Asallpotenciesareeitherinnate,likethesenses,orcomeby
practice,likethepowerofplayingtheflute,orbylearning,like
artisticpower,thosewhichcomebypracticeorbyrationalformulawe
mustacquirebypreviousexercisebutthisisnotnecessarywiththose
whicharenotofthisnatureandwhichimplypassivity。
Sincethatwhichis’capable’iscapableofsomethingandat
sometimeinsomewaywithalltheotherqualificationswhichmustbe
presentinthedefinition,andsincesomethingscanproducechange
accordingtoarationalformulaandtheirpotenciesinvolvesucha
formula,whileotherthingsarenonrationalandtheirpotenciesare
non-rational,andtheformerpotenciesmustbeinalivingthing,
whilethelattercanbebothinthelivingandinthelifeless;as
regardspotenciesofthelatterkind,whentheagentandthepatient
meetinthewayappropriatetothepotencyinquestion,theonemust
actandtheotherbeactedon,butwiththeformerkindofpotency
thisisnotnecessary。Forthenonrationalpotenciesareall
productiveofoneeffecteach,buttherationalproducecontrary
effects,sothatiftheyproducedtheireffectsnecessarilytheywould
producecontraryeffectsatthesametime;butthisisimpossible。
Theremust,then,besomethingelsethatdecides;Imeanbythis,
desireorwill。Forwhicheveroftwothingstheanimaldesires
decisively,itwilldo,whenitispresent,andmeetsthepassive
object,inthewayappropriatetothepotencyinquestion。Therefore
everythingwhichhasarationalpotency,whenitdesiresthatfor
whichithasapotencyandinthecircumstancesinwhichithasthe
potency,mustdothis。Andithasthepotencyinquestionwhenthe
passiveobjectispresentandisinacertainstate;ifnotitwill
notbeabletoact。Toaddthequalification’ifnothingexternal
preventsit’isnotfurthernecessary;forithasthepotencyonthe
termsonwhichthisisapotencyofacting,anditisthisnotin
allcircumstancesbutoncertainconditions,amongwhichwillbethe
exclusionofexternalhindrances;forthesearebarredbysomeof
thepositivequalifications。Andsoevenifonehasarational
wish,oranappetite,todotwothingsorcontrarythingsatthe
sametime,onewillnotdothem;foritisnotonthesetermsthatone
hasthepotencyforthem,norisitapotencyofdoingbothatthe
sametime,sinceonewilldothethingswhichitisapotencyof
doing,onthetermsonwhichonehasthepotency。
Sincewehavetreatedofthekindofpotencywhichisrelatedto
movement,letusdiscussactuality-what,andwhatkindofthing,
actualityis。Forinthecourseofouranalysisitwillalsobecome
clear,withregardtothepotential,thatwenotonlyascribe
potencytothatwhosenatureitistomovesomethingelse,ortobe
movedbysomethingelse,eitherwithoutqualificationorinsome
particularway,butalsousethewordinanothersense,whichisthe
reasonoftheinquiryinthecourseofwhichwehavediscussedthese
previoussensesalso。Actuality,then,istheexistenceofathingnot
inthewaywhichweexpressby’potentially’;wesaythatpotentially,
forinstance,astatueofHermesisintheblockofwoodandthe
half-lineisinthewhole,becauseitmightbeseparatedout,andwe
calleventhemanwhoisnotstudyingamanofscience,ifheis
capableofstudying;thethingthatstandsincontrasttoeachof
theseexistsactually。Ourmeaningcanbeseenintheparticularcases
byinduction,andwemustnotseekadefinitionofeverythingbutbe
contenttograsptheanalogy,thatitisasthatwhichisbuilding
istothatwhichiscapableofbuilding,andthewakingtothe
sleeping,andthatwhichisseeingtothatwhichhasitseyesshutbut
hassight,andthatwhichhasbeenshapedoutofthemattertothe
matter,andthatwhichhasbeenwroughtuptotheunwrought。Let
actualitybedefinedbyonememberofthisantithesis,andthe
potentialbytheother。Butallthingsarenotsaidinthesame
sensetoexistactually,butonlybyanalogy-asAisinBortoB,C
isinDortoD;forsomeareasmovementtopotency,andtheothers
assubstancetosomesortofmatter。
Butalsotheinfiniteandthevoidandallsimilarthingsaresaid
toexistpotentiallyandactuallyinadifferentsensefromthatwhich
appliestomanyotherthings,e。g。tothatwhichseesorwalksoris
seen。Forofthelatterclassthesepredicatescanatsometimebe
alsotrulyassertedwithoutqualification;fortheseenissocalled
sometimesbecauseitisbeingseen,sometimesbecauseitiscapableof
beingseen。Buttheinfinitedoesnotexistpotentiallyinthesense
thatitwilleveractuallyhaveseparateexistence;itexists
potentiallyonlyforknowledge。Forthefactthattheprocessof
dividingnevercomestoanendensuresthatthisactivityexists
potentially,butnotthattheinfiniteexistsseparately。
Sinceoftheactionswhichhavealimitnoneisanendbutallare
relativetotheend,e。g。theremovingoffat,orfat-removal,andthe
bodilypartsthemselveswhenoneismakingthemthinareinmovement
inthiswayi。e。withoutbeingalreadythatatwhichthemovement
aims,thisisnotanactionoratleastnotacompleteoneforitis
notanend;butthatmovementinwhichtheendispresentisan
action。E。g。atthesametimeweareseeingandhaveseen,are
understandingandhaveunderstood,arethinkingandhavethought
whileitisnottruethatatthesametimewearelearningandhave
learnt,orarebeingcuredandhavebeencured。Atthesametimewe
arelivingwellandhavelivedwell,andarehappyandhavebeen
happy。Ifnot,theprocesswouldhavehadsometimetocease,asthe
processofmakingthinceases:but,asthingsare,itdoesnot
cease;wearelivingandhavelived。Oftheseprocesses,then,wemust
calltheonesetmovements,andtheotheractualities。Forevery
movementisincomplete-makingthin,learning,walking,building;these
aremovements,andincompleteatthat。Foritisnottruethatat
thesametimeathingiswalkingandhaswalked,orisbuildingand
hasbuilt,oriscomingtobeandhascometobe,orisbeingmoved
andhasbeenmoved,butwhatisbeingmovedisdifferentfromwhathas
beenmoved,andwhatismovingfromwhathasmoved。Butitisthesame
thingthatatthesametimehasseenandisseeing,seeing,oris
thinkingandhasthought。Thelattersortofprocess,then,Icall
anactuality,andtheformeramovement。
What,andwhatkindofthing,theactualis,maybetakenas
explainedbytheseandsimilarconsiderations。Butwemustdistinguish
whenathingexistspotentiallyandwhenitdoesnot;foritisnotat
anyandeverytime。E。g。isearthpotentiallyaman?No-butrather
whenithasalreadybecomeseed,andperhapsnoteventhen。Itisjust
asitiswithbeinghealed;noteverythingcanbehealedbythe
medicalartorbyluck,butthereisacertainkindofthingwhich
iscapableofit,andonlythisispotentiallyhealthy。And1the
delimitingmarkofthatwhichasaresultofthoughtcomestoexistin
completerealityfromhavingexistedpotentiallyisthatifthe
agenthaswilledititcomestopassifnothingexternalhinders,
whiletheconditionontheotherside-viz。inthatwhichis
healed-isthatnothinginithinderstheresult。Itisonsimilar
termsthatwehavewhatispotentiallyahouse;ifnothinginthe
thingactedon-i。e。inthematter-preventsitfrombecomingahouse,
andifthereisnothingwhichmustbeaddedortakenawayor
changed,thisispotentiallyahouse;andthesameistrueofall
otherthingsthesourceofwhosebecomingisexternal。And2in
thecasesinwhichthesourceofthebecomingisintheverything
whichcomestobe,athingispotentiallyallthosethingswhichit
willbeofitselfifnothingexternalhindersit。E。g。theseedisnot
yetpotentiallyaman;foritmustbedepositedinsomethingother
thanitselfandundergoachange。Butwhenthroughitsownmotive
principleithasalreadygotsuchandsuchattributes,inthisstate
itisalreadypotentiallyaman;whileintheformerstateitneeds
anothermotiveprinciple,justasearthisnotyetpotentiallya
statueforitmustfirstchangeinordertobecomebrass。
Itseemsthatwhenwecallathingnotsomethingelsebut
’thaten’-e。g。acasketisnot’wood’but’wooden’,andwoodisnot
’earth’but’earthen’,andagainearthwillillustrateourpointifit
issimilarlynotsomethingelsebut’thaten’-thatotherthingis
alwayspotentiallyinthefullsenseofthatwordthethingwhich
comesafteritinthisseries。E。g。acasketisnot’earthen’nor
’earth’,but’wooden’;forthisispotentiallyacasketandthisis
thematterofacasket,woodingeneralofacasketingeneral,and
thisparticularwoodofthisparticularcasket。Andifthereisa
firstthing,whichisnolonger,inreferencetosomethingelse,
called’thaten’,thisisprimematter;e。g。ifearthis’airy’andair
isnot’fire’but’fiery’,fireisprimematter,whichisnota
’this’。Forthesubjectorsubstratumisdifferentiatedbybeinga
’this’ornotbeingone;i。e。thesubstratumofmodificationsis,e。g。
aman,i。e。abodyandasoul,whilethemodificationis’musical’
or’pale’。Thesubjectiscalled,whenmusiccomestobepresentin
it,not’music’but’musical’,andthemanisnot’paleness’but
’pale’,andnot’ambulation’or’movement’but’walking’or
’moving’,-whichisakintothe’thaten’。Whereverthisisso,then,
theultimatesubjectisasubstance;butwhenthisisnotsobutthe
predicateisaformanda’this’,theultimatesubjectismatterand
materialsubstance。Anditisonlyrightthat’thaten’shouldbe
usedwithreferencebothtothematterandtotheaccidents;for
bothareindeterminates。
Wehavestated,then,whenathingistobesaidtoexist
potentiallyandwhenitisnot。
Fromourdiscussionofthevarioussensesof’prior’,itis
clearthatactualityispriortopotency。AndImeanbypotencynot
onlythatdefinitekindwhichissaidtobeaprincipleofchangein
anotherthingorinthethingitselfregardedasother,butingeneral
everyprincipleofmovementorofrest。Fornaturealsoisinthesame
genusaspotency;foritisaprincipleofmovement-not,however,in
somethingelsebutinthethingitselfquaitself。Toallsuch
potency,then,actualityispriorbothinformulaandin
substantiality;andintimeitispriorinonesense,andinanother
not。
1Clearlyitispriorinformula;forthatwhichisinthe
primarysensepotentialispotentialbecauseitispossibleforit
tobecomeactive;e。g。Imeanby’capableofbuilding’thatwhich
canbuild,andby’capableofseeing’thatwhichcansee,andby
’visible’thatwhichcanbeseen。Andthesameaccountappliesto
allothercases,sothattheformulaandtheknowledgeoftheonemust
precedetheknowledgeoftheother。
2Intimeitispriorinthissense:theactualwhichis
identicalinspeciesthoughnotinnumberwithapotentially
existingthingistoit。Imeanthattothisparticularmanwhonow
existsactuallyandtothecornandtotheseeingsubjectthematter
andtheseedandthatwhichiscapableofseeing,whichare
potentiallyamanandcornandseeing,butnotyetactuallyso,are
priorintime;butpriorintimetotheseareotheractually
existingthings,fromwhichtheywereproduced。Forfromthe
potentiallyexistingtheactuallyexistingisalwaysproducedbyan
actuallyexistingthing,e。g。manfromman,musicianbymusician;
thereisalwaysafirstmover,andthemoveralreadyexists
actually。Wehavesaidinouraccountofsubstancethateverything
thatisproducedissomethingproducedfromsomethingandby
something,andthatthesameinspeciesasit。
Thisiswhyitisthoughtimpossibletobeabuilderifonehas
builtnothingoraharperifonehasneverplayedtheharp;forhewho
learnstoplaytheharplearnstoplayitbyplayingit,andallother
learnersdosimilarly。Andthencearosethesophisticalquibble,
thatonewhodoesnotpossessasciencewillbedoingthatwhichis
theobjectofthescience;forhewhoislearningitdoesnot
possessit。Butsince,ofthatwhichiscomingtobe,somepartmust
havecometobe,and,ofthatwhich,ingeneral,ischanging,some
partmusthavechangedthisisshowninthetreatiseonmovement,he
whoislearningmust,itwouldseem,possesssomepartofthescience。
Butheretoo,then,itisclearthatactualityisinthissense
also,viz。inorderofgenerationandoftime,priortopotency。
But3itisalsopriorinsubstantiality;firstly,abecause
thethingsthatareposteriorinbecomingarepriorinformandin
substantialitye。g。manispriortoboyandhumanbeingtoseed;
fortheonealreadyhasitsform,andtheotherhasnot,and
becauseeverythingthatcomestobemovestowardsaprinciple,i。e。an
endforthatforthesakeofwhichathingis,isitsprinciple,
andthebecomingisforthesakeoftheend,andtheactualityisthe
end,anditisforthesakeofthisthatthepotencyisacquired。
Foranimalsdonotseeinorderthattheymayhavesight,butthey