Thereasonwhyweteachsomuchthatisnotpracticalandinitselfuseful,isbecausewefindthattheeasiestwayofteachingwhatispracticalanduseful。Ifwecouldinanywayeliminateallthatwouldhelpamantodealsuccessfullywithdisease,andteachitbyitselfsothatitshouldbeastenaciouslyrootedinthememory,aseasilysummonedwhenwanted,asfertileinsuggestionofrelatedfacts,assatisfactorytotheperemptorydemandsoftheintelligenceasiftaughtinitsscientificconnections,Ithinkitwouldbeourdutysototeachthemomentoustruthsofmedicine,andtoregardalluselessadditionsasanintrusiononthetimewhichshouldbeotherwiseoccupied。
Butwecannotsuccessfullyeliminateandteachbyitselfthatwhichispurelypractical。Theeasiestandsurestwhyofacquiringfactsistolearnthemingroups,insystems,andsystematizedknowledgeisscience。Youcanveryoftencarrytwofactsfastenedtogethermoreeasilythanonebyitself,asahousemaidcancarrytwopailsofwaterwithahoopmoreeasilythanonewithoutit。Youcanrememberaman’sface,madeupofmanyfeatures,betterthanyoucanhisnoseorhismouthorhiseye-brow。Scoresofproverbsshowyouthatyoucanremembertwolinesthatrhymebetterthanonewithoutthejingle。
Theancients,whoknewthelawsofmemory,groupedthesevencitiesthatcontendedforthehonorofbeingHomer’sbirthplaceinalinethusgivenbyAulusGellius:
Smurna,Rodos,Colophon,Salamin,Ios,Argos,Athenai。
Iremember,intheearlierpoliticaldaysofMartinVanBuren,thatColonelStone,ofthe“NewYorkCommercial,“oroneofhiscorrespondents,saidthatsixtownsofNewYorkwouldclaiminthesamewaytohavebeenthebirth-placeofthe“LittleMagician,“ashewasthencalled;andthushegavetheirnames,anyoneofwhichI
shouldlongagohaveforgotten,butwhichasagrouphavestucktightinmymemoryfromthatdaytothis;
Catskill,Saugerties,Redhook,Kinderhook,Scaghticoke,Schodac。
Ifthememorygainssomuchbymererhythmicalassociation,howmuchmorewillitgainwhenisolatedfactsarebroughttogetherunderlawsandprinciples,whenorgansareexaminedintheirnaturalconnections,whenstructureiscoupledwithfunction,andhealthyanddiseasedactionarestudiedastheypassoneintotheother!
Systematic,orscientificstudyisinvaluableassupplyinganaturalkindofmnemonics,iffornothingelse。YoucannotproperlylearnthefactsyouwantfromAnatomyandChemistryinanywaysoeasilyasbytakingthemintheirregularorder,withotheralliedfacts,onlytheremustbecommonsenseexercisedinleavingoutagreatdealwhichbelongstoeachofthetwobranchesaspurescience。Thedullestofteachersistheonewhodoesnotknowwhattoomit。
Thelargeraimofscientifictrainingistofurnishyouwithprinciplestowhichyouwillbeabletoreferisolatedfacts,andsobringthesewithintherangeofrecordedexperience。Seewhatthe“LondonTimes“saidaboutthethreeGermanswhocrackedopenJohnBullChatwood’sstrong-boxattheFairtheotherday,whilethethreeEnglishmenhammeredawayinvainatBrotherJonathanHerring’s。TheEnglishmenrepresentedbruteforce。TheGermanshadbeentrainedtoappreciateprinciple。TheEnglishman“knowshisbusinessbyroteandruleofthumb“——science,whichwould“teachhimtodoinanhourwhathashithertooccupiedhimtwohours,““isinamannerforbiddentohim。“Tothiscausethe“Times“attributesthefallingoffofEnglishworkmenincomparisonwiththoseoftheContinent。
Grantingallthis,wemustnotexpecttoomuchfrom“science“asdistinguishedfromcommonexperience。Therearetenthousandexperimenterswithoutspecialapparatusforeveryoneinthelaboratory。Accidentisthegreatchemistandtoxicologist。Battleisthegreatvivisector。HungerhasinstitutedresearchesonfoodsuchasnoLiebig,noAcademicCommissionhaseverrecorded。
Medicine,sometimesimpertinently,oftenignorantly,oftencarelesslycalled“allopathy,“appropriateseverythingfromeverysourcethatcanbeoftheslightestusetoanybodywhoisailinginanyway,orliketobeailingfromanycause。Itlearnedfromamonkhowtouseantimony,fromaJesuithowtocureagues,fromafriarhowtocutforstone,fromasoldierhowtotreatgout,fromasailorhowtokeepoffscurvy,fromapostmasterhowtosoundtheEustachiantube,fromadairy-maidhowtopreventsmall-pox,andfromanoldmarket-
womanhowtocatchtheitch-insect。ItborrowedacupunctureandthemoxafromtheJapaneseheathen,andwastaughttheuseoflobeliabytheAmericansavage。Itstandsreadyto-daytoacceptanythingfromanytheorist,fromanyempiricwhocanmakeoutagoodcaseforhisdiscoveryorhisremedy。“Science“isoneofitsbenefactors,butonlyone,outofmany。Askthewisestpractisingphysicianyouknow,whatbranchesofsciencehelphimhabitually,andwhatamountofknowledgerelatingtoeachbranchherequiresforhisprofessionalduties。Hewilltellyouthatscientifictraininghasavalueindependentofallthespecialknowledgeacquired。Hewilltellyouthatmanyfactsareexplainedbystudyingtheminthewiderrangeofrelatedfactstowhichtheybelong。Hewillgratefullyrecognizethattheanatomisthasfurnishedhimwithindispensabledata,thatthephysiologisthassometimesputhimonthetrackofnewmodesoftreatment,thatthechemisthasisolatedtheactiveprinciplesofhismedicines,hastaughthimhowtocombinethem,hasfromtimetotimeofferedhimnewremedialagencies,andsoofothersofhisallies。
Buthewillalsotellyou,ifIamnotmistaken,thathisownbranchofknowledgeissoextensiveandsoperplexingthathemustacceptmostofhisfactsreadymadeattheirhands。Hewillowntoyouthatinthestruggleforlifewhichgoesondayandnightinourthoughtsasintheoutsideworldofnature,muchthathelearnedunderthenameofsciencehasdiedout,andthatsimplehomelyexperiencehaslargelytakentheplaceofthatscholasticknowledgetowhichheandperhapssomeofhisinstructorsonceattachedaparemountimportance。
This,then,ismyviewofscientifictrainingasconductedincoursessuchasyouareenteringon。UptoacertainpointIbelieveinsetLecturesasexcellentadjunctstowhatisfarmoreimportant,practicalinstructionatthebedside,intheoperatingroom,andundertheeyeoftheDemonstrator。ButIamsofarfromwishingthesecoursesextended,thatIthinksomeofthem——supposeIsaymyown——wouldalmostbearcurtailing。Doyouwantmetodescribemorebranchesofthesciaticandcruralnerves?IcantakeFischer’splates,andlecturingonthatscalefillupmywholecourseandnotfinishthenervesalone。Wemuststopsomewhere,andformyownpartIthinkthescholasticexercisesofourcollegeshavealreadyclaimedtheirfullshareofthestudent’stimewithoutourseekingtoextendthem。
ItrustIhavevindicatedtheapparentinconsequenceofteachingyoungstudentsagooddealthatseemsatfirstsightprofitless,butwhichhelpsthemtolearnandretainwhatisprofitable。Butthisisaninquisitiveage,andifweinsistonpilingupbeyondacertainheightknowledgewhichisinitselfmeretrashandlumbertoamanwhoselifeistobeonelongfightwithdeathanddisease,therewillbesomesharpquestionsaskedbyandby,andourquick-wittedpeoplewillperhapsfindtheycangetalongaswellwithouttheprofessor’scapaswithoutthebishop’smitreandthemonarch’scrown。
Imyselfhavenothingtodowithclinicalteaching。YetIdonothesitatetosayitismoreessentialthanalltherestputtogether,sofarastheordinarypracticeofmedicineisconcerned;andthisisbyfarthemostimportantthingtobelearned,becauseitdealswithsomanymorelivesthananyotherbranchoftheprofession。Soofpersonalinstruction,suchaswegiveandothersgiveintheintervaloflectures,muchofitatthebedside,someofitinthelaboratory,someinthemicroscope-room,someintherecitation-room,Ithinkithasmanyadvantagesofitsownoverthewintercourse,andIdonotwishtoseeitshortenedforthesakeofprolongingwhatseemstomelongenoughalready。
IfIamjealousofthetendencytoexpandthetimegiventotheacquisitionofcuriousknowledge,attheexpenseoftheplainold-
fashionedbedsideteachings,IonlysharethefeelingwhichSydenhamexpressedtwohundredyearsago,usinganimageIhavealreadyborrowed。“Hewouldbenohonestandsuccessfulpilotwhowastoapplyhimselfwithlessindustrytoavoidrocksandsandsandbringhisvesselsafelyhome,thantosearchintothecausesoftheebbingandflowingofthesea,which,thoughverywellforaphilosopher,isforeigntohimwhosebusinessitistosecuretheship。Soneitherwillaphysician,whoseprovinceitistocurediseases,beabletodoso,thoughhebeapersonofgreatgenius,whobestowslesstimeonthehiddenandintricatemethodofnature,andadaptinghismeansthereto,thanoncuriousandsubtlespeculation。“
“MedicineismywifeandScienceismymistress,“saidDr。Rush。I
donotthinkthatthebreachoftheseventhcommandmentcanbeshowntohavebeenofadvantagetothelegitimateownerofhisaffections。
ReadwhatDr。ElishaBartlettsaysofhimasapractitioner,oraskoneofourownhonoredex-professors,whostudiedunderhim,whetherDr。RushhadeverlearnedthemeaningofthatsayingofLordBacon,thatmanistheministerandinterpreterofNature,orwhetherhedidnotspeakhabituallyofNatureasanintruderinthesickroom,fromwhichhisartwastoexpelherasanincompetentandameddler。
Allaman’spowersarenottoomuchforsuchaprofessionasMedicine。“Heisalearnedman,“saidoldParsonEmmonsofFranklin,“whounderstandsonesubject,andheisaverylearnedmanwhounderstandstwosubjects。“Schonbeinsayshehasbeenstudyingoxygenforthirtyyears。Mitscherlichsaidittookfourteenyearstoestablishanewfactinchemistry。AubreysaysofHarvey,thediscovererofthecirculation,that“thoughallhisprofessionwouldallowhimtobeanexcellentanatomist,Ihaveneverheardofanywhoadmiredhistherapeuticway。“Mylearnedandexcellentfriendbeforereferredto,Dr。BrownofEdinburgh,fromwhoseverylivelyandsensibleEssay,“LockeandSydenham,“Ihaveborrowedseveralofmycitations,contrastsSirCharlesBell,thediscoverer,themanofscience,withDr。Abercrombie,themasterinthediagnosisandtreatmentofdisease。ItisthroughoneoftherarestofcombinationsthatwehaveinourFacultyateacheronwhomthescientificmantleofBellhasfallen,andwhoyetstandspreeminentinthepracticaltreatmentoftheclassofdiseaseswhichhisinventiveandardentexperimentalgeniushasillustrated。M。Brown-
Sequard’sexampleisas,eloquentashisteachinginproofoftheadvantagesofwelldirectedscientificinvestigation。Butthosewhoemulatehissuccessatonceasadiscovererandapractitionermustbecontentlikehimtolimittheirfieldofpractice。Thehighestgeniuscannotaffordinourtimetoforgettheancientprecept,Divideetimpera。
“IsupposeImustgoandearnthisguinea,“saidamedicalmanwhowassentforwhilehewasdissectingananimal。Ishouldnothavecaredtobehispatient。Hisdissectionwoulddomenogood,andhisthoughtswouldbetoomuchuponit。Iwantawholemanformydoctor,notahalfone。Iwouldhavesentforahumblerpractitioner,whowouldhavegivenhimselfentirelytome,andtoldtheother——whowasnolessamanthanJohnHunter——togoonandfinishthedissectionofhistiger。
Sydenham’s“ReadDonQuixote“shouldbeaddressednottothestudent,buttotheProfessoroftoday。Aimedathimitmeans,“Donotbetoolearned。
Donotthinkyouaregoingtolecturetopickedyoungmenwhoaretrainingthemselvestobescientificdiscoverers。Theyareoffairaveragecapacity,andtheyaregoingtobeworkingdoctors。
Theseyoungmenaretohavesomeveryseriousvitalfactstodealwith。Iwillmentionafewofthem。
Everyotherresidentadultyoumeetinthesestreetsisorwillbemoreorlesstuberculous。Thisisnotanextravagantestimate,asverynearlyonethirdofthedeathsofadultsinBostonlastyearwerefromphthisis。Iftherelativenumberislessinourothernortherncities,itisprobablyinagreatmeasurebecausetheyaremoreunhealthy;thatis,theyhaveasmuch,ornearlyasmuch,consumption,buttheyhavemorefeversorotherfataldiseases。
Theseheavy-eyedmenwiththealcoholizedbrains,thesepallidyouthswiththenicotizedopticgangliaandthinking-marrowsbrownastheirownmeerschaums,ofwhomyoumeettoomany,——willaskallyourwisdomtodealwiththeirpoisonednervesandtheirenfeebledwills。
Nearlyseventeenhundredchildrenunderfiveyearsofagediedlastyearinthiscity。Apoorhumanarticle,nodoubt,inmanycases,still,worthanattempttosavethem,especiallywhenweremembertheeffectofDr。Clarke’ssuggestionattheDublinHospital,bywhichsometwenty-fiveorthirtythousandchildren’sliveshaveprobablybeensavedinasinglecity。