Here’stherecordoftheTarletonmurders,andthecaseofVamberry,thewinemerchant,andtheadventureoftheoldRussianwoman,andthesingularaffairofthealuminiumcrutch,aswellasafullaccountofRicolettioftheclub-foot,andhisabominablewife。
  Andhere——ah,now,thisreallyissomethingalittlerecherch?”
  Hedivedhisarmdowntothebottomofthechest,andbroughtupasmallwoodenboxwithaslidinglid,suchaschildren’stoysarekeptin。Fromwithinheproducedacrumpledpieceofpaper,andold-fashionedbrasskey,apegofwoodwithaballofstringattachedtoit,andthreerustyolddisksofmetal。”Well,myboy,whatdoyoumakeofthislot?”heasked,smilingatmyexpression。”Itisacuriouscollection。””Verycurious,andthestorythathangsrounditwillstrikeyouasbeingmorecuriousstill。””Theserelicshaveahistorythen?””Somuchsothattheyarehistory。””Whatdoyoumeanbythat?”
  SherlockHolmespickedthemuponebyone,andlaidthemalongtheedgeofthetable。Thenrereseatedhimselfinhischairandlookedthemoverwithagleamofsatisfactioninhiseyes。”These,”saidhe,”areallthatIhavelefttoremindmeoftheadventureoftheMusgraveRitual。”
  Ihadheardhimmentionthecasemorethanonce,thoughIhadneverbeenabletogatherthedetails。”Ishouldbesoglad,”saidI,”ifyouwouldgivemeanaccountofit。””Andleavethelitterasitis?”hecried,mischievously。”Yourtidinesswon’tbearmuchstrainafterall,Watson。ButIshouldbegladthatyoushouldaddthiscasetoyourannals,fortherearepointsinitwhichmakeitquiteuniqueinthecriminalrecordsofthisor,Ibelieve,ofanyothercountry。Acollectionofmytriflingachievementswouldcertainlybeincompletewhichcontainednoaccountofthisverysingularbusiness。”YoumayrememberhowtheaffairoftheGloriaScott,andmyconversationwiththeunhappymanwhosefateI
  toldyouof,firstturnedmyattentioninthedirectionoftheprofessionwhichhasbecomemylife’swork。Youseemenowwhenmynamehasbecomeknownfarandwide,andwhenIamgenerallyrecognizedbothbythepublicandbytheofficialforceasbeingafinalcourtofappealindoubtfulcases。Evenwhenyouknewmefirst,atthetimeoftheaffairwhichyouhavecommemoratedin’AStudyinScarlet,’Ihadalreadyestablishedaconsiderable,thoughnotaverylucrative,connection。Youcanhardlyrealize,then,howdifficultIfounditatfirst,andhowlongIhadtowaitbeforeIsucceededinmakinganyheadway。”WhenIfirstcameuptoLondonIhadroomsinMontagueStreet,justroundthecornerfromtheBritishMuseum,andthereIwaited,fillinginmytooabundantleisuretimebystudyingallthosebranchesofsciencewhichmightmakememoreefficient。Nowandagaincasescameinmyway,principallythroughtheintroductionofoldfellow-students,forduringmylastyearsattheUniversitytherewasagooddealoftalkthereaboutmyselfandmymethods。ThethirdofthesecaseswasthatoftheMusgraveRitual,anditistotheinterestwhichwasarousedbythatsingularchainofevents,andthelargeissueswhichprovedtobeatstake,thatItracemyfirststridetowardstopositionwhichInowhold。”ReginaldMusgravehadbeeninthesamecollegeasmyself,andIhadsomeslightacquaintancewithhim。
  Hewasnotgenerallypopularamongtheundergraduates,thoughitalwaysseemedtomethatwhatwassetdownaspridewasreallyanattempttocoverextremenaturaldiffidence。Inappearancehewasamanofexceedinglyaristocratictype,thin,high-nosed,andlarge-eyed,withlanguidandyetcourtlymanners。Hewasindeedascionofoneoftheveryoldestfamiliesinthekingdom,thoughhisbranchwasacadetonewhichhadseparatedfromthenorthernMusgravessometimeinthesixteenthcentury,andhadestablisheditselfinwesternSussex,wheretheManorHouseofHurlstoneisperhapstheoldestinhabitedbuildinginthecounty。Somethingofhisbirthplaceseemedtoclingtotheman,andIneverlookedathispale,keenfaceorthepoiseofhisheadwithoutassociatinghimwithgrayarchwaysandmullionedwindowsandallthevenerablewreckageofafeudalkeep。Onceortwicewedriftedintotalk,andIcanrememberthatmorethanonceheexpressedakeeninterestinmymethodsofobservationandinference。”ForfouryearsIhadseennothingofhimuntilonemorninghewalkedintomyroominMontagueStreet。Hehadchangedlittle,wasdressedlikeayoungmanoffashion——hewasalwaysabitofadandy——andpreservedthesamequiet,suavemannerwhichhadformerlydistinguishedhim。”’HowhasallgonewityouMusgrave?”Iasked,afterwehadcordiallyshakenhands。”’Youprobablyheardofmypoorfather’sdeath,’saidhe;’hewascarriedoffabouttwoyearsago。SincethenIhaveofcoursehadtheHurlstoneestatestomanage,andasIammemberformydistrictaswell,mylifehasbeenabusyone。ButIunderstand,Holmes,thatyouareturningtopracticalendsthosepowerswithwhichyouusedtoamazeus?””’Yes,’saidI,’Ihavetakentolivingbymywits。’”’Iamdelightedtohearit,foryouradviceatpresentwouldbeexceedinglyvaluabletome。WehavehadsomeverystrangedoingsatHurlstone,andthepolicehavebeenabletothrownolightuponthematter。Itisreallythemostextraordinaryandinexplicablebusiness。’”YoucanimaginewithwhateagernessIlistenedtohim,Watson,fortheverychanceforwhichIhadbeenpantingduringallthosemonthsofinactionseemedtohavecomewithinmyreach。InmyinmostheartI
  believedthatIcouldsucceedwhereothersfailed,andnowIhadtheopportunitytotestmyself。”’Pray,letmehavethedetails,’Icried。”ReginaldMusgravesatdownoppositetome,andlitthecigarettewhichIhadpushedtowardshim。”’Youmustknow,’saidhe,’thatthoughIamabachelor,IhavetokeepupaconsiderablestaffofservantsatHurlstone,foritisaramblingoldplace,andtakesagooddealoflookingafter。Ipreserve,too,andinthepheasantmonthsIusuallyhaveahouse-party,sothatitwouldnotdotobeshort-handed。Altogetherthereareeightmaids,thecook,thebutler,twofootmen,andaboy。Thegardenandthestablesofcoursehaveaseparatestaff。”’OftheseservantstheonewhohadbeenlongestinourservicewasBruntonthebutler。Hewasayoungschool-masteroutofplacewhenhewasfirsttakenupbymyfather,buthewasamanofgreatenergyandcharacter,andhesoonbecamequiteinvaluableinthehousehold。Hewasawell-grown,handsomeman,withasplendidforehead,andthoughhehasbeenwithusfortwentyyearshecannotbemorethanfortynow。Withhispersonaladvantagesandhisextraordinarygifts——forhecanspeakseverallanguagesandplaynearlyeverymusicalinstrument——itiswonderfulthatheshouldhavebeensatisfiedsolonginsuchaposition,butIsupposethathewascomfortable,andlackedenergytomakeanychange。ThebutlerofHurlstoneisalwaysathingthatisrememberedbyallwhovisitus。”’Butthisparagonhasonefault。HeisabitofaDonJuan,andyoucanimaginethatforamanlikehimitisnotaverydifficultparttoplayinaquietcountrydistrict。Whenhewasmarrieditwasallright,butsincehehasbeenawidowerwehavehadnoendoftroublewithhim。AfewmonthsagowewereinhopesthathewasabouttosettledownagainforhebecameengagedtoRachelHowells,oursecondhouse-maid;buthehasthrownheroversincethenandtakenupwithJanetTregellis,thedaughteroftheheadgame-keeper。Rachel——whoisaverygoodgirl,butofanexcitableWelshtemperament——hadasharptouchofbrain-fever,andgoesaboutthehousenow——ordiduntilyesterday——likeablack-eyedshadowofherformerself。ThatwasourfirstdramaatHurlstone;
  butasecondonecametodriveitfromourminds,anditwasprefacedbythedisgraceanddismissalofbutlerBrunton。”’Thiswashowitcameabout。Ihavesaidthatthemanwasintelligent,andthisveryintelligencehascausedhisruin,foritseemstohaveledtoaninsatiablecuriosityaboutthingswhichdidnotintheleastconcernhim。Ihadnoideaofthelengthstowhichthiswouldcarryhim,untilthemerestaccidentopenedmyeyestoit。”’Ihavesaidthatthehouseisaramblingone。Onedaylastweek——onThursdaynight,tobemoreexact——I
  foundthatIcouldnotsleep,havingfoolishlytakenacupofstrongcaf?noiraftermydinner。Afterstrugglingagainstituntiltwointhemorning,Ifeltthatitwasquitehopeless,soIroseandlitthecandlewiththeintentionofcontinuinganovelwhichIwasreading。Thebook,however,hadbeenleftinthebilliard-room,soIpulledonmydressing-gownandstartedofftogetit。”’Inordertoreachthebilliard-roomIhadtodescendaflightofstairsandthentocrosstheheadofapassagewhichledtothelibraryandthegun-room。
  Youcanimaginemysurprisewhen,asIlookeddownthiscorridor,Isawaglimmeroflightcomingfromtheopendoorofthelibrary。Ihadmyselfextinguishedthelampandclosedthedoorbeforecomingtobed。Naturallymyfirstthoughtwasofburglars。ThecorridorsatHurlstonehavetheirwallslargelydecoratedwithtrophiesofoldweapons。FromoneoftheseIpickedabattle-axe,andthen,leavingmycandlebehindme,Icreptontiptoedownthepassageandpeepedinattheopendoor。”’Brunton,thebutler,wasinthelibrary。Hewassitting,fullydressed,inaneasy-chair,withaslipofpaperwhichlookedlakeamapuponhisknee,andhisforeheadsunkforwarduponhishandindeepthought。Istooddumbwithastonishment,watchinghimfromthedarkness。Asmalltaperontheedgeofthetableshedafeeblelightwhichsufficedtoshowmethathewasfullydressed。Suddenly,asIlooked,herosefromhischair,andwalkingovertoabureauattheside,heunlockeditanddrewoutoneofthedrawers。Fromthishetookapaper,andreturningtohisseatheflatteneditoutbesidethetaperontheedgeofthetable,andbegantostudyitwithminuteattention。MyindignationatthiscalmexaminationofourfamilydocumentsovercamemesofarthatItookastepforward,andBrunton,lookingup,sawmestandinginthedoorway。Hesprangtohisfeet,hisfaceturnedlividwithfear,andhethrustintohisbreastthechart-likepaperwhichhehadbeenoriginallystudying。