MyopponentsduringthecampaignhadlaidmuchstressuponmysupposedpersonalambitionandintentiontousetheofficeofPresidenttoperpetuatemyselfinpower。Ididnotsayanythingonthesubjectpriortotheelection,asIdidnotwishtosayanythingthatcouldbeconstruedintoapromiseofferedasaconsiderationinordertosecurevotes。Butonelectionnight,afterthereturnswereinIissuedthefollowingstatement:“ThewisecustomwhichlimitsthePresidenttotwotermsregardsthesubstanceandnottheform,andundernocircumstanceswillIbeacandidatefororacceptanothernomination。”
Thereasonformychoiceoftheexactphraseologyusedwastwofold。Inthefirstplace,manyofmysupporterswereinsistingthat,asIhadservedonlythreeandahalfyearsofmyfirstterm,cominginfromtheVice-PresidencywhenPresidentMcKinleywaskilled,Ihadreallyhadonlyoneelectiveterm,sothatthethirdtermcustomdidnotapplytome;andIwishedtorepudiatethissuggestion。IbelievedthenandIbelievenowthethirdtermcustomortraditiontobewholesome,and,therefore,Iwasdeterminedtoregarditssubstance,refusingtoquibbleoverthewordsusuallyemployedtoexpressit。Ontheotherhand,IdidnotwishsimplyandspecificallytosaythatI
wouldnotbeacandidateforthenominationin1908,becauseifIhadspecifiedtheyearwhenIwouldnotbeacandidate,itwouldhavebeenwidelyacceptedasmeaningthatIintendedtobeacandidatesomeotheryear;andIhadnosuchintention,andhadnoideathatIwouldeverbeacandidateagain。CertainnewspapermendidaskmeifI
intendedtoapplymyprohibitionto1912,andIansweredthatIwasnotthinkingof1912,norof1920,norof1940,andthatImustdeclinetosayanythingwhateverexceptwhatappearedinmystatement。
ThePresidencyisagreatoffice,andthepowerofthePresidentcanbeeffectivelyusedtosecurearenomination,especiallyifthePresidenthasthesupportofcertaingreatpoliticalandfinancialinterests。Itisforthisreason,andthisreasonalone,thatthewholesomeprincipleofcontinuinginoffice,solongasheiswillingtoserve,anincumbentwhohasprovedcapable,isnotapplicabletothePresidency。Therefore,theAmericanpeoplehavewiselyestablishedacustomagainstallowinganymantoholdthatofficeformorethantwoconsecutiveterms。ButeveryshredofpowerwhichaPresidentexerciseswhileinofficevanishesabsolutelywhenhehasonceleftoffice。Anex-Presidentstandspreciselyinthepositionofanyotherprivatecitizen,andhasnotoneparticlemorepowertosecureanominationorelectionthanifhehadneverheldtheofficeatall——
indeed,heprobablyhaslessbecauseoftheveryfactthathehasheldtheoffice。Thereforethereasoningonwhichtheanti-thirdtermcustomisbasedhasnoapplicationwhatevertoanex-President,andnoapplicationwhatevertoanythingexceptconsecutiveterms。Asabarrierofprecautionagainstmorethantwoconsecutivetermsthecustomembodiesavaluableprinciple。Appliedinanyotherwayitbecomesamereformula,andlikeallformulasapotentialsourceofmischievousconfusion。Havingthisinmind,Iregardedthecustomasapplyingpractically,ifnotjustasmuch,toaPresidentwhohadbeensevenandahalfyearsinofficeastoonewhohadbeeneightyearsinoffice,andtherefore,intheteethofapracticallyunanimousdemandfrommyownpartythatIacceptanothernomination,andthereasonablecertaintythatthenominationwouldberatifiedatthepolls,Ifeltthatthesubstanceofthecustomappliedtomein1908。Ontheotherhand,ithadnoapplicationwhatevertoanyhumanbeingsavewhereitwasinvokedinthecaseofamandesiringathirdconsecutiveterm。
Havinggivensuchsubstantialproofofmyownregardforthecustom,I
deemitadutytoaddthiscommentonit。Ibelievethatitiswelltohaveacustomofthiskind,tobegenerallyobserved,butthatitwouldbeveryunwisetohaveitdefinitelyhardenedintoaConstitutionalprohibition。ItisnotdesirableordinarilythatamanshouldstayinofficetwelveconsecutiveyearsasPresident;butmostcertainlytheAmericanpeoplearefittotakecareofthemselves,andstandinnoneedofanirrevocableself-denyingordinance。Theyshouldnotbindthemselvesnevertotakeactionwhichundersomequiteconceivablecircumstancesitmightbetotheirgreatinteresttotake。
Itisobviouslyofthelastimportancetothesafetyofademocracythatintimeofrealperilitshouldbeabletocommandtheserviceofeveryoneamongitscitizensintheprecisepositionwheretheservicerenderedwillbemostvaluable。Itwouldbeabenightedpolicyinsucheventtodisqualifyabsolutelyfromthehighestofficeamanwhowhileholdingithadactuallyshownthehighestcapacitytoexerciseitspowerswiththeutmosteffectforthepublicdefense。If,forinstance,atremendouscrisisoccurredattheendofthesecondtermofamanlikeLincoln,assuchacrisisoccurredattheendofhisfirstterm,itwouldbeaveritablecalamityiftheAmericanpeoplewereforbiddentocontinuetousetheservicesoftheonemanwhomtheyknew,anddidnotmerelyguess,couldcarrythemthroughthecrisis。Thethirdtermtraditionhasnovaluewhateverexceptasitappliestoathirdconsecutiveterm。Whileitiswelltokeepitasacustom,itwouldbeamarkbothofweaknessandunwisdomfortheAmericanpeopletoembodyitintoaConstitutionalprovisionwhichcouldnotdothemgoodandonsomegivenoccasionmightworkrealharm。
TherewasonecartoonmadewhileIwasPresident,inwhichIappearedincidentally,thatwasalwaysagreatfavoriteofmine。Itpicturedanoldfellowwithchinwhiskers,afarmer,inhisshirt-sleeves,withhisbootsoff,sittingbeforethefire,readingthePresident’sMessage。OnhisfeetwerestockingsofthekindIhaveseenhungupbythedozeninJoeFerris’sstoreatMedora,inthedayswhenIusedtocomeintotownandsleepinoneoftheroomsoverthestore。Thetitleofthepicturewas“HisFavoriteAuthor。”ThiswastheoldfellowwhomIalwaysusedtokeepinmind。HehadprobablybeenintheCivilWarinhisyouth;hehadworkedhardeversinceheleftthearmy;hehadbeenagoodhusbandandfather;hehadbroughtuphisboysandgirlstowork;hedidnotwishtodoinjusticetoanyoneelse,buthewantedjusticedonetohimselfandtootherslikehim;
andIwasboundtosecurethatjusticeforhimifitlayinmypowertodoso。[*]
[*]IbelieveIrealizedfairlywellthisambition。Ishallturntomyenemiestoattestthetruthofthisstatement。TheNewYork/Sun/,shortlybeforetheNationalConventionof1904,spokeofmeasfollows:
“PresidentRooseveltholdsthathisnominationbytheNationalRepublicanConventionof1904isanassuredthing。Hemakesnoconcealmentofhisconviction,anditisunreservedlysharedbyhisfriends。WethinkPresidentRooseveltisright。
“TherearestrongandconvincingreasonswhythePresidentshouldfeelthatsuccessiswithinhisgrasp。Hehasusedtheopportunitiesthathefoundorcreated,andhehasusedthemwithconsummateskillandundeniablesuccess。
“ThePresidenthasdisarmedallhisenemies。Everyweapontheyhad,neworold,hasbeentakenfromthemandaddedtothenowunassailableRooseveltarsenal。WhyshouldpeoplewonderthatMr。
Bryanclingstosilver?HasnotMr。RooseveltabsorbedandsequesteredeveryvestigeoftheKansasCityplatformthathadashredofpracticalvalue?SupposethatMr。BryanhadbeenelectedPresident。WhatcouldhehaveaccomplishedcomparedwithwhatMr。
Roosevelthasaccomplished?WillhismostpassionatefollowerspretendforonemomentthatMr。Bryancouldhaveconceived,muchlessenforced,anysuchpursuitofthetrustsasthatwhichMr。
Roosevelthasjustbroughttoatriumphantissue?WillMr。BryanhimselfintimatethattheFederalcourtswouldhaveturnedtohisprojectsthefriendlycountenancewhichtheyhavelenttothoseofMr。Roosevelt?
“Whereis’governmentbyinjunction’goneto?Theveryemptinessofthatoncepotentphraseisbeyonddescription!AregimentofBryanscouldnotcompetewithMr。Rooseveltinharryingthetrusts,inbringingwealthtoitsknees,andinconvertingintothepalpableactualitiesofactionthewildestdreamsofBryan’scampaignorators。Hehasoutdonethemall。
“AndhowutterlythePresidenthasroutedthepretensionsofBryan,andofthewholeDemocratichordeinrespecttoorganizedlabor!
Howemptywerealltheirprofessions,theirmouthingsandtheirhowlingsinthefaceofthesimpleandunpretentiousachievementsofthePresident!InhisownstraightforwardfashionheinflicteduponcapitalinoneshorthourofthecoalstrikeagreaterhumiliationthanBryancouldhavevisiteduponitinacentury。HeistheleaderofthelaborunionsoftheUnitedStates。Mr。
RoosevelthasputthemabovethelawandabovetheConstitution,becauseforhimtheyaretheAmericanpeople。”[Thislast,Ineedhardlysay,ismerelyarhetoricalmethodofsayingthatIgavethelaborunionpreciselythesametreatmentasthecorporation。]
SenatorLaFollette,intheissueofhismagazineimmediatelyfollowingmyleavingthePresidencyinMarch,1909,wroteasfollows:
“Rooseveltstepsfromthestagegracefully。Hehasruledhispartytoalargeextentagainstitswill。Hehasplayedalargepartintheworld’swork,forthepastsevenyears。Theactivitiesofhisremarkablyforcefulpersonalityhavebeensomanifoldthatitwillbelongbeforehistrueratingwillbefixedintheopinionoftherace。HeissaidtothinkthatthethreegreatthingsdonebyhimaretheundertakingoftheconstructionofthePanamaCanalanditsrapidandsuccessfulcarryingforward,themakingofpeacebetweenRussiaandJapan,andthesendingaroundtheworldofthefleet。
“Theseareimportantthings,butmanywillbeslowtothinkthemhisgreatestservices。ThePanamaCanalwillsurelyservemankindwheninoperation;andthemanneroforganizingthisworkseemstobefine。Butnoonecansaywhetherthisprojectwillbeagiganticsuccessoragiganticfailure;andthetaskisonewhichmust,inthenatureofthings,havebeenundertakenandcarriedthroughsometimesoon,ashistoricperiodsgo,anyhow。ThePeaceofPortsmouthwasagreatthingtoberesponsiblefor,andRoosevelt’sgoodofficesundoubtedlysavedagreatandbloodybattleinManchuria。Butthewarwasfoughtout,andthepartiesreadytoquit,andthereisreasontothinkthatitwasonlywhenthissituationwasarrivedatthatthegoodofficesofthePresidentoftheUnitedStateswere,moreorlessindirectly,invited。Thefleet’scruisewasastrongpieceofdiplomacy,bywhichweinformedJapanthatwewillsendourfleetwhereverwepleaseandwheneverweplease。Itworkedoutwell。
“Butnoneofthesethings,itwillseemtomany,cancomparewithsomeofRoosevelt’sotherachievements。Perhapsheisloathtotakecreditasareformer,forheispronetospellthewordwithquestionmarks,andtospeakdisparaginglyof’reform。’
“Butforallthat,thiscontemnerof’reformers’madereformrespectableintheUnitedStates,andthisrebukerof’muck-
rakers’hasbeenthechiefagentinmakingthehistoryof’muck-
raking’intheUnitedStatesaNationalone,concededtobeuseful。HehaspreachedfromtheWhiteHousemanydoctrines;butamongthemhehasleftimpressedontheAmericanmindtheonegreattruthofeconomicjusticecouchedinthepithyandstingingphrase’thesquaredeal。’Thetaskofmakingreformrespectableinacommercializedworld,andofgivingtheNationasloganinaphrase,isgreaterthanthemanwhoperformeditislikelytothink。
“And,then,thereisthegreatandstatesmanlikemovementfortheconservationofourNationalresources,intowhichRooseveltsoenergeticallythrewhimselfatatimewhentheNationasawholeknewnotthatweareruiningandbankruptingourselvesasfastaswecan。ThisisprobablythegreatestthingRooseveltdid,undoubtedly。Thisglobeisthecapitalstockoftherace。Itisjustsomuchcoalandoilandgas。Thismaybeeconomizedorwasted。Thesamethingistrueofphosphatesandothermineralresources。Ourwaterresourcesareimmense,andweareonlyjustbeginningtousethem。Ourforestshavebeendestroyed;theymustberestored。Oursoilsarebeingdepleted;theymustbebuiltupandconserved。
“Thesequestionsarenotofthisdayonlyorofthisgeneration。
Theybelongalltothefuture。Theirconsiderationrequiresthathighmoraltonewhichregardstheearthasthehomeofaposteritytowhomweoweasacredduty。
“ThisimmenseideaRoosevelt,withhighstatesmanship,dinnedintotheearsoftheNationuntiltheNationheeded。Hehelditsohighthatitattractedtheattentionoftheneighboringnationsofthecontinent,andwillsospreadandintensifythatwewillsoonseetheworld’sconferencesdevotedtoit。
“Nothingcanbegreaterorfinerthanthis。ItissogreatandsofinethatwhenthehistorianofthefutureshallspeakofTheodoreRooseveltheislikelytosaythathedidmanynotablethings,amongthemthatofinauguratingthemovementwhichfinallyresultedinthesquaredeal,butthathisgreatestworkwasinspiringandactuallybeginningaworldmovementforstayingterrestrialwasteandsavingforthehumanracethethingsuponwhich,anduponwhichalone,agreatandpeacefulandprogressiveandhappyracelifecanbefounded。
“Whatstatesmaninallhistoryhasdoneanythingcallingforsowideaviewandforapurposemorelofty?”