Theintellectualpoweroftwoormoreperiods,asexhibitedintheirliteratures,mayshownomarkeddifference,whilethespiritualvitalityofthesesameperiodsmayverydistinctlydiffer。Andifitbeadmittedthatliteratureproperistheproductofco-operativeintellectandspiritthelatterbeingalwaysanindispensablefactor,thoughtherecanbenohighorderofliteraturethatisnotstronglyarticulated,thatisnotwellfreighted,withthought,itfollowsthattheperiodsofaliteratureshouldbedeterminedbytheebbandflowofspirituallifewhichtheyseverallyregister,ratherthanbyanyotherconsiderations。Thereareperiodswhicharecharacterizedbya”blindnessofheart”,aninactive,quiescentconditionofthespirit,bywhichtheintellectismoreorlessdivorcedfromtheessential,theeternal,anditdirectsitselftotheshowsofthings。Suchperiodsmayembodyintheirliteraturesalargeamountofthought,——thoughtwhichisconversantwiththeexternalityofthings;butthatofitselfwillnotconstituteanobleliterature,howeverperfecttheformsinwhichitmaybeembodied,andthegeneralsenseofthecivilizedworld,independentlyofanytheoriesofliterature,willnotregardsuchaliteratureasnoble。Itismadeupofwhatmustbe,intime,superseded;ithasnotasufficientlylargeelementoftheessential,theeternal,whichcanbereachedonlythroughtheassimilatinglifeofthespirit。Thespiritmaybeso”cabined,cribbed,confined”asnottocometoanyconsciousnessofitself;oritmaybesosetfreeastogoforthandrecognizeitskinship,respondtothespiritualworldoutsideofitself,and,bysoresponding,KNOWwhatmerelyintellectualphilosopherscalltheUNKNOWABLE。
ToturnnowtothelineofEnglishpoetswhomaybesaidtohavepassedthetorchofspirituallife,fromliftedhandtohand,alongthegenerations。Andfirstis”themorningstarofsong,whomadeHismusicheardbelow:”DanChaucer,thefirstwarbler,whosesweetbreathPreludedthosemelodiousburststhatfillThespacioustimesofgreatElizabethWithsoundsthatechostill。”
Chaucerexhibits,inahighdegree,thislifeofthespirit,anditisthesecretofthecharmwhichhispoetrypossessesforusafteralapseoffivehundredyears。Itvitalizes,warms,fuses,andimpartsalightsomenesstohisverse;itcreepsandkindlesbeneaththetissuesofhisthought。WhenwecompareDryden’smodernizationsofChaucerwiththeoriginals,weseethedifferencebetweentheverseofapoet,withahealthyvitalityofspirit,and,throughthathealthyvitalityofspirit,havingsecretdealingswiththings,andversewhichislargelytheproductoftherhetoricalorliteraryfaculty。Wedonotfeel,whenreadingthelatter,thatanyunconsciousmightco-operatedwiththeconsciouspowersofthewriter。ButweDOfeelthiswhenwereadChaucer’sverse。
AlloftheCanterburyTaleshaveoriginalsoranalogues,mostofwhichhavebeenreproducedbytheLondonChaucerSociety。
NotoneofthetalesisofChaucer’sowninvention。Andyettheymayallbesaidtobeoriginal,inthetruest,deepestsenseoftheword。
Theyhavebeenvitalizedfromthepoet’sownsoul。Hehasinfusedhisownpersonality,hisownspirit-life,intohisoriginals;
hehas”createdasoulundertheribsofdeath。”ItisthisinfusedvitalitywhichwillconstitutethecharmoftheCanterburyTalesforallgenerationsofEnglishspeakingandEnglishreadingpeople。Thislifeofthespirit,ofwhichIamspeaking,asdistinguishedfromtheintellect,isfelt,thoughmuchlessdistinctly,inacontemporarywork,`TheVisionofWilliamconcerningPiersthePlowman’。
Whattheauthorcalls”KINDWIT”,thatis,”naturalintelligence”,has,generally,theascendency。Wemeet,however,withpowerfulpassages,whereinthethoughtsareaglowwiththewarmthfromthewriter’sinnerspirit。HeshowsattimesthemoralindignationofaHebrewprophet。
The`ConfessioAmantis’ofJohnGower,anothercontemporarywork,exhibitscomparativelylittleofthelifeofthespirit,eitherinitsverseorinitsthought。Thethoughtrarelypassesthelimitofnaturalintelligence。Thestories,whichthepoetdrewfromthe`GestaRomanorum’andnumerousothersources,canhardlybesaidtohavebeenBORNAGAIN。Theverseissmoothandfluent,butthereaderfeelsittobetheproductofliteraryskill。
Itwantswhatcanbeimpartedonlybyanunconsciousmightbackoftheconsciouslyactiveandtrainedpowers。ItisthisunconsciousmightwhichJohnKeats,inhis`SleepandPoetry’,speaksofas”mighthalfslumberingonitsownrightarm”,andwhicheveryreader,withtherequisitesusceptibility,canalwaysdetectintheverseofatruepoet。
IntheintervalbetweenChaucerandSpenser,thislifeofthespiritisnotdistinctlymarkedinanyofitsauthors,notexceptingevenHenryHoward,EarlofSurrey,whosesadfategaveafactitiousinteresttohiswritings。ItismorenoticeableinThomasSackville,LordBuckhurst’s`InductiontotheMirrorforMagistrates’,which,inthewordsofHallam,”formsalinkwhichunitestheschoolofChaucerandLydgatetothe`FaerieQueene’。”
TheRev。JamesByrne,ofTrinityCollege,Dublin,inhislectureon`TheInfluenceofNationalCharacteronEnglishLiterature’,remarksofSpenser:”AfterthatdarkperiodwhichseparatedhimfromChaucer,afterallthedesolationoftheWarsoftheRoses,andallthedeeptrialsoftheReformation,heroseonEnglandasif,touseanimageofhisown,”`AtlastthegoldenorientallgateOfgreatestheavengantoopenfayre,AndPhoebus,freshasbrydegrometohismate,Camedauncingforth,shakinghisdeawiehayre,Andhurledhisglisteringbeamsthroughgloomyayre。’”ThatbaptismofbloodandfirethroughwhichEnglandpassedattheReformation,raisedbothProtestantandCatholictoanewnessoflife。Thatmightyworkingofheartandmindwithwhichthenationthenheavedthroughout,wentthrougheverymanandwoman,andtriedwhatmannerofspiritstheywereof。Whatapreparationwasthisforthatperiodofourliteratureinwhichman,thegreatactorofthedramaoflife,wasabouttoappearonthestage!
Itwastobeexpectedthatthedramashouldthenstartintolife,andthathumancharactershouldspeakfromthestagewithadepthoflifeneverknownbefore;butwhocouldhaveimaginedShakespeare?”
AndwhatanewmusicburstupontheworldinSpenser’sverse!
Hisnoblestanza,soadmirablyadaptedtopictorialeffect,hassincebeenusedbysomeofthegreatestpoetsoftheliterature,Thomson,Scott,Wordsworth,Byron,Keats,Shelley,andnumerousothers;
butnoneofthem,exceptinrareinstances,havedrawnthemusicoutofitwhichSpenserdrew。
ProfessorGoldwinSmithwellremarks,inhisarticleonMarkPattison’sMilton,”Thegreatgrowthsofpoetryhavecoincidedwiththegreatburstsofnationallife,andthegreatburstsofnationallifehavehithertobeengenerallyperiodsofcontroversyandstruggle。Artitself,initshighestforms,hasbeentheexpressionoffaith。Wehavenowpeoplewhoprofesstocultivateartforitsownsake;buttheyhavehardlyproducedanythingwhichtheworldacceptsasgreat,thoughtheyhavesuppliedsomesubjectsfor`Punch’。”
Spenserwho,ofallthegreatEnglishpoets,isregardedbysomecriticsasthemostremotefromreallife,andtheleastreflectinghisage,is,nevertheless,filledwiththespiritofhisage——itschivalric,romantic,patriotic,moral,andreligiousspirit。Whenhebegantowrite,thenationhadjustpassedthroughthefieryfurnaceofareligiouspersecution,andwasrejoicinginitsdeliverancefromthepapisticalruleofMary。
Thedevotiontothenewqueenwithwhichitwasinspiredwasgrateful,generous,enthusiastic,andevenromantic。ThisdevotionSpenser’sgreatpoemeverywherereflects,andithasbeenjustlypronouncedtobethebestexponentofthesubtletiesofthatCalvinismwhichwasthearistocraticformofProtestantismatthattimeinbothFranceandEngland。
TherenewedspirituallifewhichsetinsostronglywithSpenser,reacheditsspringtideinShakespeare。Itwasthesecretofthatsenseofmoralproportionwhichpervadeshisplays。
Moralproportioncannotbesecuredthroughthelawsoftheancients,orthroughanyformulatedtheoryofart。Itwas,Iamassured,throughhisdeepandsensitivespirit-lifethatShakespearefelttheuniversalspiritandconstitutionoftheworldasfully,perhaps,asthehumansoul,inthislife,iscapableoffeelingit。Throughithetookcognizanceoftheworkingsofnature,andofthelifeofman,BYDIRECTASSIMILATIONOFTHEIRHIDDENPRINCIPLES,——
principleswhichcannotbereachedthroughanobservation,bythenaturalintelligence,ofthephenomenal。Hethusbecamepossessedofaknowledge,orratherwisdom,farbeyondhisconsciousobservationandobjectiveexperience。
Shakespearemayberegardedasthefirstandthelastgreatartisticphysiologistornaturalhistorianofthepassions;
andhewasthisbyvirtueofthelifeofthespirit,whichenabledhimtoreproducesympatheticallythewholerangeofhumanpassionwithinhimself。Hewasthefirstoftheworld’sdramatiststhatexhibitedthepassionsintheirevolutions,andintheirsubtlestcomplications。Andthemoralproportionhepreservedinexhibitingthecomplexandoftenwildplayofthepassionsmusthavebeenlargelyduetotheharmonyofhissoulwiththeconstitutionofthings。WhattheRestorationdramatistsregardedorunderstoodasmoralproportion,wasnotmoralproportionatall,butaproportionfashionedaccordingtomerelyconventionalideasofjustice。Shakespeare’smoralproportionappearedtothem,intheirlowspiritualcondition,amoralchaos,whichtheysetaboutconverting,insomeofhisgreatplays,intoacosmos;
andasadmuss,ifnotaridiculousmuss,theymadeofit。
Signalexamplesofthisarethe`rifacimenti’oftheTempestbyDrydenandDavenant,theKingLearbyTate,andtheAntonyandCleopatraentitled`AllforLove,ortheWorldwellLost’byDryden。
InMilton,thoughthereisanoticeable,anevendistinctlymarked,reductionofthelifeofthespiritinthesenseinwhichIhavebeenusingthesewordsexhibitedbyShakespeare,itisstillverystrongandefficient,andcontinuesuninfluencedbythemalignatmospherearoundhimthelastfifteenyearsofhislife,whichwerelivedinthereignofCharlesII。Withinthatperiodhewrotethe`ParadiseLost’,`ParadiseRegained’,and`SamsonAgonistes’。”Milton,”saysEmerson,”wasthestairorhightable-landtoletdowntheEnglishgeniusfromthesummitsofShakespeare。””Theseheightscouldnotbemaintained。Theywerefollowedbyameannessandadescentofthemindintolowerlevels;
thelossofwings;nohighspeculation。Locke,towhomthemeaningofideaswasunknown,becamethetypeofphilosophy,andhis”understanding”themeasure,inallnations,oftheEnglishintellect。HiscountrymenforsooktheloftysidesofParnassus,onwhichtheyhadoncewalkedwithechoingsteps,anddisusedthestudiesoncesobeloved;thepowersofthoughtfellintoneglect。”
Thehighestpowersofthoughtcannotberealizedwithoutthelifeofthespirit。Itisthis,asIhavealreadysaid,whichhasbeenthegloryofthegreatestthinkerssincetheworldbegan;
nottheirintellects,buttheco-operating,unconsciouspowerIMMANENTintheirintellects。
DuringtheRestorationperiod,andlater,spirituallifewasatitsverylowestebb。Imean,spirituallifeasexhibitedinthepoeticanddramaticliteratureofthetime,whosepoisonedfountain-headwasthedissolutecourtofCharlesII。