Ath。OCleinias,amanwhenheisabouttodieisanintractablecreature,andisapttouselanguagewhichcausesagreatdealofanxietyandtroubletothelegislator。
Cle。Inwhatway?
Ath。Hewantstohavetheentirecontrolofallhisproperty,andwilluseangrywords。
Cle。Suchaswhat?
Ath。OyeGods,hewillsay,howmonstrousthatIamnotallowedtogive,ornottogivemyowntowhomIwill-lesstohimwhohasbeenbadtome,andmoretohimwhohasbeengoodtome,andwhosebadnessandgoodnesshavebeentestedbymeintimeofsicknessorinoldageandineveryothersortoffortune!
Cle。WellStranger,andmayhenotveryfairlysayso?
Ath。Inmyopinion,Cleinias,theancientlegislatorsweretoogood-natured,andmadelawswithoutsufficientobservationorconsiderationofhumanthings。
Cle。Whatdoyoumean?
Ath。Imean,myfriendthattheywereafraidofthetestator’sreproaches,andsotheypassedalawtotheeffectthatamanshouldbeallowedtodisposeofhispropertyinallrespectsasheliked;butyouandI,ifIamnotmistaken,willhavesomethingbettertosaytoourdepartingcitizens。
Cle。What?
Ath。Omyfriends,wewillsaytothem,hardisitforyou,whoarecreaturesofaday,toknowwhatisyours-hardtoo,astheDelphicoraclesays,toknowyourselvesatthishour。NowI,asthelegislator,regardyouandyourpossessions,notasbelongingtoyourselves,butasbelongingtoyourwholefamily,bothpastandfuture,andyetmoredoregardbothfamilyandpossessionsasbelongingtothestate;wherefore,ifsomeonestealsuponyouwithflattery,whenyouaretossedontheseaofdiseaseoroldage,andpersuadesyoutodisposeofyourpropertyinawaythatisnotforthebest,Iwillnot,ifIcanhelp,allowthis;butIwilllegislatewithaviewtothewhole,consideringwhatisbestbothforthestateandforthefamily,esteemingasIoughtthefeelingsofanindividualatalowerrate;andIhopethatyouwilldepartinpeaceandkindnesstowardsus,asyouaregoingthewayofallmankind;andwewillimpartiallytakecareofallyourconcerns,notneglectinganyofthem,ifwecanpossiblyhelp。Letthisbeourpreludeandconsolationtothelivinganddying,Cleinias,andletthelawbeasfollows:
Hewhomakesadispositioninatestament,ifhebethefatherofafamily,shallfirstofallinscribeashisheiranyoneofhissonswhomhemaythinkfit;andifhegivesanyofhischildrentobeadoptedbyanothercitizen,lettheadoptionbeinscribed。Andifhehasasonremainingoverandabovewhohasnotbeenadopteduponanylot,andwhomaybeexpectedtobesentouttoacolonyaccordingtolaw,tohimhisfathermaygiveasmuchashepleasesoftherestofhisproperty,withtheexceptionofthepaternallotandthefixturesonthelot。Andifthereareothersons,lethimdistributeamongthemwhatthereismorethanthelotinsuchportionsashepleases。Andifoneofthesonshasalreadyahouseofhisown,heshallnotgivehimofthemoney,norshallhegivemoneytoadaughterwhohasbeenbetrothed,butifsheisnotbetrothedhemaygivehermoney。Andifanyofthesonsordaughtersshallbefoundtohaveanotherlotoflandinthecountry,whichhasaccruedafterthetestamenthasbeenmade,theyshallleavethelotwhichtheyhaveinheritedtotheheirofthemanwhohasmadethewill。Ifthetestatorhasnosons,butonlydaughters,lethimchoosethehusbandofanyoneofhisdaughterswhomhepleases,andleaveandinscribehimashissonandheir。Andifamanhavelosthisson,whenhewasachild,andbeforehecouldbereckonedamonggrown-upmen,whetherhisownoranadoptedson,letthetestatormakementionofthecircumstanceandinscribewhomhewilltobehissecondsoninhopeofbetterfortune。Ifthetestatorhasnochildrenatall,hemayselectandgivetoanyonewhomhepleasesthetenthpartofthepropertywhichhehasacquired;butlethimnotbeblamedifhegivesalltheresttohisadoptedson,andmakesafriendofhimaccordingtothelaw。Ifthesonsofamanrequireguardians,and:thefatherwhenhediesleavesawillappointingguardians,thosehavebeennamedbyhim,whoevertheyareandwhatevertheirnumberbe,iftheyareableandwillingtotakechargeofthechildren,shallberecognizedaccordingtotheprovisionsofthewill。Butifhediesandhasmadenowill,orawillinwhichhehasappointednoguardians,thenthenextofkin,twoonthefather’sandtwoonthemother’sside,andoneofthefriendsofthedeceased,shallhavetheauthorityofguardians,whomtheguardiansofthelawshallappointwhentheorphansrequireguardians。Andthefifteeneldestguardiansofthelawshallhavethewholecareandchargeoftheorphans,dividedintothreesaccordingtoseniority-abodyofthreeforoneyear,andthenanotherbodyofthreeforthenextyear,untilthecycleofthefiveperiodsiscomplete;andthis,asfaraspossible,istocontinuealways。Ifamandies,havingmadenowillatall,andleavessonswhorequirethecareofguardians,theyshallshareintheprotectionwhichisaffordedbytheselaws。
Andifamandyingbysomeunexpectedfateleavesdaughtersbehindhim,lethimpardonthelegislatorifhegivestheminmarriage,hehavearegardonlytotwooutofthreeconditions-nearnessofkinandthepreservationofthelot,andomitsthethirdcondition,whichafatherwouldnaturallyconsider,forhewouldchooseoutofallthecitizensasonforhimself,andahusbandforhisdaughter,withaviewtohischaracteranddisposition-thefather,say,shallforgivethelegislatorifhedisregardsthis,whichtohimisanimpossibleconsideration。Letthelawaboutthesematterswherepracticablebeasfollows:-Ifamandieswithoutmakingawill,andleavesbehindhimdaughters,lethisbrother,beingthesonofthesamefatherorofthesamemother,havingnolot,marrythedaughterandhavethelotofthedeadman。Andifhehavenobrother,butonlyabrother’sson,inlikemannerletthemmarry,iftheybeofasuitableage;andiftherebenotevenabrother’sson,butonlythesonofasister,letthemdolikewise,andsointhefourthdegree,iftherebeonlythetestator’sfather’sbrother,orinthefifthdegree,hisfather’sbrother’sson,orinthesixthdegree,thechildofhisfather’ssister。Letkindredbealwaysreckonedinthisway:ifapersonleavesdaughterstherelationshipshallproceedupwardsthroughbrothersandsisters,andbrothers’andsisters’children,andfirstthemalesshallcome,andafterthemthefemalesinthesamefamily。
Thejudgeshallconsideranddeterminethesuitablenessorunsuitablenessofageinmarriage;heshallmakeaninspectionofthemalesnaked,andofthewomennakeddowntothenavel。Andiftherebealackofkinsmeninafamilyextendingtograndchildrenofabrother,ortothegrandchildrenofagrandfather’schildren,themaidenmaychoosewiththeconsentofherguardiansanyoneofthecitizenswhoiswillingandwhomshewills,andheshallbetheheirofthedeadman,andthehusbandofhisdaughter。Circumstancesvary,andtheremaysometimesbeastillgreaterlackofrelationswithinthelimitsofthestate;andifanymaidenhasnokindredlivinginthecity,andthereissomeonewhohasbeensentouttoacolony,andsheisdisposedtomakehimtheheirofherfather’spossessions,ifhebeindeedofherkindred,lethimproceedtotakethelotaccordingtotheregulationofthelaw;butifhebenotofherkindred,shehavingnokinsmenwithinthecity,andhebechosenbythedaughterofthedeadman,andempoweredtomarrybytheguardians,lethimreturnhomeandtakethelotofhimwhodiedintestate。Andifamanhasnochildren,eithermaleorfemale,anddieswithoutmakingawill,letthepreviouslawingeneralhold;
andletamanandawomangoforthfromthefamilyandsharethedesertedhouse,andletthelotbelongabsolutelytothem;andlettheheiressinthefirstdegreebeasister,andinaseconddegreeadaughterofabrother,andinthethird,adaughterofasister,inthefourthdegreethesisterofafather,andinthefifthdegreethedaughterofafather’sbrother,andinasixthdegreeofafather’ssister;andtheseshalldwellwiththeirmalekinsmen,accordingtothedegreeofrelationshipandright,asweenactedbefore。Nowwemustnotconcealfromourselvesthatsuchlawsareapttobeoppressiveandthattheremaysometimesbeahardshipinthelawgivercommandingthekinsmanofthedeadmantomarryhisrelation;
bemaybethoughtnottohaveconsideredtheinnumerablehindranceswhichmayariseamongmenintheexecutionofsuchordinances;fortheremaybecasesinwhichthepartiesrefusetoobey,andarereadytodoanythingratherthanmarry,whenthereissomebodilyormentalmaladyordefectamongthosewhoarebiddentomarryorbemarried。Personsmayfancythatthelegislatorneverthoughtofthis,buttheyaremistaken;whereforeletusmakeacommonpreludeonbehalfofthelawgiverandofhissubjects,thelawbeggingthelattertoforgivethelegislator,inthathe,havingtotakecareofthecommonweal,cannotorderatthesametimethevariouscircumstancesofindividuals,andbegginghimtopardonthemifnaturallytheyaresometimesunabletofulfiltheactwhichheinhisignoranceimposesuponthem。
Cle。Andhow,Stranger,canweactmostfairlyunderthecircumstances?
Ath。Theremustbearbiterschosentodealwithsuchlawsandthesubjectsofthem。
Cle。Whatdoyoumean?
Ath。Imeantosay,thatacasemayoccurinwhichthenephew,havingarichfather,willbeunwillingtomarrythedaughterofhisuncle;hewillhaveafeelingofpride,andhewillwishtolookhigher。Andtherearecasesinwhichthelegislatorwillbeimposinguponhimthegreatestcalamity,andhewillbecompelledtodisobeythelaw,ifheisrequired,forexample,totakeawifewhoismad,orhassomeotherterriblemaladyofsoulorbody,suchasmakeslifeintolerabletothesufferer。Thenletwhatwearesayingconcerningthesecasesbeembodiedinalaw:-Ifanyonefindsfaultwiththeestablishedlawsrespectingtestaments,bothastoothermattersandespeciallyinwhatrelatestomarriage,andassertsthatthelegislator,ifhewerealiveandpresent,wouldnotcompelhimtoobey-thatistosay,wouldnotcompelthosewhoarebyourlawrequiredtomarryorbegiveninmarriage,todoeither-andsomekinsmanorguardiandisputethis,thereplyisthatthelegislatorleftfifteenoftheguardiansofthelawtobearbitersandfathersoforphans,maleorfemale,andtothemletthedisputantshaverecourse,andbytheiraiddetermineanymattersofthekind,admittingtheirdecisiontobefinal。Butifanyonethinksthattoogreatpoweristhusgiventotheguardiansofthelaw,lethimbringhisadversariesintothecourtoftheselectjudges,andtherehavethepointsindisputedetermined。Andhewholosesthecauseshallhavecensureandblamefromthelegislator,which,byamanofsense,isfelttobeapenaltyfarheavierthanagreatlossofmoney。
Thuswillorphanchildrenhaveasecondbirth。Aftertheirfirstbirthwespokeoftheirnurtureandeducation,andaftertheirsecondbirth,whentheyhavelosttheirparents,weoughttotakemeasuresthatthemisfortuneoforphanhoodmaybeaslittlesadtothemaspossible。Inthefirstplace,wesaythattheguardiansofthelawarelawgiversandfatherstothem,notinferiortotheirnaturalfathers。Moreover,theyshalltakechargeofthemyearbyyearasoftheirownkindred;andwehavegivenbothtothemandtothechildren’sownguardiansasuitableadmonitionconcerningthenurtureoforphans。Andweseemtohavespokenopportunelyinourformerdiscourse,whenwesaidthatthesoulsofthedeadhavethepowerafterdeathoftakinganinterestinhumanaffairs,aboutwhichtherearemanytalesandtraditions,longindeed,buttrue;
andseeingthattheyaresomanyandsoancient,wemustbelievethem,andwemustalsobelievethelawgivers,whotellusthatthesethingsaretrue,iftheyarenottoberegardedasutterfools。Butifthesethingsarereallyso,inthefirstplacemenshouldhaveafearoftheGodsabove,whoregardthelonelinessoftheorphans;
andinthesecondplaceofthesoulsofthedeparted,whobynatureinclinetotakeanespecialcareoftheirownchildren,andarefriendlytothosewhohonour,andunfriendlytothosewhodishonourthem。Menshouldalsofearthesoulsofthelivingwhoareagedandhighinhonour;whereveracityiswellorderedandprosperous,theirdescendantscherishthem,andsolivehappily;oldpersonsarequicktoseeandhearallthatrelatestothem,andarepropitioustothosewhoarejustinthefulfilmentofsuchduties,andtheypunishthosewhowrongtheorphanandthedesolate,consideringthattheyarethegreatestandmostsacredoftrusts。Toallwhichmatterstheguardianandmagistrateoughttoapplyhismind,ifhehasany,andtakeheedofthenurtureandeducationoftheorphans,seekingineverypossiblewaytodothemgood,forheismakingacontributiontohisowngoodandthatofhischildren。Hewhoobeysthetalewhichprecedesthelaw,anddoesnowrongtoanorphan,willneverexperiencethewrathofthelegislator。Buthewhoisdisobedient,andwrongsanyonewhoisbereftoffatherormother,shallpaytwicethepenaltywhichhewouldhavepaidifhehadwrongedonewhoseparentshadbeenalive。Astouchingotherlegislationconcerningguardiansintheirrelationtoorphans,orconcerningmagistratesandtheirsuperintendenceoftheguardians,iftheydidnotpossessexamplesofthemannerinwhichchildrenoffreemenshouldbebroughtupinthebringingupoftheirownchildren,andofthecareoftheirpropertyinthecareoftheirown,oriftheyhadnotjustlawsfairlystatedabouttheseverythings-therewouldhavebeenreasoninmakinglawsforthem,undertheideathattheywereapeculiar-class,andwemightdistinguishandmakeseparaterulesforthelifeofthosewhoareorphansandofthosewhoarenotorphans。