InSeptember,1898,theFirstVolunteerCavalry,incompanywithmostoftherestoftheFifthArmyCorps,wasdisembarkedatMontaukPoint。
Shortlyafteritwasdisbanded,andafewdayslater,IwasnominatedforGovernorofNewYorkbytheRepublicanparty。TimothyL。WoodruffwasnominatedforLieutenant-Governor。Hewasmystanchfriendthroughoutthetermofourjointservice。
Thepreviousyear,themachineorstandpatRepublicans,whowereunderthedominationofSenatorPlatt,hadcometoacompletebreakwiththeanti-machineelementovertheNewYorkmayoralty。ThishadbroughttheRepublicanpartytoasmash,notonlyinNewYorkCity,butintheState,wheretheDemocraticcandidateforChiefJudgeoftheCourtofAppeals,AltonB。Parker,waselectedbysixtyoreightythousandmajority。Mr。Parkerwasanableman,alieutenantofMr。Hill’s,standingclosetotheconservativeDemocratsoftheWallStreettype。
TheseconservativeDemocratswereplanninghowtowresttheDemocraticpartyfromthecontrolofMr。Bryan。TheyhailedJudgeParker’svictoryasagodsend。TheJudgeatonceloomedupasaPresidentialpossibility,andwascarefullygroomedforthepositionbytheNewYorkDemocraticmachine,anditsfinancialalliesintheNewYorkbusinessworld。
TheRepublicansrealizedthatthechanceswereverymuchagainstthem。
Accordinglytheleaderswereinachastenedmoodandreadytonominateanycandidatewithwhomtheythoughttherewasachanceofwinning。I
wastheonlypossibility,and,accordingly,underpressurefromcertainoftheleaderswhorecognizedthisfact,andwhorespondedtopopularpressure,SenatorPlattpickedmeforthenomination。Hewasentirelyfrankinthematter。Hemadenopretensethathelikedmepersonally;buthedeferredtothejudgmentofthosewhoinsistedthatIwastheonlymanwhocouldbeelected,andthatthereforeIhadtobenominated。
ForemostamongtheleaderswhopressedmeonMr。Plattwho“pestered“
himaboutme,tousehisownwordswereMr。Quigg,Mr。Odell——thenStateChairmanoftheRepublicanorganization,andafterwardsGovernor——andMr。Hazel,nowUnitedStatesJudge。JudgeHazeldidnotknowmepersonally,butfeltthatthesentimentinhiscity,Buffalo,demandedmynomination,andthatthethenRepublicanGovernor,Mr。Black,couldnotbereelected。Mr。Odell,whohardlyknewmepersonally,feltthesamewayaboutMr。Black’schances,and,ashehadjusttakentheStateChairmanship,hewasveryanxioustowinavictory。Mr。Quiggknewmequitewellpersonally;hehadbeenintouchwithmeforyears,whilehewasareporteronthe/Tribune/,andalsowhenheeditedapaperinMontana;hehadbeenongoodtermswithmewhilehewasinCongressandIwasCivilServiceCommissioner,meetingmeoftenincompanywithmyespecialcroniesinCongress——menlikeLodge,SpeakerTomReed,Greenhalge,Butterworth,andDolliver——andhehadurgedmyappointmentasPoliceCommissioneronMayorStrong。
ItwasMr。QuiggwhocalledonmeatMontaukPointtosoundmeabouttheGovernorship;Mr。PlattbeingbynomeansenthusiasticoverMr。
Quigg’smission,largelybecausehedisapprovedoftheSpanishWarandofmypartinbringingitabout。Mr。Quiggsawmeinmytent,inwhichhespentacoupleofhourswithme,mybrother-in-law,DouglasRobinson,beingalsopresent。Quiggspokeveryfranklytome,statingthatheearnestlydesiredtoseemenominatedandbelievedthatthegreatbodyofRepublicanvotersintheStatesodesired,butthattheorganizationandtheStateConventionwouldfinallydowhatSenatorPlattdesired。HesaidthatcountyleaderswerealreadycomingtoSenatorPlatt,hintingatacloseelection,expressingdoubtofGovernorBlack’savailabilityforreelection,andaskingwhyitwouldnotbeagoodthingtonominateme;thatnowthatIhadreturnedtotheUnitedStatesthiswouldgoonmoreandmoreallthetime,andthatheQuiggdidnotwishthatthesemenshouldbediscouragedandbesentbacktotheirlocalitiestosuppressarisingsentimentinmyfavor。ForthisreasonhesaidthathewantedfrommeaplainstatementastowhetherornotIwantedthenomination,andastowhatwouldbemyattitudetowardtheorganizationintheeventofmynominationandelection,whetherornotIwould“makewar“onMr。
Plattandhisfriends,orwhetherIwouldconferwiththemandwiththeorganizationleadersgenerally,andgivefairconsiderationtotheirpointofviewastopartypolicyandpublicinterest。Hesaidhehadnotcometomakemeanyofferofthenomination,andhadnoauthoritytodoso,nortogetanypledgesorpromises。Hesimplywantedafrankdefinitionofmyattitudetowardsexistingpartyconditions。
TothisIrepliedthatIshouldliketobenominated,andifnominatedwouldpromisetothrowmyselfintothecampaignwithallpossibleenergy。IsaidthatIshouldnotmakewaronMr。Plattoranybodyelseifwarcouldbeavoided;thatwhatIwantedwastobeGovernorandnotafactionleader;thatIcertainlywouldconferwiththeorganizationmen,aswitheverybodyelsewhoseemedtometohaveknowledgeofandinterestinpublicaffairs,andthatastoMr。Plattandtheorganizationleaders,Iwoulddosointhesincerehopethattheremightalwaysresultharmonyofopinionandpurpose;butthatwhileI
wouldtrytogetonwellwiththeorganization,theorganizationmustwithequalsinceritystrivetodowhatIregardedasessentialforthepublicgood;andthatineverycase,afterfullconsiderationofwhateverybodyhadtosaywhomightpossessrealknowledgeofthematter,I
shouldhavetoactfinallyasmyownjudgmentandconsciencedictatedandadministertheStategovernmentasIthoughtitoughttobeadministered。QuiggsaidthatthiswaspreciselywhathesupposedI
wouldsay,thatitwasallanybodycouldexpect,andthathewouldstateittoSenatorPlattpreciselyasIhadputittohim,whichheaccordinglydid;and,throughoutmytermasGovernor,Quigglivedloyallyuptoourunderstanding。[*]
[*]InalettertomeMr。Quiggstates,whatIhadforgotten,thatI
toldhimtotelltheSenatorthatIwouldtalkfreelywithhim,andhadnointentionofbecomingafactionalleaderwithapersonalorganization,yetthatImusthavedirectpersonalrelationswitheverybody,andgettheirviewsatfirsthandwheneverIsodesired,becauseIcouldnothaveonemanspeakingforall。
Afterbeingnominated,ImadeahardandaggressivecampaignthroughtheState。Myopponentwasarespectableman,ajudge,behindwhomstoodMr。Croker,thebossofTammanyHall。MyobjectwastomakethepeopleunderstandthatitwasCroker,andnotthenominalcandidate,whowasmyrealopponent;thatthechoicelaybetweenCrokerismandmyself。Crokerwasapowerfulandtruculentman,theautocratofhisorganization,andofadomineeringnature。ForhisownreasonsheinsisteduponTammany’sturningdownanexcellentDemocraticjudgewhowasacandidateforreelection。Thisgavememychance。Undermyattack,Croker,whowasastalwartfightingmanandwhowouldnottakeanattacktamely,himselfcametothefront。Iwasabletofixthecontestinthepublicmindasonebetweenhimselfandmyself;and,againstallprobabilities,Iwonbytherathernarrowmarginofeighteenthousandplurality。
AsIhavealreadysaid,thereisalunaticfringetoeveryreformmovement。Atleastnine-tenthsofallthesincerereformerssupportedme;buttheultra-pacifists,theso-calledanti-imperialists,oranti-
militarists,orpeace-at-any-pricemen,preferredCrokertome;andanotherknotofextremistswhohadatfirstardentlyinsistedthatI
mustbe“forced“onPlatt,assoonasPlattsupportedmethemselvesopposedme/because/hesupportedme。AfterelectionJohnHaywrotemeasfollows:“WhileyouareGovernor,Ibelievethepartycanbemadesolidasneverbefore。Youhavealreadyshownthatamanmaybeabsolutelyhonestandyetpractical;areformerbyinstinctandawisepolitician;brave,bold,anduncompromising,andyetnotawildassofthedesert。Theexhibitionmadebytheprofessionalindependentsinvotingagainstyoufornoreasononearthexceptthatsomebodyelsewasvotingforyou,isalessonthatisworthitscost。”
Atthattimebossrulewasatitsveryzenith。Mr。Bryan’scandidacyin1896onafreesilverplatformhadthreatenedsuchfrightfulbusinessdisasterastomakethebusinessmen,thewage-workers,andtheprofessionalclassesgenerally,turneagerlytotheRepublicanparty。EastoftheMississippitheRepublicanvoteforMr。McKinleywaslargerbyfarthanithadbeenforAbrahamLincolninthedayswhenthelifeoftheNationwasatstake。Mr。Bryanchampionedmanysorelyneededreformsintheinterestoftheplainpeople;butmanyofhisplatformproposals,economicandotherwise,wereofsuchacharacterthattohaveputthemintopracticewouldhavemeanttoplungeallourpeopleintoconditionsfarworsethananyofthoseforwhichhesoughtaremedy。Thefreesilveradvocatesincludedsincereanduprightmenwhowereabletomakeastrongcasefortheirposition;butwiththemanddominatingthemwereallthebelieversinthecompleteorpartialrepudiationofNational,State,andprivatedebts;andnotonlythebusinessmenbuttheworkingmengrewtofeelthatunderthesecircumstancestooheavyapricecouldnotbepaidtoaverttheDemocratictriumph。ThefearofMr。Bryanthrewalmostalltheleadingmenofallclassesintothearmsofwhoeveropposedhim。
TheRepublicanbosses,whowerealreadyverypowerful,andwhowerealreadyinfairlyclosealliancewiththeprivilegedinterests,nowfoundeverythingworkingtotheiradvantage。Goodandhigh-mindedmenofconservativetemperamentintheirpanicplayedintothehandsoftheultra-reactionariesofbusinessandpolitics。Thealliancebetweenthetwokindsofprivilege,politicalandfinancial,wascloselycemented;andwherevertherewasanyattempttobreakitup,thecrywasatonceraisedthatthismerelyrepresentedanotherphaseoftheassaultonNationalhonestyandindividualandmercantileintegrity。
Assooftenhappens,theexcessesandthreatsofanunwiseandextremeradicalismhadresultedinimmenselystrengtheningthepositionofthebeneficiariesofreaction。ThiswastheerawhentheStandardOilCompanyachievedamasteryofPennsylvaniapoliticssofar-reachingandsocorruptthatitisdifficulttodescribeitwithoutseemingtoexaggerate。
InNewYorkState,UnitedStatesSenatorPlattwastheabsolutebossoftheRepublicanparty。“Bigbusiness“wasbackofhim;yetatthetimethis,themostimportantelementinhisstrength,wasonlyimperfectlyunderstood。ItwasnotuntilIwaselectedGovernorthatI
myselfcametounderstandit。Wewerestillaccustomedtotalkingofthe“machine“asifitweresomethingmerelypolitical,withwhichbusinesshadnothingtodo。SenatorPlattdidnotusehispoliticalpositiontoadvancehisprivatefortunes——thereindifferingabsolutelyfrommanyotherpoliticalbosses。Helivedinhotelsandhadfewextravaganttastes。Indeed,Icouldnotfindthathehadanytastesatallexceptforpolitics,andonrareoccasionsforaverydrytheologywhollydivorcedfrommoralimplications。Butbigbusinessmencontributedtohimlargesumsofmoney,whichenabledhimtokeephisgriponthemachineandsecuredforthemthehelpofthemachineiftheywerethreatenedwithadverselegislation。Thecontributionsweregivenintheguiseofcontributionsforcampaignpurposes,ofmoneyforthegoodoftheparty;whenthemoneywascontributedtherewasrarelytalkofspecificfavorsinreturn。[*]ItwassimplyputintoMr。Platt’shandsandtreatedbyhimasinthecampaignchest。Thenhedistributeditinthedistrictswhereitwasmostneededbythecandidatesandorganizationleaders。Ordinarilynopledgewasrequiredfromthelattertothebosses,anymorethanitwasrequiredbythebusinessmenfromMr。Plattorhislieutenants。Nopledgewasneeded。
Itwasalla“gentlemen’sunderstanding。”AstheSenatoroncesaidtome,ifaman’scharacterwassuchthatitwasnecessarytogetapromisefromhim,itwasclearproofthathischaracterwassuchthatthepromisewouldnotbeworthanythingafteritwasmade。
[*]Eachnationhasitsownpetsinstowhichitismercifulandalsosinswhichittreatsasmostabhorrent。InAmericawearepeculiarlysensitiveaboutbigmoneycontributionsforwhichthedonorsexpectanyreward。InEngland,whereinsomewaysthestandardishigherthanhere,suchcontributionsareacceptedasamatterofcourse,nay,asoneofthemethodsbywhichwealthymenobtainpeerages。Itwouldbewell-nighanimpossibilityforamantosecureaseatintheUnitedStatesSenatebymerecampaigncontributions,inthewaythatseatsintheBritishHouseofLordshaveoftenbeensecuredwithoutanyscandalbeingcausedthereby。