BookI
1
WEhavealreadydiscussedthefirstcausesofnature,andallnaturalmotion,alsothestarsorderedinthemotionoftheheavens,andthephysicalelement-enumeratingandspecifyingthemandshowinghowtheychangeintooneanother-andbecomingandperishingingeneral。Thereremainsforconsiderationapartofthisinquirywhichallourpredecessorscalledmeteorology。Itisconcernedwitheventsthatarenatural,thoughtheirorderislessperfectthanthatofthefirstoftheelementsofbodies。Theytakeplaceintheregionnearesttothemotionofthestars。Sucharethemilkyway,andcomets,andthemovementsofmeteors。Itstudiesalsoalltheaffectionswemaycallcommontoairandwater,andthekindsandpartsoftheearthandtheaffectionsofitsparts。Thesethrowlightonthecausesofwindsandearthquakesandalltheconsequencesthemotionsofthesekindsandpartsinvolve。Ofthesethingssomepuzzleus,whileothersadmitofexplanationinsomedegree。Further,theinquiryisconcernedwiththefallingofthunderboltsandwithwhirlwindsandfire-winds,andfurther,therecurrentaffectionsproducedinthesesamebodiesbyconcretion。Whentheinquiryintothesemattersisconcludedletusconsiderwhataccountwecangive,inaccordancewiththemethodwehavefollowed,ofanimalsandplants,bothgenerallyandindetail。Whenthathasbeendonewemaysaythatthewholeofouroriginalundertakingwillhavebeencarriedout。
Afterthisintroductionletusbeginbydiscussingourimmediatesubject。
2
Wehavealreadylaiddownthatthereisonephysicalelementwhichmakesupthesystemofthebodiesthatmoveinacircle,andbesidesthisfourbodiesowingtheirexistencetothefourprinciples,themotionoftheselatterbodiesbeingoftwokinds:eitherfromthecentreortothecentre。Thesefourbodiesarefire,air,water,earth。Fireoccupiesthehighestplaceamongthemall,earththelowest,andtwoelementscorrespondtotheseintheirrelationtooneanother,airbeingnearesttofire,watertoearth。Thewholeworldsurroundingtheearth,then,theaffectionsofwhichareoursubject,ismadeupofthesebodies。Thisworldnecessarilyhasacertaincontinuitywiththeuppermotions:consequentlyallitspowerandorderisderivedfromthem。(Fortheoriginatingprincipleofallmotionisthefirstcause。Besides,thatclementiseternalanditsmotionhasnolimitinspace,butisalwayscomplete;whereasalltheseotherbodieshaveseparateregionswhichlimitoneanother。)
Sowemusttreatfireandearthandtheelementslikethemasthematerialcausesoftheeventsinthisworld(meaningbymaterialwhatissubjectandisaffected),butmustassigncausalityinthesenseoftheoriginatingprincipleofmotiontotheinfluenceoftheeternallymovingbodies。
3
Letusfirstrecallouroriginalprinciplesandthedistinctionsalreadydrawnandthenexplainthe’milkyway’andcometsandtheotherphenomenaakintothese。
Fire,air,water,earth,weassert,originatefromoneanother,andeachofthemexistspotentiallyineach,asallthingsdothatcanberesolvedintoacommonandultimatesubstrate。
Thefirstdifficultyisraisedbywhatiscalledtheair。Whatarewetotakeitsnaturetobeintheworldsurroundingtheearth?Andwhatisitspositionrelativelytotheotherphysicalelements。(Forthereisnoquestionastotherelationofthebulkoftheearthtothesizeofthebodieswhichexistaroundit,sinceastronomicaldemonstrationshavebythistimeprovedtousthatitisactuallyfarsmallerthansomeindividualstars。Asforthewater,itisnotobservedtoexistcollectivelyandseparately,norcanitdosoapartfromthatvolumeofitwhichhasitsseatabouttheearth:thesea,thatis,andrivers,whichwecansee,andanysubterraneanwaterthatmaybehiddenfromourobservation。)Thequestionisreallyaboutthatwhichliesbetweentheearthandtheneareststars。Arewetoconsiderittobeonekindofbodyormorethanone?Andifmorethanone,howmanyarethereandwhataretheboundsoftheirregions?
Wehavealreadydescribedandcharacterizedthefirstelement,andexplainedthatthewholeworldoftheuppermotionsisfullofthatbody。
Thisisanopinionwearenotaloneinholding:itappearstobeanoldassumptionandonewhichmenhaveheldinthepast,forthewordetherhaslongbeenusedtodenotethatelement。Anaxagoras,itistrue,seemstometothinkthatthewordmeansthesameasfire。
Forhethoughtthattheupperregionswerefulloffire,andthatmenreferredtothoseregionswhentheyspokeofether。Inthelatterpointhewasright,formenseemtohaveassumedthatabodythatwaseternallyinmotionwasalsodivineinnature;and,assuchabodywasdifferentfromanyoftheterrestrialelements,theydeterminedtocallit’ether’。
Fortheumopinionsappearincyclesamongmennotoncenortwice,butinfinitelyoften。
Nowtherearesomewhomaintainthatnotonlythebodiesinmotionbutthatwhichcontainsthemispurefire,andtheintervalbetweentheearthandthestarsair:butiftheyhadconsideredwhatisnowsatisfactorilyestablishedbymathematics,theymighthavegivenupthispuerileopinion。Foritisaltogetherchildishtosupposethatthemovingbodiesareallofthemofasmallsize,becausetheysotous,lookingatthemfromtheearth。
Thisamatterwhichwehavealreadydiscussedinourtreatmentoftheupperregion,butwemayreturntothepointnow。
Iftheintervalswerefulloffireandthebodiesconsistedoffireeveryoneoftheotherelementswouldlongagohavevanished。
However,theycannotsimplybesaidtobefullofaireither;forevenifthereweretwoelementstofillthespacebetweentheearthandtheheavens,theairwouldfarexceedthequantiturequiredtomaintainitsproperproportiontotheotherelements。Forthebulkoftheearth(whichincludesthewholevolumeofwater)isinfinitesimalincomparisonwiththewholeworldthatsurroundsit。
Nowwefindthattheexcessinvolumeisnotproportionatelygreatwherewaterdissolvesintoairorairintofire。Whereastheproportionbetweenanygivensmallquantityofwaterandtheairthatisgeneratedfromitoughttoholdgoodbetweenthetotalamountofairandthetotalamountofwater。Nordoesitmakeanydifferenceifanyonedeniesthattheelementsoriginatefromoneanother,butassertsthattheyareequalinpower。Foronthisviewitiscertainamountsofeachthatareequalinpower,justaswouldbethecaseiftheyactuallyoriginatedfromoneanother。
Soitisclearthatneitherairnorfirealonefillstheintermediatespace。
Itremainstoexplain,afterapreliminarydiscussionofdifficulties,therelationofthetwoelementsairandfiretothepositionofthefirstelement,andthereasonwhythestarsintheupperregionimpartheattotheearthanditsneighbourhood。Letusfirsttreatoftheair,asweproposed,andthengoontothesequestions。
Sincewaterisgeneratedfromair,andairfromwater,whyarecloudsnotformedintheupperair?Theyoughttoformtherethemore,thefurtherfromtheearthandthecolderthatregionis。Foritisneitherappreciablyneartotheheatofthestars,nortotheraysrelectedfromtheearth。Itisthesethatdissolveanyformationbytheirheatandsopreventcloudsfromformingneartheearth。Forcloudsgatheratthepointwherethereflectedraysdisperseintheinfinityofspaceandarelost。Toexplainthiswemustsupposeeitherthatitisnotallairwhichwaterisgenerated,or,ifitisproducedfromallairalike,thatwhatimmediatelysurroundstheearthisnotmereair,butasortofvapour,andthatitsvaporousnatureisthereasonwhyitcondensesbacktowateragain。Butifthewholeofthatvastregionisvapour,theamountofairandofwaterwillbedisproportionatelygreat。Forthespacesleftbytheheavenlybodiesmustbefilledbysomeelement。Thiscannotbefire,forthenalltherestwouldhavebeendriedup。Consequently,whatfillsitmustbeairandthewaterthatsurroundsthewholeearth-vapourbeingwaterdissolved。
Afterthisexpositionofthedifficultiesinvolved,letusgoontolaydownthetruth,withaviewatoncetowhatfollowsandtowhathasalreadybeensaid。Theupperregionasfarasthemoonweaffirmtoconsistofabodydistinctbothfromfireandfromair,butvaryingdegreeofpurityandinkind,especiallytowardsitslimitonthesideoftheair,andoftheworldsurroundingtheearth。Nowthecircularmotionofthefirstelementandofthebodiesitcontainsdissolves,andinflamesbyitsmotion,whateverpartofthelowerworldisnearesttoit,andsogeneratesheat。Fromanotherpointofviewwemaylookatthemotionasfollows。Thebodythatliesbelowthecircularmotionoftheheavensis,inasort,matter,andispotentiallyhot,cold,dry,moist,andpossessedofwhateverotherqualitiesarederivedfromthese。Butitactuallyacquiresorretainsoneoftheseinvirtueofmotionorrest,thecauseandprincipleofwhichhasalreadybeenexplained。Soatthecentreandrounditwegetearthandwater,theheaviestandcoldestelements,bythemselves;roundthemandcontiguouswiththem,airandwhatwecommonlycallfire。Itisnotreallyfire,forfireisanexcessofheatandasortofebullition;butinreality,ofwhatwecallair,thepartsurroundingtheearthismoistandwarm,becauseitcontainsbothvapourandadryexhalationfromtheearth。Butthenextpart,abovethat,iswarmanddry。Forvapourisnaturallymoistandcold,buttheexhalationwarmanddry;andvapourispotentiallylikewater,theexhalationpotentiallylikefire。Sowemusttakethereasonwhycloudsarenotformedintheupperregiontobethis:
thatitisfillednotwithmereairbutratherwithasortoffire。
However,itmaywellbethattheformationofcloudsinthatupperregionisalsopreventedbythecircularmotion。Fortheairroundtheearthisnecessarilyallofitinmotion,exceptthatwhichiscutoffinsidethecircumferencewhichmakestheearthacompletesphere。Inthecaseofwindsitisactuallyobservablethattheyoriginateinmarshydistrictsoftheearth;andtheydonotseemtoblowabovethelevelofthehighestmountains。Itistherevolutionoftheheavenwhichcarriestheairwithitandcausesitscircularmotion,firebeingcontinuouswiththeupperelementandairwithfire。Thusitsmotionisasecondreasonwhythatairisnotcondensedintowater。
Butwheneveraparticleofairgrowsheavy,thewarmthinitissqueezedoutintotheupperregionanditsinks,andotherparticlesinturnarecarrieduptogetherwiththefieryexhalation。Thustheoneregionisalwaysfullofairandtheotheroffire,andeachofthemisperpetuallyinastateofchange。
Somuchtoexplainwhycloudsarenotformedandwhytheairisnotcondensedintowater,andwhataccountmustbegivenofthespacebetweenthestarsandtheearth,andwhatisthebodythatfillsit。
Asfortheheatderivedfromthesun,therightplaceforaspecialandscientificaccountofitisinthetreatiseaboutsense,sinceheatisanaffectionofsense,butwemaynowexplainhowitcanbeproducedbytheheavenlybodieswhicharenotthemselveshot。
Weseethatmotionisabletodissolveandinflametheair;
indeed,movingbodiesareoftenactuallyfoundtomelt。Nowthesun’smotionaloneissufficienttoaccountfortheoriginofterrestrialwarmthandheat。Foramotionthatistohavethiseffectmustberapidandnear,andthatofthestarsisrapidbutdistant,whilethatofthemoonisnearbutslow,whereasthesun’smotioncombinesbothconditionsinasufficientdegree。Thatmostheatshouldbegeneratedwherethesunispresentiseasytounderstandifweconsidertheanalogyofterrestrialphenomena,forhere,too,itistheairthatisnearesttoathinginrapidmotionwhichisheatedmost。Thisisjustwhatweshouldexpect,asitisthenearestairthatismostdissolvedbythemotionofasolidbody。
Thisthenisonereasonwhyheatreachesourworld。Anotheristhatthefiresurroundingtheairisoftenscatteredbythemotionoftheheavensanddrivendownwardsinspiteofitself。
Shooting-starsfurthersuffixtoprovethatthecelestialsphereisnothotorfiery:fortheydonotoccurinthatupperregionbutbelow:yetthemoreandthefasterathingmoves,themoreaptitistotakefire。Besides,thesun,whichmostofallthestarsisconsideredtobehot,isreallywhiteandnotfieryincolour。
4
Havingdeterminedtheseprinciplesletusexplainthecauseoftheappearanceintheskyofburningflamesandofshooting-stars,andof’torches’,and’goats’,assomepeoplecallthem。Allthesephenomenaareoneandthesamething,andareduetothesamecause,thedifferencebetweenthembeingoneofdegree。
Theexplanationoftheseandmanyotherphenomenaisthis。Whenthesunwarmstheearththeevaporationwhichtakesplaceisnecessarilyoftwokinds,notofoneonlyassomethink。Onekindisratherofthenatureofvapour,theotherofthenatureofawindyexhalation。Thatwhichrisesfromthemoisturecontainedintheearthandonitssurfaceisvapour,whilethatrisingfromtheearthitself,whichisdry,islikesmoke。Ofthesethewindyexhalation,beingwarm,risesabovethemoistervapour,whichisheavyandsinksbelowtheother。Hencetheworldsurroundingtheearthisorderedasfollows。Firstbelowthecircularmotioncomesthewarmanddryelement,whichwecallfire,forthereisnowordfullyadequatetoeverystateofthefumidevaporation:butwemustusethisterminologysincethiselementisthemostinflammableofallbodies。Belowthiscomesair。Wemustthinkofwhatwejustcalledfireasbeingspreadroundtheterrestrialsphereontheoutsidelikeakindoffuel,sothatalittlemotionoftenmakesitburstintoflamejustassmokedoes:forflameistheebullitionofadryexhalation。Sowheneverthecircularmotionstirsthisstuffupinanyway,itcatchesfireatthepointatwhichitismostinflammable。Theresultdiffersaccordingtothedispositionandquantityofthecombustiblematerial。Ifthisisbroadandlong,weoftenseeaflameburningasinafieldofstubble:
ifitburnslengthwiseonly,weseewhatarecalled’torches’and’goats’andshooting-stars。Nowwhentheinflammablematerialislongerthanitisbroadsometimesitseemstothrowoffsparksasitburns。(Thishappensbecausemattercatchesfireatthesidesinsmallportionsbutcontinuouslywiththemainbody。)Thenitiscalleda’goat’。Whenthisdoesnothappenitisa’torch’。Butifthewholelengthoftheexhalationisscatteredinsmallpartsandinmanydirectionsandinbreadthanddepthalike,wegetwhatarecalledshooting-stars。
Thecauseoftheseshooting-starsissometimesthemotionwhichignitestheexhalation。Atothertimestheairiscondensedbycoldandsqueezesoutandejectsthehotelement;makingtheirmotionlookmorelikethatofathingthrownthanlikearunningfire。Forthequestionmightberaisedwhetherthe’shooting’ofa’star’isthesamethingaswhenyouputanexhalationbelowalampanditlightsthelowerlampfromtheflameabove。Forheretootheflamepasseswonderfullyquicklyandlookslikeathingthrown,andnotasifonethingafteranothercaughtfire。Orisa’star’whenit’shoots’asinglebodythatisthrown?Apparentlybothcasesoccur:sometimesitisliketheflamefromthelampandsometimesbodiesareprojectedbybeingsqueezedout(likefruitstonesfromone’sfingers)
andsoareseentofallintotheseaandonthedryland,bothbynightandbydaywhentheskyisclear。Theyarethrowndownwardsbecausethecondensationwhichpropelstheminclinesdownwards。
Thunderboltsfalldownwardsforthesamereason:theiroriginisnevercombustionbutejectionunderpressure,sincenaturallyallheattendsupwards。
Whenthephenomenonisformedintheupperregionitisduetothecombustionoftheexhalation。Whenittakesplaceatalowerlevelitisduetotheejectionoftheexhalationbythecondensingandcoolingofthemoisterevaporation:forthislatterasitcondensesandinclinesdownwardcontracts,andthrustsoutthehotelementandcausesittobethrowndownwards。Themotionisupwardsordownwardsorsidewaysaccordingtothewayinwhichtheevaporationlies,anditsdispositioninrespectofbreadthanddepth。Inmostcasesthedirectionissidewaysbecausetwomotionsareinvolved,acompulsorymotiondownwardsandanaturalmotionupwards,andunderthesecircumstancesanobjectalwaysmovesobliquely。Hencethemotionof’shooting-stars’isgenerallyoblique。
Sothematerialcauseofallthesephenomenaistheexhalation,theefficientcausesometimestheuppermotion,sometimesthecontractionandcondensationoftheair。Further,allthesethingshappenbelowthemoon。Thisisshownbytheirapparentspeed,whichisequaltothatofthingsthrownbyus;foritisbecausetheyareclosetous,thattheselatterseemfartoexceedinspeedthestars,thesun,andthemoon。
5
Sometimesonafinenightweseeavarietyofappearancesthatforminthesky:’chasms’forinstanceand’trenches’andblood-redcolours。These,too,havethesamecause。Forwehaveseenthattheupperaircondensesintoaninflammableconditionandthatthecombustionsometimestakesontheappearanceofaburningflame,sometimesthatofmovingtorchesandstars。Soitisnotsurprisingthatthissameairwhencondensingshouldassumeavarietyofcolours。
Foraweaklightshiningthroughadenseair,andtheairwhenitactsasamirror,willcauseallkindsofcolourstoappear,butespeciallycrimsonandpurple。Forthesecoloursgenerallyappearwhenfire-colourandwhitearecombinedbysuperposition。Thusonahotday,orthroughasmoky,medium,thestarswhentheyriseandsetlookcrimson。Thelightwillalsocreatecoloursbyreflectionwhenthemirrorissuchastoreflectcolouronlyandnotshape。
Theseappearancesdonotpersistlong,becausethecondensationoftheairistransient。
’Chasms’gettheirappearanceofdepthfromlightbreakingoutofadarkblueorblackmassofair。Whentheprocessofcondensationgoesfurtherinsuchacaseweoftenfind’torches’ejected。Whenthe’chasm’contractsitpresentstheappearanceofa’trench’。
Ingeneral,whiteincontrastwithblackcreatesavarietyofcolours;likeflame,forinstance,throughamediumofsmoke。Butbydaythesunobscuresthem,and,withtheexceptionofcrimson,thecoloursarenotseenatnightbecausetheyaredark。
Thesethenmustbetakentobethecausesof’shooting-stars’andthephenomenaofcombustionandalsooftheothertransientappearancesofthiskind。
6
Letusgoontoexplainthenatureofcometsandthe’milkyway’,afterapreliminarydiscussionoftheviewsofothers。
AnaxagorasandDemocritusdeclarethatcometsareaconjunctionoftheplanetsapproachingoneanotherandsoappearingtotouchoneanother。
SomeoftheItalianscalledPythagoreanssaythatthecometisoneoftheplanets,butthatitappearsatgreatintervalsoftimeandonlyrisesalittleabovethehorizon。ThisisthecasewithMercurytoo;becauseitonlyrisesalittleabovethehorizonitoftenfailstobeseenandconsequentlyappearsatgreatintervalsoftime。
AviewliketheirswasalsoexpressedbyHippocratesofChiosandhispupilAeschylus。Onlytheysaythatthetaildoesnotbelongtothecometiself,butisoccasionallyassumedbyitonitscourseincertainsituations,whenoursightisreflectedtothesunfromthemoistureattractedbythecomet。Itappearsatgreaterintervalsthantheotherstarsbecauseitisslowesttogetclearofthesunandhasbeenleftbehindbythesuntotheextentofthewholeofitscirclebeforeitreappearsatthesamepoint。Itgetsclearofthesunbothtowardsthenorthandtowardsthesouth。Inthespacebetweenthetropicsitdoesnotdrawwatertoitselfbecausethatregionisdriedupbythesunonitscourse。Whenitmovestowardsthesouthithasnolackofthenecessarymoisture,butbecausethesegmentofitscirclewhichisabovethehorizonissmall,andthatbelowitmanytimesaslarge,itisimpossibleforthesuntobereflectedtooursight,eitherwhenitapproachesthesoutherntropic,oratthesummersolstice。Henceintheseregionsitdoesnotdevelopatailatall。
Butwhenitisvisibleinthenorthitassumesatailbecausethearcabovethehorizonislargeandthatbelowitsmall。Forunderthesecircumstancesthereisnothingtopreventourvisionfrombeingreflectedtothesun。
Theseviewsinvolveimpossibilities,someofwhicharecommontoallofthem,whileothersarepeculiartosomeonly。
Thisisthecase,first,withthosewhosaythatthecometisoneoftheplanets。Foralltheplanetsappearinthecircleofthezodiac,whereasmanycometshavebeenseenoutsidethatcircle。Againmorecometsthanonehaveoftenappearedsimultaneously。Besides,iftheirtailisduetoreflection,asAeschylusandHippocratessay,thisplanetoughtsometimestobevisiblewithoutatailsince,astheyitdoesnotpossessatailineveryplaceinwhichitappears。
But,asamatteroffact,noplanethasbeenobservedbesidesthefive。Andallofthemareoftenvisibleabovethehorizontogetheratthesametime。Further,cometsareoftenfoundtoappear,aswellwhenalltheplanetsarevisibleaswhensomearenot,butareobscuredbytheneighbourhoodofthesun。Moreoverthestatementthatacometonlyappearsinthenorth,withthesunatthesummersolstice,isnottrueeither。ThegreatcometwhichappearedatthetimeoftheearthquakeinAchaeaandthetidalwaveroseduewest;andmanyhavebeenknowntoappearinthesouth。AgaininthearchonshipofEuclees,sonofMolon,atAthensthereappearedacometinthenorthinthemonthGamelion,thesunbeingaboutthewintersolstice。Yettheythemselvesadmitthatreflectionoversogreataspaceisanimpossibility。
Anobjectionthattellsequallyagainstthosewhoholdthistheoryandthosewhosaythatcometsareacoalescenceoftheplanetsis,first,thefactthatsomeofthefixedstarstoogetatail。ForthiswemustnotonlyaccepttheauthorityoftheEgyptianswhoassertit,butwehaveourselvesobservedthefact。ForastarinthethighoftheDoghadatail,thoughafaintone。Ifyoufixedyoursightonititslightwasdim,butifyoujustglancedatit,itappearedbrighter。Besides,allthecometsthathavebeenseeninourdayhavevanishedwithoutsetting,graduallyfadingawayabovethehorizon;andtheyhavenotleftbehindthemeitheroneormorestars。Forinstancethegreatcometwementionedbeforeappearedtothewestinwinterinfrostyweatherwhentheskywasclear,inthearchonshipofAsteius。Onthefirstdayitsetbeforethesunandwasthennotseen。Onthenextdayitwasseen,beingeversolittlebehindthesunandimmediatelysetting。Butitslightextendedoverathirdpartoftheskylikealeap,sothatpeoplecalledita’path’。ThiscometrecededasfarasOrion’sbeltandtheredissolved。
Democritushowever,insistsuponthetruthofhisviewandaffirmsthatcertainstarshavebeenseenwhencometsdissolve。Butonhistheorythisoughtnottooccuroccasionallybutalways。Besides,theEgyptiansaffirmthatconjunctionsoftheplanetswithoneanother,andwiththefixedstars,takeplace,andwehaveourselvesobservedJupitercoincidingwithoneofthestarsintheTwinsandhidingit,andyetnocometwasformed。Further,wecanalsogivearationalproofofourpoint。Itistruethatsomestarsseemtobebiggerthanothers,yeteachonebyitselflooksindivisible。Consequently,justas,iftheyreallyhadbeenindivisible,theirconjunctioncouldnothavecreatedanygreatermagnitude,sonowthattheyarenotinfactindivisiblebutlookasiftheywere,theirconjunctionwillnotmakethemlookanybigger。
Enoughhasbeensaid,withoutfurtherargument,toshowthatthecausesbroughtforwardtoexplaincometsarefalse。
7
Weconsiderasatisfactoryexplanationofphenomenainaccessibletoobservationtohavebeengivenwhenouraccountofthemisfreefromimpossibilities。Theobservationsbeforeussuggestthefollowingaccountofthephenomenawearenowconsidering。Weknowthatthedryandwarmexhalationistheoutermostpartoftheterrestrialworldwhichfallsbelowthecircularmotion。It,andagreatpartoftheairthatiscontinuouswithitbelow,iscarriedroundtheearthbythemotionofthecircularrevolution。Inthecourseofthismotionitoftenigniteswhereveritmayhappentobeoftherightconsistency,andthiswemaintaintobethecauseofthe’shooting’ofscattered’stars’。Wemaysay,then,thatacometisformedwhentheuppermotionintroducesintoagatheringofthiskindafieryprinciplenotofsuchexcessivestrengthastoburnupmuchofthematerialquickly,norsoweakassoontobeextinguished,butstrongerandcapableofburningupmuchmaterial,andwhenexhalationoftherightconsistencyrisesfrombelowandmeetsit。Thekindofcometvariesaccordingtotheshapewhichtheexhalationhappenstotake。Ifitisdiffusedequallyoneverysidethestarissaidtobefringed,ifitstretchesoutinonedirectionitiscalledbearded。Wehaveseenthatwhenafieryprincipleofthiskindmovesweseemtohaveashooting-star:similarlywhenitstandsstillweseemtohaveastarstandingstill。Wemaycomparethesephenomenatoaheapormassofchaffintowhichatorchisthrust,orasparkthrown。Thatiswhatashooting-starislike。Thefuelissoinflammablethatthefirerunsthroughitquicklyinaline。Nowifthisfireweretopersistinsteadofrunningthroughthefuelandperishingaway,itscoursethroughthefuelwouldstopatthepointwherethelatterwasdensest,andthenthewholemightbegintomove。Suchisacomet-likeashooting-starthatcontainsitsbeginningandendinitself。
Whenthematterbeginstogatherinthelowerregionindependentlythecometappearsbyitself。Butwhentheexhalationisconstitutedbyoneofthefixedstarsortheplanets,owingtotheirmotion,oneofthembecomesacomet。Thefringeisnotclosetothestarsthemselves。
Justashaloesappeartofollowthesunandthemoonastheymove,andencirclethem,whentheairisdenseenoughforthemtoformalongunderthesun’scourse,sotoothefringe。Itstandsintherelationofahalotothestars,exceptthatthecolourofthehaloisduetoreflection,whereasinthecaseofcometsthecolourissomethingthatappearsactuallyonthem。
Nowwhenthismattergathersinrelationtoastarthecometnecessarilyappearstofollowthesamecourseasthestar。Butwhenthecometisformedindependentlyitfallsbehindthemotionoftheuniverse,liketherestoftheterrestrialworld。Itisthisfact,thatacometoftenformsindependently,indeedoftenerthanroundoneoftheregularstars,thatmakesitimpossibletomaintainthatacometisasortofreflection,notindeed,asHippocratesandhisschoolsay,tothesun,buttotheverystaritisallegedtoaccompany-infact,akindofhalointhepurefueloffire。
Asforthehaloweshallexplainitscauselater。
Thefactthatcometswhenfrequentforeshadowwindanddroughtmustbetakenasanindicationoftheirfieryconstitution。Fortheiroriginisplainlyduetotheplentifulsupplyofthatsecretion。
Hencetheairisnecessarilydrierandthemoistevaporationissodissolvedanddissipatedbythequantityofthehotexhalationasnotreadilytocondenseintowater-Butthisphenomenontooshallbeexplainedmoreclearlylaterwhenthetimecomestospeakofthewinds-Sowhentherearemanycometsandtheyaredense,itisaswesay,andtheyearsareclearlydryandwindy。Whentheyarefewerandfainterthiseffectdoesnotappearinthesamedegree,thoughasaruletheisfoundtobeexcessiveeitherindurationorstrength。
ForinstancewhenthestoneatAegospotamifelloutoftheair-ithadbeencarriedupbyawindandfelldowninthedaytime-thentooacomethappenedtohaveappearedinthewest。Andatthetimeofthegreatcometthewinterwasdryandnorthwindsprevailed,andthewavewasduetoanoppositionofwinds。Forinthegulfanorthwindblewandoutsideitaviolentsouthwind。AgaininthearchonshipofNicomachusacometappearedforafewdaysabouttheequinoctialcircle(thisonehadnotriseninthewest),andsimultaneouslywithittherehappenedthestormatCorinth。
Thattherearefewcometsandthattheyappearrarelyandoutsidethetropiccirclesmorethanwithinthemisduetothemotionofthesunandthestars。Forthismotiondoesnotonlycausethehotprincipletobesecretedbutalsodissolvesitwhenitisgathering。
Butthechiefreasonisthatmostofthisstuffcollectsintheregionofthemilkyway。
8
Letusnowexplaintheorigin,cause,andnatureofthemilkyway。
Andheretooletusbeginbydiscussingthestatementsofothersonthesubject。
(1)Oftheso-calledPythagoreanssomesaythatthisisthepathofoneofthestarsthatfellfromheavenatthetimeofPhaethon’sdownfall。Otherssaythatthesunusedoncetomoveinthiscircleandthatthisregionwasscorchedormetwithsomeotheraffectionofthiskind,becauseofthesunanditsmotion。
ButitisabsurdnottoseethatifthiswerethereasonthecircleoftheZodiacoughttobeaffectedinthesameway,andindeedmoresothanthatofthemilkyway,sincenotthesunonlybutalltheplanetsmoveinit。Wecanseethewholeofthiscircle(halfofitbeingvisibleatanytimeofthenight),butitshowsnosignsofanysuchaffectionexceptwhereapartofittouchesthecircleofthemilkyway。
(2)Anaxagoras,Democritus,andtheirschoolssaythatthemilkywayisthelightofcertainstars。For,theysay,whenthesunpassesbelowtheearthsomeofthestarsarehiddenfromit。Nowthelightofthoseonwhichthesunshinesisinvisible,beingobscuredbytheofthesun。Butthemilkywayisthepeculiarlightofthosestarswhichareshadedbytheearthfromthesun’srays。
This,too,isobviouslyimpossible。Themilkywayisalwaysunchangedandamongthesameconstellations(foritisclearlyagreatestcircle),whereas,sincethesundoesnotremaininthesameplace,whatishiddenfromitdiffersatdifferenttimes。Consequentlywiththechangeofthesun’spositionthemilkywayoughttochangeitspositiontoo:butwefindthatthisdoesnothappen。Besides,ifastronomicaldemonstrationsarecorrectandthesizeofthesunisgreaterthanthatoftheearthandthedistanceofthestarsfromtheearthmanytimesgreaterthanthatofthesun(justasthesunisfurtherfromtheearththanthemoon),thentheconemadebytheraysofthesunwouldterminateatnogreatdistancefromtheearth,andtheshadowoftheearth(whatwecallnight)wouldnotreachthestars。Onthecontrary,thesunshinesonallthestarsandtheearthscreensnoneofthem。
(3)Thereisathirdtheoryaboutthemilkyway。Somesaythatitisareflectionofoursighttothesun,justastheysaythatthecometis。
Butthistooisimpossible。Foriftheeyeandthemirrorandthewholeoftheobjectwereseverallyatrest,thenthesamepartoftheimagewouldappearatthesamepointinthemirror。Butifthemirrorandtheobjectmove,keepingthesamedistancefromtheeyewhichisatrest,butatdifferentratesofspeedandsonotalwaysatthesameintervalfromoneanother,thenitisimpossibleforthesameimagealwaystoappearinthesamepartofthemirror。Nowtheconstellationsincludedinthecircleofthemilkywaymove;andsodoesthesun,theobjecttowhichoursightisreflected;butwestandstill。Andthedistanceofthosetwofromusisconstantanduniform,buttheirdistancefromoneanothervaries。FortheDolphinsometimesrisesatmidnight,sometimesinthemorning。Butineachcasethesamepartsofthemilkywayarefoundnearit。Butifitwereareflectionandnotagenuineaffectionofthesethisoughtnottobethecase。
Again,wecanseethemilkywayreflectedatnightinwaterandsimilarmirrors。Butunderthesecircumstancesitisimpossibleforoursighttobereflectedtothesun。
Theseconsiderationsshowthatthemilkywayisnotthepathofoneoftheplanets,northelightofimperceptiblestars,norareflection。Andthosearethechieftheorieshandeddownbyothershitherto。
Letusrecallourfundamentalprincipleandthenexplainourviews。Wehavealreadylaiddownthattheoutermostpartofwhatiscalledtheairispotentiallyfireandthatthereforewhentheairisdissolvedbymotion,thereisseparatedoffakindofmatter-andofthismatterweassertthatcometsconsist。Wemustsupposethatwhathappensisthesameasinthecaseofthecometswhenthematterdoesnotformindependentlybutisformedbyoneofthefixedstarsortheplanets。Thenthesestarsappeartobefringed,becausematterofthiskindfollowstheircourse。Inthesameway,acertainkindofmatterfollowsthesun,andweexplainthehaloasareflectionfromitwhentheairisoftherightconstitution。Nowwemustassumethatwhathappensinthecaseofthestarsseverallyhappensinthecaseofthewholeoftheheavensandalltheuppermotion。Foritisnaturaltosupposethat,ifthemotionofasinglestarexcitesaflame,thatofallthestarsshouldhaveasimilarresult,andespeciallyinthatregioninwhichthestarsarebiggestandmostnumerousandnearesttooneanother。Nowthecircleofthezodiacdissolvesthiskindofmatterbecauseofthemotionofthesunandtheplanets,andforthisreasonmostcometsarefoundoutsidethetropiccircles。Again,nofringeappearsroundthesunormoon:fortheydissolvesuchmattertooquicklytoadmitofitsformation。Butthiscircleinwhichthemilkywayappearstooursightisthegreatestcircle,anditspositionissuchthatitextendsfaroutsidethetropiccircles。Besidestheregionisfullofthebiggestandbrightestconstellationsandalsoofwhatcalled’scattered’stars(youhaveonlytolooktoseethisclearly)。Soforthesereasonsallthismatteriscontinuallyandceaselesslycollectingthere。Aproofofthetheoryisthis:Inthecircleitselfthelightisstrongerinthathalfwherethemilkywayisdivided,andinittheconstellationsaremorenumerousandclosertooneanotherthanintheotherhalf;whichshowsthatthecauseofthelightisthemotionoftheconstellationsandnothingelse。Forifitisfoundinthecircleinwhichtherearemostconstellationsandatthatpointinthecircleatwhichtheyaredensestandcontainthebiggestandthemoststars,itisnaturaltosupposethattheyarethetruecauseoftheaffectioninquestion。Thecircleandtheconstellationsinitmaybeseeninthediagram。Theso-called’scattered’starsitisnotpossibletosetdowninthesamewayonthespherebecausenoneofthemhaveanevidentpermanentposition;
butifyoulookuptotheskythepointisclear。Forinthiscirclealonearetheintervalsfullofthesestars:intheothercirclesthereareobviousgaps。Henceifweacceptthecauseassignedfortheappearanceofcometsasplausiblewemustassumethatthesamekindofthingholdsgoodofthemilkyway。Forthefringewhichintheformercaseisanaffectionofasinglestarhereformsinthesamewayinrelationtoawholecircle。Soifwearetodefinethemilkywaywemaycallit’afringeattachingtothegreatestcircle,andduetothemattersecreted’。This,aswesaidbefore,explainswhytherearefewcometsandwhytheyappearrarely;itisbecauseateachrevolutionoftheheavensthismatterhasalwaysbeenandisalwaysbeingseparatedoffandgatheredintothisregion。
Wehavenowexplainedthephenomenathatoccurinthatpartoftheterrestrialworldwhichiscontinuouswiththemotionsoftheheavens,namely,shooting-starsandtheburningflame,cometsandthemilkyway,thesebeingthechiefaffectionsthatappearinthatregion。
9
Letusgoontotreatoftheregionwhichfollowsnextinorderafterthisandwhichimmediatelysurroundstheearth。Itistheregioncommontowaterandair,andtheprocessesattendingtheformationofwaterabovetakeplaceinit。Wemustconsidertheprinciplesandcausesofallthesephenomenatooasbefore。Theefficientandchiefandfirstcauseisthecircleinwhichthesunmoves。Forthesunasitapproachesorrecedes,obviouslycausesdissipationandcondensationandsogivesrisetogenerationanddestruction。Nowtheearthremainsbutthemoisturesurroundingitismadetoevaporatebythesun’sraysandtheotherheatfromabove,andrises。Butwhentheheatwhichwasraisingitleavesit,inpartdispersingtothehigherregion,inpartquenchedthroughrisingsofarintotheupperair,thenthevapourcoolsbecauseitsheatisgoneandbecausetheplaceiscold,andcondensesagainandturnsfromairintowater。
Andafterthewaterhasformeditfallsdownagaintotheearth。
Theexhalationofwaterisvapour:aircondensingintowateriscloud。Mistiswhatisleftoverwhenacloudcondensesintowater,andisthereforeratherasignoffineweatherthanofrain;formistmightbecalledabarrencloud。Sowegetacircularprocessthatfollowsthecourseofthesun。Foraccordingasthesunmovestothissideorthat,themoistureinthisprocessrisesorfalls。Wemustthinkofitasariverflowingupanddowninacircleandmadeuppartlyofair,partlyofwater。Whenthesunisnear,thestreamofvapourflowsupwards;whenitrecedes,thestreamofwaterflowsdown:
andtheorderofsequence,atallevents,inthisprocessalwaysremainsthesame。Soif’Oceanus’hadsomesecretmeaninginearlywriters,perhapstheymayhavemeantthisriverthatflowsinacircleabouttheearth。
Sothemoistureisalwaysraisedbytheheatanddescendstotheearthagainwhenitgetscold。Theseprocessesand,insomecases,theirvarietiesaredistinguishedbyspecialnames。Whenthewaterfallsinsmalldropsitiscalledadrizzle;whenthedropsarelargeritisrain。
10
Someofthevapourthatisformedbydaydoesnotrisehighbecausetheratioofthefirethatisraisingittothewaterthatisbeingraisedissmall。Whenthiscoolsanddescendsatnightitiscalleddewandhoar-frost。Whenthevapourisfrozenbeforeithascondensedtowateragainitishoar-frost;andthisappearsinwinterandiscommonerincoldplaces。Itisdewwhenthevapourhascondensedintowaterandtheheatisnotsogreatastodryupthemoisturethathasbeenraisednorthecoldsufficient(owingtothewarmthoftheclimateorseason)forthevapouritselftofreeze。
Fordewismorecommonlyfoundwhentheseasonortheplaceiswarm,whereastheopposite,ashasbeensaid,isthecasewithhoar-frost。
Forobviouslyvapouriswarmerthanwater,havingstillthefirethatraisedit:consequentlymorecoldisneededtofreezeit。
Bothdewandhoar-frostarefoundwhentheskyisclearandthereisnowind。Forthevapourcouldnotberaisedunlesstheskywereclear,andifawindwereblowingitcouldnotcondense。
Thefactthathoar-frostisnotfoundonmountainscontributestoprovethatthesephenomenaoccurbecausethevapourdoesnotrisehigh。Onereasonforthisisthatitrisesfromhollowandwateryplaces,sothattheheatthatisraisingit,bearingasitweretooheavyaburdencannotliftittoagreatheightbutsoonletsitfallagain。Asecondreasonisthatthemotionoftheairismorepronouncedataheight,andthisdissolvesagatheringofthiskind。
Everywhere,exceptinPontus,dewisfoundwithsouthwindsandnotwithnorthwinds。Theretheoppositeisthecaseanditisfoundwithnorthwindsandnotwithsouth。Thereasonisthesameasthatwhichexplainswhydewisfoundinwarmweatherandnotincold。Forthesouthwindbringswarm,andthenorth,wintryweather。Forthenorthwindiscoldandsoquenchestheheatoftheevaporation。ButinPontusthesouthwinddoesnotbringwarmthenoughtocauseevaporation,whereasthecoldnessofthenorthwindconcentratestheheatbyasortofrecoil,sothatthereismoreevaporationandnotless。Thisisathingwhichwecanoftenobserveinotherplacestoo。Wells,forinstance,giveoffmorevapourinanorththaninasouthwind。Onlythenorthwindsquenchtheheatbeforeanyconsiderablequantityofvapourhasgathered,whileinasouthwindtheevaporationisallowedtoaccumulate。
Water,onceformed,doesnotfreezeonthesurfaceoftheearth,inthewaythatitdoesintheregionoftheclouds。
11
Fromthelattertherefallthreebodiescondensedbycold,namelyrain,snow,hail。Twoofthesecorrespondtothephenomenaonthelowerlevelandareduetothesamecauses,differingfromthemonlyindegreeandquantity。
Snowandhoar-frostareoneandthesamething,andsoarerainanddew:onlythereisagreatdealoftheformerandlittleofthelatter。Forrainisduetothecoolingofagreatamountofvapour,fortheregionfromwhichandthetimeduringwhichthevapouriscollectedareconsiderable。Butofdewthereislittle:forthevapourcollectsforitinasingledayandfromasmallarea,asitsquickformationandscantyquantityshow。
Therelationofhoar-frostandsnowisthesame:whencloudfreezesthereissnow,whenvapourfreezesthereishoar-frost。
Hencesnowisasignofacoldseasonorcountry。Foragreatdealofheatisstillpresentandunlessthecoldwereoverpoweringitthecloudwouldnotfreeze。Fortherestillsurvivesinitagreatdealoftheheatwhichcausedthemoisturetoriseasvapourfromtheearth。
Hailontheotherhandisfoundintheupperregion,butthecorrespondingphenomenoninthevaporousregionneartheearthislacking。For,aswesaid,tosnowintheupperregioncorrespondshoar-frostinthelower,andtorainintheupperregion,dewinthelower。Butthereisnothingheretocorrespondtohailintheupperregion。Whythisissowillbeclearwhenwehaveexplainedthenatureofhail。
12
Butwemustgoontocollectthefactsbearingontheoriginofit,boththosewhichraisenodifficultiesandthosewhichseemparadoxical。
Hailisice,andwaterfreezesinwinter;yethailstormsoccurchieflyinspringandautumnandlessofteninthelatesummer,butrarelyinwinterandthenonlywhenthecoldislessintense。Andingeneralhailstormsoccurinwarmer,andsnowincolderplaces。
Again,thereisadifficultyaboutwaterfreezingintheupperregion。
Itcannothavefrozenbeforebecomingwater:andwatercannotremainsuspendedintheairforanyspaceoftime。Norcanwesaythatthecaseislikethatofparticlesofmoisturewhicharecarriedupowingtotheirsmallsizeandrestontheiar(thewaterswimmingontheairjustassmallparticlesofearthandgoldoftenswimonwater)。Inthatcaselargedropsareformedbytheunionofmanysmall,andsofalldown。Thiscannottakeplaceinthecaseofhail,sincesolidbodiescannotcoalescelikeliquidones。Clearlythendropsofthatsizeweresuspendedintheairorelsetheycouldnothavebeensolargewhenfrozen。
Somethinkthatthecauseandoriginofhailisthis。Thecloudisthrustupintotheupperatmosphere,whichiscolderbecausethereflectionofthesun’sraysfromtheearthceasesthere,anduponitsarrivaltherethewaterfreezes。Theythinkthatthisexplainswhyhailstormsarecommonerinsummerandinwarmcountries;theheatisgreateranditthruststhecloudsfurtherupfromtheearth。Butthefactisthathaildoesnotoccuratallatagreatheight:yetitoughttodoso,ontheirtheory,justasweseethatsnowfallsmostonhighmountains。Againcloudshaveoftenbeenobservedmovingwithagreatnoiseclosetotheearth,terrifyingthosewhoheardandsawthemasportentsofsomecatastrophe。Sometimes,too,whensuchcloudshavebeenseen,withoutanynoise,therefollowsaviolenthailstorm,andthestonesareofincrediblesize,andangularinshape。Thisshowsthattheyhavenotbeenfallingforlongandthattheywerefrozenneartotheearth,andnotasthattheorywouldhaveit。Moreover,wherethehailstonesarelarge,thecauseoftheirfreezingmustbepresentinthehighestdegree:forhailisiceaseveryonecansee。Nowthosehailstonesarelargewhichareangularinshape。Andthisshowsthattheyfrozeclosetotheearth,forthosethatfallfararewornawaybythelengthoftheirfallandbecomeroundandsmallerinsize。
Itclearlyfollowsthatthecongelationdoesnottakeplacebecausethecloudisthrustupintothecoldupperregion。
Nowweseethatwarmandcoldreactupononeanotherbyrecoil。
Henceinwarmweatherthelowerpartsoftheeartharecoldandinafrosttheyarewarm。Thesamething,wemustsuppose,happensintheair,sothatinthewarmerseasonsthecoldisconcentratedbythesurroundingheatandcausesthecloudtogooverintowatersuddenly。(Forthisreasonrain-dropsaremuchlargeronwarmdaysthaninwinter,andshowersmoreviolent。Ashowerissaidtobemoreviolentinproportionasthewatercomesdowninabody,andthishappenswhenthecondensationtakesplacequickly,-thoughthisisjusttheoppositeofwhatAnaxagorassays。Hesaysthatthishappenswhenthecloudhasrisenintothecoldair;whereaswesaythatithappenswhenthecloudhasdescendedintothewarmair,andthatthemorethefurtherthecloudhasdescended)。Butwhenthecoldhasbeenconcentratedwithinstillmorebytheouterheat,itfreezesthewaterithasformedandthereishail。Wegethailwhentheprocessoffreezingisquickerthanthedescentofthewater。Forifthewaterfallsinacertaintimeandthecoldissufficienttofreezeitinless,thereisnodifficultyaboutitshavingfrozenintheair,providedthatthefreezingtakesplaceinashortertimethanitsfall。Thenearertotheearth,andthemoresuddenly,thisprocesstakesplace,themoreviolentistherainthatresultsandthelargertheraindropsandthehailstonesbecauseoftheshortnessoftheirfall。Forthesamereasonlargeraindropsdonotfallthickly。
Hailisrarerinsummerthaninspringandautumn,thoughcommonerthaninwinter,becausetheairisdrierinsummer,whereasinspringitisstillmoist,andinautumnitisbeginningtogrowmoist。
Itisforthesamereasonthathailstormssometimesoccurinthelatesummeraswehavesaid。
Thefactthatthewaterhaspreviouslybeenwarmedcontributestoitsfreezingquickly:forsoitcoolssooner。Hencemanypeople,whentheywanttocoolhotwaterquickly,beginbyputtingitinthesun。SotheinhabitantsofPontuswhentheyencampontheicetofish(theycutaholeintheiceandthenfish)pourwarmwaterroundtheirreedsthatitmayfreezethequicker,fortheyusetheicelikeleadtofixthereeds。Nowitisinhotcountriesandseasonsthatthewaterwhichformssoongrowswarm。
ItisforthesamereasonthatrainfallsinsummerandnotinwinterinArabiaandEthiopiatoo,andthatintorrentsandrepeatedlyonthesameday。Fortheconcentrationorrecoilduetotheextremeheatofthecountrycoolsthecloudsquickly。
Somuchforanaccountofthenatureandcausesofrain,dew,snow,hoar-frost,andhail。
13
Letusexplainthenatureofwinds,andallwindyvapours,alsoofriversandofthesea。Buthere,too,wemustfirstdiscussthedifficultiesinvolved:for,asinothermatters,sointhisnotheoryhasbeenhandeddowntousthatthemostordinarymancouldnothavethoughtof。
Somesaythatwhatiscalledair,whenitisinmotionandflows,iswind,andthatthissameairwhenitcondensesagainbecomescloudandwater,implyingthatthenatureofwindandwateristhesame。Sotheydefinewindasamotionoftheair。Hencesome,wishingtosayacleverthing,assertthatallthewindsareonewind,becausetheairthatmovesisinfactallofitoneandthesame;theymaintainthatthewindsappeartodifferowingtotheregionfromwhichtheairmayhappentoflowoneachoccasion,butreallydonotdifferatall。Thisisjustlikethinkingthatallriversareoneandthesameriver,andtheordinaryunscientificviewisbetterthanascientifictheorylikethis。Ifallriversflowfromonesource,andthesameistrueinthecaseofthewinds,theremightbesometruthinthistheory;butifitisnomoretrueintheonecasethanintheother,thisingeniousideaisplainlyfalse。Whatrequiresinvestigationisthis:thenatureofwindandhowitoriginates,itsefficientcauseandwhencetheyderivetheirsource;whetheroneoughttothinkofthewindasissuingfromasortofvesselandflowinguntilthevesselisempty,asifletoutofawineskin,or,aspaintersrepresentthewinds,asdrawingtheirsourcefromthemselves。
Wefindanalogousviewsabouttheoriginofrivers。Itisthoughtthatthewaterisraisedbythesunanddescendsinrainandgathersbelowtheearthandsoflowsfromagreatreservoir,alltheriversfromone,oreachfromadifferentone。Nowateratallisgenerated,butthevolumeoftheriversconsistsofthewaterthatisgatheredintosuchreservoirsinwinter。Henceriversarealwaysfullerinwinterthaninsummer,andsomeareperennial,othersnot。
Riversareperennialwherethereservoirislargeandsoenoughwaterhascollectedinittolastoutandnotbeusedupbeforethewinterrainreturns。Wherethereservoirsaresmallerthereislesswaterintherivers,andtheyaredriedupandtheirvesselemptybeforethefreshraincomeson。
Butifanyonewillpicturetohimselfareservoiradequatetothewaterthatiscontinuouslyflowingdaybyday,andconsidertheamountofthewater,itisobviousthatareceptaclethatistocontainallthewaterthatflowsintheyearwouldbelargerthantheearth,or,atanyrate,notmuchsmaller。
Thoughitisevidentthatmanyreservoirsofthiskinddoexistinmanypartsoftheearth,yetitisunreasonableforanyonetorefusetoadmitthatairbecomeswaterintheearthforthesamereasonasitdoesaboveit。Ifthecoldcausesthevaporousairtocondenseintowaterabovetheearthwemustsupposethecoldintheearthtoproducethissameeffect,andrecognizethattherenotonlyexistsinitandflowsoutofitactuallyformedwater,butthatwateriscontinuallyforminginittoo。
Again,eveninthecaseofthewaterthatisnotbeingformedfromdaytodaybutexistsassuch,wemustnotsupposeassomedothatrivershavetheirsourceindefinitesubterraneanlakes。Onthecontrary,justasabovetheearthsmalldropsformandthesejoinothers,tillfinallythewaterdescendsinabodyasrain,sotoowemustsupposethatintheearththewateratfirsttricklestogetherlittlebylittle,andthatthesourcesoftheriversdrip,asitwere,outoftheearthandthenunite。Thisisprovedbyfacts。Whenmenconstructanaqueducttheycollectthewaterinpipesandtrenches,asiftheearthinthehighergroundweresweatingthewaterout。
Hence,too,thehead-watersofriversarefoundtoflowfrommountains,andfromthegreatestmountainsthereflowthemostnumerousandgreatestrivers。Again,mostspringsareintheneighbourhoodofmountainsandofhighground,whereasifweexceptrivers,waterrarelyappearsintheplains。Formountainsandhighground,suspendedoverthecountrylikeasaturatedsponge,makethewateroozeoutandtrickletogetherinminutequantitiesbutinmanyplaces。Theyreceiveagreatdealofwaterfallingasrain(foritmakesnodifferencewhetheraspongyreceptacleisconcaveandturneduporconvexandturneddown:ineithercaseitwillcontainthesamevolumeofmatter)and,theyalsocoolthevapourthatrisesandcondenseitbackintowater。
Hence,aswesaid,wefindthatthegreatestriversflowfromthegreatestmountains。Thiscanbeseenbylookingatitineraries:whatisrecordedinthemconsistseitherofthingswhichthewriterhasseenhimselforofsuchashehascompiledafterinquiryfromthosewhohaveseenthem。
InAsiawefindthatthemostnumerousandgreatestriversflowfromthemountaincalledParnassus,admittedlythegreatestofallmountainstowardsthesouth-east。Whenyouhavecrossedityouseetheouterocean,thefurtherlimitofwhichisunknowntothedwellersinourworld。BesidesotherriversthereflowfromittheBactrus,theChoaspes,theAraxes:fromthelastabranchseparatesoffandflowsintolakeMaeotisastheTanais。Fromit,too,flowstheIndus,thevolumeofwhosestreamisgreatestofallrivers。FromtheCaucasusflowsthePhasis,andverymanyothergreatriversbesides。NowtheCaucasusisthegreatestofthemountainsthatlietothenortheast,bothasregardsitsextentanditsheight。Aproofofitsheightisthefactthatitcanbeseenfromtheso-called’deeps’andfromtheentrancetothelake。Again,thesunshinesonitspeaksforathirdpartofthenightbeforesunriseandagainaftersunset。Itsextentisprovedbythefactthatthoughtcontainsmanyinhabitableregionswhichareoccupiedbymanynationsandinwhichtherearesaidtobegreatlakes,yettheysaythatalltheseregionsarevisibleuptothelastpeak。FromPyrene(thisisamountaintowardsthewestinCeltice)thereflowtheIstrusandtheTartessus。Thelatterflowsoutsidethepillars,whiletheIstrusflowsthroughallEuropeintotheEuxine。MostoftheremainingriversflownorthwardsfromtheHercynianmountains,whicharethegreatestinheightandextentaboutthatregion。Intheextremenorth,beyondfurthestScythia,arethemountainscalledRhipae。Thestoriesabouttheirsizearealtogethertoofabulous:however,theysaythatthemostand(aftertheIstrus)
thegreatestriversflowfromthem。So,too,inLibyathereflowfromtheAethiopianmountainstheAegonandtheNyses;andfromtheso-calledSilverMountainthetwogreatestofnamedrivers,therivercalledChremetesthatflowsintotheouterocean,andthemainsourceoftheNile。OftheriversintheGreekworld,theAchelousflowsfromPindus,theInachusfromthesamemountain;theStrymon,theNestus,andtheHebrusallthreefromScombrus;manyrivers,too,flowfromRhodope。
Allotherriverswouldbefoundtoflowinthesameway,butwehavementionedtheseasexamples。Evenwhereriversflowfrommarshes,themarshesinalmosteverycasearefoundtoliebelowmountainsorgraduallyrisingground。
Itisclearthenthatwemustnotsupposeriverstooriginatefromdefinitereservoirs:forthewholeearth,wemightalmostsay,wouldnotbesufficient(anymorethantheregionofthecloudswouldbe)ifweweretosupposethattheywerefedbyactuallyexistingwateronlyanditwerenotthecasethatassomewaterpassedoutofexistencesomemorecameintoexistence,butriversalwaysdrewtheirstreamfromanexistingstore。Secondly,thefactthatriversriseatthefootofmountainsprovesthataplacetransmitsthewateritcontainsbygradualpercolationofmanydrops,littlebylittle,andthatthisishowthesourcesofriversoriginate。However,thereisnothingimpossibleabouttheexistenceofsuchplacescontainingaquantityofwaterlikelakes:onlytheycannotbebigenoughtoproducethesupposedeffect。Tothinkthattheyareisjustasabsurdasifoneweretosupposethatriversdrewalltheirwaterfromthesourceswesee(formostriversdoflowfromsprings)。Soitisnomorereasonabletosupposethoselakestocontainthewholevolumeofwaterthanthesesprings。
Thatthereexistsuchchasmsandcavitiesintheearthwearetaughtbytheriversthatareswallowedup。Theyarefoundinmanypartsoftheearth:inthePeloponnesus,forinstance,therearemanysuchriversinArcadia。ThereasonisthatArcadiaismountainousandtherearenochannelsfromitsvalleystothesea。Sotheseplacesgetfullofwater,andthis,havingnooutlet,underthepressureofthewaterthatisaddedabove,findsawayoutforitselfunderground。
InGreecethiskindofthinghappensonquiteasmallscale,butthelakeatthefootoftheCaucasus,whichtheinhabitantsofthesepartscallasea,isconsiderable。ManygreatriversfallintoitandithasnovisibleoutletbutissuesbelowtheearthoffthelandoftheCoraxiabouttheso-called’deepsofPontus’。Thisisaplaceofunfathomabledepthinthesea:atanyratenoonehasyetbeenabletofindbottomtherebysounding。Atthisspot,aboutthreehundredstadiafromland,therecomesupsweetwateroveralargearea,notallofittogetherbutinthreeplaces。AndinLiguriaariverequalinsizetotheRhodanusisswallowedupandappearsagainelsewhere:
theRhodanusbeinganavigableriver。