardtask-masterswhencomparedwiththeirlaycontemporaries,norwasthereanythinglikeastrongpopularfeelingagainsttheChurch。Stilltheimmensewealthofthereligiousinstitutions,theprevalenceofabuses,andthefailureoftheclergytoinstructthepeopleintherealdoctrinesoftheirfaithwereaconstantsourceofmenacetotheChurchinSweden,andleftitopentoacrushingattackbyaleaderwhoknewhowtowinthemassestohissidebyproclaiminghimselfthechampionofnationalindependenceandofreligiousreform。
In1515StenSture,theadministratorofSweden,supportedbytheBishopofLinkopingasleaderofthepopularparty,madeagallantattempttorallyhiscountrymentoshakeofftheDanishyoke。
UnfortunatelyforthesuccessofhisundertakinghesoonfoundadangerousopponentinthepersonofGustafTrolle,ArchbishopofUpsala,thenomineeandsupporteroftheKingofDenmark。ThearchbishopthrewthewholeweightofhisinfluenceintothescalesofDenmark,andpartlyowingtohisopposition,partlyowingtothewantofsufficientpreparationthenationaluprisingwascrushedearlyin1520。ChristianII。wascrownedKingofSwedenbytheArchbishopofUpsala。Hesignifiedhiselevationtothethronebyageneralmassacreofhisopponentswhichlastedfortwodays,andduringwhichmanyofthebestbloodofSwedenwereputtodeathNov。1520。ThearchbishopwasrewardedforhisservicestoDenmarkbyreceivinganappointmentasregionoradministratorofSweden。Heandhispartymadeloudboastoftheirpoliticalvictory,buthadtheybeengiftedwithalittleprudenceandzealtheywouldhavefoundgoodreasontoregretatriumphthathadbeensecuredbycommittingtheChurchtothesupportofaDanishtyrantagainstthewishesofthemajoritywhofavourednationalindependence。Religionandpatriotismwerebroughtintoseriousconflict,and,givenonlyacapableleaderwhowouldknowhowtoconducthiscampaignwithskill,itwasnotdifficulttoforeseetheresultsofsuchaconflict。
Asithappened,suchaleaderwasathandinthepersonofGustafEriksson,betterknownasGustavusVasa。HisfatherhadbeenputtodeathinthemassacreofStockholm,andhehimselfwhenayouthhadbeengivenasahostagetotheKingofDenmark。HemadehisescapeandfledtoLubeck,wherehewaskindlyreceived,andremaineduntilanopportunityaroseforhisreturntoSweden。HeplacedhimselfimmediatelyattheheadofthepartywillingtofightagainstDenmark,calleduponhiscountrymentorallytohisstandard,andinashorttimesucceededindrivingtheDanishforcesfromSweden。Hewasproclaimedadministratorofhiscountryin1521,andtwoyearslateranationalDietassembledatStrengnasofferedhimthecrown。
Suchanofferwasinexactaccordancewithhisownwishes。ButhehadnointentionofbecomingkingofSwedenmerelytoremainatoolinthehandsofthespiritualandlaylordsasthekingsofDenmarkhadremained。DeterminedinhisownmindtomakehimselfabsoluterulerofSwedenbycrushingthebishopsandbarons,herecognisedthatLuther'steaching,withwhichhewasfamiliarowingtohisstayatLubeck,heldoutgoodhopesforthesuccessofsuchaproject。ThewarmattachmentoftheBishopofUpsalafortheDanishfactionhadweakenedthedevotionofthepeopletotheChurch,andhadpreparedthewayforthechangewhichGustavuscontemplated。SomeoftheSwedishecclesiastics,notablythebrothersOlafandLaurencePeterson,bothstudentsofWittenberg,theformerawell-knownpreacheratStockholm,thelatteraprofessoratUpsala,werestronglyLutheranintheirtendencies,andwerereadytoassisttheking。ThoughinhisletterstoRomeandinhispublicpronouncementsGustavusprofessedhimselftobeasinceresonoftheChurch,anxiousonlytopreventatallcoststhespreadofLutheranisminhisdominions,hewastakingstepssecretlytoencouragehisLutheransupportersandtoridhimselfofthebishopsandmembersofthereligiousordersfromwhomhefearedseriousopposition。Aswasdoneelsewhere,hearrangedforapublicdisputationatwhichOlafPetersonundertooktodefendthemainprinciplesadvocatedbyLuther,buttheresultsofthecontroversywerenotsosatisfactoryforhispartyashehadanticipated。
Gustavusnowthrewoffthemaskofhypocrisy,andcameforwardboldlyasthechampionofthenewreligion。Heremovedthosebishopswhoweremostoutspokenintheiropposition,banishedtheDominicanswhostoodloyaltoRome,andtriedtoforcetheclergytoacceptthechange。
AnxioustoenrichhistreasurybyconfiscatingthewealthoftheChurchhescatteredbroadcastLuther'spamphletontheconfiscationofecclesiasticalproperty,andengagedtheprofessorsoftheUniversityofUpsalatousetheireffortstodefendandpopularisetheviewsitcontained。Acommissionwasappointedtomakeaninventoryofthegoodsofthebishopsandreligiousinstitutionsandtoinducethemonasteriestomakeavoluntarysurrenderoftheirproperty。Bymeansofthreatsandpromisesthecommissionerssecuredcompliancewiththewishesofthekinginsomedistricts,thoughinothers,asforexampleinUpsala,thearrivalofthecommissionledtoscenesofthegreatestviolenceandcommotion。Moreseveremeasureswerenecessarytooverawethepeople,andGustavuswasnotamantohesitateatanythinglikelytopromotethesuccessofhisplans。BishopJakobsonandsomeoftheclergywerearrested,andafterhavingbeentreatedwitheveryspeciesofindignitywereputtodeath1527。
Inthisyear,1527,anationalDietwasheldatVesterasprincipallyforthediscussionofthereligiousdifficultiesthathadarisen。Bothparties,thesupportersoftheoldandofthenew,musteredtheirforcesforafinalconflict。Gustavustookthesideoftheso-calledreformers,andproposedthemeasureswhichhemaintainedwererequiredbothintheinterestsofreligionandofthepublicweal。TheCatholicpartywereslightlyinthemajorityandrefusedtoassenttotheseproposals。Gustavus,thoughdisappointedattheresult,didnotdespair。HeannouncedtotheDietthatinviewofitsrefusaltoagreetohistermshecouldundertakenolongerthegovernmentanddefenceofthecountry。Ameasuresuchasthis,calculatedtoleadtoanarchyandpossiblytoanewsubjugationofthecountrybyDenmark,wasregardedbybothsidesasanationaldisaster,andsecuredforthekingthesupportofthewaverers。ThemassesofthepeoplewerealarmedlesttheiroppositionmightleadtotherestorationofDanishtyranny,whilethesupportofthenobleswassecuredbythepublicationofadecreeauthorisingthemtoresumepossessionofallpropertyhandedoverbytheirancestorstoreligiousinstitutionsforthelasteightyyears。TheremainderofthepossessionsoftheChurchwereappropriatedfortheroyaltreasury。Thekingnowissuedaproclamationinfavourofthenewreligion,insistedontheadoptionofaliturgyinthevulgartongue,andabolishedclericalcelibacy。AttheNationalAssemblyofOrebro1529theCatholicreligionwasabolishedinfavourofLutheranism,andtwoyearslaterLaurencePetersonwasappointedfirstLutheranArchbishopofUpsala。
ThoughtheLutheranteachinghadbeenaccepted,greatcarewastakennottoshockthepeoplebyanyviolentchange。EpiscopalgovernmentoftheChurchwasretained;mostoftheCatholicritualinregardtothesacramentsandtheMasswasadoptedinthenewliturgy,andeveninsomecasesthepicturesandstatueswerenotremovedfromthechurches。ButtherevolutionthatGustavushadmostatheartwasfullyaccomplished。TheauthorityofthePopehadbeenoverthrown,andinhisplacethekinghadbeenacceptedastheheadoftheSwedishChurch。NordidtheLutheranbishopsfindthemselvesintheenjoymentofgreaterlibertyandrespectasaresultoftheirtreasontotheChurch。Gustavuswarnedthemthattheymustnotcarrythemselveslikelords,andiftheywouldattempttowieldtheswordhewouldknowhowtodealwiththeminasummarymanner。ResentingsuchdictationandtyrannytheybegantoattackGustavusintheirsermonsandtoorganiseplotsfortheoverthrowofhisgovernment。Theconspiracywasdiscovered1540。OlafandLaurencePeterson,thetwoprominentleadersofthereformingparty,werecondemnedtodeath,butwerereprievedonthepaymentofalargefine。Laurencewas,however,removedfromhispositionasArchbishopofUpsala。IntheDietofVesterasin1544thecrownofSwedenwasdeclaredtobehereditary,andwasvestedinthefamilyandheirsofGustavus。Thusthewell-
consideredpolicyofGustavuswascrownedwithsuccess。BymeansoftheLutheranrevolthehadchangedthewholeconstitutionofthecountry,hadmadehimselfabsolutemasterofSweden,andhadsecuredthesuccessiontothethroneforhisownfamily。
Buthehadnotbrokenthepowerofhisopponentssocompletelyastobringpeacetohiscountry,nor,ifcredencebegiventotheproclamationsinwhichhebewailedtheincreaseofevilunderthepleaofevangelicalfreedom,didthereformedreligiontendtotheelevationofpublicmorals。Onhisdeathin1560hewassucceededbyhissonErikXIV。1560-9。Hardlyhadthenewkingbeenproclaimedthantheprincipleofprivatejudgmentintroducedbythereformersbegantoproduceitsnaturalresults。Calvinism,whichwassoopposedtoLutheranismbothindoctrineandinchurchgovernment,founditswayintoSweden,andattractedthefavourablenoticeoftheking。
RegardlessforthetimebeingoftheCatholicChurch,whichtoallappearanceswasdeadinSweden,thetwoparties,LutheransandCalvinists,struggledforsupremacy。ErikwaswonovertothesideoftheCalvinists,andmeasuresweretakentoovercometheLutheransbyforce,butthekinghadneitherthecapacitynortheenergyofhisfather。Theplanmiscarried;theCalvinistsweredefeated1568,andErikwasdeposedandimprisoned。
HisyoungerbrotherJohnsucceededtothethroneunderthetitleJohnIII。Hewasamanofconsiderableability,andwasbynomeanssatisfiedwiththenewreligion。HismarriagewithCatharine,sisterofSigismund,KingofPoland,herselfadevotedCatholic,whostipulatedforlibertytopracticeherreligion,helpedtomakehimmorefavourabletoaCatholicrevival。HesethimselftostudytheScripturesandwritingsoftheHolyFathersundertheguidanceofCatharine'schaplains,andconvincedhimselfthatheshouldreturntotheCatholicChurchandendeavourtorescuehiscountryfromtheconditionofheresyintowhichithadfallen。HeallowedthemonksandnunswhowerestillinSwedentoformcommunitiesagain,andendeavouredtowinovertheclergybyaseriesofordinancescouchedinaCatholictonewhichheissuedfortheirguidance。In1571heinducedtheArchbishopofUpsalatopublishanumberofregulationsknownasthe/Agenda/,whichbothinritualanddoctrineindicatedareturntoRome,andheemployedsomeJesuitmissionariestoexplainthemisrepresentationsofCatholicdoctrineindulgedinbytheLutheranandCalvinistleaders。HisgreatestdifficultyinbringingaboutareunionwasthepresenceofLutheranbishops,butfortunatelyforhimmanyofthemwereoldmenwhoseplacesweresoonvacantbydeath,towhoseSeesheappointedthoseuponwhomhecouldrelyforsupport。WhenhethoughtthetimewasripehesummonedaNationalSynodin1574,wherehedeliveredanaddressdeploringthesadconditiontowhichreligiousdissensionshadreducedthecountry。HepointedoutthatsuchastateofaffairshadbeenbroughtaboutbytheReformationandcouldberemediedonlybyareturntotheChurch。Theaddressreceivedfromtheclergyamuchmorefavourablereceptionthanhehadanticipated。AstheArchbishopricofUpsalawasvacant,hesecuredtheelectionofanarchbishop,whohavehisadhesiontoseventeenarticlesoffaithwhollysatisfactorytoCatholics,andwhoallowedhimselftobeconsecratedaccordingtotheCatholicritual。Hepromisedalsotousehisinfluencetosecuretheadhesionoftheotherbishops。In1576thekingissuedanewliturgy,/TheRedBookofSweden/,whichwasadoptedbytheDietin1577,andacceptedbyalargebodyoftheclergy。Itsprincipalwastheking'sbrother,Karl,DukeofSuthermanland,whoforpoliticalreasonshadconstitutedhimselfheadoftheLutheranparty,andwhorefusedtoagreewiththeRomantendenciesofthekingonthegroundthattheywereopposedtothelastwishesofGustavusandtothelawsofSweden。AdisputationwasarrangedtotakeplaceatUpsala,wheretheBelgianJesuit,LaurenceNicolai,vindicatedtriumphantlyagainsthisLutheranopponentstheCatholicteachingontheChurchandtheMass。CopiesofthecelebratedcatechismoftheBlessedPeterCanisiuswerecirculatedthroughoutSweden,andmadeanexcellentimpressiononthepeople。
Encouragedbythesehopefulsigns,thekingdespatchedanembassytoRometoarrangeforthereconciliationofSwedentotheChurch。Theroyalcommissionerswereinstructedtorequest,thatowingtothepeculiarcircumstancesofthecountry,permissionshouldbegivenforCommunionunderbothkinds,forthecelebrationoftheMassintheSwedishlanguage,andfortheabrogationofthelawofcelibacyatleastinregardtotheclergywhowerealreadymarried。GregoryXIII。,deeplymovedbytheking'sofferofareunion,senttheJesuit,AnthonyPossevin,ashislegatetodiscusstheterms。JohnsetanexamplehimselfbyabjuringpubliclyhiserrorsandbyannouncinghissubmissiontotheChurch1578。
AcommissionwasappointedatRometodiscusstheconcessionswhichthekingdemanded,andunfortunatelythedecisionwasregardedinSwedenasunfavourable。Awarmcontroversy,fomentedandencouragedbytheenemiesofreunion,brokeoutbetweentheopponentsandsupportersofthenewliturgy。DukeKarl,whohadnowbecomethehopeoftheLutheranparty,dideverythinghecouldtostirupstrife,whileatthesametimeRomerefusedtoacceptthetermsproposedbytheking。
IndignantatwhatheconsideredtheunreasonableattitudeoftheRomanauthorities,Johnbegantolosehisenthusiasmforhisreligiouspolicy,andafterthedeathofhiswifewhowasunwaveringinherdevotiontoherreligion,therewasnolongermuchhopethatSwedenwastobewonfromheresy1584。ThekingmarriedanotherwhowasstronglyLutheraninhersympathies,andwhousedherinfluenceoverhimtosecuretheexpulsionoftheJesuits。ThoughJohnIII。tooknofurtherstepstobringaboutreunionhecouldnotbeinducedtowithdrawtheliturgy,theuseofwhichheinsistedupontillhisdeathin1592。
HissonSigismundIII。shouldhavesucceeded。HewasanardentCatholicashismotherhadbeen,butashehadbeenelectedKingofPoland1586hewasabsentfromSwedenwhenthethronebecamevacantbythedeathofhisfather。DukeKarlandhisfriendsdidnotfailtotakeadvantageofhisabsence。WhentheSynodmetthesenatorsdemandedthatSigismundshouldaccepttheAugsburgConfessionasaconditionforhiselectiontothethrone。TothisSigismundsenttheonlyreplythatagoodCatholicandanhonestmancouldsend,namely,abluntrefusal。Hisuncle,DukeKarl,theactingregentofSweden,tookstepstoseducetheSwedishpeoplefromtheirallegiancetotheirlawfulking,andtopreparethewayforhisownaccession。HeproclaimedhimselftheprotectorofLutheranismandendeavouredtowinoverthebishopstohisside。InanationalAssemblyheldatUpsalaThe"Upsala-mote"1593afteraveryviolentaddressfromtheregentagainsttheCatholicChurch,thebishopsconfessedthattheyhadblunderedinacceptingtheliturgyofJohnIII。,andtheAssemblydeclareditselfstronglyinfavouroftheAugsburgConfession。
When,therefore,SigismundreturnedtoclaimthethronehefoundthatLutheranismwasentrenchedsafelyoncemore,andthateventhemostmoderateofthebishopsappointedbyhisfathermustbereckonedwithasopponents。TheclergyunitedwithDukeKarlinstirringupthepeopleagainsthim。Intheseconditionshewasforcedtoabandonhisprojectsofreform,andtoentrusthisunclewiththeadministrationofSwedenwhenhehimselfwasobligedtoreturntoPoland。WhileSigismundwasengagedinPoland,theregentconductedamostskilfulcampaign,nominallyonbehalfofProtestantism,butinrealitytosecurethedepositionofSigismundandhisownelectiontothethrone。
IntheDietofSuderkoping1595SigismundwascondemnedforhavingbestowedappointmentsonCatholicsandforhavingtoleratedtheCatholicreligioninhiskingdomofSweden,anditwasorderedthatallwhoprofessedthedoctrinesofRomeshouldabandontheirerrorswithinsixmonthsunderpainofexpulsionfromthecountry。TheArchbishopofUpsalamadeavisitationofthechurches,duringwhichheorderedthatallthosewhoabsentedthemselvesfromtheLutheranserviceshouldbefloggedinhispresence,thatthepictures,statues,andreliquariesshouldbedestroyed,andthattheliturgyintroducedbyJohnIII。shouldbeabolished。ThegreatestviolencewasusedtowardsthesupportersofKingSigismund,mostofwhomwereeitherCatholicoratleastfavourablyinclinedtowardsCatholicism。
EnragedbyadecreethatnoedictofthekingshouldhaveanybindingforceunlessconfirmedbytheSwedishDiet,anddriventodesperationbythetyrannyandoppressionoftheregent,someofSigismund'sfollowersraisedthestandardonbehalfoftheirking,andSigismundreturnedtoSwedenwithanarmyoffivethousandmen。Hefoundhimselfopposedbytheforcesoftheregentagainstwhomhewasatfirstsuccessful,butinhistreatmentofhisuncleandhisrebelfollowersheshowedhimselffartooforgiving。Inreturnforhiskindness,havingstrengthenedthemselvesbyalargearmytheyforcedhimtosubmittothedecisionofanationalAssemblytobeheldatJonkoping1599。AtthismeetingDukeKarlaccusedthekingofendeavouringtoplungeSwedenoncemoreintotheerrorsfromwhichithadbeenrescuedbythereformers。InMayofthesameyeararesolutionwaspasseddeclaringthatthekinghadforfeitedtheallegianceofhissubjectsunlessheyieldedtotheirdemands,andmoreespeciallyunlesshehandedoverhissonandheirtoberearedbytheregentasaProtestant。Manyofhissupporters,includingninemembersoftheCouncilofState,wereputtodeath。Finallyin1604Sigismundwasformallydeposed,andthecrownwasbestowedonhisuncle,DukeKarl,whobecamekingunderthetitleofCharlesIX。ProtestantismhadtriumphedatlastinSweden,butevenitsstrongestsupporterswouldhardlyliketomaintainthattheissuewasdecidedonreligiousgrounds,orthatthemeansadoptedbyCharlesIX。tosecurethevictorywereworthyoftheapostleofanewreligion——
[1]AFranciscan。Hewastheauthorofthe/ConfutatioLutheranismiDanici/,editedandpublished1902。
CHAPTERIII
PROGRESSOFCALVINISM
aInSwitzerland。
/CalviniJoannis,Operaquaesupersunt/inthe/Corp。
Reformatorum/,vols。xxix-lxxxvii。Doumergue,/JeanCalvin,leshommesetleschosesdesontemps/,1900-5。Kampschulte,/JohannCalvin,seineKircheundseinstaatinGenf/,1899。Fleury,/Histoiredel'EglisedeGeneve/,3vols。,1880。Mignet,/EtablissementdelareformereligieuseetconstitionducalvinismeaGeneve/,1877。Choisy,/LatheocratieaGeneveautempsdeCalvin/,1897。/CambridgeMod。History/,ii。,chap。xi。
Bibliography,769-83。Forcompletebibliography,see/Diction。
Theologique/art。Calvin。