Well,ayearlateraCongressionalCommitteeactuallydidinvestigatethem。Theinvestigationwasinstigatedbysomeunscrupulouslocalpoliticiansandbysomesettlerswhowishedtoberelievedfrompayingtheirjustobligations;andthemembersoftheCommitteejoinedintheattackonasfineandhonorableasetofpublicservantsastheGovernmenthaseverhad;anattackmadeonthemsolelybecausetheywerehonorableandefficientandloyaltotheinterestsbothoftheGovernmentandthesettlers。
WhenIbecamePresident,theBureauofForestrysince1905theUnitedStatesForestServicewasasmallbutgrowingorganization,underGiffordPinchot,occupiedmainlywithlayingthefoundationofAmericanforestrybyscientificstudyoftheforests,andwiththepromotionofforestryonprivatelands。ItcontainedallthetrainedforestersintheGovernmentservice,buthadchargeofnopublictimberlandwhatsoever。TheGovernmentforestreservesofthatdaywereinthecareofaDivisionintheGeneralLandOffice,underthemanagementofclerkswhollywithoutknowledgeofforestry,fewifanyofwhomhadeverseenafootofthetimberlandsforwhichtheywereresponsible。Thusthereserveswereneitherwellprotectednorwellused。TherewerenoforestersamongthemenwhohadchargeoftheNationalForests,andnoGovernmentforestsinchargeoftheGovernmentforesters。
InmyfirstmessagetoCongressIstronglyrecommendedtheconsolidationoftheforestworkinthehandsofthetrainedmenoftheBureauofForestry。Thisrecommendationwasrepeatedinothermessages,butCongressdidnotgiveeffecttoituntilthreeyearslater。Inthemeantime,bythoroughstudyoftheWesternpublictimberlands,thegroundworkwaslaidfortheresponsibilitieswhichweretofallupontheBureauofForestrywhenthecareoftheNationalForestscametobetransferredtoit。ItwasevidentthattrainedAmericanForesterswouldbeneededinconsiderablenumbers,andaforestschoolwasestablishedatYaletosupplythem。
In1901,atmysuggestionasPresident,theSecretaryoftheInterior,Mr。Hitchcock,madeaformalrequestfortechnicaladvicefromtheBureauofForestryinhandlingtheNationalForests,andanextensiveexaminationoftheirconditionandneedswasaccordinglytakenup。ThesameyearastudywasbegunoftheproposedAppalachianNationalForest,theplanofwhich,alreadyformulatedatthattime,hassincebeencarriedout。AyearlaterexperimentalplantingontheNationalForestswasalsobegun,andstudiespreparatorytotheapplicationofpracticalforestrytotheIndianReservationswereundertaken。In1903,sorapidlydidthepublicworkoftheBureauofForestryincrease,thattheexaminationoflandfornewforestreserveswasaddedtothestudyofthosealreadycreated,theforestlandsofthevariousStateswerestudied,andcooperationwithseveralofthemintheexaminationandhandlingoftheirforestlandswasundertaken。
Whilethesepracticaltaskswerepushedforward,atechnicalknowledgeofAmericanForestswasrapidlyaccumulated。Thespecialknowledgegainedwasmadepublicinprintedbulletins;andatthesametimetheBureauundertook,throughthenewspaperandperiodicalpress,tomakeallthepeopleoftheUnitedStatesacquaintedwiththeneedsandthepurposesofpracticalforestry。ItisdoubtfulwhethertherehaseverbeenelsewhereundertheGovernmentsucheffectivepublicity——
publicitypurelyintheinterestofthepeople——atsolowacost。
BeforetheeducationalworkoftheForestServicewasstoppedbytheTaftAdministration,itwassecuringthepublicationoffactsaboutforestryinfiftymillioncopiesofnewspapersamonthatatotalexpenseof$6000ayear。NotonecenthaseverbeenpaidbytheForestServicetoanypublicationofanykindfortheprintingofthismaterial。Itwasgivenoutfreely,andpublishedwithoutcostbecauseitwasnews。WithoutthispublicitytheForestServicecouldnothavesurvivedtheattacksmadeuponitbytherepresentativesofthegreatspecialinterestsinCongress;norcouldforestryinAmericahavemadetherapidprogressithas。
TheresultofalltheworkoutlinedabovewastobringtogetherintheBureauofForestry,bytheendof1904,theonlybodyofforestexpertsundertheGovernment,andpracticallyallofthefirst-handinformationaboutthepublicforestswhichwastheninexistence。In1905,theobviousfoolishnessofcontinuingtoseparatetheforestersandtheforests,reenforcedbytheactionoftheFirstNationalForestCongress,heldinWashington,broughtabouttheActofFebruary1,1905,whichtransferredtheNationalForestsfromthecareoftheInteriorDepartmenttotheDepartmentofAgriculture,andresultedinthecreationofthepresentUnitedStatesForestService。
ThemenuponwhomtheresponsibilityofhandlingsomesixtymillionacresofNationalForestlandswasthusthrownwerereadyforthework,bothintheofficeandinthefield,becausetheyhadbeenpreparingforitformorethanfiveyears。Withoutdelaytheyproceeded,undertheleadershipofPinchot,toapplytothenewworktheprinciplestheyhadalreadyformulated。OneofthesewastoopenalltheresourcesoftheNationalForeststoregulateduse。Anotherwasthatofputtingeverypartofthelandtothatuseinwhichitwouldbestservethepublic。Followingthisprinciple,theActofJune11,1906,wasdrawn,anditspassagewassecuredfromCongress。ThislawthrowsopentosettlementalllandintheNationalForeststhatisfound,onexamination,tobechieflyvaluableforagriculture。
Hithertoallsuchlandhadbeenclosedtothesettler。
Theprinciplesthusformulatedandappliedmaybesummedupinthestatementthattherightsofthepublictothenaturalresourcesoutweighprivaterights,andmustbegivenitsfirstconsideration。
Untilthattime,indealingwiththeNationalForests,andthepubliclandsgenerally,privaterightshadalmostuniformlybeenallowedtooverbalancepublicrights。Thechangewemadewasright,andwasvitallynecessary;but,ofcourse,itcreatedbitteroppositionfromprivateinterests。
Oneoftheprincipleswhoseapplicationwasthesourceofmuchhostilitywasthis:ItisbetterfortheGovernmenttohelpapoormantomakealivingforhisfamilythantohelparichmanmakemoreprofitforhiscompany。Thisprinciplewastoosoundtobefoughtopenly。Itisthekindofprincipletowhichpoliticiansdelighttopayunctuoushomageinwords。Butwetranslatedthewordsintodeeds;
andwhentheyfoundthatthiswasthecase,manyrichmen,especiallysheepowners,werestirredtohostility,andtheyusedtheCongressmentheycontrolledtoassaultus——gettingmostaidfromcertaindemagogues,whowereequallygladimproperlytodenouncerichmeninpublicandimproperlytoservetheminprivate。TheForestServiceestablishedandenforcedregulationswhichfavoredthesettlerasagainstthelargestockowner;requiredthatnecessaryreductionsinthestockgrazedonanyNationalForestshouldbearfirstonthebigman,beforethefewheadofthesmallman,uponwhichthelivingofhisfamilydepended,werereduced;andmadegrazingintheNationalForestsahelp,insteadofahindrance,topermanentsettlement。Asaresult,thesmallsettlersandtheirfamiliesbecame,onthewhole,thebestfriendstheForestServicehas;althoughinplacestheirignorancewasplayedonbydemagoguestoinfluencethemagainstthepolicythatwasprimarilyfortheirowninterest。
Anotherprinciplewhichledtothebitterestantagonismofallwasthis——whoeverexceptabona-fidesettlertakespublicpropertyforprivateprofitshouldpayforwhathegets。Intheefforttoapplythisprinciple,theForestServiceobtainedadecisionfromtheAttorney-GeneralthatitwaslegaltomakethemenwhograzedsheepandcattleontheNationalForestspayforwhattheygot。Accordingly,inthesummerof1906,forthefirsttime,suchachargewasmade;
and,inthefaceofthebitterestopposition,itwascollected。
UptothetimetheNationalForestswereputunderthechargeoftheForestService,theInteriorDepartmenthadmadenoefforttoestablishpublicregulationandcontrolofwaterpowers。Uponthetransfer,theServiceimmediatelybeganitsfighttohandlethepowerresourcesoftheNationalForestssoastopreventspeculationandmonopolyandtoyieldafairreturntotheGovernment。OnMay1,1906,anActwaspassedgrantingtheuseofcertainpowersitesinSouthernCaliforniatotheEdisonElectricPowerCompany,whichAct,atthesuggestionoftheService,limitedtheperiodofthepermittofortyyears,andrequiredthepaymentofanannualrentalbythecompany,thesameconditionswhichwerethereafteradoptedbytheServiceasthebasisforallpermitsforpowerdevelopment。ThenbeganavigorousfightagainstthepositionoftheServicebythewater-powerinterests。Therighttochargeforwater-powerdevelopmentwas,however,sustainedbytheAttorney-General。
In1907,theareaoftheNationalForestswasincreasedbyPresidentialproclamationmorethanforty-threemillionacres;theplantnecessaryforthefulluseoftheForests,suchasroads,trails,andtelephonelines,begantobeprovidedonalargescale;
theinterchangeoffieldandofficemen,soastopreventtheantagonismbetweenthem,whichissodestructiveofefficiencyinmostgreatbusinesses,wasestablishedasapermanentpolicy;andthereallyeffectivemanagementoftheenormousareaoftheNationalForestsbegantobesecured。
Withallthisactivityinthefield,theprogressoftechnicalforestryandpopulareducationwasnotneglected。In1907,forexample,sixty-onepublicationsonvariousphasesofforestry,withatotalofmorethanamillioncopies,wereissued,asagainstthreepublications,withatotalofeighty-twothousandcopies,in1901。Bythistime,also,theoppositionoftheservantsofthespecialinterestsinCongresstotheForestServicehadbecomestronglydeveloped,andmoretimeappearedtobespentintheyearlyattacksuponitduringthepassageoftheappropriationbillsthanonallotherGovernmentBureausputtogether。EveryyeartheForestServicehadtofightforitslife。
Oneincidentintheseattacksisworthrecording。WhiletheAgriculturalAppropriationBillwaspassingthroughtheSenate,in1907,SenatorFulton,ofOregon,securedanamendmentprovidingthatthePresidentcouldnotsetasideanyadditionalNationalForestsinthesixNorthwesternStates。Thismeantretainingsomesixteenmillionofacrestobeexploitedbylandgrabbersandbytherepresentativesofthegreatspecialinterests,attheexpenseofthepublicinterest。
ButforfouryearstheForestServicehadbeengatheringfieldnotesastowhatforestsoughttobesetasideintheseStates,andsowaspreparedtoact。Itwasequallyundesirabletovetothewholeagriculturalbill,andtosignitwiththisamendmenteffective。
Accordingly,aplantocreatethenecessaryNationalForestintheseStatesbeforetheAgriculturalBillcouldbepassedandsignedwaslaidbeforemebyMr。Pinchot。Iapprovedit。Thenecessarypaperswereimmediatelyprepared。Isignedthelastproclamationacoupleofdaysbefore,bymysignature,thebillbecamelaw;and,whenthefriendsofthespecialinterestsintheSenategottheiramendmentthroughandwokeup,theydiscoveredthatsixteenmillionacresoftimberlandhadbeensavedforthepeoplebyputtingthemintheNationalForestsbeforethelandgrabberscouldgetatthem。TheopponentsoftheForestServiceturnedhandspringsintheirwrath;anddireweretheirthreatsagainsttheExecutive;butthethreatscouldnotbecarriedout,andwerereallyonlyatributetotheefficiencyofouraction。
By1908,thefirepreventionworkoftheForestServicehadbecomesosuccessfulthateighty-sixpercentofthefiresthatdidoccurwerehelddowntoanareaoffiveacresorless,andthetimbersales,whichyielded$60,000in1905,in1908produced$850,000。Inthesameyear,inadditiontotheworkoftheNationalForests,theresponsibilityfortheproperhandlingofIndiantimberlandswaslaidupontheForestService,whereitremainedwithgreatbenefittotheIndiansuntilitwaswithdrawn,asapartoftheattackontheConservationpolicymadeafterIleftoffice。
ByMarch4,1909,nearlyhalfamillionacresofagriculturallandintheNationalForestshadbeenopenedtosettlementundertheActofJune11,1906。ThebusinessmanagementoftheForestServicebecamesoexcellent,thankstotheremarkableexecutivecapacityoftheAssociateForester,OvertonW。PriceremovedafterIleftoffice,thatitwasdeclaredbyawell-knownfirmofbusinessorganizerstocomparefavorablywiththebestmanagedofthegreatprivatecorporations,anopinionwhichwasconfirmedbythereportofaCongressionalinvestigation,andbythereportofthePresidentialCommitteeonDepartmentmethod。TheareaoftheNationalForestshadincreasedfrom43to194millionacres;theforcefromabout500tomorethan3000。TherewassavedforpublicuseintheNationalForestsmoreGovernmenttimberlandduringthesevenandahalfyearspriortoMarch4,1909,thanduringallpreviousandsucceedingyearsputtogether。