Theloveofourcountryseems,inordinarycases,toinvolveinittwodifferentprinciples;first,acertainrespectandreverenceforthatconstitutionorformofgovernmentwhichisactuallyestablished;andsecondly,anearnestdesiretorendertheconditionofourfellow-citizensassafe,respectable,andhappyaswecan。Heisnotacitizenwhoisnotdisposedtorespectthelawsandtoobeythecivilmagistrate;andheiscertainlynotagoodcitizenwhodoesnotwishtopromote,byeverymeansinhispower,thewelfareofthewholesocietyofhisfellow-citizens。
Inpeaceableandquiettimes,thosetwoprinciplesgenerallycoincideandleadtothesameconduct。Thesupportoftheestablishedgovernmentseemsevidentlythebestexpedientformaintainingthesafe,respectable,andhappysituationofourfellow-citizens;whenweseethatthisgovernmentactuallymaintainstheminthatsituation。Butintimesofpublicdiscontent,faction,anddisorder,thosetwodifferentprinciplesmaydrawdifferentways,andevenawisemanmaybedisposedtothinksomealterationnecessaryinthatconstitutionorformofgovernment,which,initsactualcondition,appearsplainlyunabletomaintainthepublictranquillity。Insuchcases,however,itoftenrequires,perhaps,thehighesteffortofpoliticalwisdomtodeterminewhenarealpatriotoughttosupportandendeavourtore-establishtheauthorityoftheoldsystem,andwhenheoughttogivewaytothemoredaring,butoftendangerousspiritofinnovation。
Foreignwarandcivilfactionarethetwosituationswhichaffordthemostsplendidopportunitiesforthedisplayofpublicspirit。Theherowhoserveshiscountrysuccessfullyinforeignwargratifiesthewishesofthewholenation,andis,uponthataccount,theobjectofuniversalgratitudeandadmiration。Intimesofcivildiscord,theleadersofthecontendingparties,thoughtheymaybeadmiredbyonehalfoftheirfellow-citizens,arecommonlyexecratedbytheother。Theircharactersandthemeritoftheirrespectiveservicesappearcommonlymoredoubtful。
Theglorywhichisacquiredbyforeignwaris,uponthisaccount,almostalwaysmorepureandmoresplendidthanthatwhichcanbeacquiredincivilfaction。
Theleaderofthesuccessfulparty,however,ifhehasauthorityenoughtoprevailuponhisownfriendstoactwithpropertemperandmoderationwhichhefrequentlyhasnot,maysometimesrendertohiscountryaservicemuchmoreessentialandimportantthanthegreatestvictoriesandthemostextensiveconquests。Hemayre-establishandimprovetheconstitution,andfromtheverydoubtfulandambiguouscharacteroftheleaderofaparty,hemayassumethegreatestandnoblestofallcharacters,thatofthereformerandlegislatorofagreatstate;and,bythewisdomofhisinstitutions,securetheinternaltranquillityandhappinessofhisfellow-citizensformanysucceedinggenerations。
Amidsttheturbulenceanddisorderoffaction,acertainspiritofsystemisapttomixitselfwiththatpublicspiritwhichisfoundedupontheloveofhumanity,uponarealfellow-feelingwiththeinconvenienciesanddistressestowhichsomeofourfellow-citizensmaybeexposed。Thisspiritofsystemcommonlytakesthedirectionofthatmoregentlepublicspirit;
alwaysanimatesit,andofteninflamesiteventothemadnessoffanaticism。Theleadersofthediscontentedpartyseldomfailtoholdoutsomeplausibleplanofreformationwhich,theypretend,willnotonlyremovetheinconvenienciesandrelievethedistressesimmediatelycomplainedof,butwillprevent,inalltimecoming,anyreturnofthelikeinconvenienciesanddistresses。Theyoftenpropose,uponthisaccount,tonew-modeltheconstitution,andtoalter,insomeofitsmostessentialparts,thatsystemofgovernmentunderwhichthesubjectsofagreatempirehaveenjoyed,perhaps,peace,security,andevenglory,duringthecourseofseveralcenturiestogether。Thegreatbodyofthepartyarecommonlyintoxicatedwiththeimaginarybeautyofthisidealsystem,ofwhichtheyhavenoexperience,butwhichhasbeenrepresentedtotheminallthemostdazzlingcoloursinwhichtheeloquenceoftheirleaderscouldpaintit。
Thoseleadersthemselves,thoughtheyoriginallymayhavemeantnothingbuttheirownaggrandisement,becomemanyofthemintimethedupesoftheirownsophistry,andareaseagerforthisgreatreformationastheweakestandfoolishestoftheirfollowers。
Eventhoughtheleadersshouldhavepreservedtheirownheads,asindeedtheycommonlydo,freefromthisfanaticism,yettheydarenotalwaysdisappointtheexpectationoftheirfollowers;butareoftenobliged,thoughcontrarytotheirprincipleandtheirconscience,toactasiftheywereunderthecommondelusion。Theviolenceoftheparty,refusingallpalliatives,alltemperaments,allreasonableaccommodations,byrequiringtoomuchfrequentlyobtainsnothing;andthoseinconvenienciesanddistresseswhich,withalittlemoderation,mightinagreatmeasurehavebeenremovedandrelieved,areleftaltogetherwithoutthehopeofaremedy。
Themanwhosepublicspiritispromptedaltogetherbyhumanityandbenevolence,willrespecttheestablishedpowersandprivilegeseVenofindividuals,andstillmorethoseofthegreatordersandsocieties,intowhichthestateisdivided。Thoughheshouldconsidersomeofthemasinsomemeasureabusive,hewillcontenthimselfwithmoderating,whatheoftencannotannihilatewithoutgreatviolence。Whenhecannotconquertherootedprejudicesofthepeoplebyreasonandpersuasion,hewillnotattempttosubduethembyforce;butwillreligiouslyobservewhat,byCicero,isjustlycalledthedivinemaximofPlato,nevertouseviolencetohiscountrynomorethantohisparents。
Hewillaccommodate,aswellashecan,hispublicarrangementstotheconfirmedhabitsandprejudicesofthepeople;andwillremedyaswellashecan,theinconveniencieswhichmayflowfromthewantofthoseregulationswhichthepeopleareaversetosubmitto。Whenhecannotestablishtheright,hewillnotdisdaintoamelioratethewrong;butlikeSolon,whenhecannotestablishthebestsystemoflaws,hewillendeavourtoestablishthebestthatthepeoplecanbear。
Themanofsystem,onthecontrary,isapttobeverywiseinhisownconceit;andisoftensoenamouredwiththesupposedbeautyofhisownidealplanofgovernment,thathecannotsufferthesmallestdeviationfromanypartofit。Hegoesontoestablishitcompletelyandinallitsparts,withoutanyregardeithertothegreatinterests,ortothestrongprejudiceswhichmayopposeit。Heseemstoimaginethathecanarrangethedifferentmembersofagreatsocietywithasmucheaseasthehandarrangesthedifferentpiecesuponachess-board。Hedoesnotconsiderthatthepiecesuponthechess-boardhavenootherprincipleofmotionbesidesthatwhichthehandimpressesuponthem;butthat,inthegreatchess-boardofhumansociety,everysinglepiecehasaprincipleofmotionofitsown,altogetherdifferentfromthatwhichthelegislaturemightchusetoimpressuponit。Ifthosetwoprinciplescoincideandactinthesamedirection,thegameofhumansocietywillgooneasilyandharmoniously,andisverylikelytobehappyandsuccessful。Iftheyareoppositeordifferent,thegamewillgoonmiserably,andthesocietymustbeatalltimesinthehighestdegreeofdisorder。
Somegeneral,andevensystematical,ideaoftheperfectionofpolicyandlaw,maynodoubtbenecessaryfordirectingtheviewsofthestatesman。Buttoinsistuponestablishing,anduponestablishingallatonce,andinspiteofallopposition,everythingwhichthatideamayseemtorequire,mustoftenbethehighestdegreeofarrogance。Itistoerecthisownjudgmentintothesupremestandardofrightandwrong。Itistofancyhimselftheonlywiseandworthymaninthecommonwealth,andthathisfellow-citizensshouldaccommodatethemselvestohimandnothetothem。Itisuponthisaccount,thatofallpoliticalspeculators,sovereignprincesarebyfarthemostdangerous。
Thisarroganceisperfectlyfamiliartothem。Theyentertainnodoubtoftheimmensesuperiorityoftheirownjudgment。Whensuchimperialandroyalreformers,therefore,condescendtocontemplatetheconstitutionofthecountrywhichiscommittedtotheirgovernment,theyseldomseeanythingsowronginitastheobstructionswhichitmaysometimesopposetotheexecutionoftheirownwill。TheyholdincontemptthedivinemaximofPlato,andconsiderthestateasmadeforthemselves,notthemselvesforthestate。Thegreatobjectoftheirreformation,therefore,istoremovethoseobstructions;toreducetheauthorityofthenobility;totakeawaytheprivilegesofcitiesandprovinces,andtorenderboththegreatestindividualsandthegreatestordersofthestate,asincapableofopposingtheircommands,astheweakestandmostinsignificant。
OfuniversalBenevolenceThoughoureffectualgoodofficescanveryseldombeextendedtoanywidersocietythanthatofourowncountry;ourgood-williscircumscribedbynoboundary,butmayembracetheimmensityoftheuniverse。Wecannotformtheideaofanyinnocentandsensiblebeing,whosehappinessweshouldnotdesire,ortowhosemisery,whendistinctlybroughthometotheimagination,weshouldnothavesomedegreeofaversion。Theideaofamischievous,thoughsensible,being,indeed,naturallyprovokesourhatred:buttheill-willwhich,inthiscase,webeartoit,isreallytheeffectofouruniversalbenevolence。Itistheeffectofthesympathywhichwefeelwiththemiseryandresentmentofthoseotherinnocentandsensiblebeings,whosehappinessisdisturbedbyitsmalice。
Thisuniversalbenevolence,hownobleandgeneroussoever,canbethesourceofnosolidhappinesstoanymanwhoisnotthoroughlyconvincedthatalltheinhabitantsoftheuniverse,themeanestaswellasthegreatest,areundertheimmediatecareandprotectionofthatgreat,benevolent,andall-wiseBeing,whodirectsallthemovementsofnature;andwhoisdetermined,byhisownunalterableperfections,tomaintaininit,atalltimes,thegreatestpossiblequantityofhappiness。Tothisuniversalbenevolence,onthecontrary,theverysuspicionofafatherlessworld,mustbethemostmelancholyofallreflections;fromthethoughtthatalltheunknownregionsofinfiniteandincomprehensiblespacemaybefilledwithnothingbutendlessmiseryandwretchedness。Allthesplendourofthehighestprosperitycanneverenlightenthegloomwithwhichsodreadfulanideamustnecessarilyover-shadowtheimagination;nor,inawiseandvirtuousman,canallthesorrowofthemostafflictingadversityeverdryupthejoywhichnecessarilyspringsfromthehabitualandthoroughconvictionofthetruthofthecontrarysystem。
Thewiseandvirtuousmanisatalltimeswillingthathisownprivateinterestshouldbesacrificedtothepublicinterestofhisownparticularorderorsociety。Heisatalltimeswilling,too,thattheinterestofthisorderorsocietyshouldbesacrificedtothegreaterinterestofthestateorsovereignty,ofwhichitisonlyasubordinatepart。Heshould,therefore,beequallywillingthatallthoseinferiorinterestsshouldbesacrificedtothegreaterinterestoftheuniverse,totheinterestofthatgreatsocietyofallsensibleandintelligentbeings,ofwhichGodhimselfistheimmediateadministratoranddirector。Ifheisdeeplyimpressedwiththehabitualandthoroughconvictionthatthisbenevolentandall-wiseBeingcanadmitintothesystemofhisgovernment,nopartialevilwhichisnotnecessaryfortheuniversalgood,hemustconsiderallthemisfortuneswhichmaybefalhimself,hisfriends,hissociety,orhiscountry,asnecessaryfortheprosperityoftheuniverse,andthereforeaswhatheought,notonlytosubmittowithresignation,butaswhathehimself,ifhehadknownalltheconnexionsanddependenciesofthings,oughtsincerelyanddevoutlytohavewishedfor。
NordoesthismagnanimousresignationtothewillofthegreatDirectoroftheuniverse,seeminanyrespectbeyondthereachofhumannature。Goodsoldiers,whobothloveandtrusttheirgeneral,frequentlymarchwithmoregaietyandalacritytotheforlornstation,fromwhichtheyneverexpecttoreturn,thantheywouldtoonewheretherewasneitherdifficultynordanger。