Theselastarenotalwaysthemostscholarlynorthemostlearnednorthemostpatient,buttheyarethosewhopossessinahighdegreethatspecialvision,thatgift,properlyspeakingpoetic,whichisknownastheclinicaleye,whichatthefirstglanceperceivesandconfirmsthediagnosisinallitsdetail。
Fabrehasamindpropitioustosuchprocesses;andif,bychance,circumstanceshaddirectedhisattentiontomedicine,thatsciencewhichisbaseduponanabundantprovisionoffacts,butinwhichgoodsenseandakindofdivinationplayastillwiderpart,thereisnodoubtthathewouldhavebeencapableofbecomingashininglightinthisnewarena。
HewasfullofadmirationforthatotherillustriousVauclusian,Fran?oisRaspail7/16。,whosemedicalgeniusanticipatedPasteurandalltheconceptionsofmodernmedicine。Itwouldseemthathefoundinhimhisowntemper,hisownfashionofseeingandrepresentingthings。HelovedRaspail’sbooksandhisprescriptions,fullofreasonandamostjudiciousgoodsense,distrustingforhimselfandforhisfamilythecomplicatedformulaeandcunningremediesofanarttooconsideredandstillunproved。
AtCarpentras,whilehisfirst-born,émile,washoveringbetweenlifeanddeath,andthephysicianwhocametoseehim,“beingattheendofhisresources。”didnothingmoreforhimandsoonceasedtocome,thinkingthatthechildwouldnotlasttillthemorrow,FabreflewtotheworksofRaspail。
“Isearchedtodiscoverwhathismaladywas。Ifoundit,andhewastreateddayandnightaccordingly。To-dayheisconvalescent;andhisappetitehasreturned。Ibelieveheissaved,andIshallsay,likeAmbroiseParé,’I
havenursedhim;Godhascuredhim。’“7/17。
Theepisodewhichherelates,when,attheprimaryschoolofAvignon,aretorthadjustburst,“spurtinginalldirectionsitscontentsofvitriol。”rightinthemidstofthesuddenlyinterruptedchemistrylesson,andwhen,thankstohispromptaction,hesavedthesightofoneofhiscomrades,doeshonourtohisinitiativeandpresenceofmind。7/18。
While“allphysiciansshouldbowbeforethefactswhichheexcelsindiscovering“7/19。,hehasalsobeenabletomakedirectapplicationofthemarvelsofentomologytosomeoftheproblemsofhygieneandmedicine。
Hehasshownthattheirritantpoisonsecretedbycertaincaterpillars,“whichsetsthefingerswhichhandlethemonfire。”isnothingbutawasteproductoftheorganism,aderivativeofuricacid;hedoesnothesitatetoperformpainfulexperimentsonhimselfinordertofurnishtheproofofhistheory;andheexplainsthusthecuriouscasesofdermatitiswhichareoftenobservedamongsilkworm-breeders。7/20。Heprovestheuselessnessofourmeat-safesofmetallicgauze,intendedtopreservemeatagainstcontamination,andtheefficacyofamereenvelopeofpaper,notonlytopreservemeatfromflies,butalsoourgarmentsfromtheclothes-moth。
7/21。HerecommendsthecuriousProven?alrecipe,whichconsistsinboilingsuspectedmushroomsinsaltandwaterbeforeeatingthem。Finallyhesuggeststomembersofthemedicalprofessionthattheymightperhapsextractheroicremediesfromthesetreacherousvegetables。7/22。
Hehadneedofthatindefiniteleisurewhichhadhithertobeensowhollylacking,fortheeventsofephemerallivesoccuratindeterminatehours,atunexpectedmoments,andareofbriefduration。
So,attentivetotheirleastmovements,Fabregoesforthtoobservethemattheearliestbreakofday,inthereddawn,whenthebee“popsherheadoutofheratticwindowtoseewhattheweatheris。”andthespidersofthethicketslieinwaitunderthewhorlsoftheirnets,“whichthetearsofnighthavechangedintochapletsofdewdrops,whosemagicjewellery,sparklinginthesun。”isalreadyattractingmothsandmidges。
Seatedforhoursbeforeasprigofterebinth,hiseye,armedwiththemagnifyingglass,followstheslowmanoeuvresoftheterebinthlouse,whoseproboscis“cunninglydistilsthevenomwhichcausestheleaftoswellandproducesthoseenormoustumours,thosemisshapenandmonstrousgalls,inwhichtheyoungpasstheirperiodofslumber。”
Hewatchesatnight,bythedimlightofalantern,tocopytheScolopendraathertask,seekingtosurprisethesecretofhereggs7/23。;toobservetheCioneconstructinghercapsuleofgoldbeater’sskin,ortheProcessionalcaterpillarstravellingheadtotailalongtheirsatintrail,extinguishinghiscandleonlywhensleepatlastsetshiseyelidsblinking。
Hewillwakeearlytowitnessthefairy-likeresurrectionofthesilkwormmoth7/24。;“inordernottolosethemomentwhenthenymphburstsherswaddling-bands。”orwhenthewingofthelocustissuesfromitssheathand“commencestosprout“;nospectacleintheworldismorewonderfulthanthesightof“thisextraordinaryanatomyinprocessofformation。”theunrollingofthese“bundlesoftissue,cunninglyfoldedandreducedtothesmallestpossiblecompass“intheinsignificantalarstumps,whichgraduallyunfold“likeanimmensesetofsails。”likethe“body-linenoftheprincess“ofthefairy-tale,whichwascontainedinonesinglehemp-
seed。7/25。
InhisHarmasheislikeastrangerdiscoveringanunknownworld;“likeakindlygiantfromSirius,holdingamagnifyingglasstohiseye,retaininghisbreath,lestitshouldoverturnandsweepawaythepigmieswhichheisobserving。”
HispassionforinterrogatingtheSphinxoflife,everywhereandatallmoments,sufficedtofillhisdaysfromoneendoftheyeartotheother。
Whensomedistantsubjectinterestedhim,evenonthemostscorchingdays,hewouldput“hislunchinhispocket,anappleandacrustofbread。”andsitoutinthehotsunlight,accompaniedbyhisdog,Vasco,Tom,orRabbit;
fearingonlythatsomeimportunatethirdpersonmightcomebetweennatureandhimself。
Whenhewalkedinhisgardenhewouldletnothingescapehim;witnessthoseprecisenotesofaneclipseofthesun,andoftheeffectswhichthatphenomenonproducesuponanimallifeasawhole。
Whilehischildrenfollowedtheprogressofthemoonacrossthesunthroughapaneofsmokedglass,heattentivelyobservedallthatoccurredinthecountryside。
“Itisfour;thedaygrowspale;thetemperatureisfresher;thecockscrow,surprisedbythiskindoftwilightwhichcomesbeforethehour。Afewdogsarebaying……Theswallows,numerousbefore,havealldisappeared……acouplehavetakenrefugeinmystudy,onewindowofwhichisopen……whenthenormallightreturnstheywillcomeoutdoorsoncemore……Thenightingale,whichhadsolongimportunedmebyhisinterminablesong,issilentatlast7/26。;theblack-cappedskylarks,whichwerewarblingcontinually,aresuddenlystill……onlytheyounghouse-sparrowsunderthetilesoftheroofaremournfullychirping……Peaceandsilence,thedaylightmorethanhalfgone……IntheHarmasIcannolongerseetheinsectsflying;
Ifindonlyonebeepillagingtherosemary;alllifehasdisappeared。
“Onlyaweevil,theLixus。”whichheisobservinginacage,“continues,stepbystep,withouttheslightestemotion,hisamorousby-play,asthoughnothingunusualwerehappening……Thenightingaleandtheskylarkmaybesilent,oppressedbyfear;thebeemayre-enterherhive;butisaweeviltobeupsetbecausethesunthreatenstogoout?“7/27。
Hewasnolesscuriousconcerningtheresurrectionofthesun,andeverytimehemadeanexcursiontotheVentouxhewascarefulnottomissthisspectacle;settingoutatanearlyhourfromthefootofthemountain,sothathemightseethedawngrowbrightfromthesummitofitsrockymass;
thenthesun,suddenlyrisinginthemorningbreeze,andsettingfire,littlebylittle,totheAlpsofDauphinéandthehillsofComtat;andtheRh?ne,farbelow,slenderasasilverthread。
Hetookinfinitepleasuretooindrinkinghisfillofthesublimeterrorsofthethunderstorm,whichheregardedasoneofthemostmagnificentspectacleswhichnaturecanoffer;notcontentwithobservingitthroughglass,hewouldopenwidethewindowsatnightthebettertoenjoythephosphorescenceoftheatmosphere,theconflagrationoftheclouds,theburstsofthunder,andallthesolemnpompwithwhichthegreatpurifyingphenomenonmanifestsitself。
Butpureobservation,aspractisedbyhispredecessors,RéaumurandHuber,isofteninsufficient,or“furnishesonlyaglimpseofmatters。”
Hehadrecourse,therefore,toartificialobservationofthekindknownasexperimentation,andwemaysaythatFabrewasreallythefirsttoemploytheexperimentalmethodinthestudyofthemindsofanimals。
Nearthefieldofobservation,therefore,isthenaturalist’sworkshop,“theanimallaboratory。”inwhichsuchinductionsasmaybesuggestedbythedoingsandthemovementsoftheinsects“whichroamatlibertyamidstthethymeandlavender“aresubjectedtothetestofexperiment。Itisagreat,silent,isolatedroom,brilliantlylightedbytwowindowsfacingsouth,uponthegarden,oneatleastofwhichisalwayskeptopenthattheinsectsmaycomeandgoatliberty。
Intheglass-toppedboxesofpinewhichoccupyalmosttheentireheightofthewhitewashedwallsarecarefullyarrangedthecollectionssopatientlyamassed;alltheentomologicalfaunaoftheSouthofFrance,andthesea-
shellsoftheMediterranean;anabundantwealthalsoofdiversrarities;
numismaticaltreasuresandfragmentsofpotteryandotherprehistoricaldocuments,ofwhichthenumerousossuariesintheneighbourhoodofSérignan,scatteredhereandthereuponthehills,containmanyspecimens。
Atthetop,crowningthefacadeofglass-toppedcaseslikeanimmensefrieze,isthecolossalherbarium,thefirstvolumesofwhichgobacktotheearlyyouthoftheirowner;alltheflora,bothoftheMidiandtheNorth,thoseoftheplainsandthoseofthemountains,andallthealgaeoffreshandsaltwater。
ButitmustnotbesupposedthatFabreattachesanygreatvaluetothesecollections,enormousthoughthesumoflabourwhichtheyrepresent。Tohimtheyhavebeenameansofeducation,ameansoforganizingandarranginghisknowledge,andnotofsatisfyinganidlecuriosity;nottheamusementofonecontentwiththerindofthings。Inordertoidentifyatfirstsightsuchspecimensasoneencountersandproposestoexamine,onemustfirstofalllearntoobserveandtoseethoroughly,andtoschooltheeyesinthecoloursandformspeculiartoeachindividualspecies。
OnemayfairlycomplainofRéaumur,forexample,thathisknowledgewasuncertainandincomplete。Toooftenheleaveshisreadersundecidedastothenatureofthespecieswhosehabitshedescribes。Fabrehimself,bydintofcriticizingwithsomuchhumourtheabuseofclassifications,hassometimesallowedhimselftofallintothesamefault。7/28。Hehastakengoodcare,however,nottoneglectthesystematicstudyofspecies;witnesshis“FloraoftheVaucluse“andthatcarefulcatalogueofAvignonwhichhehasnotdisdainedtorepublish。7/29。Thetruthisthat“ifwedonotknowtheirnamestheknowledgeofthethingsescapesus“7/30。,andhewasprofoundlyconsciousofthetruthofthispreceptofthegreatLinnaeus。
Themiddleoftheroomisentirelyoccupiedbyagreattableofwalnut-
wood,onwhicharearrangedbottles,test-tubes,andoldsardine-boxes,whichFabreemploysinordertowatchtheevolutionofathousandnamelessordoubtfuleggs,toobservethelaboursoftheirlarvae,thecreationandthehatchingofcocoons,andthelittlemiraclesofmetamorphosis,“afteragerminationmorewonderfulthanthatoftheacornwhichmakestheoak。”
Coversofmetallicgauzerestingonearthenwaresaucersfullofsand,afewcarboysandflower-potsorsweetmeatjarsclosedwithasquareofglass;
theseserveasobservationorexperimentalcagesinwhichtheprogressandtheactionsof“thesetinylivingmachines“canbeexamined。
Fabrehasrevealedhimselfasapsychologistwithoutrival,ofaconsummateskillinthedifficultanddelicateartofexperimentation;theartofmakingtheinsectspeak,ofputtingquestionstoit,offorcingittobetrayitssecrets;forexperimentis“theonlymethodwhichcanthrowanylightuponthenatureofinstincts。”
Hisresourcesbeingslenderandhismindinventive,hehasingeniouslysupplementedthepovertyofhisequipment,andhasdiscoveredlesscostlyandlesscomplexmeansofconductinghisexperiments;knowingthesecretofextractingthesublimesttruthfromclumsycombinationsof“trivial,peasant-madearticles。”
Hehassucceeded,inhisrusticlaboratory,inapplyingtherigorousrulesofinvestigationandexperimentationestablishedbythegreatbiologists。
Hehasthereforebeenabletoestablishhisbeautifulobservationsinamannersoindisputablethatthosewhocomeafterhimandaretemptedtostudythesamethingscanbutarriveatthesameresults,andderiveinspirationfromhisresearches。
Tonotewithcareallthedetailsofaphenomenonisthefirstessential,sothatothersmayafterwardsrefertothemandprofitbythem;thedifficultthingistointerpretthem,todiscoverthecircumstances,thewhysandwherefores,theconsequences,andtheconnectinglinks。
Butasinglefactobservedbychanceatthewayside,andwhichwouldnotevenattracttheattentionofanother,willbeinstantlyluminoustothissearchingunderstanding,itwillsuggestquestionsunforeseen,andwillevoke,byanticipation,preconceivedideasandsuddenflashesofintuition,whichwillnecessitatethetestofexperiment。
Why,forexample,doesthePhilanthus,thatslenderwasp,whichcapturesthehoney-beeupontheblossomsinordertofeedherlarvae;why,beforeshecarriesherpreytoheroffspring,doesshe“outragethedyinginsect。”
bysqueezingitscropinordertoemptyitofhoney,inwhichsheappearstodelight,anddoesindeedactuallydelight?
“Thebanditgreedilytakesinhermouththeextendedandsugaredtongueofthedeadinsect;thenoncemoreshepressestheneckandthethorax,andoncemoreappliesthepressureofherabdomentothehoney-sacofthebee。
Thehoneyoozesforthandisinstantlylickedup。Thusthebeeisgraduallycompelledtodisgorgethecontentsofthecrop。Thisatrociousmeallastsoftenhalfanhourandlonger,untilthelasttraceofhoneyhasdisappeared。”
Thedetailedanswerisobtainedbyexperiment,whichperfectlyexplainsthis“odiousfeast。”theexcuseforwhichissimplymaternity。ThePhilanthusknows,instinctively,withouthavinglearnedit,thathoney,whichisherordinaryfare,is,byaverysingular“inversion。”amortalpoisontoherlarvae。7/31。
Asanaccomplishedphysiologist,Fabreconductsallkindsofexperiments。
Behindthewiresofhiscages,heprovokesthemovingspectacleofthescorpionatgripwiththewholeentomologicalfauna,inordertotesttheeffectsofitsterriblevenomuponvariousspecies;andthushediscoversthestrangeimmunityoflarvae;thevirus,“thereagentofatranscendentchemistry,distinguishesthefleshofthelarvafromthatoftheadult;itisharmlesstotheformer,butmortaltothelatter“;afreshproofthat“metamorphosismodifiesthesubstanceoftheorganismtothepointofchangingitsmostintimateproperties。”7/32。
Youmayjudgefromthisthatheknowsthroughandthroughthehistoryofthecreatureswhichformthesubjectsofhisfaithfulnarratives。Heisinformedofthesmallesteventsoftheirlives。Hepossessesacalendaroftheirbirths;herecordstheirchronologyandthesuccessionofgenerations;hehasnotedtheirmethodsofwork,examinedtheirdiet,andrecordedtheirmeals。Hediscoversthemotiveswhichdictatetheirpeculiaritiesofchoice;whytheCerceris,forinstance,amongallthevictimsatitsdisposal,neverselectsanythingbuttheBuprestisandtheweevils。Heisfamiliartoowiththeirtacticsofwarfareandtheirmethodsofconflict。
Hisgazehaspenetratedeventhemosthiddendwellings;thoseinwhichtheHalictus“varnisheshercellsandmakestheroundloafwhichistoreceivetheegg“;inwhich,underthecoverofcocoons,murderousgrubsdevourslumberingnymphs;eventhedepthsofthesoilarenothiddenfromhim,forthere,thankstohisartifices,hehassurprisedtheastonishingsecretoftheMinotaur。
Hesiftsalldoubtfulstories;anecdotes,statementsofsupposedhabits;
allthatisincoherent,orillobserved,ormisinterpreted;alltheclicheswhichthemakersofbookspassfromhandtohand。
Inplaceofrepetitionhegivesuslaws,constantfacts,fixedrules。
Withincomparableskill,herepeatsandteststheancientexperimentsofRéaumur。
HeisnotcontenttoshowusthatErasmusDarwinismistaken;hepointsouthowitisthathehasfallenintoerror。7/33。
Hesetshimselftodecipherthemeaningofoldtales,skilfullydisengagingthelittleparceloftruthwhichusuallyliesbeneathamassofincorrectorevenfalsestatements。HecriticisesLaFontaine,andquestionsthestatementsofHorusApolloandPliny。Fromamassofundigestedknowledgehehascreatedthelivingscienceofentomology,whichhadreceivedfromRéaumurafirstbreathofvitality,insuchwisethateachindividualcreatureispresentedinhisworkwithitspreciseexpressionandtheabsolutetruthofitscharacterandattitudes;theinhabitantsofthewoodsandfields,whetherthosewhichfeeduponthecropsorthosewhichliveinthecrevicesoftherocks,ortheobscureworkersthatcrawlupontheearth;allthosewhichhaveasecrettotellorsomethingtoteachus;theCigale,sodifferentfromtheinsectoftheFable;andaboveallthatbeetlewhosenamehadhithertobeenencounteredarrayedinthemostfantasticlegends,thefamousScarabaeussacerofthetombs,whichFabrepreferredtoplaceattheheadofhisepicasanagreeableprologue,althoughtheinquiryrelativetohisamazingfeatsbelongschronologicallytoacomparativelyrecentperiodofhiscareer。
Howmoderateheisinsuchsuppositionsasheventures;howcautiouswhenhispersistentpatiencehasatlaststruckagainst“theinaccessiblewalloftheUnknowable“!Then,withadmirablefrankness,tranquilandsincere,hesimplyownsthat“hedoesnotknow。”unlikesomanyothers,whoseuncriticalmindsarecontentedwithafragmentaryvision,andrunsofaraheadofthefactsthattheycanonlypromoteindefiniteillusionanderror。
Oneissurprisedindeedtoremarkhowfewevenofthemostlearnedandwell-informedofmenhavearealaptitudeforobservation,andahighlyinstructivebookmightbewrittenconcerningthediscrepanciesandtheweakpointsinourknowledge。Iftheyweresubjectedtoasufficientlyseveretest,howthreadbarewouldappearmanyofthoseproblemswhichnatureandtheworldpresent,andwhichareregardedasresolved!
Howlong,forinstance,wasneededtodestroythelegendofthecuckoo,incessantlyrepeateddowntothedaysofXavierRaspail,andtoussofamiliar;toelucidateitshistory,andtosetitinitstruelight!
7/34。
Itisbymeansofsuchdataasthesethatascienceisfounded,fortheoriesdecay,andonlywell-observedfactsremainirrefragable。Withstonessuchasthese,whicharehewnbythegreatartisan,thestructuresofthefuturewillbebuilt,andourownscience,perhaps,willonedayberefashioned。
ForthisreasonFabre’sbooksareaneducationforallthosewhowishtodevotethemselvestoobservation;amanualofmentaldiscipline,atrue“essayuponmethod。”whichshouldbereadbyeverynaturalist,andthemostinteresting,instructive,familiaranddelightfulcourseoftrainingthathaseverbeenknown。
Ontheotherhand,itisimpossibletoconceivewhatlabourthisdelicateworkdemands;whatperseveranceFabrehasrequiredpainfullytoextractonegrainofgold;togleanandunitethedefinitefactors,thepositivedocuments,whichservedasfoundationsforeachofhisessays;lucid,limpid,andcaptivatingasthemostdelightfuloffairy-tales。Wearecharmed,fascinated,andastonished;weseenothingofthegropingadvance,thechecks,andallthetoilandthepatiencedemanded。Wedonotsuspectthelongwaiting,thehesitation,thedesperatelengthoftheinquiries。
Forexample,toestablishthecuriousrelationswhichexistbetweenthewaspsandtheVolucellae,whatlongandrepeatedexperimentswereneedful!
Hisnotebooks,inwhichherecords,fromdaytoday,allthathesees,areevidenceofthis。Whatwatchesinthealleyoflilacs,yearafteryear,todecipherthemechanismandthemodeofconstructionofthehunting-netoftheEpe?ra!Someofthesehistories,likethatofthehyper-metamorphosisoftheMelo?,wereonlycompletedastheresultoftwenty-fiveyearsofassiduousinquiry,whilefortyyearswererequiredtocompletethatoftheScarabaeussacer,forhisobservationofitwasalwayspartial;itisalmostalwaysimpossibletodivinewhatonecannotseefromthelittlethatonedoessee;andasaruleonemustreturntothesamepointoverandoveragaininordertofilluplacunae。
ThemajorityoftheinsectswhichFabrehasstudiedaresolitary,andareonlytobeencounteredsingly,scatteredoverwideareasofcountry。Someliveonlyindeterminedspots,andnotelsewhere,suchasthefamousCerceris,ortheyellow-wingedSphex,ofwhichnotraceistobefoundbeyondthelimitsoftheCarpentrascountryside。
Theproperseasonmustbewatchedfor;onemustbereadyatanymomenttoprofitbyaluckychance,andresignoneselftointerminablewatchesatthebottomofaravine,orkeeponthealertforhoursunderafierysun。Oftenthechancegoesby,orthetrailfollowedprovesfalse;buttheseasonisover,andonemustwaitforthereturnofanotherspring。ThetradeofobserverinmanycasesresemblestheexhaustinglaboursoftheSisyphusbeetle,painfullypushinghispelletuparoughandstonypath;sothattheteamhaltsandstaggersateverymoment,theloadspillsoverandrollsaway,andallhastobecommencedoveragain。
Wecannowcastback,inordertoconsideratleisuretheimmortalstudywhichmarkedthebeginningofhisfame,withthegreaterinterestandprofitinthatFabrehasbeenable,duringhisretirement,togeneralizeandextendhisdiscovery。7/35。
LetusfirstofallnotehowtheobservationwhichDufourhadmadeofthenestoftheCerceriswastransformedinhishands,andwhatdevelopmentshewasabletoevolvetherefrom。
SincetheyhavebeendefinitelyestablishedbyFabrethesecuriousfactshavebeenwell-known。Theyformperhapsthegreatestprodigypresentedbyentomology,thatsciencesofullofmarvels。
Thesewaspsnourishthemselvesonlyonthenectarofflowers;buttheirlarvae,whichtheywillneverbehold,musthavefreshandsucculentfleshstillpalpitatingwithlife。
Theinsectdigsatunnelinthesoil,inwhichsheplaceshereggs,andhavingprovisionedthecellwithselectedgame——cricket,spider,caterpillar,orbeetle——shefinallyclosestheentrance,whichshedoesnotagaincross。
Likenearlyallinsects,theyoungwaspisborninthelarvalstate,andfromthemomentofitshatchingtotheendofitsgrowth——thatistosay,foraperiodofmanydays——thegrubenclosedinitscellcanlookfornohelpfromwithout。
Herethenisafascinatingproblem:eitherthevictimsdepositedbythemotheraredead,anddesiccationorputrefactionattacksthempromptly,orelsetheyareliving,asindeedthelarvaerequire;butthen“whatwillbecomeofthisfragilecreature,whichamerenothingwilldestroy,shutinthenarrowchamberoftheburrowamongvigorousbeetles,forweeksonendworkingtheirlongspurredlegs;oratgripswithamonstrouscaterpillarmakingplaywithitsflanksandmandibles,rollingandunrollingitstortuousfolds?“
SuchisthethrillingmysteryofwhichFabrediscoveredthekey。
Withinconceivableingenuity,thevictimisseizedandthrowntotheground,andthewaspplungeshersting,notatrandomintothebody,whichwouldinvolvetheriskofdeath,butatdeterminedpoints,exactlyintotheseatofthoseinvisiblenervousganglionswhosemechanismcommandsthevariousmovementsofthecreature。
Immediatelyafterthesesubtlewoundsthepreyisparalysedthroughoutitsbody;itsmembersappeartobedisarticulated,“asthoughallthespringswerebroken“;thetruecorpseisnotmoremotionless。
Butthewoundisnotmortal;notonlydoestheinsectcontinuetolive,butithasacquiredthestrangeprerogativeofbeingabletoliveforaverylongperiodwithouttakinganynourishment,thankspreciselytotheconditionofimmobility,insomesortvegetative,whichparalysisconfersuponit。
Whenthehourstrikesthehungrylarvawillfinditsfavouritemeatservedtoitsliking;anditwillattackthisdefencelesspreywithallthecircumspectionofarefinedeater;“withanexquisitelydelicateart,nibblingthevisceraofitsvictimlittlebylittle,withaninfalliblemethod;thelessessentialpartsfirstofall,andonlyinthelastinstancethosewhicharenecessarytolife。Herethenisanincomprehensiblespectacle;thespectacleofananimalwhich,eatenalive,mouthfulbymouthful,duringnearlyafortnight,ishollowedout,growslessandless,andfinallycollapses。”whileretainingtotheenditssucculenceanditsfreshness。
Thefactisthatthemotherhastakencaretodepositheregg“atapointalwaysthesame“intheregionwhichherstinghasrenderedinsensible,sothatthefirstmouthfulsareonlyfeeblyresented。Butastheenemygoesdeeperanddeeper“itsometimeshappensthatthecricket,bittentothequick,attemptstoretaliate;butitonlysucceedsinopeningandclosingthepincersofitsmandiblesontheemptyair,orinuselesslywavingitsantennae。”Vainefforts:“fornowthevoraciousbeasthasbittendeepintothespot,andcanwithimpunityransacktheentrails。”Whataslowandhorribleagonyfortheparalysedvictim,shouldsomeglimmerofconsciousnessstilllingerinitspunybrain!Whataterriblenightmareforthelittlefield-cricket,suddenlyplungedintothedenoftheSphex,sofarfromthesunlittuftofthymewhichsheltereditsretreat!
Toparalysewithoutkilling,“todeliverthepreytothelarvaeinertbutliving“:thatistheendtobeattained;onlythemethodvariesaccordingtothespeciesofthehunterandthestructureoftheprey;thustheCerceris,whichattacksthecoleoptera,andtheScolia,whichpreysuponthelarvaeoftherose-beetle,stingthemonlyonceandinasingleplace,becausethereisconcentratedthemassofthemotorganglions。
ThePompilus,whichselectsaspiderforitsvictim,nolessthantheredoubtableTarantula,knowsthatitsquarry“hastwonervouscentreswhichanimaterespectivelythemovementsofthelimbsandthoseoftheterriblefangs;hencethetwostabsofthesting。”7/36。
TheSphexplungesherdaggerthreetimesintothebreastofthecricket,becausesheknows,byanintuitionthatwecannotcomprehend,thatthelocomotorinnervationofthecricketisactuatedbythreenervouscentres,whichliewideapart。7/37。
Finally,theAmmophila,“thehighestmanifestationofthelogicofinstinct,whoseprofoundknowledgeleavesusconfounded,stabsthecaterpillarinnineplaces,becausethebodyofthevictimwithwhichitfeedsitslarvaeisaseriesofrings,setendtoend,eachofwhichpossessesitslittleindependentnervouscentre。”7/38。
Thisisnotall;thegeniusoftheSphexisnotyetattheendofitsforesight。Youhavedoubtlessheardofthecomatosestateintowhichthewoundedfallwhen,afterafractureoftheskull,thebrainiscompressedbyaviolenthaemorrhageorabonysplinter。Thephysiologistsimitatethisprocessofnaturewhentheywish,forexample,toobtain,inanimalsunderexperiment,astateofcompleteimmobility。Butdidthefirstsurgeonwhothoughtoftrepanningtheskullinordertoexertonthebrain,bymeansofasponge,acertaindegreeofcompression,everimaginethatananalogousprocedurehadlongbeenemployedintheinsectworld,andthattheseclumsymethodsweremerelychild’splaybesidetheastonishingfeatsoftheUnconscious?
Forthestabinthethoracicganglions,howeverefficacious,isofteninsufficient。Althoughthesixlimbsareparalysed,althoughthevictimcannotmove,itsmandibles,“pointed,sharp,serrated,whichcloselikeapairofscissors,stillremainamenacetothetyrant;theymightatleast,bygrippingthesurroundinggrasses,opposeamoreorlesseffectualresistancetotheprocessofcarryingoff。”Sotheprecedingmanoeuvresareconsummatedbyakindofgarrotting;thatis,theinsect“takescaretocompressthebrainofitsvictim,butsoastoavoidwoundingit;producingonlyastupor,asimpletorpor,apassinglethargy。”Isnottheingeniousobserverjustifiedinconcludingthat“thisisalarminglyscientific“?
BetweenthedrystatementsofDufour,whichservedFabreashisoriginaltheme,andtheunaccustomedwealthofthisvastphysiologicalpoetry,whatadistancehasbeencovered!
Howfarhaveweoutstrippedthisbarrenmatter,theseshapelesssketches!
Dufour,anothersolitary,whoretiredtohisprovince,inthedepthoftheLandes,wasabovealladescriptiveanatomist,andhelimitedhimselftoaninventoryofthenestofaCerceris。
ForhimtheBuprestesweredead,andtheirstateofpreservationwasexplainedsimplyasakindofembalming,duetosomespecialactionofthevenomoftheHymenoptera。
Thesefacts,therefore,werestatedassimplecuriosities。
Fabreprovedthatthesevictimspossessedalltheattributesoflifeexceptingmovement,byprovokingcontractionsintheirmembersundertheinfluenceofvariousstimulants,andbykeepingthemaliveartificiallyforanindefiniteperiod。
Ontheotherhand,hedemonstratedthecomparativeinnocuousnessofthevenomofthesewasps,someofwhich,likethegreatCercerisorthebeautifulandformidableScolia,alarmbytheirenormoussizeandtheirterrifyingaspect;sothattheconservationofthepreycouldnotbeduetoanyoccultquality,tosomemoreorlessactiveantisepticvirtueofthevenomousfluid,butsimplytotheprecisionofthestabandthemiraculousdeftnessofthe“surgeon。”
Healsopointedoutthefactthatthestingoftheinsectisableimmediatelytodissociatethenervoussystemofthevegetativelifefromthatofthecorrelativelife,sparingtheformer,andtakingcarenottowoundtheabdomen,whichcontainstheganglionsofthegreatsympatheticnerve,whileitannihilatesthelatter,whichismoreorlessconcentratedalongtheventralfaceofthethoracicregion。
Hecompletedthissplendiddemonstration,notonlybyprovokingunderhisowneyesthe“murderousmanoeuvres,theintimateandpassionatedrama。”butalsobyreproducingexperimentallyalltheseastonishingphenomena;
expoundingtheirmechanismandtheirvariationswithalogicandlucidity,anartandsagacitywhichraisethismarvellousobservation,oneofthemostbeautifulknowntoscience,totheheightofthemostimmortaldiscoveriesofphysiology。ClaudeBernard,inhiscelebratedexperiments,certainlyexhibitednogreaterinvention,notruergenius。
CHAPTER8。THEMIRACLEOFINSTINCT。
“TheSpiritBlowethWhitheritListeth。”
Whatisthisinstinct,whichguidestheinsecttosuchmarvellousresults?
Isitmerelyadegreeofintelligence,orsomeabsolutelydifferentformofactivity?
Isitpossible,bystudyingthehabitsofanimals,todiscoversomeofthoseelementaryspringsofactionwhoseknowledgewouldenableustodivemoredeeplyintoourownnatures?
FabrehaspresentedustohisSphex,the“infallibleparalyser。”Arewetocredithernotonlywithmemory,butalsowiththefacultyofassociatingideas,ofjudgment,andofpursuingatrainofreasoninginrespectofherastonishinglyco-ordinatedactions?
Puttothequestionbythemaliceoftheoperator,the“transcendent“
anatomisttripsoverameretrifle,andtheslightestnoveltyconfoundsher。
Withoutthecircleofherordinaryhabits,whatstupidity,“whatdarknesswrapsherround“!Sheretreats;sherefusestounderstand;“shewasheshereyes,firstpassingherhandsacrosshermouth;sheassumesadreamy,meditativeair。”Whatcanshebepondering?Underwhatformofthought,illusion,ormiragedoestheunfamiliarproblemwhichhasobtrudeditselfintohercustomarylifepresentitselfbehindthosefacetedeyes?8/1。
Howcanwetell?Wecanonlyattaintoknowledgeofourselvesbydirectintuition。Itisonlytheideaofouregowhichenablesustoconjecturewhatispassinginthebrainsofourfellows。Betweentheinsectandourselvesnounderstandingispossible,soremotearetheanalogiesbetweenitsorganizationandourown;andwecanonlyformidlehypothesesastoitsstatesofconsciousnessandtherealmotiveofitsactions。
Consideronlythatunknownandmysteriousenergywhichtheinsectsdisplayintheiroperationsandtheirlabours,asitisinitself,andletuscontentourselves,firstofall,withcomparingittoourownintelligence,suchasweconceiveittobe。
Inseekingtoappreciatewherebyitdiffersperhapsweshallgainmorethanbyvainlyseekingpointsofresemblance。Weshalldiscover,infact,behindtheinsectanditsprodigiousinstincts,avastandremotehorizon,aregionatoncemoreprofound,moreextensive,andmorefruitfulthanthatoftheintelligence;andifFabreisabletohelpustodecipherafewpagesof“themostdifficultofallvolumes,thebookofourselves。”itisprecisely,asaphilosophertoldhim,because“manhasremainedinstinctiveinprocessofbecomingintelligent。”8/2。
TheworkofFabreisfromthispointofviewaninvaluabletreasuryofobservationsandexperiments,andtherichestcontributionwhichhaseverbeenmadetothestudyofthesefascinatingproblems。
“Thefunctionoftheintelligenceistoreflect,tobeconscious;thatis,torelatetheeffecttoitscause,toadda“because“toa“why“;toremedytheaccidental;toadaptanewcourseofconducttonewcircumstances。”
InrelationtothehumanintelligencethusdefinedFabrehasconsideredthesenervousaptitudes,sowelladjusted,accordingtotheevolutionists,byancienthabit,thattheyhavefinallybecomeimpulsiveandunconscious,and,properlyspeaking,innate。Hehasdemonstrated,withanabundanceofproofandapowerofargumentthatwemustadmire,theblindmechanismwhichdeterminesallthemanifestations,eventhemostextraordinary,ofthatwhichwecallinstinct,andwhichheredityhasfixedinaspeciesofunchangeableautomatism,liketherhythmoftheheartandthelungs。8/3。
Letus,fromthiswealthofmaterial,fromamongthemostsuggestiveexamples,selectsomeofhismoststrikingdemonstrations,whichareclassicsoftheirkind。
Fabrehasnotattemptedtodefineinstinct,foritisindefinable;nortoprobeitsessentialnature,whichisimpenetrable。Buttorecognizetheorderofnatureisinitselfasufficientlyfascinatingstudy,withoutstrivingtocrackanunbreakableboneorwastingtimeinponderinginsolubleenigmas。Theimportantmatteristoavoidtheintroductionofillusions,tobewareofexceedingthedataofobservationandexperiment,ofsubstitutingourowninferencesforthefacts,ofoutstrippingrealityandamplifyingthemarvellous。
Letuslistentothescrupulousanalysiswhoselessons,scatteredthroughfourthousandpages,teachusmoreconcerninginstinctanditsinnumerablevariationsthanallthemostlearnedtreatisesandspeculationsofthephilosophers。
Nothingintheworldperplexesthemindoftheobserverlikethespectacleofthebirthandgrowthoftheinstincts。
Atpreciselytherightmoment,justasfailureordisasterseemsforeordainedbythepreviouslyestablishedcircumstances,Fabreshowsushisinsectsassuddenlymasteredbyanirresistibleforce。
“Attherightmoment“theyinvinciblyobeysomesortofmysteriousandinflexibleprescription。Withoutapprenticeship,theyperformtheveryactionsrequired,andblindlyaccomplishtheirdestiny。
Then,themomenthavingpassed,theinstincts“disappearanddonotreawaken。Afewdaysmoreorlessmodifythetalents,andwhattheyounginsectknewtheadulthasoftenforgotten。”8/4。
AmongtheLycosae,atthemomentofexodus,asuddeninstinctisevolvedwhichafewhourslaterdisappearsnevertoreturn。Itistheclimbinginstinct,unknowntotheadultspider,andsoonforgottenbytheemancipatedyoung,whoaredestinedtoroamuponthefaceoftheearth。ButtheyoungLycosae,anxioustoleavethematernalhomeandtotravel,becomesuddenlyardentclimbersandaeronauts,eachreleasingalong,lightthreadwhichservesitasparachute。Thevoyageaccomplished,notraceofthisingenuityisleft。Suddenlyacquired,theclimbinginstinctnolesssuddenlydisappears。8/5。
Thegreathistoriographerofinstincthasthrownawonderfullight,byhisbeautifulexperimentsrelatingtothenidificationofthemason-bee,upontheindissolublesuccessionofitsdifferentphases;thelinealconcatenation,theinevitableandnecessaryorderwhichpresidesovereachofthesenervousdischargesofwhichthetotalseriesconstitutes,properlyspeaking,amodeofaction。
Themason-beecontinuestobuildupontheready-completednestpresentedtoher。Sheobstinatelyinsistsuponprovisioningacellalreadydulyfilledwiththequantityofhoneyrequiredbythelarva,because,inthiscaseasintheother,theimpulsewhichinciteshertobuildortoprovisionthenesthasnotyetbeenexhausted。
Ontheotherhand,ifweemptythelittlecupofitscontentswhenshehasfilleditshewillnotrecommenceherlabours。“Theprocessofprovisioningbeingcomplete,thesecretimpulsewhichurgedhertocollectherhoneyisnolongeractive。Theinsectthereforeceasestostoreherhoney,and,inspiteofthisaccident,layshereggintheemptycell,thusleavingthefuturenurslingwithoutnourishment。”8/6。
InthecaseofthePelopaeus,Fabrecallsourattentiontooneofthemostinstructivephysiologicalspectaclesthatcanbeimagined。
Whilethemason-beedoesnotnoticethathercellhasbeenemptied,thePelopaeuscannotperceivethatthetricksoftheexperimenterhaveresultedinthedisappearanceofherprogeny;andshe“continuestostoreawayspidersforagermthatnolongerexists;sheperseveresuntiringlyinheruselesshunting,asthoughthefutureofherlarvadependedonit;sheamassesprovisionswhichwillfeednoone;more,shepushesaberrationtotheextentofplasteringeventheplacewherehernestwasifweremoveit,givingthelaststrokesofthetroweltoanimaginarybuilding,andputtinghersealsuponemptynothing。”8/7。
>Fromthesefacts,andothers,nolesscelebrated,whichshow“theinabilityofinsectstoescapefromtheroutineoftheircustomsandtheirhabituallabours。”Fabrederivessomanyproofsoftheirlackofintelligence。
TheEpe?rafasciataisincapableofreplacingasingleradialthreadinthegeometricalstructureofitsweb,whenbroken;itrecommencestheentirewebeveryevening,andweavesitatonestretchwiththemostbeautifulmastery,asthoughmerelyamusingitself。
ThecaterpillaroftheGreaterPeacockmothteachesusthesamelesson;
whenoccupiedinweavingitscocoonitdoesnotknowhowtorepairanartificialrent;and“inspiteofthecertaintyofitsdeath,orratherthatofthefuturebutterfly,itquietlycontinuestospin,withouttroublingtocovertherent;devotingitselftoasuperfluoustask,andignoringthetreacherousbreach,whichleavesthecocoonanditsinhabitantatthemercyofthefirstthiefthatfindsit。”8/8。
Thus“becauseoneactionhasjustbeenperformed,anothermustinevitablybeperformedtocompletethefirst;whatisdoneisdone,andisneverrepeated。Likethewatercourse,whichcannotclimbthehillsandreturntoitssource,theinsectdoesnotretraceitsstepsorrepeatitsactions,whichfollowoneanotherinvariably,andareinevitablyconnectedinanecessaryorder,likeaseriesofechoes,oneofwhichawakensanother……Theinsectknowsnothingofitsmarvelloustalents,justasthestomachknowsnothingofitscunningchemistry。Itbuildslikeabricklayer,weaves,hunts,stabs,andparalyses,asitsecretesthevenomofitsweapons,thesilkofitscocoon,thewaxofitscomb,orthethreadsofitsweb;alwayswithouttheslightestknowledgeofthemeansandtheend。”8/9。
Thusinstinctisonethingandintelligenceisanother;andforFabrethereisnotransitionwhichcantransformtheoneintotheother。
Buthowprofoundandabundant,howinfiniteisthesourcefromwhichthismanifoldactivityderives,distributedasitisthroughouttheentireanimalkingdom;andwhichinourselvescommandstheprofoundestpartofournature;unconscious,oreveninoppositiontoourwonderfulintelligence,whichitoftensilencesoraltogetheroverwhelms。
Althoughtheinsect“hasnoneedoflessonsfromitselders“inordertoaccomplishitsbeautifulmasterpieces,thecomprehensiveconceptofthegeniuswhichrisesspontaneouslyandatasinglesteptotheloftiestconceptionsisnotalwaysaproductofpurereason。
Comparethesublimelogicofanimalmaternity,theimpeccabledictatesofinstinct,withthehesitations,thegropings,theuncertainties,theerrorsandtragicfailuresofhumanmaternity,whenitseekstoreplacetheunerringcommandsofinstinctbytheclumsyeffortsoftheintelligence!
Ifallisdarknesstotheanimal,apartfromitshabitualpaths,howfeebleandhesitating,howfalteringandunequalisreasonwhenitseekstoopposeitslaboriousinductionstotheinfalliblewisdomoftheunconscious!
Itis,infact,tothisconcatenationofactions,narrowlyconnectedbyamutualdependence,thatweowethisinexhaustibleseriesofcunningindustriesandwonderfularts。ToFabretheyaresomanyfeatsofalearnedunconsciousness。
“Seethenest,theaccustomedmasterpieceofmothers;itismoreoftenthanotherwiseananimalfruit,acofferfullofgerms,containingeggsinplaceofseeds。”
ThesatinbagoftheEpe?rafasciata,inwhichhereggsareenclosed,“breaksatthecaressofthesun,liketheskinofanover-ripepomegranate。”
TheDorthesia,thelouseinhabitingtheeuphorbia,“treblesthelengthofherbody,prolongingitshinderpartintoapouch,comparabletothatoftheopossum,intowhichtheeggsaredropped,andinwhichtheyoungarehatched,toleaveitafterwardsatwill。”8/10。
TheChermesoftheilex“hardensintoarampartofebony,whenceaninnumerablelegionofverminburstsforthonedaywithoutchangingtheirplace。”
Thecapsuleofgold-beater’sskin,inwhichthegrubsoftheCioneareenclosed,dividesitself,atthemomentofliberation,intotwohemispheres“ofaregularitysoperfectthattheyrecallexactlytheburstingofthepyxidiumwhentheseedisdistributed。”8/11。
Hereandthere,however,wecatchaglimpseofarudimentofwhatweunderstandbyconsciousness,intheshapeofa“vaguediscrimination。”
Eachplanthasitslover,drawntoitbyakindofelectiveaffinityandinvariabletendency。TheLarramakesforthethistle,theVanessaforthenettle,theClytusfortheilex,andtheCriocerisforthelily。“Theweevilknowsnothingbutitspeasandbeans,thegoldenRhynchitesonlythesloe,andtheBalaninusonlythenutoracorn。”
ButthePieris,whichhauntsthecabbage,frequentsthenasturtiumalso,andthegoldenrose-beetle,which“intoxicatesitselfattheclustersofthehawthorn。”isnolessaddictedtothenectaroftherose。
TheXylocopa,whichburrowsinthetrunksoftreesandoldrafters,forminglittleroundcorridorsinwhichtolodgeheroffspring,“willutilizeartificialgallerieswhichshehasnotherselfbored。”
TheChalicodoma“alsoisawareoftheeconomicadvantagesofanoldabandonednest“;theAnthophoraiscarefultoestablishherfamily“attheleastexpense。”andprofitsonoccasionbygallerieswhichhavebeenminedbypreviousgenerations;adaptingherselftothesenewconditions,sherepairsthetunnelswhichshedidnotconstruct“andeconomizesherforces。”8/12。
Itwouldseem,therefore,thatthesetinymindsarecreatedandshapedbymeansofexperience;theyrecognize“thatwhichismostfitting“;theylearn,theycompare;maywenotalsosaythattheyjudge?
DoesnottheMason-bee,“whichrakestheroadsforadrypowderydustandmixesitwithsalivatoconvertitintoahardcement。”foreseethatthismudwillharden?
IsthePelopaeusdevoidofjudgmentwhensheseekstheinteriorofdwelling-housesinordertoshelterhernestofdriedclay,whichtheleastdropofrainwouldreducetoitsoriginalstateofmud?
Isitwithoutknowledgeoftheeffectsthatthesloe-weevilbuildsaventilatingchimneytopreventtheasphyxiationofherlarva?thattheScarabaeussacercontrivesafilteratthesmallerendofitspear-shapedball,bymeansofwhichthegrubisabletobreathe?orthatArachnelabyrintha“introducesinhersilk-workarampartofcompressedearthtoprotecthereggsfromtheprobeoftheIchneumon“?
Maywenotalsoseeamasterpieceofthehighestlogicinthehouseofthetrap-doorspider,Arachneclotho,whichisfurnishedwithadoor,atruedoor“whichshethrowsopenwithapushoftheleg,andcarefullyboltsbehindheronreturningbymeansofalittlesilk“?8/13。
WhatamiracleofinventiontooistheprodigiousnestoftheEumenes,“withitseggsuspendedbyathreadfromtheroof,likeapendulum,oscillatingatthelightestbreathinordertosaveitfromcontactwiththecaterpillars,which,incompletelyparalysed,arewrigglingandwrithingbelow“!Later,whentheeggishatched,“thefilamentistransformedintoatube,aplaceofrefuge,upwhichthegrubclambersbackwards。Attheleastsignofdangerfromthemassofcaterpillarsthelarvaretreatsintoitssheathandascendstotheroof,wherethewrigglingswarmcannotreachit。”
8/14。
LetusreferalsototheremarkablehistoryoftheCopris。Wecannotdenythatthevaliantdung-beetleiscapableof“evadingtheaccidental“whichtoFabreconstitutesoneofthedistinctivecharacteristicsoftheintelligence,sinceitimmediatelyintervenesifwiththepointofapenknifeweopentheroofofitsnestandlaybareitsegg。“Thefragmentsraisedbytheknifeareimmediatelybroughttogetherandsoldered,sothatnotraceisleftoftheinjury,andallisoncemoreinorder。”WemayreadalsowithwhatincredibleaddressthemotherCopriswasabletouseandtoprofitbytheready-madepelletsofcow-dungwhichitoccurredtoFabretoofferher。8/15。
Buttheirscopeislimited,andencroachesverylittle,intheeyesofthegreatobserver,onthedomainofintelligence。Thishedemonstratestosatiety,andhisastonishingNecrophori,whichadaptthemselvessoadmirablytocircumstancesandtriumphovertheexperimentaldifficultiestowhichhesubjectsthem,seemscarcelytoexceedthelimitsofthoseactionswhichatbottomaremerelyunconscious。8/16。
WiththespawningoftheOsmia,Fabrethrowsafreshandunexpectedlightontheintuitiveknowledgeofinstinct。
Wearestillgropingourwayamongthecauseswhichrulethedeterminationofthesexes。Biologyhasonlybeenabletothrowafewscatteredlightsonthesubject,andwepossessonlyafewapproximatedata;whichneverthelessareturnedtoaccountbythebreedersofinsects。Wearestillintheregionofillusionandimperfectprognostics。
ButtheOsmiaknowswhatwedonot。Sheisdeeplyversedinallphysiologicalandanatomicalknowledge,andinthefacultyofcreatingchildrenofeithersexatwill。
Theseprettybees,“withcopperyskinandfleeceofruddyvelvet。”whichestablishtheirprogenyinthehollowofabramblestump,thecavityofareed,orthewindingstaircaseofanemptysnail-shell,knowthefixedandimmutablegeneticlawswhichwecanonlyguessat,andarenevermistaken。
ThismarvellousprerogativetheOsmiashareswithahostofapiaries,inwhichtheunequaldevelopmentofthemalesandfemalesrequiresanunequalprovisionofspaceandofnourishmentforthefuturelarvae。Forthefemales,whoexceedinpointofsize,hugecellsandabundantprovision;
forthemorepunymales,narrowcellsandasmallerrationofpollenandhoney。
NowthecircumstanceswhichareencounteredbytheOsmia,when,pressedbythenecessitiesofspawning,shesearchesforadwelling,areoftenfortuitousandincapableofmodification;andinordertogiveeachsetoflarvaethenecessaryspace“shelaysatwillamaleorafemaleegg,accordingtotheconditionsofspace。”
Inthismarvellousstudy,whichconstitutes,withthehistoryoftheCerceris,thefinestmasterpieceofexperimentalentomology,FabrebrilliantlyestablishesallthedetailsofthatcuriouslawwhichintheHymenopterarulesboththedistributionandthesuccessionofthesexes。Inhisartificialhives,inglasscylinders,heforcestheOsmiatocommenceherspawningwiththemales,insteadofbeginningwiththefemalesasnaturerequires,sincetheinsectisprimarilypreoccupiedwiththemoreimportantsex,thatwhichensuresparexcellencetheperpetuationofthespecies。Heevenforcesthewholeswarmwhichbuzzesabouthiswork-tables,hisbooks,hisbottles,andapparatus,completelytochangetheorderofitsspawning。HeshowsfinallythatintheheartoftheovariestheeggoftheOsmiahasasyetnodeterminedsex,andthatitisonlyattheprecisemomentwhentheeggisonthepointofemergingfromtheoviductthatitreceives,ATTHEWILLOFTHEMOTHER,themysterious,final,andinevitableimprint。
ButwhencedoestheOsmiaderivethis,“distinctideaoftheinvisible“?
HereagainisoneofthoseriddlesofnaturewhichFabredeclareshimselfquiteincapableofsolving。8/17。
Isthisall?No;wearefarfromhavingmadethetourofthismiraculousandincommensurablekingdomthroughwhichthisadmirablemasterleadsus,andIshouldneverbedonewereItoattempttoexhaustallthespectacleswhichheoffersus。Letusdescendyetanotherstep,amongcreaturesyetsmallerandhumbler。Weshallfindtendencies,impulses,preferences,efforts,intentions,“Machiavellicrusesandunheard-ofstratagems。”
Certainmiserableblackmites,livingspecks,thelarvaeofabeetle,oneoftheMeloidae,theSitaris,areparasitesofthesolitarybee,theAnthophora。Theywaitpatientlyallthewinterattheentranceofhertunnel,ontheslopeofasunnybank,forthespringtimeemergenceoftheyoungbees,asyetimprisonedintheircellsofclay。AmaleAnthophora,hatchedalittleearlierthanthefemales,appearsintheentranceofthetunnel;thesemites,whicharearmedwithrobusttalons,rousethemselves,hastentoandfro,hookthemselvestohisfleece,andaccompanyhiminallhisperegrinations;buttheyquicklyrecognizetheirerror;fortheseanimatedspecksarewellawarethatthemales,occupiedalldaylonginscouringthecountryandpillagingtheflowers,liveexclusivelyoutofdoors,andwouldinnowiseservetheirend。ButthemomentcomeswhentheAnthophorapayscourttothefairsex,andtheimperceptiblecreatureimmediatelyprofitsbytheamorousencountertochangeitswingedcourser。
“Thesepigmiesthereforehaveamemory,anexperienceoffacts“andhowoneistemptedtoadd,aglimmeringofintelligence!。Grapplednowtothefemalebee,thegruboftheSitaris“concealsitself,andallowsitselftobecarriedbyher“totheendofthegalleryinwhichsheisnowcontrivinghercradle,“watchestheprecisemomentwhentheeggislaid,installsitselfuponit,andallowsitselftofalltherewithuponthesurfaceofthehoney,inordertosubstituteitselfforthefutureoffspringoftheAnthophora,andpossessitselfofhouseandvictuals。”8/18。
Another“littlegelatinousspeck。”“ashadowofacreature。”thelarvaofaChalcidian,theLeucopsis,oneoftheparasitesoftheMason-bee,knowsthatinthecellofthemasonthereisfoodforoneonly。Scarcelyhasitenteredthetinydwellingbutweseethis“namelessshape“forseveraldays“anxiouslywandering;itvisitsthetopandbottom,theback,thefront,thesides“;itmakesthetourofitsdomain;“itsearchesinthedarkness,palpitating,seeminglywithanobjectinview。”Whatdoesthis“animatedglobule“want?whyisthisatomsoexcited?Itissearchingtodiscoverifthereisnotinsomecornerhithertounexploredanotherlarva,arival,thatitmayexterminateit!8/19。
Whatthenintrinsicallyisinstinct?Andwhatintrinsicallyisintelligence?
Howcanweproposetodrawuptheinexhaustibleinventoryofallthemanifestationsoflife,andwhyattempttoincludeallitsspeciesandtheirunknownvarietiesinnarrowclasses?Whysaythatthereareonlytwomodesoflife,instinctontheonehandandintelligenceontheother,“whenweknowhowsubtleandillusiveisthisProteus,andthattherearenottwothingsonly,butathousanddissimilarthings“8/20。:orratherisitnotalwaysthesamething,everywherepresentandactinginlivingmatter,andsusceptibleofinfinitedegrees,underformsanddisguisesinnumerable?
Thisiswhyitescapesthe“scalpelofthemasters“andtheapparatusofthechemists。Wemaydissect,wemayscrutinizeorgansunderthemagnifyingglass,examinewing-cases,countthenervuresofthewings,thenumberofarticulationsinthelimbs;wemayreckoneverypoint,likeRéaumurforgettingnotaline,notahair;wemaycompareandmeasureeveryportionofthemouth,anddefinetheclass;andweshallnotfindasinglepointinallthisphysicalarchitecturewhichwillpositivelyinformusofthehabitsoftheinsect。Ofwhataccountareafewslightdifferences?Itisinthephysicalfarmorethanintheanatomicaldifferencesthattheinviolabledemarcationbetweentwospeciesexists。Instinctsdominateforms;thetooldoesnotmaketheartisan;“andnoneofthesevariousstructures,howeverwelladaptedtheymayappeartous,bearswithinititsreasonoritsfinality。”
Thuswhateveropinionwemayholdastothenatureofinstinct,theaccomplishmentsandhabitsofinsectsarenot,properlyspeaking,connectedwiththeexternalandvisibleformoftheirorgans,andtheiractsdonotnecessarilypresupposetheinstrumentswhichwouldbeappropriatetothem。
Weknowthatwithmostorganisms,andparticularlywithplants,analmostimperceptiblevariationinmaterialcircumstancesisoftenenoughtomodifytheircharacterandtoproducefreshaptitudes。Nevertheless,wecanbutwonder,withFabre,thatphysicalmodifications,which,whentheydoexist,aresoslightalwaysastohaveescapedthemostperfectobservation,shouldhavesufficedtodeterminetheappearanceofprofoundlydissimilarfaculties。Inexplicableabilities,unexpectedhabits,unforeseenphysicalaptitudes,andunheard-ofindustriesareexercisedbymeansoforganswhicharehereandtherepracticallyidentical。“Thesametoolsareequallygoodforanypurpose。Talentaloneisabletoadaptthemtomanifoldends。”
TheAnthidiahavetwoparticularindustries;“thosewhichfeltcottonandcardthesoftdownofhairyplantshavethesameclaws,thesamemandibles,composedofthesameportionsasthosewhichkneadresinandmixitwithfinegravel。”8/21。
Thesloe-weevil“boresthehardstoneofthesloewiththesamerostrumasthatwhichitscongeners,solikeitinconformation,employtorolltheleavesofthevineandthepoplarintotinycigars。”
TheimplementoftheMegachile,therose-fly,isbynomeansappropriatetoitsindustry;“yettheperfectlycircularfragmentsofleaveshavethepreciseperfectionofformthatapunchwouldgive。”
TheXylocopa,inordertopiercewoodandtoboreitsgalleriesinanoldrafter,employs“thesameutensilswhichinothersaretransformedintopicksandmattockstoattackclayandgravel,anditisonlyapredispositionoftalentthatholdseachworkertohisspeciality。”
Moreover,havenotthesuperioranimalsthesamesensesandthesamestructure,yetwhatinequalitythereisamongthem,inthematterofaptitudesanddegreesofintelligence!
Habitsarenomoredeterminedbyanatomicalpeculiaritiesthanareaptitudesorindustries。
ThetwoGoat-mothcaterpillars,ofsimilarstructure,haveentirelydifferentstomachicaptitudes;“theexclusiveportionoftheoneistheoakandoftheotherthehawthornorthecherry-laurel。”
“WhencedoestheMantisderiveitsexcessivehunger,itspugnacity,itscannibalism,andtheEmpusaitssobriety,itspeaceableness,whentheiralmostidenticalorganizationwouldseemtoindicateanidentityofneeds,instincts,andhabits?“
Inthesamewaytheblackscorpionappearstopresentnoneoftheinterestingpeculiaritieswhichweobserveinthehabitsofitscongener,thewhitescorpionofLanguedoc。8/22。
Structure,therefore,tellsusnothingofaptitude;theorgandoesnotexplainitsfunction。Letthespecialistshypnotizethemselvesovertheirlensesandmicroscopes;theymayaccumulateatleisuremassesofdetailsrelatingtothisorthatfamilyorgenusorindividual;theymayundertakethemostsubtleinquiries,maywritethousandsandthousandsofpagesinordertodetailafewslightvariations,withoutevensucceedinginexhaustingthematter:theywillnotevenhaveseenwhatismostwonderful。
Whenthelittleinsecthasforthelasttimecleaneditsclaws,thesecretofthelittlemindhasfledforever,withallthefeelingsthatanimateditandgaveitlife。Thatwhichiscrystallizedindeathcannotexplainwhatwaslife。ThisisthethoughtwhichtheProven?alsinger,withthatintuitionwhichistheprivilegeofgenius,hasexpressedinthesemelodiouslines:
“Oh!paudesènqu’emél’escaupreFurnantlamort,cresondesaupre,Lavertudel’abihoelousecrètdoùméu。”
Omenoflittlesense,whoseek,Scalpelinhand,tomakeDeathtellThevirtueofthebee,thesecretofhercell!8/23。
CHAPTER9。EVOLUTIONOR“TRANSFORMISM。”
“Howdidamiserablegrubacquireitsmarvellousknowledge?Areitshabits,itsaptitudes,anditsindustriestheintegrationoftheinfinitelylittle,acquiredbysuccessiveexperiencesonthelimitlesspathoftime?“
ItisinthesewordsthatFabrepresentstheproblemofevolution。
Difficultthoughitmaybetofollowthesequenceofformswhichhaveendlesslysucceededandreplacedoneanotheronthefaceoftheearth,sincethebeginningoftheworld,itiscertainthatalllivingcreaturesarecloselyrelated;andthemagnificentandfertilehypothesisofevolution,whichseekstoexplainhowextantformsarederivedfromextinct,hastheimmenseadvantageofgivingaplausiblereasonforthemajorityofthefactswhichatleastceasetobecompletelyunintelligible。
Otherwisewecancertainlyneverimaginehowsomanyinstincts,andthesesocomplexandperfect,couldhaveissuedsuddenly“fromtheurnofhazard。”
ButFabrewillsupposenothing;hewillonlyrecordthefacts。Insteadofwanderingintheregionofprobabilities,hepreferstoconfinehimselftothereality,andfortheresttoreplysimplythat“wedonotknow。”
Thisstern,positive,rigorous,independent,andobservantmind,nourishedupongeometryandtheexactsciences,whichhasneverbeenabletocontentitselfwithapproximationsandprobabilities,couldbutdistrusttheseductionsofhypotheses。
Hisrobustcommonsense,whichwasalwayshisprotectionagainstprecipitateconclusions,tooclearlycomprehendsthelimitsofscienceandthenecessityofaccumulatingfacts“uponthethornypathofobservationandexperiment“toindulgeingeneralization。Hefeelsthatlifehassecretswhichourmindsarepowerlesstoprobe,andthat“humanknowledgewillbeerasedfromthearchivesoftheworldbeforeweknowthelastwordconcerningthesmallestfly。”
Thisiswhyhewasregardedas“suspect“bythecompanyofofficialscientists,towhomhewasadissenter,almostatraitor,especiallyatamomentwhenthetheoriesofevolution,theninthefirstflushoftheirnovelty,wereeverywherethecauseofageneralelation。
Nooneasyetwascapableofdiviningthemanofthefutureinthismodestthinkerwhowouldnotacceptthewordofthemastersinterested,butinopposingthetheoryoftransformation,farfrombeingreactionary,Fabrerevealedhimself,atleastinthedomainofanimalpsychology,asaninnovator,atrueprecursor。
Moreover,hisobservations,alwayssodirectandpersonal,oftenrevealedthecontraryofwhatwasassertedorforeseenbythemagicformulaesuggestedbythemind。
Totheingeniousmechanisminventedbythetransformistshepreferredtooppose,notcontraryargument,butthenakedundeniablefact,theobvioustestimony,thecertainandirrefragableexample。“Isit。”hewouldaskthem,“torepulsetheirenemiesthatcertaincaterpillarssmearthemselveswithacorrosiveproduct?ButthelarvaoftheCalosomasycophanta,whichfeedsontheProcessionalcaterpillaroftheoak-tree,paysnoheedtoit,neitherdoestheDermestes,whichfeedsontheentrailsoftheProcessionalcaterpillarofthepine-tree。”
Andconsidermimicry。Accordingtothetheoryofevolution,certaininsectswouldutilizetheirresemblancetocertainothersinordertoconcealthemselves,andtointroducethemselvesintothedwellingsofthelatterasparasiteslivingattheirexpense。SuchwouldbethecasewiththeVolucella,alargeflywhosecostume,stripedwithbrownandyellowbands,givesitaruderesemblancetothewasp。Obliged,ifnotforitsownsakeatleastforthatofitsfamily,toforceitselfintothewasp’sdwellingasaparasite,itdeceitfullydressesitself,wearetold,intheliveryofitsvictim,thusaffordingthemostcuriousandstrikingexampleofmimicry;andnaturalistsinsufficientlyinformedwouldregarditasoneofthegreatesttriumphsofevolution。
NowwhatdoestheVolucellado?Itistruethatitlaysitseggswithoutbeingdisturbedinthenestofthewasp。But,astherigorousobserverwilltellyou,itisapreciousauxiliaryandnotanenemyofthecommunity。Itsgrubs,farfromdisguisingorconcealingthemselves,“comeandgoopenlyuponthecombs,althougheverystrangerisimmediatelymassacredandthrownout。”Moreover,“theywatchthehygieneofthecitybyclearingthenestofitsdeadandriddingthelarvaeofthewaspsoftheirexcretoryproducts。”
Plungingsuccessivelyintoeachchamberofthedormitorytheforepartoftheirbodies,“theyprovoketheemissionofthatfluidexcrementofwhichthelarvae,owingtotheircloistration,containanextremereserve。”Inaword,thegrubsoftheVolucella“arethenursesofthelarvae。”performingthemostintimateduties。”9/1。
Whatanastonishingconclusion!Whatadisconcertingandunexpectedreplytothe“theoriesinvogue“!
Fabre,however,withhispoetictemperamentandardentimagination,seemedadmirablypreparedtograspallthatvastnetworkofrelationsbywhichallcreaturesareconnected;butwhatprovesthesolidityofhisimperishableworkisthatalltheories,alldoctrines,andallsystemsmayresorttoitinturnandprofitbyhisproofsandarguments。
Andhehimself,althoughheboastswithsomuchreasonofputtingforwardnopretensions,notheories,nosystems,hashenotevensoyieldedsomewhattothesuggestionsoftheprevailingschoolofthought,andhavenothisverdictsagainstevolutionoftenbeenthemoreexcessiveinthathehaspaidsonotableatributetotheevolutionaryprogressofcreation?
Inthefirstplace,heisfarfromexcludingtheundeniableinfluenceofenvironingcauses;theimmenseroleofthosemyriadexternalcircumstancesonwhichLamarcksostronglyinsisted;buttheworkofthesefactorsis,inhiseyes,onlyaccessoryandwhollysecondaryintheeconomyofnature;andinanycaseitisfarfromexplainingthedefinitedirectionandthetranscendentharmonywhichcharacterizeevolution,bothinitstotalityandinitsmostinfinitesimaldetails。
Inoneofhisadmirablelittletextbooks,intendedtoteachandtopopularizescience,hecomplacentlyenumeratesthehappymodificationseffectedbythat“sublimemagician。”selectionasunderstoodbyDarwin。Heevokesthemetamorphosesofthepotato,which,onthemountainsofChili,ismerelyawretchedvenomoustubercle,andthoseofthecabbage,whichontherockyfaceofoceanicprecipicesisnothingbutaweed,“withatallstemandscantydisorderedleavesofacrudegreen,anacridsavour,andaranksmell“;hespeaksofwheat,formerlyapoorunknowngrass;theprimitivepear-tree“anuglyintractablethornybush,withdetestablebitterfruit“;thewildcelery,whichgrowsbesideponds,“greenallover,hard,witharepulsiveflavour,andwhichgraduallybecomestenderer,sweeter,whiter。”and“ceasestodistilitspoison。”9/2。
Withprofoundexactitudethisgreatbiologisthasalsoperceivedthedegreetowhichsizemaybemodified;maydwindletodwarfnesswhenaniggardlysoilrefusestofurnishbeastandplantalikewithasufficientnourishment。
Withoutanycommunicationwiththeotherscientistswhowereoccupiedbythesamequestions,knowingnothingoftheresultswhichtheseexperimentershadattainedinthecaseofsmallmammiferousanimals,andwhichprovethatdwarfnesshasoftennoothercausethanphysiologicalpoverty,heconfirmedandexpandedtheirideasfromanentomologicalpointofview。9/3。
Scarcelyever,indeed,washefirstinspiredbythedoingsofothersinthisorthatdirection;hereadscarcelyanything,andnaturewashissoleteacher。Heconsideredthattheknowledgetobeobtainedfrombooksisbutsomuchvapourcomparedwiththerealities;heborrowedonlyfromhimself,andresorteddirectlytothefactsasnaturepresentedthem。Onehasonlytoseehisscantylibraryofoddvolumestobeconvincedhowlittleheowestoothers,whetherwritersorworkers。
Atruenaturalistphilosopher,thisprofoundobserverhasalsothrownalightuponcertainsingularanomalieswhich,intheinsectworld,seemtoconstituteanexception,atalleventsinourEurope,tothegeneralrules。
Itisnotonlytothecuriosityandfortheamusementofentomologiststhatheproposesthesecuriousanatomicalproblems,butalso,andchiefly,totheDarwinianwisdomoftheevolutionists。
Why,forexample,istheScarabaeussacerbornandwhydoesitremainmaimedallitslife;thatistosay,deprivedofallthedigitsontheanteriorlimbs?
“Ifitistruethateverychangeintheformofanappendageisonlythesignofahabit,aspecialinstinct,oramodificationintheconditionsoflife,thetheoryofevolutionshouldendeavourtoaccountforthismutilation,forthesecreaturesare,likeallothers,constructedonthesameplanandprovidedwithabsolutelythesameappendages。”
TheposteriorlimbsoftheGeotrupesstercorarius,“perfectlydevelopedintheadult,areatrophiedinthelarvae,reducedtomerespecks。”
Thegeneralhistoryofthespecies,ofitsmigrationsanditschanges,willdoubtlessonedaythrowlightuponthesestrangeinfirmities,heretemporaryandtherepermanent,whichmayperhapsbeexplainedbyunforeseenencounterswithundiscoveredspecimens,strayedperhapsintodistantcountries。9/4。
WhatinvaluabledocumentsfortheentomologistandthehistorianoftheevolutionofthespeciesarethosemultipleandfabulousmetamorphosesoftheSitaresandtheMelo?daewhichthisindefatigableinquirerhasrevealedinalltheirastonishingphases!
Oneofthefinestexamplesofscientificinvestigationisthepursuit,throughaperiodoftwenty-fiveyears,withasagacitywhichseemstoborderondivination,ofthisproblemofHYPER-METAMORPHOSIS。Thelarvaeofthosecoleopterawhichwehaveseenintroduced,withinfernalcunning,intothecellsoftheAnthophoraSeeChapter8above。,suffernolessthanfourmoultsbeforetheybecomenymphs。
Thesemerelyexternaltransformations,whichinvolveonlytheenvelope,andrespecttheinternalstructure,correspondeachwithachangeofenvironmentandofdiet。Eachtimetheorganismadaptsitselftoitsnewmodeofexistence,“asperfectlyaswhenitbecomesadult“;andweseetheinsect,whichwasclear-sighted,becomeblind;itlosesitsfeet,torecoverthemlater;itsslenderbodybecomesventripotent;hard,itgrowssoft;itsmandibles,atfirststeely,becomehollowedoutspoonwise,eachmodificationofconformationhavingitsmotiveinafreshmodificationoftheconditionsofthecreature’slife。
Howexplainthisstrangeevolutionofafourfoldlarvalexistence,thesesuccessiveappearancesoforgans,whichbecomeentirelyunlikewhattheywere,toservefunctionseachtimedifferent?