“FrereJacques,“whotaughtthelithotomistsofParis,oweshisecclesiasticaltitletocourtesy,ashedidnotbelongtoareligiousorder。
Medicalscience,andespeciallythestudyofmentaldisease,isdestined,Ibelieve,toreacttomuchgreateradvantageonthetheologyofthefuturethantheologyhasactedonmedicineinthepast。Theliberalspiritverygenerallyprevailinginbothprofessions,andthegoodunderstandingbetweentheirmostenlightenedmembers,promisewellforthefutureofbothinacommunitywhichholdseverypointofhumanbelief,everyinstitutioninhumanhands,andeverywordwritteninahumandialect,opentofreediscussiontoday,to-morrow,andtotheendoftime。Whethertheworldatlargewilleverbecuredoftrustingtospecificsasasubstituteforobservingthelawsofhealth,andtomechanicalorintellectualformulaasasubstituteforcharacter,mayadmitofquestion。Quackeryandidolatryareallbutimmortal。
Wecanfindmostoftheoldbeliefsaliveamongstusto-day,onlyhavingchangedtheirdressesandthesocialspheresinwhichtheythrive。WethinkthequarrelsofGalenistsandchemistsbelongtothepast,forgettingthatThomsonismhasitsnumerousapostlesinourcommunity;thatitiscommontoseeremediesvauntedaspurelyvegetable,andthattheprejudiceagainst“mineralpoisons,“
especiallymercury,isasstronginmanyquartersnowasitwasatthebeginningoftheseventeenthcentury。Namesareonlyair,andblowawaywithachangeofwind;butbeliefsarerootedinhumanwantsandweakness,anddiehard。TheoaksofDodonaareprostrate,andtheshrineofDelphiisdesolate;butthePythonessandtheSibylmaybeconsultedinLowellStreetforaverymoderatecompensation。
NostradamusandLillyseemimpossibleinourtime;butwehaveseentheadvertisementsofanastrologerinourBostonpapersyearafteryear,whichseemstoimplythathefoundbelieversandpatrons。YousmiledwhenIrelatedSirKenelmDigby’sprescriptionwiththeliveeelinit;butifeachofyouweretoemptyhisorherpockets,wouldtherenotrollout,frommorethanoneofthem,ahorse-chestnut,carriedaboutasacureforrheumatism?ThebrazenheadofRogerBaconismute;butisnot“Planchette“utteringherresponsesinahundredhousesofthiscity?WethinkofpalmistryorchiromancyasbelongingtothedaysofAlbertusMagnus,or,ifexistinginourtime,asgivenovertothegypsies;butaverydistinguishedpersonhasrecentlyshownmethelineoflife,andthelineoffortune,onthepalmofhishand,withaseemingconfidenceinthesanguinepredictionsofhiscareerwhichhadbeendrawnfromthem。Whatshallwesayoftheplausibleandwell-dressedcharlatansofourowntime,whotradeinfalsepretences,likeNicholasKnappofold,butwithoutanyfearofbeingfinedorwhipped;orofthemanyfolliesandinanities,imposingonthecredulouspartofthecommunity,eachofthemgapingwitheager,openmouthforagratuitousadvertisementbythementionofitsfoolishnameinanyrespectableconnection?
Iturnfromthislesspleasingaspectofthecommonintelligencewhichrenderssuchfolliespossible,toclosethehonorablerecordofthemedicalprofessioninthis,ourancientCommonwealth。
Wehaveseenitinthefirstcenturydividedamongclergymen,magistrates,andregularpractitioners;yet,onthewhole,forthetime,andunderthecircumstances,respectable,exceptwhereitinvokedsupernaturalagenciestoaccountfornaturalphenomena。
Inthesecondcenturyitsimplifieditspractice,educatedmanyintelligentpractitioners,andbegantheworkoforganizingforconcertedaction,andformedicalteaching。
Inthis,ourowncentury,ithasbuilthospitals,perfectedandmultiplieditsassociationsandeducationalinstitutions,enlargedandcreatedmuseums,andchallengedaplaceintheworldofsciencebyitsliterature。
Inreviewingthewholecourseofitshistorywereadalonglistofhonorednames,andapreciousrecordwritteninprivatememories,inpubliccharities,inpermanentcontributionstomedicalscience,ingeneroussacrificesforthecountry。WecanpointtoourcapitalastheportofentryfortheNewWorldofthegreatmedicaldiscoveriesoftwosuccessivecenturies,andwecanclaimforitthetriumphoverthemostdreadedfoethatassailsthehumanbody,——atriumphwhichtheannalsoftheracecanhardlymatchinthreethousandyearsofmedicalhistory。
THEYOUNGPRACTITIONER
[AValedictoryAddressdeliveredtotheGraduatingClassoftheBellevueHospitalCollege,March2,1871。]
Theoccasionwhichcallsustogetherremindsusnotalittleofthatotherceremonywhichunitesamanandwomanforlife。Thebannshavealreadybeenpronouncedwhichhaveweddedouryoungfriendstotheprofessionoftheirchoice。Itremainsonlytoaddresstothemsomefriendlywordsofcheeringcounsel,andtobestowuponthemthepartingbenediction。
Thisisnotthetimeforrhetoricaldisplayorambitiouseloquence。
Wemustforgetourselves,andthinkonlyofthem。Tousitisanoccasion;tothemitisanepoch。Thespectatorsattheweddinglookcuriouslyatthebrideandbridegroom;atthebridalveil,theorange-flowergarland,thegivingandreceivingofthering;theylistenforthetremulous“Iwill,“andwonderwhatarethemysterioussyllablestheclergymanwhispersintheearofthemarriedmaiden。
Buttothenewly-weddedpairwhatmeaninginthosewords,“forbetter,forworse,““insicknessandinhealth,““tilldeathusdopart!“Tothefather,tothemother,whoknowtoowellhowoftenthedeadlynightshadeisinterwovenwiththewreathoforange-blossoms,howemptythepageant,howmomentousthereality!
YouwillnotwonderthatIaddressmyselfchieflytothosewhoarejustleavingacademiclifeforthesternerstruggleandthelargertasksofmaturedandinstructedmanhood。Thehourbelongstothem;
ifothersfindpatiencetolisten,theywillkindlyrememberthat,afterall,theyarebutasthespectatorsatthewedding,andthatthepriestisthinkinglessofthemthanoftheirfriendswhoarekneelingatthealtar。
Ispeakmoredirectlytoyou,then,gentlemenofthegraduatingclass。Thedaysofyoureducation,aspupilsoftrainedinstructors,areover。Yourfirstharvestisallgarnered。Henceforthyouaretobesowersaswellasreapers,andyourfieldistheworld。Howdoesyourknowledgestandto-day?Whathaveyougainedasapermanentpossession?Whatmustyouexpecttoforget?Whatremainsforyouyettolearn?Thesearequestionswhichitmayinterestyoutoconsider。
Thereisanotherquestionwhichmustforceitselfonthethoughtsofmanyamongyou:“HowamItoobtainpatientsandtokeeptheirconfidence?“Youhavechosenalaboriouscalling,andmademanysacrificestofityourselvesforitssuccessfulpursuit。Youwishtobeemployedthatyoumaybeuseful,andthatyoumayreceivetherewardofyourindustry。Iwouldtakeadvantageofthesemostreceptivemomentstogiveyousomehintswhichmayhelpyoutorealizeyourhopesandexpectations。SuchistheoutlineofthefamiliartalkIshallofferyou。
Youracquaintancewithsomeoftheaccessorybranchesisprobablygreaternowthanitwillbeinayearfromnow,——muchgreaterthanitwillbytenyearsfromnow。Theprogressofknowledge,itmaybefeared,orhoped,willhaveoutrunthetext-booksinwhichyoustudiedthesebranches。Chemistry,forinstance,isveryapttospoilonone’shands。“Nousavonschangetoutcela“mightserveasthestandingmottoofmanyofourmanuals。Scienceisagreattraveller,andwearshershoesoutprettyfast,asmightbeexpected。
Youarenowfreshfromthelecture-roomandthelaboratory。Youcanpassanexaminationinanatomy,physiology,chemistry,materiamedica,whichthemeninlargepracticeallaroundyouwouldfindamorepotentsudorificthananyinthePharmacopceia。Thesemastersoftheartofhealingwereonceasreadywiththeiranswersasyouarenow,buttheyhavegotridofagreatdealofthelessimmediatelypracticalpartoftheiracquisitions,andyoumustundergothesamedepletingprocess。Hardworkwilltrainitoff,assharpexercisetrainsoffthefatofaprize-fighter。
Yet,pauseamomentbeforeyouinferthatyourteachersmusthavebeeninfaultwhentheyfurnishedyouwithmentalstoresnotdirectlyconvertibletopracticalpurposes,andlikelyinafewyearstolosetheirplaceinyourmemory。Allsystematicknowledgeinvolvesmuchthatisnotpractical,yetitistheonlykindofknowledgewhichsatisfiesthemind,andsystematicstudyproves,inthelong-run,theeasiestwayofacquiringandretainingfactswhicharepractical。
Therearemanythingswhichwecanaffordtoforget,whichyetitwaswelltolearn。Yourmentalconditionisnotthesameasifyouhadneverknownwhatyounowtryinvaintorecall。Thereisaperpetualmetempsychosisofthought,andtheknowledgeofto-dayfindsasoilintheforgottenfactsofyesterday。Youcannotseeanythinginthenewseasonoftheguanoyouplacedlastyearabouttherootsofyourclimbingplants,butitisblushingandbreathingfragranceinyourtrellisedroses;ithasscaledyourporchinthebee-hauntedhoney-
suckle;ithasfounditswaywheretheivyisgreen;itisgonewherethewoodbineexpandsitsluxuriantfoliage。
Yourdiplomaseemsverybroadto-daywithyourlistofaccomplishments,butitbeginstoshrinkfromthishourlikethePeaudeChagrinofBalzac’sstory。Donotworryaboutit,forallthewhiletherewillbemakingoutforyouanamplerandfairerparchment,signedbyoldFatherTimehimselfasPresidentofthatgreatUniversityinwhichexperienceistheoneperpetualandall-
sufficientprofessor。
Yourpresentplethoraofacquirementswillsooncureitself。
KnowledgethatisnotwanteddiesoutliketheeyesofthefishesoftheMammothCave。Whenyoucometohandlelifeanddeathasyourdailybusiness,yourmemorywillofitselfbidgood-bytosuchinmatesasthewell-knownforaminaofthesphenoidboneandthefamiliaroxidesofmethyl-ethylamyl-phenyl-ammonium。Bethankfulthatyouhaveonceknownthem,andrememberthateventhelearnedignoranceofanomenclatureissomethingtohavemastered,andmayfurnishpegstohangfactsuponwhichwouldotherwisehavestrewedthefloorofmemoryinloosedisorder。
Butyoureducationhas,afterall,beenverylargelypractical。Youhavestudiedmedicineandsurgery,notchieflyinbooks,butatthebedsideandintheoperatingamphitheatre。Itisthespecialadvantageoflargecitiesthattheyaffordtheopportunityofseeingagreatdealofdiseaseinashortspaceoftime,andofseeingmanycasesofthesamekindofdiseasebroughttogether。Letusnotbeunjusttotheclaimsoftheschoolsremotefromthelargercentresofpopulation。WhoamongushastaughtbetterthanNathanSmith,betterthanElishaBartlett?whoteachesbetterthansomeofourlivingcontemporarieswhodividetheirtimebetweencityandcountryschools?Iamafraidwedonotalwaysdojusticetoourcountrybrethren,whosemeritsarelessconspicuouslyexhibitedthanthoseofthegreatcityphysiciansandsurgeons,suchespeciallyashavechargeoflargehospitals。Therearemodestpractitionerslivinginremoteruraldistrictswhoaregiftedbynaturewithsuchsagacityandwisdom,trainedsowellinwhatismostessentialtothepracticeoftheirart,taughtsothoroughlybyvariedexperience,forcedtosuchmanlyself-reliancebytheircomparativeisolation,that,fromconversewiththemalone,fromridingwiththemontheirlongroundsastheypassfromvillagetovillage,fromtalkingovercaseswiththem,puttinguptheirprescriptions,watchingtheirexpedients,listeningtotheircautions,markingtheeventoftheirpredictions,hearingthemtelloftheirmistakes,andnowandthengloryalittleinthedetectionofanother’sblunder,ayoungmanwouldfindhimselfbetterfittedforhisrealworkthanmanywhohavefollowedlongcoursesoflecturesandpassedashowyexamination。Buttheyoungmanisexceptionallyfortunatewhoenjoystheintimacyofsuchateacher。Anditmustbeconfessedthatthegreathospitals,infirmaries,anddispensariesoflargecities,wheremenofwell-
siftedreputationsareinconstantattendance,arethetruecentresofmedicaleducation。Nostudents,Ibelieve,aremorethoroughlyawareofthisthanthosewhohavegraduatedatthisinstitution。
Here,asinallourlargercityschools,thegreatestpainsaretakentoteachthingsaswellasnames。Youhaveenteredintotheinheritanceofavastamountoftransmittedskillandwisdom,whichyouhavetaken,warm,asitwere,withthelifeofyourwell-schooledinstructors。Youhavenotlearnedallthatarthastoteachyou,butyouaresaferpractitionersto-daythanweremanyofthosewhosenameswehardlymentionwithoutagenuflection。Ihadratherbecaredforinafeverbythebest-taughtamongyouthanbytherenownedFerneliusortheillustriousBoerhaave,couldtheycomebacktousfromthatbetterworldwheretherearenophysiciansneeded,and,iftheoldadagecanbetrusted,notmanywithincall。IhadratherhaveoneofyouexercisehissurgicalskilluponmethanfindmyselfinthehandsofaresuscitatedFabriciusHildanus,orevenofawiseAmbroisePare,revisitingearthinthelightofthenineteenthcentury。
Youwillnotaccusemeofunderratingyouraccomplishments。Youknowwhattodoforachildinafit,foranaldermaninanapoplexy,foragirlthathasfainted,forawomaninhysterics,foralegthatisbroken,foranarmthatisoutofjoint,forfeversofeverycolor,forthesailor’srheumatism,andthetailor’scachexy。Infactyoudoreallyknowsomuchatthisveryhour,thatnothingbutthesearchingtestoftimecanfullyteachyouthelimitationsofyourknowledge。
Ofsomeoftheseyouwillpermitmetoremindyou。Youwillneverhaveoutgrownthepossibilityofnewacquisitions,forNatureisendlessinhervariety。Buteventheknowledgewhichyoumaybesaidtopossesswillbeadifferentthingafterlonghabithasmadeitapartofyourexistence。Thetactuseruditusextendstothemindaswellastothefinger-ends。Experiencemeanstheknowledgegainedbyhabitualtrial,andanexpertisonewhohasbeeninthehabitoftrying。ThisisthekindofknowledgethatmadeUlysseswiseinthewaysofmen。Manycitieshadheseen,andknownthemindsofthosewhodweltinthem。ThisknowledgeitwasthatChaucer’sShipmanbroughthomewithhimfromtheseaa“Inmanyatempesthadhisberdbeshake。“
Thisistheknowledgeweplacemostconfidencein,inthepracticalaffairsoflife。
Ourtraininghastwostages。Thefirststagedealswithourintelligence,whichtakestheideaofwhatistobedonewiththemostcharmingeaseandreadiness。Letitbeagameofbilliards,forinstance,whichthemarkerisgoingtoteachus。Wehavenothingtodobuttomakethisballglancefromthatballandhitthatotherball,andtoknockthatballwiththisballintoacertaincaecalsacculusordiverticulumwhichourprofessionalfriendcallsapocket。Nothingcanbeclearer;itisaseasyas“playinguponthispipe,“forwhichHamletgivesGuildensternsuchluciddirections。
ButthisintelligentMe,whostepsforwardastheseniorpartnerinourdualpersonality,turnsouttobeaterriblebungler。Hemissesthoseglancinghitswhichthehard-featuredyoungprofessionalpersoncalls“carroms,“andinsistsonpocketinghisownballinsteadoftheotherone。