“ItistotheBritishpractitioner,“saysDr。Rigby,“thatweareindebtedforstronglyinsistinguponthisimportantanddangerouscharacterofpuerperalfever。“
ThenamesofGordon,JohnClarke,Denman,Burns,Young,Hamilton,Haighton,Good,Waller;Blundell,Gooch,Ramsbotham,Douglas,Lee,Ingleby,Locock,Abercrombie,Alison;Travers,Rigby,andWatson,manyofwhosewritingsIhavealreadyreferredto,mayhavesomeinfluencewiththosewhoprefertheweightofauthoritiestothesimpledeductionsoftheirownreasonfromthefactslaidbeforethem。AfewContinentalwritershaveadoptedsimilarconclusions。Itgivesmepleasuretoremember,thatwhilethedoctrinehasbeenunceremoniouslydiscreditedinoneoftheleadingJournals,andmadeverylightofbyteachersintwooftheprincipalMedicalSchools,ofthiscountry,Dr。Channinghasformanyyearsinculcated,andenforcedbyexamples,thedangertobeapprehendedandtheprecautionstobetakeninthediseaseunderconsideration。
Ihavenowishtoexpressanyharshfeelingwithregardtothepainfulsubjectwhichhascomebeforeus。Ifthereareanysofarexcitedbythestoryofthesedreadfuleventsthattheyaskforsomewordofindignantremonstrancetoshowthatsciencedoesnotturntheheartsofitsfollowersintoiceorstone,letmeremindthemthatsuchwordshavebeenutteredbythosewhospeakwithanauthorityI
couldnotclaim。ItisasalessonratherthanasareproachthatI
callupthememoryoftheseirreparableerrorsandwrongs。Notonguecantelltheheart-breakingcalamitytheyhavecaused;theyhaveclosedtheeyesjustopeneduponanewworldofloveandhappiness;
theyhavebowedthestrengthofmanhoodintothedust;theyhavecastthehelplessnessofinfancyintothestranger’sarms,orbequeathedit,withlesscruelty,thedeathofitsdyingparent。Thereisnotonedeepenoughforregret,andnovoiceloudenoughforwarning。
Thewomanabouttobecomeamother,orwithhernew-borninfantuponherbosom,shouldbetheobjectoftremblingcareandsympathywherevershebearshertenderburden,orstretchesherachinglimbs。
Theveryoutcastofthestreetshaspityuponhersisterindegradation,whenthesealofpromisedmaternityisimpresseduponher。Theremorselessvengeanceofthelaw,broughtdownuponitsvictimbyamachineryassureasdestiny,isarrestedinitsfallatawordwhichrevealshertransientclaimformercy。Thesolemnprayeroftheliturgysinglesouthersorrowsfromthemultipliedtrialsoflife,topleadforherinthehourofperil。Godforbidthatanymemberoftheprofessiontowhichshetrustsherlife,doublypreciousatthateventfulperiod,shouldhazarditnegligently,unadvisedly,orselfishly!
TheremaybesomeamongthosewhomIaddresswhoaredisposedtoaskthequestion,Whatcoursearewetofollowinrelationtothismatter?Thefactsarebeforethem,andtheanswermustbelefttotheirownjudgmentandconscience。Ifanyshouldcaretoknowmyownconclusions,theyarethefollowing;andintakingthelibertytostatethemveryfreelyandbroadly,Iwouldasktheinquirertoexaminethemasfreelyinthelightoftheevidencewhichhasbeenlaidbeforehim。
1。Aphysicianholdinghimselfinreadinesstoattendcasesofmidwiferyshouldnevertakeanyactivepartinthepost-mortemexaminationofcasesofpuerperalfever。
2。Ifaphysicianispresentatsuchautopsies,heshouldusethoroughablution,changeeveryarticleofdress,andallowtwenty-
fourhoursormoretoelapsebeforeattendingtoanycaseofmidwifery。Itmaybewelltoextendthesamecautiontocasesofsimpleperitonitis。
3。Similarprecautionsshouldbetakenaftertheautopsyorsurgicaltreatmentofcasesoferysipelas,ifthephysicianisobligedtounitesuchofficeswithhisobstetricalduties,whichisinthehighestdegreeinexpedient。
4。Ontheoccurrenceofasinglecaseofpuerperalfeverinhispractice,thephysicianisboundtoconsiderthenextfemaleheattendsinlabor,unlesssomeweeksatleasthaveelapsed,asindangerofbeinginfectedbyhim,anditishisdutytotakeeveryprecautiontodiminishherriskofdiseaseanddeath。
5。Ifwithinashortperiodtwocasesofpuerperalfeverhappenclosetoeachother,inthepracticeofthesamephysician,thediseasenotexistingorprevailingintheneighborhood,hewoulddowiselytorelinquishhisobstetricalpracticeforatleastonemonth,andendeavortofreehimselfbyeveryavailablemeansfromanynoxiousinfluencehemaycarryaboutwithhim。
6。Theoccurrenceofthreeormorecloselyconnectedcases,inthepracticeofoneindividual,noothersexistingintheneighborhood,andnoothersufficientcausebeingallegedforthecoincidence,isprimafacieevidencethatheisthevehicleofcontagion。
7。Itisthedutyofthephysiciantotakeeveryprecautionthatthediseaseshallnotbeintroducedbynursesorotherassistants,bymakingproperinquiriesconcerningthem,andgivingtimelywarningofeverysuspectedsourceofdanger。
8。Whateverindulgencemaybegrantedtothosewhohaveheretoforebeentheignorantcausesofsomuchmisery,thetimehascomewhentheexistenceofaprivatepestilenceinthesphereofasinglephysicianshouldbelookedupon,notasamisfortune,butacrime;
andintheknowledgeofsuchoccurrencesthedutiesofthepractitionertohisprofessionshouldgivewaytohisparamountobligationstosociety。
ADDITIONALREFERENCESANDCASES。
FifthAnnualReportoftheRegistrar-GeneralofEngland,1843。Appendix。LetterfromWilliamFarr,Esq——SeveralnewseriesofcasesaregivenintheLetterofMr。Stows,containedintheAppendixtothisReport。Mr。StowssuggestsprecautionssimilartothoseIhavelaiddown,andtheseprecautionsarestronglyenforcedbyMr。Farr,whois,therefore,obnoxioustothesamecriticismsasmyself。
HallandDexter,inAm。JournalofMed。Sc。forJanuary,1844-
Casesofpuerperalfeverseemingtooriginateinerysipelas。
Elkington,ofBirmingham,inProvincialMed。Journal,citedinAm。
Journ。Med。Se。forApril,1844——Sixcasesinlessthanafortnight,seemingtooriginateinacaseoferysipelas。
West’sReports,inBrit。andFor。Med。ReviewforOctober,1845,andJanuary,1847——Affectionofthearm,resemblingmalignantpustule,afterremovingtheplacentaofapatientwhodiedfrompuerperalfever。ReferencetocasesatWurzburg,asprovingcontagion,andtoKeiller’scasesintheMonthlyJournalforFebruary,1846,asshowingconnectionofpuerperalfeveranderysipelas。
Kneeland——ContagiousnessofPuerperalFever。Am。Jour。Med。
Se。,January,1846。Also,ConnectionbetweenPuerperalFeverandEpidemicErysipelas。Ibid。,April,1846。
RobertStorrs——ContagiousEffectsofPuerperalFeverontheMaleSubject;oronPersonsnotChild-bearing。FromProvincialMed。andSurg。Journal。Am。Jour。Med。Sc。,January,184,6。Numerouscases。SeealsoDr。Reid’scaseinsameJournalforApril,1846。
Routh’spaperinProc。ofRoyalMed。Chir。Soc。,Am。Jour。Med。
Sc。,April,1849,alsoinB。andF。Med。Chir。Review,April,1850。
Hill,ofLeuchars——ASeriesofCasesillustratingtheContagiousNatureofErysipelasandofPuerperalFever,andtheirIntimatePathologicalConnection。FromMonthlyJournalofMed。Sc。Am。
Jour。Med。Se。,July,1850。
SkodaontheCausesofPuerperalFever。Peritonitisinrabbits,frominoculationwithdifferentmorbidsecretions。Am。Jour。Med。
Se。,October,1850。
Arneth。PaperreadbeforetheNationalAcademyofMedicine。Annalesd’Hygiene,TomeLXV。2ePartie。MeansofDisinfectionproposedbyM。“Semmeliveis“Semmelweiss。Lotionsofchlorideoflimeanduseofnail-brushbeforeadmissiontolying-inwards。Allegedsuddenandgreatdecreaseofmortalityfrompuerperalfever。Causeofdiseaseattributedtoinoculationwithcadavericmatters。SeealsoRouth’spaper,mentionedabove。
Moir。RemarksatameetingoftheEdinburghMedico-ChirurgicalSociety。ReferstocasesofDr。Kellie,ofLeith。Sixteeninsuccession,allfatal。Alsotoseveralinstancesofindividualpupilshavinghadasuccessionofcasesinvariousquartersofthetown,whileothers,practisingasextensivelyinthesamelocalities,hadnone。Alsotoseveralspecialcasesnotmentionedelsewhere。
Am。Jour。Med。Se。forOctober,1851。FromNewMonthlyJournalofMed。Science。
Simpson——ObservationsataMeetingoftheEdinburghObstetricalSociety。An“eminentgentleman,“accordingtoDr。Meigs,whose“nameisaswellknowninAmericaasinhisnativeland。“
Obstetrics。Phil。1852,pp。368,375。Thestudentisreferredtothispaperforavaluableresumeofmanyofthefacts,andthenecessaryinferences,relatingtothissubject。Alsoforanotherseriesofcases,Mr。Sidey’s,fiveorsixinrapidsuccession。
Dr。SimpsonattendedthedissectionoftwoofDr。Sidey’scases,andfreelyhandledthediseasedparts。Hisnextfourchild-bedpatientswereaffectedwithpuerperalfever,anditwasthefirsttimehehadseenitinpractice。AsDr。SimpsonisagentlemanDr。Meigs,asabove,andas“agentleman’shandsareclean“Dr。Meigs’SixthLetter,itfollowsthatagentlemanwithcleanhandsmaycarrythedisease。Am。Jour。Med。Sc。,October,1851。
Peddle——ThefiveorsixcasesofDr。Sidey,followedbythefourofDr。Simpson,didnotendtheseries。ApractitionerinLeithhavingexaminedinDr。Simpson’shouse,aportionoftheuterusobtainedfromoneofthepatients,hadimmediatelyafterwardsthreefatalcasesofpuerperalfever。Dr。Veddiereferredtotwodistinctseriesofconsecutivecasesinhisownpractice。Hehadsincetakenprecautions,andnotmetwithanysuchcases。Am。Jour。Med。Sc。,October,1851。
Copland。Considersitprovedthatpuerperalfevermaybepropagatedbythehandsandtheclothes,oreither,ofathirdperson,thebed-
clothesorbody-clothesofapatient。Mentionsanewseriesofcases,oneofwhichhesaw,withthepractitionerwhohadattendedthem。Shewasthesixthhehadhadwithinafewdays。Alldied。
Dr。Coplandinsistedthatcontagionhadcausedthesecases;advisedprecautionarymeasures,andthepractitionerhadnoothercasesforaconsiderabletime。Considersitcriminal,aftertheevidenceadduced,——whichhecouldhavequadrupled,——andtheweightofauthoritybroughtforward,forapractitionertobethemediumoftransmittingcontagionanddeathtohispatients。Dr。Coplandlaysdownrulessimilartothosesuggestedbymyself,andisthereforeentitledtothesameepithetforsodoing。MedicalDictionary,NewYork,1852。Article,PuerperalStatesandDiseases。
Ifthereisanyappetiteforfactssocravingastobeyetunappeased,——Lesotho,necdumsatiata,——morecanbeobtained。
Dr。Hodgeremarksthat“thefrequencyandimportanceofthissingularcircumstancethatthediseaseisoccasionallymoreprevalentwithonepractitionerthananotherhasbeenexceedinglyoverrated。“Morethanthirtystringsofcases,morethantwohundredandfiftysufferersfrompuerperalfever,morethanonehundredandthirtydeathsappearastheresultsofasparingestimateofsuchamongthefactsIhavegleanedascouldbenumericallyvalued。Thesefactsconstitute,wemaytakeitforgranted,butasmallfractionofthosethathaveactuallyoccurred。Thenumberofthemmightbegreater,but“’tisenough,’twillserve,“inMercutio’smodestphrase,sofarasfrequencyisconcerned。Forajustestimateoftheimportanceofthesingularcircumstance,itmightbepropertoconsultthelanguidsurvivors,thewidowedhusbands,andthemotherlesschildren,aswellas“theunfortunateaccoucheur。“
III
CURRENTSANDCOUNTER-CURRENTSINMEDICALSCIENCE
AnAddressdeliveredbeforetheMassachusettsMedicalSociety,attheAnnualMeeting,May30,1860。
“Facultatemagisquamviolentia。
HIPPOCRATES。
OurAnnualMeetingneverfailstoteachusatleastonelesson。TheartwhoseprovinceitistohealandtosavecannotprotectitsownranksfromtheinroadsofdiseaseandthewasteoftheDestroyer。
SeventeenofourassociateshavebeentakenfromussinceourlastAnniversary。Mostofthemfollowedtheircallinginthevillagesortownsthatlieamongthehillsoralongtheinlandstreams。Onlythosewhohavelivedthekindly,mutuallydependentlifeofthecountry,cantellhownearthephysicianwhoisthemainrelianceinsicknessofallthefamiliesthroughoutathinlysettledregioncomestotheheartsofthepeopleamongwhomhelabors,howtheyvaluehimwhileliving,howtheycherishhismemorywhendead。Forthesefriendsofourswhohavegonebefore,thereisnownomoretoil;theystartfromtheirslumbersnomoreatthecryofpain;theysallyforthnomoreintothestorms;theyridenolongeroverthelonelyroadsthatknewthemsowell;theirwheelsarerustingontheiraxlesorrollingwithotherburdens;theirwatchfuleyesareclosedtoallthesorrowstheylivedtosoothe。Notoneofthesewasfamousinthegreatworld;somewerealmostunknownbeyondtheirownimmediatecircle。Buttheyhaveleftbehindthemthatlovingremembrancewhichisbetterthanfame,andiftheirepitaphsarechiselledbrieflyinstone,theyarewrittenatfulllengthonlivingtabletsinathousandhomestowhichtheycarriedtheirever-welcomeaidandsympathy。