answeredhim,“ThetroublewithRodneyisthathemisestimateshisrelationstocosmos“;towhichheresponded,“Cosmos——Cosmos?Neverheardofhim。YousticktoRodney。He’syourman!”Outsideofthepublicservantsthereweremultitudesofmen,innewspaperoffices,inmagazineoffices,inbusinessortheprofessionsoronfarmsorinshops,whoactivelysupportedthepoliciesforwhichIstoodanddidworkofgenuineleadershipwhichwasquiteaseffectiveasanyworkdonebymeninpublicoffice。WithouttheactivesupportofthesemenIwouldhavebeenpowerless。Inparticular,theleadingnewspapercorrespondentsatWashingtonwereasawholeasingularlyable,trustworthy,andpublic-spiritedbodyofmen,andthemostusefulofallagentsinthefightforefficientanddecentgovernment。
Asforthemenundermeinexecutiveoffice,IcouldnotoverstatethedebtofgratitudeIowethem。Fromtheheadsofthedepartments,theCabinetofficers,down,themoststrikingfeatureoftheAdministrationwasthedevoted,zealous,andefficientworkthatwasdoneassoonasitbecameunderstoodthattheonebondofinterestamongallofuswasthedesiretomaketheGovernmentthemosteffectiveinstrumentinadvancingtheinterestsofthepeopleasawhole,theinterestsoftheaveragemenandwomenoftheUnitedStatesandoftheirchildren。IdonotthinkIoverstatethecasewhenIsaythatmostofthemenwhodidthebestworkundermefeltthatourswasapartnership,thatweallstoodonthesamelevelofpurposeandservice,andthatitmatterednotwhatpositionanyoneofusheldsolongasinthatpositionhegavetheverybestthatwasinhim。Weworkedveryhard;butImadeapointofgettingacoupleofhoursoffeachdayforequallyvigorousplay。ThemenwithwhomIthenplayed,whomwelaughinglygrewtocallthe“TennisCabinet。”havebeenmentionedinapreviouschapterofthisbookinconnectionwiththegifttheygavemeatthelastbreakfastwhichtheytookattheWhiteHouse。ThereweremanyothersinthepublicserviceundermewithwhomIhappenednottoplay,butwhodidtheirshareofourcommonworkjustaseffectivelyasitwasdonebyuswhodidplay。OfcoursenothingcouldhavebeendoneinmyAdministrationifithadnotbeenforthezeal,intelligence,masterfulability,anddownrighthardlaborofthesemenincountlesspositionsunderme。Iwashelplesstodoanythingexceptasmythoughtsandordersweretranslatedintoactionbythem;and,moreover,eachofthem,ashegrewspeciallyfitforhisjob,usedtosuggesttometherightthoughttohave,andtherightordertogive,concerningthatjob。Itisofcoursehardformetospeakwithcoldanddispassionatepartialityofthesemen,whowereasclosetomeaswerethemenofmyregiment。ButtheoutsideobserversbestfittedtopassjudgmentaboutthemfeltasIdid。AttheendofmyAdministrationMr。Bryce,theBritishAmbassador,toldmethatinalonglife,duringwhichhehadstudiedintimatelythegovernmentofmanydifferentcountries,hehadneverinanycountryseenamoreeager,high-minded,andefficientsetofpublicservants,menmoreusefulandmorecreditabletotheircountry,thanthementhendoingtheworkoftheAmericanGovernmentinWashingtonandinthefield。IrepeatthisstatementwiththepermissionofMr。Bryce。
Ataboutthesametime,oralittlebefore,inthespringof1908,thereappearedintheEnglish/FortnightlyReview/anarticle,evidentlybyacompetenteyewitness,settingforthmoreindetailthesameviewstowhichtheBritishAmbassadorthusprivatelygaveexpression。Itwasinpartasfollows:
“Mr。Roosevelthasgatheredaroundhimabodyofpublicservantswhoarenowheresurpassed,Iquestionwhethertheyareanywhereequaled,forefficiency,self-sacrifice,andanabsolutedevotiontotheircountry’sinterests。Manyofthemarepoormen,withoutprivatemeans,whohavevoluntarilyabandonedhighprofessionalambitionsandturnedtheirbacksontherewardsofbusinesstoservetheircountryonsalariesthatarenotmerelyinadequate,butindecentlyso。Thereisnotoneofthemwhoisnotconstantlyassailedbyoffersofpositionsintheworldofcommerce,finance,andthelawthatwouldsatisfyeverymaterialambitionwithwhichhebeganlife。Thereisnotoneofthemwhocouldnot,ifhechose,earnoutsideWashingtonfromtentotwentytimestheincomeonwhichheeconomizesasaStateofficial。ButthesemenareasindifferenttomoneyandtothepowerthatmoneybringsastotheallurementsofNewportandNewYork,ortomerelypersonaldistinctions,ortothecommercializedidealswhichthegreatbulkoftheirfellow-countrymenacceptwithoutquestion。Theyarecontent,andmorethancontent,tosinkthemselvesintheNationalservicewithoutathoughtofprivateadvancement,andoftenataheavysacrificeofworldlyhonors,andtotoilon……sustainedbytheirownnativeimpulsetomakeofpatriotismanefficientinstrumentofpublicbetterment。”
TheAmericanpublicrarelyappreciatethehighqualityoftheworkdonebysomeofourdiplomats——work,usuallyentirelyunnoticedandunrewarded,whichredoundstotheinterestandthehonorofallofus。
Themostusefulmanintheentirediplomaticservice,duringmypresidency,andformanyyearsbefore,wasHenryWhite;andIsaythishavinginmindthehighqualityofworkdonebysuchadmirableambassadorsandministersasBacon,Meyer,Straus,O’Brien,Rockhill,andEgan,tonameonlyafewamongmany。WhenIleftthepresidencyWhitewasAmbassadortoFrance;shortlyafterwardshewasremovedbyMr。Taft,forreasonsunconnectedwiththegoodoftheservice。
ThemostimportantfactoringettingtherightspiritinmyAdministration,nexttotheinsistenceuponcourage,honesty,andagenuinedemocracyofdesiretoservetheplainpeople,wasmyinsistenceuponthetheorythattheexecutivepowerwaslimitedonlybyspecificrestrictionsandprohibitionsappearingintheConstitutionorimposedbytheCongressunderitsConstitutionalpowers。Myviewwasthateveryexecutiveofficer,andabovealleveryexecutiveofficerinhighposition,wasastewardofthepeopleboundactivelyandaffirmativelytodoallhecouldforthepeople,andnottocontenthimselfwiththenegativemeritofkeepinghistalentsundamagedinanapkin。IdeclinedtoadopttheviewthatwhatwasimperativelynecessaryfortheNationcouldnotbedonebythePresidentunlesshecouldfindsomespecificauthorizationtodoit。
MybeliefwasthatitwasnotonlyhisrightbuthisdutytodoanythingthattheneedsoftheNationdemandedunlesssuchactionwasforbiddenbytheConstitutionorbythelaws。UnderthisinterpretationofexecutivepowerIdidandcausedtobedonemanythingsnotpreviouslydonebythePresidentandtheheadsofthedepartments。Ididnotusurppower,butIdidgreatlybroadentheuseofexecutivepower。Inotherwords,Iactedforthepublicwelfare,I
actedforthecommonwell-beingofallourpeople,wheneverandinwhatevermannerwasnecessary,unlesspreventedbydirectconstitutionalorlegislativeprohibition。Ididnotcarearapforthemereformandshowofpower;Icaredimmenselyfortheusethatcouldbemadeofthesubstance。TheSenateatonetimeobjectedtomycommunicatingwiththeminprinting,preferringtheexpensive,foolish,andlaboriouspracticeofwritingoutthemessagesbyhand。
Itwasnotpossibletoreturntotheoutwornarchaismofhandwriting;
butweendeavoredtohavetheprintingmadeasprettyaspossible。
WhetherIcommunicatedwiththeCongressinwritingorbywordofmouth,andwhetherthewritingwasbyamachine,orapen,wereequally,andabsolutely,unimportantmatters。TheimportancelayinwhatIsaidandintheheedpaidtowhatIsaid。SoastomymeetingandconsultingSenators,Congressmen,politicians,financiers,andlabormen。Iconsultedallwhowishedtoseeme;andifIwishedtoseeanyone,Isentforhim;andwheretheconsultationtookplacewasamatterofsupremeunimportance。IconsultedeverymanwiththesincerehopethatIcouldprofitbyandfollowhisadvice;IconsultedeverymemberofCongresswhowishedtobeconsulted,hopingtobeabletocometoanagreementofactionwithhim;andIalwaysfinallyactedasmyconscienceandcommonsensebademeact。
AboutappointmentsIwasobligedbytheConstitutiontoconsulttheSenate;andthelong-establishedcustomoftheSenatemeantthatinpracticethisconsultationwaswithindividualSenatorsandevenwithbigpoliticianswhostoodbehindtheSenators。Iwasonlyone-halftheappointingpower;Inominated;buttheSenateconfirmed。Inpractice,bywhatwascalled“thecourtesyoftheSenate。”theSenatenormallyrefusedtoconfirmanyappointmentiftheSenatorfromtheStateobjectedtoit。Inexceptionalcases,whereIcouldarousepublicattention,IcouldforcethroughtheappointmentinspiteoftheoppositionoftheSenators;inallordinarycasesthiswasimpossible。
Ontheotherhand,theSenatorcouldofcoursedonothingforanymanunlessIchosetonominatehim。InconsequencetheConstitutionitselfforcedthePresidentandtheSenatorsfromeachStatetocometoaworkingagreementontheappointmentsinandfromthatState。
Mycoursewastoinsistonabsolutefitness,includinghonesty,asaprerequisitetoeveryappointment;andtoremoveonlyforgoodcause,and,wheretherewassuchcause,torefuseeventodiscusswiththeSenatorininteresttheunfitservant’sretention。Subjecttotheseconsiderations,InormallyacceptedeachSenator’srecommendationsforofficesofaroutinekind,suchasmostpost-officesandthelike,butinsistedonmyselfchoosingthemenforthemoreimportantpositions。
Iwaswillingtotakeanygoodmanforpostmaster;butinthecaseofaJudgeorDistrictAttorneyorCanalCommissionerorAmbassador,I
wasapttoinsisteitheronagivenmanorelseonanymanwithagivenclassofqualifications。IftheSenatordeceivedme,Itookcarethathehadnoopportunitytorepeatthedeception。
Icanperhapsbestillustratemytheoryofactionbytwospecificexamples。InNewYorkGovernorOdellandSenatorPlattsometimesworkedinagreementandsometimeswereatswords’points,andbothwishedtobeconsulted。ToafriendlyCongressman,whowasalsotheirfriend,IwroteasfollowsonJuly22,1903:
“IwanttoworkwithPlatt。IwanttoworkwithOdell。Iwanttosupportbothandtaketheadviceofboth。ButofcourseultimatelyImustbethejudgeastoactingontheadvicegiven。When,asinthecaseofthejudgeship,Iamconvincedthattheadviceofbothiswrong,IshallactasIdidwhenIappointedHolt。WhenIcanfindafriendofOdell’slikeCooley,whoisthoroughlyfitforthepositionIdesiretofill,itgivesmethegreatestpleasuretoappointhim。WhenPlattproposestomeamanlikeHamiltonFish,itisequallyapleasuretoappointhim。”
ThiswaswritteninconnectionwitheventswhichleduptomyrefusingtoacceptSenatorPlatt’sorGovernorOdell’ssuggestionsastoaFederalJudgeshipandaFederalDistrictAttorneyship,andinsistingontheappointment,firstofJudgeHoughandlaterofDistrictAttorneyStimson;becauseineachcaseIfeltthattheworktobedonewasofsohighanorderthatIcouldnottakeanordinaryman。
TheothercasewasthatofSenatorFulton,ofOregon。ThroughFrancisHeneyIwasprosecutingmenwhowereimplicatedinavastnetworkofconspiracyagainstthelawinconnectionwiththetheftofpubliclandinOregon。IhadbeenactingonSenatorFulton’srecommendationsforoffice,intheusualmanner。HeneyhadbeeninsistingthatFultonwasinleaguewiththemenwewereprosecuting,andthathehadrecommendedunfitmen。FultonhadbeenprotestingagainstmyfollowingHeney’sadvice,particularlyasregardsappointingJudgeWolvertonasUnitedStatesJudge。FinallyHeneylaidbeforemeareportwhichconvincedmeofthetruthofhisstatements。IthenwrotetoFultonasfollows,onNovember20,1905:“MydearSenatorFulton:IincloseyouherewithacopyofthereportmadetomebyMr。Heney。IhaveseentheoriginalsofthelettersfromyouandSenatorMitchellquotedtherein。
Idonotatthistimedesiretodiscussthereportitself,whichofcourseImustsubmittotheAttorney-General。ButIhavebeenobligedtoreachthepainfulconclusionthatyourownlettersasthereinquotedtendtoshowthatyourecommendedforthepositionofDistrictAttorneyBwhenyouhadgoodreasontobelievethathehadhimselfbeenguiltyoffraudulentconduct;thatyourecommendedCforthesamepositionsimplybecauseitwasforB’sinterestthatheshouldbesorecommended,and,asthereisreasontobelieve,becausehehadagreedtodividethefeeswithBifhewereappointed;andthatyoufinallyrecommendedthereappointmentofHwiththeknowledgethatifHwereappointedhewouldabstainfromprosecutingBforcriminalmisconduct,thisbeingwhyBadvocatedH’sclaimsforreappointment。Ifyoucaretomakeanystatementinthematter,Ishallofcoursebegladtohearit。AstheDistrictJudgeofOregonIshallappointJudgeWolverton。”
IntheletterIofcoursegaveinfullthenamesindicatedabovebyinitials。SenatorFultongavenoexplanation。IthereforeceasedtoconsulthimaboutappointmentsundertheDepartmentofJusticeandtheInterior,thetwodepartmentsinwhichthecrookednesshadoccurred