Iwouldextendthehospitalityoftheseshelvestoaclassofworkswhichweareinthehabitofconsideringasbeingoutsideofthepaleofmedicalscience,properlysocalled,andsometimesofcouplingwithadisrespectfulname。Suchhasalwaysbeenmyownpractice。I
havewelcomedCulpeperandSalmontomybookcaseaswillinglyasDioscoridesorQuincy,orParisorWoodandBache。IhavefoundaplaceforSt。JohnLong,andreadthestoryofhistrialformanslaughterwithasmuchinterestasthelaurel-watercaseinwhichJohnHunterfiguredasawitness。IwouldgiveSamuelHahnemannaplacebythesideofSamuelThomson。AmInotafraidthatsomestudentofimaginativeturnandnotprovidedwiththeneedfulcerebralstrainerswithoutwhichalltherefuseofgimcrackintelligencesgetsintothementaldrainsandchokesthemup,——amI
notafraidthatsomesuchstudentwillgetholdofthe“Organon“orthe“MaladiesChroniques“andbewonoverbytheirdelusions,andsobelosttothosethatlovehimasamanofcommonsenseandabrotherintheirhighcalling?Notintheleast。IfheshowedanysymptomsofinfectionIwouldforoncehaverecoursetotheprincipleofsimiliasimilibus。TocurehimofHahnemannIwouldprescribemyfavoritehomoeopathicantidote,Okie’sBonninghausen。Ifthatfailed,IwouldorderGrauvoglasaheroicremedy,andifhesurvivedthatuncured,Iwouldgivehimmyblessing,ifIthoughthimhonest,andbidhimdepartinpeace。Formeheisnolongeranindividual。
HebelongstoaclassofmindswhichweareboundtobepatientwithiftheirMakerseesfittoindulgethemwithexistence。Wemustaccepttheconjuringultra-ritualist,thedreamysecondadventist,theerraticspiritualist,thefantastichomoeopathist,asnotunworthyofphilosophicstudy;notmoreunworthyofitthanthesquarersofthecircleandtheinventorsofperpetualmotion,andtheotherwhimsicalvisionariestowhomDeMorganhasdevotedhismostinstructiveandentertaining“BudgetofParadoxes。“Ihope,therefore,thatourlibrarywilladmittheworksoftheso-calledEclectics,oftheThomsonians,ifanyareinexistence,oftheClairvoyants,iftheyhavealiterature,andespeciallyoftheHomoeopathists。Thiscountryseemstobetheplaceforsuchacollection,whichwillbyandbybecuriousandofmorevaluethanatpresent,forHomoeopathyseemstobefollowingthepathologicallawoferysipelas,fadingoutwhereitoriginatedasitspreadstonewregions。AtleastIjudgesobythefollowingtranslatedextractfromacriticismofanAmericanworkinthe“HomoeopatischeRundschau“ofLeipzigforOctober,1878,whichIfindinthe“HomoeopathicBulletin“forthemonthofNovemberjustpassed:
“WhilewefeelproudofthespreadandriseofHomoeopathyacrosstheocean,andwhiletheHomoeopathicworksreachingusfromthere,andpublishedinastylesuchasisunknowninGermany,beareloquenttestimonytotheeminentactivityofourtransatlanticcolleagues,weareovercomebysorrowfulregretsatthepositionHomoeopathyoccupiesinGermany。Suchawork[astheAmericanonereferredto]
withuswouldbeimpossible;itwouldlackthenecessarysupport。“
ByallmeansletourlibrarysecureagoodrepresentationoftheliteratureofHomoeopathybeforeitleavesusits“sorrowfulregrets“
andmigrateswithitssugarofmilkpellets,whichhavetakentheplaceoftheoldpilulaemicaepanis,toAlaska,to“NovaZembla,ortheLordknowswhere。“
WhatshallIsayinthispresenceofthedutiesofaLibrarian?
Wherehavetheyeverbeenbetterperformedthaninourownpubliccitylibrary,wherethelateMr。JewettandthelivingMr。Winsorhaveshownuswhatalibrarianoughttobe,——theorganizinghead,thevigilantguardian,theseeker’sindex,thescholar’scounsellor?Hisworkisnotmerelythatofadministration,manifoldandlaboriousasitsdutiesare。Hemusthaveaquickintelligenceandaretentivememory。Heisapubliccarrierofknowledgeinitsgerms。Hisofficeislikethatwhichnaturalistsattributetothebumble-bee,——
helaysuplittlehoneyforhimself,butheconveysthefertilizingpollenfromflowertoflower。
Ourundertaking,justcompleted,——andjustbegun——hascomeattherighttime,notadaytoosoon。Ourpractitionersneedalibrarylikethis,forwithalltheirskillanddevotionthereistoolittlegenuineerudition,suchasaliberalprofessionoughttobeabletoclaimformanyofitsmembers。InreadingtherecentobituarynoticesofthelateDr。GeddingsofSouthCarolina,IrecalledwhatourlamentedfriendDr。Coaleusedtotellmeofhislearningandaccomplishments,andIcouldnothelpreflectinghowfewsuchmedicalscholarswehadtoshowinBostonorNewEngland。Wemustclearupthisunilluminatedatmosphere,andhere,——hereisthetrueelectriclightwhichwillirradiateitsdarkness。
Thepublicwillcatchtheraysreflectedfromthesamesourceoflight,anditneedsinstructiononthegreatsubjectsofhealthanddisease,——needsitsadly。Itispreyeduponbyeverykindofimpositionalmostwithouthindrance。Itsignoranceandprejudicesreactupontheprofessiontothegreatinjuryofboth。Thejealousfeeling,forinstance,withregardtosuchprovisionsforthestudyofanatomyasaresanctionedbythelawsinthisStateandcarriedoutwithstrictregardtothoselaws,threatensthewelfare,ifnottheexistenceofinstitutionsformedicalinstructionwhereveritisnotheldincheckbyenlightenedintelligence。Andontheotherhandtheprofessionhasjustbeenstartledbyaverdictagainstaphysician,ruinousinitsamount,——enoughtodrivemanyahard-
workingyoungpractitioneroutofhouseandhome,——averdictwhichleadstothefearthatsuitsformalpracticemaytaketheplaceofthepanelgameandchild-stealingasameansofextortingmoney。IftheprofessioninthisState,whichclaimsahighstandardofcivilization,istobecrushedandgroundbeneaththeuppermillstoneofthedearthofeducationaladvantagesandthelowermillstoneofruinouspenaltiesforwhattheignorantignorantlyshalldecidetobeignorance,allIcansayisGodsavetheCommonhealthofMassachusetts!
Oncemore,wecannotfailtoseethatjustasastrologyhasgivenplacetoastronomy,sotheology,thescienceofHimwhombysearchingnomancanfindout,isfastbeingreplacedbywhatwemaynotimproperlycalltheonomy,orthescienceofthelawsaccordingtowhichtheCreatoracts。Andsincetheselawsfindtheirfullestmanifestationsforus,atleast,inrationalhumannatures,thestudyofanthropologyislargelyreplacingthatofscholasticdivinity。WemustcontemplateourMakerindirectlyinhumanattributesaswetalkofHiminhumanpartsofspeech。Andthisgivesasacrednesstothestudyofmaninhisphysical,mental,moral,social,andreligiousnaturewhichelevatesthefaithfulstudentsofanthropologytothedignityofapriesthood,andshedsaholylightontherecordedresultsoftheirlabors,broughttogetherastheyareinsuchacollectionasthiswhichisnowspreadoutbeforeus。
Thus,then,ourlibraryisatempleastrulyasthedome-crownedcathedralhallowedbythebreathofprayerandpraise,wherethedeadreposeandthelivingworship。Mayit,withallitstreasures,beconsecratedlikethattothegloryofGod,throughthecontributionsitshallmaketotheadvancementofsoundknowledge,tothereliefofhumansuffering,tothepromotionofharmoniousrelationsbetweenthemembersofthetwonobleprofessionswhichdealwiththediseasesofthesoulandwiththoseofthebody,andtothecommoncauseinwhichallgoodmenareworking,thefurtheranceofthewell-beingoftheirfellow-creatures!
NOTE——Asanillustrationofthestatementinthelastparagraphbutone,Itakethefollowingnoticefromthe“BostonDailyAdvertiser,“
ofDecember4th,thedayafterthedeliveryoftheaddress:
“PrinceLucienBonaparteisnowlivinginLondon,andisdevotinghimselftotheworkofcollectingthecreedsofallreligionsandsects,withaviewtotheirclassification,——hisobjectbeingsimplyscientificoranthropological。“
Sincedeliveringtheaddress,also,Ifindaleadingarticleinthe“CincinnatiLancetandClinic“ofNovember30th,headed“TheDecadenceofHomoeopathy,“abundantlyillustratedbyextractsfromthe“HomoeopathicTimes,“theleadingAmericanorganofthatsect。
IntheNewYork“MedicalRecord“ofthesamedate,whichIhadnotseenbeforethedeliveryofmyaddress,isanaccountoftheactionoftheHomoeopathicMedicalSocietyofNorthernNewYork,inwhichHahnemann’stheoryof“dynamization“ischaracterizedinaformalresolveas“unworthytheconfidenceoftheHomoeopathicprofession。“
ItwillbeadisappointmenttotheGermanHomoeopathiststoreadinthe“HomoeopathicTimes“suchastatementasthefollowing:
“WhatevertheinfluenceshavebeenwhichhavecheckedtheoutwarddevelopmentofHomoeopathy,itisplainlyevidentthattheHomoeopathicschool,asregardsthenumberofitsopenlyavowedrepresentatives,hasattaineditsmajority,andhasbeguntodeclinebothinthiscountryandinEngland。“
AllwhichisanadditionalreasonformakingacollectionoftheincrediblycuriousliteratureofHomoeopathybeforethatpseudologicalinanityhasfadedoutlikesomanyotherdelusions。
SOMEOFMYEARLYTEACHERS
[AFarewellAddresstotheMedicalSchoolofHarvardUniversity,November28,1882。]
IhadintendedthattherecitationofFridaylastshouldbefollowedbyafewpartingwordstomyclassandanyfriendswhomighthappentobeinthelecture-room。ButIlearnedontheprecedingeveningthattherewasanexpectation,adesire,thatmyfarewellshouldtakeasomewhatdifferentform;andnottodisappointthewishesofthosewhomIwasanxioustogratify,Imadeupmymindtoappearbeforeyouwithsuchhastypreparationasthescantytimeadmitted。
Therearethreeoccasionsuponwhichahumanbeinghasarighttoconsiderhimselfasacentreofinteresttothoseabouthim:whenheischristened,whenheismarried,andwhenheisburied。Everyoneisthechiefpersonage,thehero,ofhisownbaptism,hisownwedding,andhisownfuneral。
Thereareotheroccasions,lessmomentous,inwhichonemaymakemoreofhimselfthanunderordinarycircumstanceshewouldthinkitpropertodo;whenhemaytalkabouthimself,andtellhisownexperiences,infact,indulgeinamoreorlessegotisticmonologuewithoutfearorreproach。
IthinkImayclaimthatthisisoneofthoseoccasions。Ihavedeliveredmylastanatomicallectureandheardmyclassreciteforthelasttime。Theywishtohearfrommeagaininalessscholasticmoodthanthatinwhichtheyhaveknownme。Willyounotindulgemeintellingyousomethingofmyownstory?
Thisisthethirty-sixthCourseofLecturesinwhichIhavetakenmyplaceandperformedmydutiesasProfessorofAnatomy。FormorethanhalfofmytermofofficeIgaveinstructioninPhysiology,afterthefashionofmypredecessorsandinthemannerthengenerallyprevalentinourschools,wherethephysiologicallaboratorywasnotanecessarypartoftheapparatusofinstruction。ItwaswithmyheartyapprovalthattheteachingofPhysiologywasconstitutedaseparatedepartmentandmadeanindependentProfessorship。Beforemytime,Dr。WarrenhadtaughtAnatomy,Physiology,andSurgeryinthesamecourseofLectures,lastingonlythreeorfourmonths。Astheboundariesofscienceareenlarged,newdivisionsandsubdivisionsofitsterritoriesbecomenecessary。IntheplaceofsixProfessorsin1847,whenIfirstbecameamemberoftheFaculty,IcounttwelveupontheCataloguebeforeme,andIfindthewholenumberengagedintheworkofinstructionintheMedicalSchoolamountstonolessthanfifty。
SinceIbeganteachinginthisschool,theaspectofmanybranchesofsciencehasundergoneaveryremarkabletransformation。ChemistryandPhysiologyarenolongerwhattheywere,astaughtbytheinstructorsofthattime。Wearelookingforwardtothesynthesisofneworganiccompounds;ourartificialmadderisalreadyinthemarket,andtheindigo-raisersarenowfearingthattheircropwillbesupplantedbythemanufacturedarticle。Inthelivingbodywetalkoffuelsuppliedandworkdone,inmovement,inheat,justasifweweredealingwithamachineofourowncontrivance。
Aphysiologicallaboratoryofto-dayisequippedwithinstrumentsofresearchofsuchingeniouscontrivance,suchelaborateconstruction,thatonemightsupposehimselfinaworkshopwheresomeexquisitefabricwastobewrought,suchasQueenslovetowear,andKingsdonotalwayslovetopayfor。Theyare,indeed,weavingacharmedweb,forthesearetheloomsfromwhichcomestheknowledgethatclothesthenakednessoftheintellect。Herearethemillsthatgrindfoodforitshunger,and“isnotthelifemorethanmeat,andthebodythanraiment?“
Butwhilemanyofthescienceshavesochangedthattheteachersofthepastwouldhardlyknowthem,ithasnotbeensowiththebranchI
teach,or,rather,withthatdivisionofitwhichischieflytaughtinthisamphitheatre。Generalanatomy,orhistology,ontheotherhand,isalmostallnew;ithasgrownup,mainly,sinceIbeganmymedicalstudies。IneversawacompoundmicroscopeduringmyyearsofstudyinParis。Individualshadbeguntousetheinstrument,butIneverhearditalludedtobyeitherProfessorsorstudents。IndescriptiveanatomyIhavefoundlittletounlearn,andnotagreatdealthatwasbothnewandimportanttolearn。Triflingadditionsaremadefromyeartoyear,nottobedespisedandnottobeovervalued。Someoftheolderanatomicalworksarestilladmirable,someoftheneweronesverymuchthecontrary。Ihavehadrecentanatomicalplatesbroughtmeforinspection,andIhaveactuallybutton-holedthebook-agent,abeingcommonlyashardtogetridofasthetar-babyinthenegrolegend,thatImightputhimtoshamewiththeimperialillustrationsofthebonesandmusclesinthegreatfolioofAlbinus,publishedin1747,andtheunapproachedfiguresofthelymphaticsystemofMascagni,nowwithinaveryfewyearsofacenturyold,andstillcopied,or,rather,pretendedtobecopied,inthemostrecentworksonanatomy。