_Washington,Jan。29,1804_
DEARSIR,——YourfavorofDecember12camedulytohand,asdidthe2’d。lettertoDoctorLinn,andthetreatiseofPhlogiston,forwhichIprayyoutoacceptmythanks。ThecopyforMr。
Livingstonhasbeendelivered,togetherwithyourlettertohim,toMr。Harvie,mysecretary,whodepartsinadayortwoforParis,&
willdeliverthemhimselftoMr。Livingston,whoseattentiontoyourmattercannotbedoubted。IhavealsotoaddmythankstoMr。
Priestley,yourson,forthecopyofyourHarmony,whichIhavegonethroughwithgreatsatisfaction。ItisthefirstIhavebeenabletomeetwith,whichisclearofthoselongrepetitionsofthesametransaction,asifitwereadifferentonebecauserelatedwithsomedifferentcircumstances。
IrejoicethatyouhaveundertakenthetaskofcomparingthemoraldoctrinesofJesuswiththoseoftheancientPhilosophers。Youaresomuchinpossessionofthewholesubject,thatyouwilldoiteasier&betterthananyotherpersonliving。Ithinkyoucannotavoidgiving,aspreliminarytothecomparison,adigestofhismoraldoctrines,extractedinhisownwordsfromtheEvangelists,andleavingouteverythingrelativetohispersonalhistoryandcharacter。Itwouldbeshortandprecious。Withaviewtodothisformyownsatisfaction,IhadsenttoPhiladelphiatogettwotestamentsGreekofthesameedition,&twoEnglish,withadesigntocutoutthemorselsofmorality,andpastethemontheleavesofabook,inthemanneryoudescribeashavingbeenpursuedinformingyourHarmony。ButIshallnowgetthethingdonebybetterhands。
IveryearlysawthatLouisianawasindeedaspeckinourhorizonwhichwastoburstinatornado;andthepublicareunapprizedhownearthiscatastrophewas。Nothingbutafrank&
friendlydevelopmentofcauses&effectsonourpart,andgoodsenseenoughinBonapartetoseethatthetrainwasunavoidable,andwouldchangethefaceoftheworld,savedusfromthatstorm。IdidnotexpecthewouldyieldtillawartookplacebetweenFranceandEngland,andmyhopewastopalliateandendure,ifMessrs。Ross,Morris,&c。didnotforceaprematurerupture,untilthatevent。I
believedtheeventnotverydistant,butacknolegeitcameonsoonerthanIhadexpected。Whether,however,thegoodsenseofBonapartemightnotseethecoursepredictedtobenecessary&unavoidable,evenbeforeawarshouldbeimminent,wasachancewhichwethoughtitourdutytotry;buttheimmediateprospectofrupturebroughtthecasetoimmediatedecision。The_denoument_hasbeenhappy;andI
confessIlooktothisduplicationofareafortheextendingagovernmentsofreeandeconomicalasours,asagreatachievementtothemassofhappinesswhichistoensue。Whetherweremaininoneconfederacy,orformintoAtlanticandMississippiconfederacies,I
believenotveryimportanttothehappinessofeitherpart。Thoseofthewesternconfederacywillbeasmuchourchildren&descendantsasthoseoftheeastern,andIfeelmyselfasmuchidentifiedwiththatcountry,infuturetime,aswiththis;anddidInowforeseeaseparationatsomefutureday,yetIshouldfeeltheduty&thedesiretopromotethewesterninterestsaszealouslyastheeastern,doingallthegoodforbothportionsofourfuturefamilywhichshouldfallwithinmypower。
HaveyouseenthenewworkofMalthusonpopulation?ItisoneoftheablestIhaveeverseen。Altho’hismainobjectistodelineatetheeffectsofredundancyofpopulation,andtotestthepoorlawsofEngland,&otherpalliationsforthatevil,severalimportantquestionsinpoliticaleconomy,alliedtohissubjectincidentally,aretreatedwithamasterlyhand。Itisasingle4’to。
volume,andIhavebeenonlyabletoreadaborrowedcopy,theonlyoneIhaveyetheardof。ProbablyourfriendsinEnglandwillthinkofyou,&giveyouanopportunityofreadingit。Acceptmyaffectionatesalutations,andassurancesofgreatesteem&respect。
MALTHUSANDTHENEWWORLD
_ToJeanBaptisteSay_
_Washington,February1,1804_
DEARSIR,——Ihavetoacknowledgethereceiptofyourobligingletter,andwithit,oftwoveryinterestingvolumesonPoliticalEconomy。ThesefoundmeengagedingivingtheleisuremomentsI
rarelyfind,totheperusalofMalthus’workonpopulation,aworkofsoundlogic,inwhichsomeoftheopinionsofAdamSmith,aswellasoftheeconomists,areablyexamined。Iwaspleased,onturningtosomechapterswhereyoutreatthesamequestions,tofindhisopinionscorroboratedbyyours。Ishallproceedtothereadingofyourworkwithgreatpleasure。Inthemeantime,thepresentconveyance,byagentlemanofmyfamilygoingtoParis,istoosafetohazardadelayinmakingmyacknowledgmentsforthismarkofattention,andforhavingaffordedtomeasatisfaction,whichtheordinarycourseofliterarycommunicationscouldnothavegivenmeforaconsiderabletime。
ThedifferencesofcircumstancebetweenthisandtheoldcountriesofEurope,furnishdifferencesoffactwhereontoreason,inquestionsofpoliticaleconomy,andwillconsequentlyproducesometimesadifferenceofresult。There,forinstance,thequantityoffoodisfixed,orincreasinginaslowandonlyarithmeticalratio,andtheproportionislimitedbythesameratio。
Supernumerarybirthsconsequentlyaddonlytoyourmortality。Heretheimmenseextentofuncultivatedandfertilelandsenableseveryonewhowilllabortomarryyoung,andtoraiseafamilyofanysize。
Ourfood,then,mayincreasegeometricallywithourlaborers,andourbirths,howevermultiplied,becomeeffective。Again,therethebestdistributionoflaborissupposedtobethatwhichplacesthemanufacturinghandsalongsidetheagricultural;sothattheonepartshallfeedboth,andtheotherpartfurnishbothwithclothesandothercomforts。Wouldthatbebesthere?Egoismandfirstappearancessayyes。Orwoulditbebetterthatallourlaborersshouldbeemployedinagriculture?Inthiscaseadoubleortrebleportionoffertilelandswouldbebroughtintoculture;adoubleortreblecreationoffoodbeproduced,anditssurplusgotonourishthenowperishingbirthsofEurope,whoinreturnwouldmanufactureandsendusinexchangeourclothesandothercomforts。Moralitylistenstothis,andsoinvariablydothelawsofnaturecreateourdutiesandinterests,thatwhentheyseemtobeatvariance,weoughttosuspectsomefallacyinourreasonings。Insolvingthisquestion,too,weshouldallowitsjustweighttothemoralandphysicalpreferenceoftheagricultural,overthemanufacturing,man。Myoccupationspermitmeonlytoaskquestions。Theydenymethetime,ifIhadtheinformation,toanswerthem。Perhaps,asworthytheattentionoftheauthoroftheTraited’EconomiePolitique,Ishallfindthemansweredinthatwork。Iftheyarenot,thereasonwillhavebeenthatyouwroteforEurope;whileIshallhaveaskedthembecauseIthinkforAmerica。Accept,Sir,myrespectfulsalutations,andassurancesofgreatconsideration。
GRIEFANDGRIEVANCES
_ToAbigailAdams_
_Washington,June13,1804_
DEARMADAM——TheaffectionatesentimentswhichyouhavehadthegoodnesstoexpressinyourletterofMay20。towardsmydeardeparteddaughter,haveawakenedinmesensibilitiesnaturaltotheoccasion,andrecalledyourkindnessestoherwhichIshalleverrememberwithgratitudeandfriendship。Icanassureyouwithtruththeyhadmadeanindelibleimpressiononhermind,andthat,tothelast,onourmeetingsafterlongseparations,whetherIhadheardlatelyofyou,andhowyoudid,wereamongtheearliestofherenquiries。IngivingyouthisassuranceIperformasacreddutyforher,andatthesametimeamthankfulfortheoccasionfurnishedmeofexpressingmyregretthatcircumstancesshouldhavearisenwhichhaveseemedtodrawalineofseparationbetweenus。Thefriendshipwithwhichyouhonouredmehaseverbeenvalued,andfullyreciprocated;andaltho’eventshavebeenpassingwhichmightbetryingtosomeminds,Ineverbelievedyourstobeofthatkind,norfeltthatmyownwas。Neithermyestimateofyourcharacter,northeesteemfoundedinthat,haveeverbeenlessenedforasinglemoment,althoughdoubtswhetheritwouldbeacceptablemayhaveforbiddenmanifestationsofit。Mr。Adams’sfriendshipandminebeganatanearlierdate。Itaccompaniedusthro’longandimportantscenes。
Thedifferentconclusionswehaddrawnfromourpoliticalreadingandreflectionswerenotpermittedtolessenmutualesteem,eachpartybeingconscioustheyweretheresultofanhonestconvictionintheother。Likedifferencesofopinionexistingamongourfellowcitizensattachedthemtotheoneortheotherofus,andproducedarivalshipintheirmindswhichdidnotexistinours。Weneverstoodinoneanother’sway:forifeitherhadbeenwithdrawnatanytime,hisfavorerswouldnothavegoneovertotheother,butwouldhavesoughtforsomeoneofhomogeneousopinions。Thisconsiderationwassufficienttokeepdownalljealousybetweenus,andtoguardourfriendshipfromanydisturbancebysentimentsofrivalship:andIcansaywithtruththatoneactofMr。Adams’slife,andoneonly,evergavemeamoment’spersonaldispleasure。Ididconsiderhislastappointmentstoofficeaspersonallyunkind。Theywerefromamongmymostardentpoliticalenemies,fromwhomnofaithfulcooperationcouldeverbeexpected,andlaidmeundertheembarrasmentofactingthro’menwhoseviewsweretodefeatmine;ortoencountertheodiumofputtingothersintheirplaces。Itseemedbutcommonjusticetoleaveasuccessorfreetoactbyinstrumentsofhisownchoice。Ifmyrespectforhimdidnotpermitmetoascribethewholeblametotheinfluenceofothers,itleftsomethingforfriendshiptoforgive,andafterbroodingoveritforsomelittletime,andnotalwaysresistingtheexpressionofit,Iforgaveitcordially,andreturnedtothesamestateofesteemandrespectforhimwhichhadsolongsubsisted。HavingcomeintolifealittlelaterthanMr。Adams,hiscareerhasprecededmine,asmineisfollowedbysomeother,anditwillprobablybeclosedatthesamedistanceafterhimwhichtimeoriginallyplacedbetweenus。Imaintainforhim,andshallcarryintoprivatelifeanuniformandhighmeasureofrespectandgoodwill,andforyourselfasincereattachment。Ihavethus,mydearMadam,openedmyselftoyouwithoutreserve,whichIhavelongwishedanopportunityofdoing;and,withoutknowinghowitwillberecieved,Ifeelrelieffrombeingunbosomed。AndIhavenowonlytoentreatyourforgivenessforthistransitionfromasubjectofdomesticafflictiontoonewhichseemsofadifferentaspect。Butthoconnectedwithpoliticalevents,ithasbeenviewedbymemoststronglyinit’sunfortunatebearingsonmyprivatefriendships。Theinjurythesehavesustainedhasbeenaheavypriceforwhathasnevergivenmeequalpleasure。Thatyoumaybothbefavoredwithhealth,tranquilityandlonglife,istheprayerofonewhotendersyoutheassurancesofhishighestconsiderationandesteem。
FREEDOMOFTHEPRESS
_ToJudgeJohnTyler_
_Washington,June28,1804_
DEARSIR,——Yourfavorofthe10thinstanthasbeendulyreceived。Amidstthedirectfalsehoods,themisrepresentationsoftruth,thecalumniesandtheinsultsresortedtobyafactiontomisleadthepublicmind,andtooverwhelmthoseentrustedwithitsinterests,oursupportistobefoundintheapprovingvoiceofourconscienceandcountry,inthetestimonyofourfellowcitizens,thattheirconfidenceisnotshakenbytheseartifices。Whentotheplauditsofthehonestmultitude,thesoberapprobationofthesageinhisclosetisadded,itbecomesagratificationofanhigherorder。Itisthesanctionofwisdomsuperaddedtothevoiceofaffection。Theterms,therefore,inwhichyouaresogoodastoexpressyoursatisfactionwiththecourseofthepresentadministrationcannotbutgivemegreatpleasure。Imayerrinmymeasures,butnevershalldeflectfromtheintentiontofortifythepubliclibertybyeverypossiblemeans,andtoputitoutofthepowerofthefewtoriotonthelaborsofthemany。Noexperimentcanbemoreinterestingthanthatwearenowtrying,andwhichwetrustwillendinestablishingthefact,thatmanmaybegovernedbyreasonandtruth。Ourfirstobjectshouldthereforebe,toleaveopentohimalltheavenuestotruth。Themosteffectualhithertofound,isthefreedomofthepress。Itistherefore,thefirstshutupbythosewhofeartheinvestigationoftheiractions。Thefirmnesswithwhichthepeoplehavewithstoodthelateabusesofthepress,thediscernmenttheyhavemanifestedbetweentruthandfalsehood,showthattheymaysafelybetrustedtoheareverythingtrueandfalse,andtoformacorrectjudgmentbetweenthem。Aslittleisitnecessarytoimposeontheirsenses,ordazzletheirmindsbypomp,splendor,orforms。Insteadofthisartificial,howmuchsureristhatrealrespect,whichresultsfromtheuseoftheirreason,andthehabitofbringingeverythingtothetestofcommonsense。
Iholdit,therefore,certain,thattoopenthedoorsoftruth,andtofortifythehabitoftestingeverythingbyreason,arethemosteffectualmanacleswecanrivetonthehandsofoursuccessorstopreventtheirmanaclingthepeoplewiththeirownconsent。Thepanicintowhichtheywereartfullythrownin1798,thefrenzywhichwasexcitedinthembytheirenemiesagainsttheirapparentreadinesstoabandonalltheprinciplesestablishedfortheirownprotection,seemedforawhiletocountenancetheopinionsofthosewhosaytheycannotbetrustedwiththeirowngovernment。ButIneverdoubtedtheirrallying;andtheydidrallymuchsoonerthanIexpected。Onthewhole,thatexperimentontheircredulityhasconfirmedmyconfidenceintheirultimategoodsenseandvirtue。
Ilamenttolearnthatalikemisfortunehasenabledyoutoestimatetheafflictionsofafatheronthelossofabelovedchild。
Howeverterriblethepossibilityofsuchanotheraccident,itisstillablessingforyouofinestimablevaluethatyouwouldnoteventhendescendchildlesstothegrave。Threesons,andhopefulonestoo,arearichtreasure。IrejoicewhenIhearofyoungmenofvirtueandtalents,worthytoreceive,andlikelytopreservethesplendidinheritanceofself-government,whichwehaveacquiredandshapedforthem。
ThecomplementofmidshipmenfortheTripolinesquadron,isfull;andIhopethefrigateshavelefttheCapesbythistime。I
have,however,thisday,signedwarrantsofmidshipmenforthetwoyounggentlemenyourecommended。ThesewillbeforwardedbytheSecretaryoftheNavy。Hetellsmethattheirfirstserviceswillbetobeperformedonboardthegunboats。
Acceptmyfriendlysalutations,andassurancesofgreatesteemandrespect。”THEOFFICEOFHANGMAN”
_ToLarkinSmith_
_Washington,Nov。26,1804_
SIR,——Yourletterofthe10thcametohandyesterdayevening。
Itwaswrittenwithfranknessandindependanceandwillbeansweredinthesameway。YoucomplainthatIdidnotansweryourlettersapplyingforoffice。Butifyouwillreflectamomentyoumayjudgewhetherthisoughttobeexpected。Tothesuccessfulapplicantforanofficethecommissionistheanswer。TotheunsuccessfulmultitudeamItogowitheveryoneintothereasonsfornotappointinghim?Besidesthatthiscorrespondencewouldliterallyengrossmywholetime,intowhatcontroversieswoulditleadme。