Ittookthemotheramonthtogetbackherfullforce，vigor，andeffect；
thisbringsustoJuly27thandthedeadlyCornelia。Ifawifeofeighteenisstudyingwithherhusbandandhegetssmittenwithanotherwoman，isn’thelikelytoloseinterestinhiswife’sstudiesforthatreason，andisnothiswife’sinterestinherstudieslikelytolanguishforthesamereason？Wouldnotthemeresightofthosebooksofherssharpenthepainthatisinherheart？Thissuddenbreakingdownofamutualintellectualinterestoftwoyears’standingiscoincidentwithShelley’sre-encounterwithCornelia；andweareallowedtogatherfromthattimeforthfornearlytwomonthshedidallhisstudyinginthatperson’ssociety。WefeelatlibertytoruleoutCountNo。2fromtheindictmentagainstHarriet。
Shelley’shappinessinhishomehadbeenwoundedandbruisedalmosttodeath，thirdly，becauseHarriet’swalkswithHoggcommonlyledtosomefashionablebonnet-shop。Ioffernopalliation；Ionlyaskwhythedispassionate，impartialjudgedidnotofferonehimself——merely，Imean，tooffsethisleniencyinasimilarcaseortwowherethegirlwhoranawaywithHarriet’shusbandwastheshopper。Thereareseveraloccasionswheresheinterestedherselfwithshopping——amongthembeingwalkswhichendedatthebonnet-shop——yetinnoneofthesecasesdoesshegetawordofblamefromthegoodjudge，whileinoneofthemhecoversthedeedwithajustifyingremark，shedoingtheshoppingthattimetofindeasementforhermind，herchildhavingdied。
Shelley’shappinessinhishomehadbeenwoundedandbruisedalmosttodeath，fourthly，bytheintroductionthereofawet-nurse。Thewet-nursewasintroducedatthetimeoftheEdinburghsojourn，immediatelyafterShelleyhadbeenenjoyingthetwomonthsofstudywithCorneliawhichbrokeuphiswife’sstudiesanddestroyedhispersonalinterestinthem。
Why，bythistime，nothingthatShelley’swifecoulddowouldhavebeensatisfactorytohim，forhewasinlovewithanotherwoman，andwasnevergoingtobecontentedagainuntilhegotbacktoher。Ifhehadbeenstillinlovewithhiswifeitisnoteasilyconceivablethathewouldcaremuchwhonursedthebaby，providedthebabywaswellnursed。
Harriet’sjealousywasassuredlyvoicingitselfnow，Shelley’sconsciencewasassuredlynagginghim，pesteringhim，persecutinghim。Shelleyneededexcusesforhisalteredattitudetowardshiswife；Providencepitiedhimandsentthewet-nurse。IfProvidencehadsenthimacottondoughnutitwouldhaveansweredjustaswell；allhewantedwassomethingtofindfaultwith。
Shelley’shappinessinhishomehadbeenwoundedandbruisedalmosttodeath，fifthly，becauseHarrietnarrowlywatchedasurgicaloperationwhichwasbeingperformeduponherchild，and，"totheastonishmentoftheoperator，"whowaswatchingHarrietinsteadofattendingtohisoperation，shebetrayed"notthesmallestsignofemotion。"Theauthorofthisbiographywasnotashamedtosetdownthatexultantslander。
Hewasapparentlynotawarethatitwasasmallbusinesstobringintohiscourtawitnesswhosenamehedoesnotknow，andwhosecharacterandveracitythereisnonetovouchfor，andallowhimtostrikethisblowatthemother-heartofthisfriendlessgirl。Thebiographersays，"WemaynotinferfromthisthatHarrietdidnotfeel"——whyputitin，then？——
"butwelearnthatthoseabouthercouldbelievehertobehardandinsensible。"Whowerethosewhowereabouther？Herhusband？Hehatedhernow，becausehewasinloveelsewhere。Hersister？Ofcoursethatisnotcharged。Peacock？Peacockdoesnottestify。Thewet-nurse？Shedoesnottestify。Ifanyothersweretherewehavenomentionofthem。
"Thoseabouther"arereducedtooneperson——herhusband。Whoreportsthecircumstance？ItisHogg。Perhapshewasthere——wedonotknow。
Butifhewas，hestillgothisinformationatsecond-hand，asitwastheoperatorwhonoticedHarriet’slackofemotion，nothimself。HoggisnotgiventosayingkindthingswhenHarrietishissubject。Hemayhavesaidthemthetimethathetriedtotempthertosoilherhonor，butafterthathementionsherusuallywithasneer。"Amongthosewhowereabouther"wasonewitnesswellequippedtosilencealltongues，abolishalldoubts，setourmindsatrest；onewitness，notcalled，andnotcallable，whoseevidence，ifwecouldbutgetit，wouldoutweightheoathsofwholebattalionsofhostileHoggsandnamelesssurgeons——thebaby。Iwishwehadthebaby’stestimony；andyetifwehadititwouldnotdousanygood——afurtiveconjecture，aslyinsinuation，apious"if"ortwo，wouldbesmuggledin，hereandthere，withasolemnairofjudicialinvestigation，anditspositivenesswouldwiltintodubiety。
ThebiographersaysofHarriet，"Ifwordsoftenderaffectionandmotherlyprideprovedtherealityoflove，thenundoubtedlyshelovedherfirstbornchild。"Thatis，ifmereemptywordscanproveit，itstandsproved——andinthisway，withoutcommittinghimself，hegivesthereaderachancetoinferthatthereisn’tanyextantevidencebutwords，andthathedoesn’ttakemuchstockinthem。Howseldomheshowshishand！
Heisalwayslurkingbehindanon-committal"if"orsomethingofthatkind；alwaysglidinganddodgingaround，distributingcolorlesspoisonhereandthereandeverywhere，butalwaysleavinghimselfinapositiontosaythathislanguagewillbefoundinnocuousiftakentopiecesandexamined。Heclearlyexhibitsasteadyandnever-relaxingpurposetomakeHarrietthescapegoatforherhusband’sfirstgreatsin——butitisinthegeneralviewthatthisisrevealed，notinthedetails。Hisinsidiousliteratureislikebluewater；youknowwhatitisthatmakesitblue，butyoucannotproduceandverifyanydetailofthecloudofmicroscopicdustinitthatdoesit。Youradversarycandipupaglassfulandshowyouthatitispurewhiteandyoucannotdenyit；andhecandipthelakedry，glassbyglass，andshowthateveryglassfuliswhite，andproveittoanyone’seye——andyetthatlakewasblueandyoucanswearit。Thisbookisblue——withslanderinsolution。
Letthereaderexamine，forexample，theparagraphofcommentwhichimmediatelyfollowsthelettercontainingShelley’sself-exposurewhichwehavebeenconsidering。Thisisit。Oneshouldinspecttheindividualsentencesastheygoby，thenpasstheminprocessionandreviewthecake-walkasawhole：
"Shelley’shappinessinhishome，asisevidentfromthispatheticletter，hadbeenfatallystricken；itisevident，also，thatheknewwheredutylay；hefeltthathispartwastotakeuphisburden，silentlyandsorrowfully，andtobearithenceforthwiththequietnessofdespair。Butwecanperceivethathescarcelypossessedthestrengthandfortitudeneedfulforsuccessinsuchanattempt。AndclearlyShelleyhimselfwasawarehowperilousitwastoacceptthatrespiteofblissfuleasewhichheenjoyedintheBoinvillehousehold；forgentlevoicesanddewylooksandwordsofsympathycouldnotfailtoremindhimofanidealoftranquillityorofjoywhichcouldneverbehis，andwhichhemusthenceforthsternlyexcludefromhisimagination。"
Thatparagraphcommitstheauthorinnoway。Takensentencebysentenceitassertsnothingagainstanybodyorinfavorofanybody，pleadsfornobody，accusesnobody。Takendetailbydetail，itisasinnocentasmoonshine。Andyet，takenasawhole，itisadesignagainstthereader；
itsintentistoremovethefeelingwhichthelettermustleavewithhimifletalone，andputadifferentoneinitsplace——toremoveafeelingjustifiedbytheletterandsubstituteonenotjustifiedbyit。Theletteritselfgivesyounouncertainpicture——nolecturerisneededtostandbywithastickandpointoutitsdetailsandletontoexplainwhattheymean。Thepictureistheveryclearandremorsefullyfaithfulpictureofafallenandfetteredangelwhoisashamedofhimself；anangelwhobeatshissoiledwingsandcries，whocomplainstothewomanwhoenticedhimthathecouldhavebornehiswaywardlot，hecouldhavestoodbyhisdutyifithadnotbeenforherbeguilements；anangelwhorailsatthe"boundlessoceanofabhorredsociety，"andragesathispoorjudicioussister-in-law。Ifthereisanydignityaboutthisspectacleitwillescapemostpeople。
Yetwhentheparagraphofcommentistakenasawhole，thepictureisfullofdignityandpathos；wehavebeforeusablamelessandnoblespiritstrickentotheearthbymalignpowers，butnotconquered；
tempted，butgrandlyputtingthetemptationaway；enmeshedbysubtlecoils，butsternlyresolvedtorendthemandmarchforthvictorious，atanyperiloflifeorlimb。Curtain——slowmusic。
WasitthepurposeoftheparagraphtotakethebadtasteofShelley’sletteroutofthereader’smouth？Ifthatwasnotit，goodinkwaswasted；withoutthat，ithasnorelevancy——themultiplicationtablewouldhavepaddedthespaceasrationally。
Wehaveinspectedthesixreasonswhichweareaskedtobelievedroveamanofconspicuouspatience，honor，justice，fairness，kindliness，andironfirmness，resolution，andsteadfastness，fromthewifewhomhelovedandwholovedhim，toarefugeinthemephiticparadiseofBracknell。
Thesearesixinfinitelylittlereasons；butthereweresixcolossalones，andthesethecounselforthedestructionofHarrietShelleypersistsinnotconsideringveryimportant。
Moreover，thecolossalsixprecededthelittlesixandhaddonethemischiefbeforetheywereborn。Letusdouble-columnthetwelve；thenweshallseeataglancethateachlittlereasonisinturnansweredbyaretortingreasonofasizetoovershadowitandmakeitinsignificant：
1。Harrietsetsupcarriage。1。CORNELIATURNER。
2。Harrietstopsstudying。2。CORNELIATURNER。
3。Harrietgoestobonnet-shop。3。CORNELIATURNER。
4。Harriettakesawet-nurse。4。CORNELIATURNER。
5。Harriethastoomuchnerve。5。CORNELIATURNER。
6。Detestedsister-in-law。fi。6。CORNELIATURNER。
AssoonaswecomprehendthatCorneliaTurnerandtheItalianlessonshappenedbeforethelittlesixhadbeendiscoveredtobegrievances，weunderstandwhyShelley’shappinessinhishomehadbeenwoundedandbruisedalmosttodeath，andnoonecanpersuadeusintolayingitonHarriet。ShelleyandCorneliaaretheresponsiblepersons，andwecannotinhonoranddecencyallowthecrueltieswhichtheypractisedupontheunoffendingwifetobepushedasideinordertogiveusachancetowastetimeandtearsoversixsentimentaljustificationsofanoffencewhichthesixcan’tjustify，norevenrespectablyassistinjustifying。
Six？Therewereseven；butincharitytothebiographertheseventhoughtnottobeexposed。Still，hehungitouthimself，andnotonlyhungitout，butthoughtitwasagoodpointinShelley’sfavor。FortwoyearsShelleyfoundsympathyandintellectualfoodandallthatathome；
therewasenoughforspiritualandmentalsupport，butnotenoughforluxury；andso，attheendofthecontentedtwoyears，thislatterdetailjustifieshimingoingbagandbaggageovertoCorneliaTurnerandsupplyingtherestofhisneedinthewayofsurplussympathyandintellectualpieunlawfully。Bythesamereasoningamaninmerelycomfortablecircumstancesmayrobabankwithoutsin。
III
Itis1814，itisthe16thofMarch，Shelleyhas，writtenhisletter，hehasbeenintheBoinvilleparadiseamonth，hisdesertedwifeisinherhusbandlesshome。Mischiefhadbeenwrought。Itisthebiographerwhoconcedesthis。WegreatlyneedsomelightonHarriet’ssideofthecasenow；weneedtoknowhowsheenjoyedthemonth，butthereisnowaytoinformourselves；thereseemstobeastrangeabsenceofdocumentsandlettersanddiariesonthatside。Shelleykeptadiary，theapproachingMaryGodwinkeptadiary，herfatherkeptone，herhalf-sisterbymarriage，adoption，andthedispensationofGodkeptone，andtheentiretribeandallitsfriendswroteandreceivedletters，andtheletterswerekeptandareproduciblewhenthisbiographyneedsthem；butthereareonlythreeorfourscrapsofHarriet’swriting，andnodiary。
Harrietwroteplentyofletterstoherhusband——nobodyknowswheretheyare，Isuppose；shewroteplentyofletterstootherpeople——apparentlytheyhavedisappeared，too。Peacocksaysshewrotegoodletters，butapparentlyinterestedpeoplehadsagacityenoughtomislaythemintime。
Afterallherindustryshewentdownintohergraveandliessilentthere——silent，whenshehassomuchneedtospeak。Wecanonlywonderatthismystery，notaccountforit。
No，thereisnowayoffindingoutwhatHarriet’sstateoffeelingwasduringthemonththatShelleywasdisportinghimselfintheBracknellparadise。Wehavetofallbackuponconjecture，asourfabulistdoeswhenhehasnothingmoresubstantialtoworkwith。ThenweeasilyconjecturethatasthedaysdraggedbyHarriet’sheartgrewheavierandheavierunderitstwoburdens——shameandresentment：theshameofbeingpointedatandgossipedaboutasadesertedwife，andresentmentagainstthewomanwhohadbeguiledherhusbandfromherandnowkepthiminadisreputablecaptivity。Desertedwives——desertedwhetherforcauseorwithoutcause——findsmallcharityamongthevirtuousandthediscreet。
Weconjecturethatoneafteranothertheneighborsceasedtocall；thatoneafteranothertheygottobeing"engaged"whenHarrietcalled；thatfinallytheyoneaftertheothercutherdeadonthestreet；thatafterthatshestayedinthehousedaytimes，andbroodedoverhersorrows，andnighttimesdidthesame，therebeingnothingelsetodowiththeheavyhoursandthesilenceandsolitudeandthedrearyintervalswhichsleepshouldhavecharitablybridged，butdidn’t。
Yes，mischiefhadbeenwrought。Thebiographerarrivesatthisconclusion，anditisamostjustone。Then，justasyoubegintohalfhopeheisgoingtodiscoverthecauseofitandlaunchhotboltsofwrathattheguiltymanufacturersofit，youhavetoturnawaydisappointed。Youaredisappointed，andyousigh。Thisiswhathesays——theitalics[’’]aremine：
"Howeverthemischiefmayhavebeenwrought——’andatthisdaynoonecanwishtoheapblameananyburiedhead’——"
SoitispoorHarriet，afterall。Sternjusticemusttakeitscourse——
justicetemperedwithdelicacy，justicetemperedwithcompassion，justicethatpitiesaforlorndeadgirlandrefusestostrikeher。Exceptintheback。Willnotbeignobleandsaytheharshthing，butonlyinsinuateit。Sternjusticeknowsaboutthecarriageandthewet-nurseandthebonnet-shopandtheotherdarkthingsthatcausedthissadmischief，andmaynot，mustnotblinkthem；soitdeliversjudgmentwherejudgmentbelongs，butsoftenstheblowbynotseemingtodeliverjudgmentatall。
Toresume——theitalicsaremine：
"Howeverthemischiefmayhavebeenwrought——andatthisdaynoonecanwishtoheapblameonanyburiedhead——’itiscertainthatsomecauseorcausesofdeepdivisionbetweenShelleyandhiswifewereinoperationduringtheearlypartoftheyear1814’。"
Thisshowspenetration。Nodeductioncouldbemoreaccuratethanthis。
Therewereindeedsomecausesofdeepdivision。Butnextcomesanotherdisappointingsentence：
"Toguessattheprecisenatureofthesecafes，intheabsenceofdefinitestatement，wereuseless。"
Why，hehasalreadybeenguessingatthemforseveralpages，andwehavebeentryingtooutguesshim，andnowallofasuddenheistiredofitandwon’tplayanymore。Itisnotquitefairtous。However，hewillgetoverthisby-and-by，whenShelleycommitshisnextindiscretionandhastobeguessedoutofitatHarriet’sexpense。
"WemayrestcontentwithShelley’sownwords"——inaChancerypaperdrawnupbyhimthreeyearslater。Theywerethese："Delicacyforbidsmetosaymorethanthatweweredisunitedbyincurabledissensions。"
Asforme，Idonotquiteseewhyweshouldrestcontentwithanythingofthesort。Itisnotaverydefinitestatement。Itdoesnotnecessarilymeananythingmorethanthathedidnotwishtogointothetediousdetailsofthosefamilyquarrels。Delicacycouldquiteproperlyexcusehimfromsaying，"IwasinlovewithCorneliaallthattime；mywifekeptcryingandworryingaboutitandupbraidingmeandbeggingmetocutmyselffreefromaconnectionwhichwaswrongingheranddisgracingusboth；andIbeingstungbythesereproachesretortedwithfierceandbitterspeeches——foritismynaturetodothatwhenIamstirred，especiallyifthetargetofthemisapersonwhomIhadgreatlylovedandrespectedbefore，aswitnessmyvariousattitudestowardsMissHitchener，theGisbornes，Harriet’ssister，andothers——andfinallyIdidnotimprovethisstateofthingswhenIdesertedmywifeandspentawholemonthwiththewomanwhohadinfatuatedme。"
No，hecouldnotgointothosedetails，andweexcusehim；but，nevertheless，wedonotrestcontentwiththisblandpropositiontopuffawaythatwholelongdisreputableepisodewithasinglemean，meaninglessremarkofShelley’s。
Wedoadmitthat"itiscertainthatsomecauseorcausesofdeepdivisionwereinoperation。"Wewouldadmititjustthesameifthegrammarofthestatementwereasstraightasastring，forwedriftintoprettyindifferentgrammarourselveswhenweareabsorbedinhistoricalwork；butwehavetodeclinetoadmitthatwecannotguessthosecauseorcauses。
Butguessingisnotreallynecessary。Thereisevidenceattainable——
evidencefromthebatchdiscreditedbythebiographerandsetoutatthebackdoorinhisappendix-basket；andyetacourtoflawwouldthinktwicebeforethrowingitout，whereasitwouldbeahardypersonwhowouldventuretoofferinsuchaplaceagoodpartofthematerialwhichisplacedbeforethereadersofthisbookas"evidence，"andsotreatedbythisdaringbiographer。Amongsomeletters（intheappendix-basket）
fromMrs。Godwin，detailingtheGodwinianshareintheShelleyaneventsof1814，shetellshowHarrietShelleycametoherandherhusband，agitatedandweeping，toimplorethemtoforbidShelleythehouse，andpreventhisseeingMaryGodwin。
"SherelatedthatlastNovemberhehadfalleninlovewithMrs。
TurnerandpaidhersuchmarkedattentionsMr。Turner，thehusband，hadcarriedoffhiswifetoDevonshire。"
Thebiographerfindsatechnicalfaultinthis；"theShelleyswereinEdinburghinNovember。"Whatofthat？Thewomanisrecallingaconversationwhichismorethantwomonthsold；besides，shewasprobablymoreintentuponthecentralandimportantfactofitthanuponitsunimportantdate。Harriet’squotedstatementhassomesenseinit；forthatreason，iffornoother，itoughttohavebeenputinthebodyofthebook。Still，thatwouldnothaveanswered；eventhebiographer’senemycouldnotbecruelenoughtoaskhimtoletthisrealgrievance，thiscompactandsubstantialandpicturesquefigure，thisrawhead-and-
bloody-bones，comestridinginthereamongthosepaleshams，thosericketyspectreslabeledWET-NURSE，BONNET-SHOP，andsoon——no，thefatherofallmalicecouldnotaskthebiographertoexposehispatheticgoblinstoacompetitionlikethat。
Thefabulistfindsfaultwiththestatementbecauseithasatechnicalerrorinit；andhedoesthisatthemomentthatheisfurnishingusanerrorhimself，andofagraversort。Hesays：
"IfTurnercarriedoffhiswifetoDevonshirehebroughtherbackandShelleywasstayingwithherandhermotherontermsofcordialintimacyinMarch，1814。"
Weacceptthe"cordialintimacy"——itwastheverythingHarrietwascomplainingof——butthereisnothingtoshowthatitwasTurnerwhobroughthiswifeback。Thestatementisthrowninasifitwerenotonlytrue，butwasproofthatTurnerwasnotuneasy。Turner’smovementsareproofofnothing。NothingbutastatementfromTurner’smouthwouldhaveanyvaluehere，andhemadenone。
SixdaysafterwritinghisletterShelleyandhiswifeweretogetheragainforamoment——togetremarriedaccordingtotheritesoftheEnglishChurch。
Withinthreeweeksthenewhusbandandwifewereapartagain，andtheformerwasbackinhisodorousparadise。Thistimeitisthewifewhodoesthedeserting。ShefindsCorneliatoostrongforher，probably。
Atanyrate，shegoesawaywithherbabyandsister，andwehaveaplayfulflingatherfromgoodMrs。Boinville，the"mysteriousspinnerMaimuna"；shewhose"facewasasadamsel’sface，andyetherhairwasgray"；sheofwhomthebiographerhassaid，"Shelleywasindeedcaughtinanalmostinvisiblethreadspunaroundhim，butunconsciously，bythissubtleandbenignantenchantress。"ThesubtleandbenignantenchantresswritestoHogg，April18："Shelleyisagainawidower；hisbeauteoushalfwenttotownonThursday。"
ThenShelleywritesapoem——achantofgriefoverthehardfatewhichobligeshimnowtoleavehisparadiseandtakeupwithhiswifeagain。
Itseemstointimatethattheparadiseiscoolingtowardshim；thatheiswarnedoffbyacclamation；thathemustnotevenventuretotemptwithonelasttearhisfriendCornelia’sungentlemood，forhereyeisglazedandcoldanddaresnotentreatherlovertostay：
ExhibitE
"Pausenot！thetimeispast！Everyvoicecries’Away！’
Temptnotwithonelasttearthyfriend’sungentlemood；
Thylover’seye，soglazedandcold，daresnotentreatthystay：
Dutyandderelictionguidetheebacktosolitude。"
Backtothesolitudeofhisnowemptyhome，thatis！
"Away！away！tothysadandsilenthome；
Pourbittertearsonitsdesolatedhearth。"……
Buthewillhaverestinthegraveby-and-by。Untilthattimecomes，thecharmsofBracknellwillremaininhismemory，alongwithMrs。
Boinville’svoiceandCorneliaTurner’ssmile：
"Thouinthegraveshaltrest——yet，tillthephantomsfleeWhichthathouseandhearthandgardenmadedeartotheeerewhile，ThyremembranceandrepentanceanddeepmusingsarenotfreeFromthemusicoftwovoicesandthelightofonesweetsmile。"
WecannotwonderthatHarrietcouldnotstandit。Anyofuswouldhaveleft。Wewouldnotevenstaywithacatthatwasinthiscondition。
EventheBoinvillescouldnotendureit；andso，aswehaveseen，theygavethisonenotice。
"EarlyinMay，ShelleywasinLondon。HedidnotyetdespairofreconciliationwithHarriet，norhadheceasedtoloveher。"
Shelley’spoemsareagooddealoftroubletohisbiographer。Theyareconstantlyinsertedas"evidence，"andtheymakemuchconfusion。Assoonasoneofthemhasprovedonething，anotheronefollowsandprovesquiteadifferentthing。ThepoemjustquotedshowsthathewasinlovewithCornelia，butamonthlaterheisinlovewithHarrietagain，andthereisapoemtoproveit。
"InthispiteousappealShelleydeclaresthathehasnownogriefbutone——thegriefofhavingknownandlosthiswife’slove。"
ExhibitF
"ThylookoflovehaspowertocalmThestormiestpassionofmysoul。"
Butwithoutdoubtshehadbeenreservingherlooksofloveagoodpartofthetimefortenmonths，now——eversincehebegantolavishhisownonCorneliaTurnerattheendofthepreviousJuly。HedoesreallyseemtohavealreadyforgottenCornelia’smeritsinonebriefmonth，forheeulogizesHarrietinawaywhichrulesallcompetitionout：
"Thouonlyvirtuous，gentle，kind，Amidaworldofhate。"
Hecomplainsofherhardness，andbegshertomaketheconcessionofa"slightendurance"——ofhiswaywardness，perhaps——forthesakeof"afellow-being’slastingweal。"Butthemainforceofhisappealisinhisclosingstanza，andisstronglyworded：
"Otractforoncenoerringguide！
Bidtheremorselessfeelingflee；
’Tismalice，’tisrevenge，’tispride，’Tisanythingbutthee；
Ideignanoblerpridetoprove，Andpityifthoucanstnotlove。"
ThisisinMay——apparentlytowardstheendofit。HarrietandShelleywerecorrespondingallthetime。Harrietgotthepoem——acopyexistsinherownhandwriting；shebeingtheonlygentleandkindpersonamidaworldofhate，accordingtoShelley’sowntestimonyinthepoem，wearepermittedtothinkthatthedailyletterswouldpresentlyhavemeltedthatkindandgentleheartandbroughtaboutthereconciliation，iftherehadbeentimebuttherewasn’t；forinaveryfewdays——infact，beforethe8thofJune——Shelleywasinlovewithanotherwoman。
Andso——perhapswhileHarrietwaswalkingthefloornights，tryingtogetherpoembyheart——herhusbandwasdoingafreshone——fortheothergirl——MaryWollstonecraftGodwin——withsentimentsliketheseinit：
ExhibitG
Tospendyearsthusandberewarded，Asthou，sweetlove，requitedmeWhennonewerenear……thylipsdidmeetMinetremblingly；……，"Gentleandgoodandmildthouart，NorcanIliveifthouappearAughtbutthyself。"……
Andsoon。"BeforethecloseofJuneitwasknownandfeltbyMaryandShelleythateachwasinexpressiblydeartotheother。"Yes，Shelleyhadfoundthischildofsixteentohisliking，andhadwooedandwonherinthegraveyard。Butthatisnothing；itwasbetterthanwooingherinhernursery，atanyrate，whereitmighthavedisturbedtheotherchildren。
However，shewasachildinyearsonly。FromthedaythatshesethermasculinegriponShelleyhewastofrisknomore。IfshehadoccupiedtheonlykindandgentleHarriet’splaceinMarchitwouldhavebeenathrillingspectacletoseeherinvadetheBoinvillerookeryandreadtheriotact。ThatholidayofShelley’swouldhavebeenofshortduration，andCornelia’shairwouldhavebeenasgrayashermother’swhentheserviceswereover。
HoggwenttotheGodwinresidenceinSkinnerStreetwithShelleyonthat8thofJune。TheypassedthroughGodwin’slittledebt-factoryofabook-
shopandwentup-stairshuntingfortheproprietor。Nobodythere。
Shelleystrodeabouttheroomimpatiently，makingitscrazyfloorquakeunderhim。Thenadoor"waspartiallyandsoftlyopened。Athrillingvoicecalled’Shelley！’Athrillingvoiceanswered，’Mary！’Andhedartedoutoftheroomlikeanarrowfromthebowofthefar-shootingKing。Averyyoungfemale，fairandfair-haired，pale，indeed，andwithapiercinglook，wearingafrockoftartan，anunusualdressinLondonatthattime，hadcalledhimoutoftheroom。"
ThisisMaryGodwin，asdescribedbyHogg。ThethrillofthevoicesshowsthattheloveofShelleyandMarywasalreadyupwardofafortnightold；thereforeithadbeenbornwithinthemonthofMay——bornwhileHarrietwasstilltryingtogetherpoembyheart，wethink。ImustnotbeaskedhowIknowsomuchaboutthatthrill；itismysecret。ThebiographerandIhaveprivatewaysoffindingoutthingswhenitisnecessarytofindthemoutandthecustomarymethodsfail。
ShelleyleftLondonthatday，andwasgonetendays。ThebiographerconjecturesthathespentthisintervalwithHarrietinBath。Itwouldbejustlikehim。Totheendofhisdayshelikedtobeinlovewithtwowomenatonce。HewasmoreinlovewithMissHitchenerwhenhemarriedHarrietthanhewaswithHarriet，andtoldtheladysowithsimpleandunostentatiouscandor。HewasmoreinlovewithCorneliathanhewaswithHarrietintheendof1813andthebeginningof1814，yethesuppliedbothofthemwithlovepoemsofanequaltemperaturemeantime；
helovedMaryandHarrietinJune，andwhilegettingreadytorunoffwiththeone，itisconjecturedthatheputinhisoddtimetryingtogetreconciledtotheother；by-and-by，whilestillinlovewithMary，hewillmakelovetoherhalf-sisterbymarriage，adoption，andthevisitationofGod，throughthemediumofclandestineletters，andshewillanswerwithlettersthatarefornoeyebuthisown。
WhenShelleyencounteredMaryGodwinhewaslookingaroundforanotherparadise。Hehad，tastesofhisown，andtherewerefeaturesabouttheGodwinestablishmentthatstronglyrecommendedit。Godwinwasanadvancedthinkerandanablewriter。Oneofhisromancesisstillread，buthisphilosophicalworks，oncesoesteemed，areoutofvoguenow；
theirauthoritywasalreadydecliningwhenShelleymadehisacquaintance——thatis，itwasdecliningwiththepublic，butnotwithShelley。TheyhadbeenhismoralandpoliticalBible，andtheywerethatyet。ShelleytheinfidelwouldhimselfhaveclaimedtobelessaworkofGodthanaworkofGodwin。Godwin’sphilosophieshadformedhismindandinterwoventhemselvesintoitandbecomeapartofitstexture；heregardedhimselfasGodwin’sspiritualson。Godwinwasnotwithoutself-appreciation；
indeed，itmaybeconjecturedthatfromhispointofviewthelastsyllableofhisnamewassurplusage。Helivedsereneinhisloftyworldofphilosophy，farabovethemeanintereststhatabsorbedsmallermen，andonlycamedowntothegroundatintervalstopassthehatforalmstopayhisdebtswith，andinsultthemanthatrelievedhim。Severalofhisprincipleswereoutoftheordinary。Forexample，hewasopposedtomarriage。Hewasnotawarethathispreachingsfromthistextwerebuttheoryandwind；hesupposedhewasinearnestinimploringpeopletolivetogetherwithoutmarrying，untilShelleyfurnishedhimaworkingmodelofhisschemeandapracticalexampletoanalyze，byapplyingtheprincipleinhisownfamily；themattertookadifferentandsurprisingaspectthen。ThelateMatthewArnoldsaidthatthemaindefectinShelley’smake-upwasthathewasdestituteofthesenseofhumor。ThisepisodemusthaveescapedMr。Arnold’sattention。
Butwehavesaidenoughabouttheheadofthenewparadise。Mrs。Godwinisdescribedasbeinginseveralwaysaterror；andevenwhenhersoulwasinreposesheworegreenspectacles。ButIsuspectthathermainunattractivenesswasbornofthefactthatshewrotethelettersthatareoutintheappendix-basketinthebackyard——letterswhichareanoutrageandwhollyuntrustworthy，fortheysaysomekindthingsaboutpoorHarrietandtellsomedisagreeabletruthsaboutherhusband；andthesethingsmakethefabulistgrithisteethagooddeal。
NextwehaveFannyGodwin——aGodwinbycourtesyonly；shewasMrs。
Godwin’snaturaldaughterbyaformerfriend。Shewasasweetandwinninggirl，butshepresentlyweariedoftheGodwinparadise，andpoisonedherself。
LastinthelistisJane（orClaire，asshepreferredtocallherself）
Clairmont，daughterofMrs。Godwinbyaformermarriage。Shewasveryyoungandprettyandaccommodating，andalwaysreadytodowhatshecouldtomakethingspleasant。AfterShelleyranoffwithherpart-sisterMary，shebecametheguestofthepair，andcontributedanaturalchildtotheirnursery——Allegra。LordByronwasthefather。
WehavenamedtheseveralmembersandadvantagesofthenewparadiseinSkinnerStreet，withitscrazybook-shopunderneath。Shelleywasallrightnow，thiswasabetterplacethantheother；morevarietyanyway，andmoredifferentkindsoffragrance。Onecouldturnoutpoetryherewithoutanytroubleatall。
Thewaythenewlove-matchcameaboutwasthis：
ShelleytoldMaryallhisaggravationsandsorrowsandgriefs，andaboutthewet-nurseandthebonnetshopandthesurgeonandthecarriage，andthesister-in-lawthatblockedtheLondongame，andaboutCorneliaandhermamma，andhowtheyhadturnedhimoutofthehouseaftermakingsomuchofhim；andhowhehaddesertedHarrietandthenHarriethaddesertedhim，andhowthereconciliationwasworkingalongandHarrietgettingherpoembyheart；andstillhewasnothappy，andMarypitiedhim，forshehadhadtroubleherself。ButIamnotsatisfiedwiththis。
Itreadstoomuchlikestatistics。Itlackssmoothnessandgrace，andistooearthyandbusiness-like。Ithasthesordidlookofatrades-unionprocessionoutonstrike。Thatisnottherightformforit。Thebookdoesitbetter；wewillfallbackonthebookandhaveacake-walk：
"Itwaseasytodivinethatsomerestlessgriefpossessedhim；
Maryherselfwasnotunlearnedintheloreofpain。Hisgenerouszealinherfather’sbehalf，hisspiritualsonshiptoGodwin，hisreverenceforhermother’smemory，wereguaranteeswithMaryofhisexcellence。——[Whatshewasafterwasguaranteesofhisexcellence。Thathestoodreadytodeserthiswifeandchildwasoneofthem，apparently。]——Thenewfriendscouldnotlacksubjectsofdiscourse，andunderneaththeirwordsaboutMary’smother，and’PoliticalJustice，’and’RightsofWoman，’weretwoyounghearts，eachfeelingtowardstheother，eachperhapsunaware，tremblinginthedirectionoftheother。Thedesiretoassuagethesufferingofonewhosehappinesshasgrownprecioustousmaybecomeahungerofthespiritaskeenasanyother，andthishungernowpossessedMary’sheart；whenhereyesrestedunseenonShelley，itwaswithalookfulloftheardorofa’soothingpity。’"
Yes，thatisbetterandhasmorecomposure。Thatisjustthewayithappened。Hetoldheraboutthewet-nurse，shetoldhimaboutpoliticaljustice；hetoldheraboutthedeadlysister-in-law，shetoldhimabouthermother；hetoldheraboutthebonnet-shop，shemurmuredbackabouttherightsofwoman；thenheassuagedher，thensheassuagedhim；thenheassuagedhersomemore，nextsheassuagedhimsomemore；thentheybothassuagedoneanothersimultaneously；andsotheywentonbythehourassuagingandassuagingandassuaging，untilatlastwhatwastheresult？
Theywereinlove。Itwillhappensoeverytime。
"Hehadmarriedawomanwho，ashenowpersuadedhimself，hadnevertrulylovedhim，wholovedonlyhisfortuneandhisrank，andwhoprovedherselfishnessbydesertinghiminhismisery。"
IthinkthatthatisnotquitefairtoHarriet。WehavenocertaintythatsheknewCorneliahadturnedhimoutofthehouse。HewentbacktoCornelia，andHarrietmayhavesupposedthathewasashappywithherasever。Still，itwasjudicioustobegintolayonthewhitewash，forShelleyisgoingtoneedmanyacoatofitnow，andthesoonerthereaderbecomesusedtotheintrusionofthebrushthesoonerhewillgetreconciledtoitandstopfrettingaboutit。
AfterShelley’s（conjectured）visittoHarrietatBath——8thofJuneto18th——"itseemstohavebeenarrangedthatShelleyshouldhenceforthjointheSkinnerStreethouseholdeachdayatdinner。"
Nothingcouldbehandierthanthis；thingswillswimalongnow。
"AlthoughnowShelleywascomingtobelievethathisweddedunionwithHarrietwasathingofthepast，hehadnotceasedtoregardherwithaffectionateconsideration；hewrotetoherfrequently，andkeptherinformedofhiswhereabouts。"
WemustnotgetimpatientoverthesecuriousinharmoniousnessesandirreconcilabilitiesinShelley’scharacter。Youcanseebythebiographer’sattitudetowardsthemthatthereisnothingobjectionableaboutthem。Shelleywasdoinghisbesttomaketwoadoringyoungcreatureshappy：hewasregardingtheonewithaffectionateconsiderationbymail，andhewasassuagingtheotheroneathome。
"UnhappyHarriet，residingatBath，hadperhapsneverdesiredthatthebreachbetweenherselfandherhusbandshouldbeirreparableandcomplete。"
Ifindnofaultwiththatsentenceexceptthatthe"perhaps"isnotstrictlywarranted。Itshouldhavebeenleftout。Insupport——orshallwesayextenuation？——ofthisopinionIsubmitthatthereisnotsufficientevidencetowarranttheuncertaintywhichitimplies。Theonly"evidence"offeredthatHarrietwashardandproudandstandingoutagainstareconciliationisapoem——thepoeminwhichShelleybeseechesherto"bidtheremorselessfeelingflee"and"pity"ifshe"cannotlove。"Wehavejustthatas"evidence，"andoutofitsmeagrematerialsthebiographerbuildsacobhouseofconjecturesasbigastheColiseum；
conjectureswhichconvincehim，theprosecutingattorney，butoughttofallfarshortofconvincinganyfair-mindedjury。
Shelley’slove-poemsmaybeverygoodevidence，butweknowwellthattheyare"goodforthisdayandtrainonly。"Weareabletobelievethattheyspokethetruthforthatoneday，butweknowbyexperiencethattheycouldnotbedependedontospeakitthenext。TheverysupplicationforarewarmingofHarriet’schilledlovewasfollowedsosuddenlybythepoet’splungeintoanadoringpassionforMaryGodwinthatifithadbeenacheckitwouldhavelostitsvaluebeforealazypersoncouldhavegottentothebankwithit。
Hardness，stubbornness，pride，vindictiveness——thesemaysometimesresideinayoungwifeandmotherofnineteen，buttheyarenotchargedagainstHarrietShelleyoutsideofthatpoem，andonehasnorighttoinsertthemintohercharacteronsuchshadowy"evidence"asthat。PeacockknewHarrietwell，andshehasaflexibleandpersuadablelook，aspaintedbyhim：
"Hermannersweregood，andherwholeaspectanddemeanorsuchmanifestemanationsofpureandtruthfulnaturethattobeonceinhercompanywastoknowherthoroughly。Shewasfondofherhusband，andaccommodatedherselfineverywaytohistastes。
Iftheymixedinsociety，sheadornedit；iftheylivedinretirement，shewassatisfied；iftheytravelled，sheenjoyedthechangeofscene。"
"Perhaps"shehadneverdesiredthatthebreachshouldbeirreparableandcomplete。Thetruthis，wedonotevenknowthattherewasanybreachatallatthistime。Weknowthatthehusbandandwifewentbeforethealtarandtookanewoathonthe24thofMarchtoloveandcherisheachotheruntildeath——andthismayberegardedasasortofreconciliationitself，andawipingoutoftheoldgrudges。ThenHarrietwentaway，andthesister-in-lawremovedherselffromhersociety。ThatwasinApril。
Shelleywrotehis"appeal"inMay，butthecorrespondingwentrightalongafterwards。Wehavearighttodoubtthatthesubjectofitwasa"reconciliation，"orthatHarriethadanysuspicionthatsheneededtobereconciledandthatherhusbandwastryingtopersuadehertoit——asthebiographerhassoughttomakeusbelieve，withhisColiseumofconjecturesbuiltoutofawaste-basketofpoetry。Forwehave"evidence"now——notpoetryandconjecture。WhenShelleyhadbeendiningdailyintheSkinnerStreetparadisefifteendaysandcontinuingthelove-matchwhichwasalreadyafortnightoldtwenty-fivedaysearlier，heforgottowriteHarriet；forgotitthenextdayandthenext。DuringfourdaysHarrietgotnoletterfromhim。Thenherfrightandanxietyrosetoexpression-heat，andshewrotealettertoShelley’spublisherwhichseemstorevealtousthatShelley’sletterstoherhadbeenthecustomaryaffectionatelettersofhusbandtowife，andhadcarriednoappealsforreconciliationandhadnotneededto：
"BATH（postmarkJuly7，1814）。
"MYDEARSIR，——YouwillgreatlyobligemebygivingtheenclosedtoMr。Shelley。Iwouldnottroubleyou，butitisnowfourdayssinceIhaveheardfromhim，whichtomeisanage。Willyouwritebyreturnofpostandtellmewhathasbecomeofhim？asIalwaysfancysomethingdreadfulhashappenedifIdonothearfromhim。IfyoutellmethatheiswellIshallnotcometoLondon，butifIdonothearfromyouorhimIshallcertainlycome，asIcannotendurethisdreadfulstateofsuspense。Youarehisfriendandyoucanfeelforme。
"Iremainyourstruly，"H。S。"
EvenwithoutPeacock’stestimonythat"herwholeaspectanddemeanorweremanifestemanationsofapureandtruthfulnature，"weshouldholdthistobeatruthfulletter，asincereletter，alovingletter；itbearsthosemarks；Ithinkitisalsotheletterofapersonaccustomedtoreceivinglettersfromherhusbandfrequently，andthattheyhavebeenofawelcomeandsatisfactorysort，too，thislongtimeback——eversincethesolemnremarriageandreconciliationatthealtarmostlikely。
ThebiographerfollowsHarriet’sletterwithaconjecture。
Heconjecturesthatshe"wouldnowgladlyhaveretracedhersteps。"
Whichmeansthatitisproventhatshehadstepstoretrace——provenbythepoem。Well，ifthepoemisbetterevidencethantheletter，wemustletitstandatthat。
ThenthebiographerattacksHarrietShelley’shonor——byauthorityofrandomandunverifiedgossipscavengeredfromagroupofpeoplewhoseverynamesmakeapersonshudder：MaryGodwin，mistresstoShelley；herpart-sister，discardedmistressofLordByron；Godwin，thephilosophicaltramp，whogathershisshareofitfromashadow——thatistosay，fromapersonwhomheshirksoutofnaming。Yetthebiographerdignifiesthissorryrubbishwiththenameof"evidence。"
Nothingremotelyresemblingadistinctchargefromanamedpersonprofessingtoknowisofferedamongthisprecious"evidence。"
1。"Shelleybelieved"soandso。
2。Byron’sdiscardedmistresssaysthatShelleytoldMaryGodwinsoandso，andMarytoldher。
3。"Shelleysaid"soandso——andlater"admittedoverandoveragainthathehadbeeninerror。"
4。TheunspeakableGodwin"wrotetoMr。Baxter"thatheknewsoandso"fromunquestionableauthority"——namenotfurnished。
How-anymaninhisrightmindcouldbringhimselftodefilethegraveofashamefullyabusedanddefencelessgirlwiththesebaselessfabrications，thismanufacturedfilth，isinconceivable。Howanyman，inhisrightmindoroutofit，couldsitdownandcoldlytrytopersuadeanybodytobelieveit，orlistenpatientlytoit，or，indeed，doanythingbutscoffatitandderideit，isastonishing。
Thechargeinsinuatedbytheseodiousslandersisoneofthemostdifficultofalloffencestoprove；itisalsoonewhichnomanhasarighttomentioneveninawhisperaboutanywoman，livingordead，unlessheknowsittobetrue，andnoteventhenunlesshecanalsoproveittobetrue。Thereisnojustificationfortheabominationofputtingthisstuffinthebook。
AgainstHarrietShelley’sgoodnamethereisnotonescrapoftarnishingevidence，andnotevenascrapofevilgossip，thatcomesfromasourcethatentitlesittoahearing。
Onthecreditsideoftheaccountwehavestrongopinionsfromthepeoplewhoknewherbest。Peacocksays：
"IfeelitduetothememoryofHarriettostatemymostdecidedconvictionthatherconductasawifewasaspure，astrue，asabsolutelyfaultless，asthatofanywhoforsuchconductareheldmostinhonor。"
ThorntonHunt，whohadpickedandpublishedslightflawsinHarriet’scharacter，says，asregardsthisallegedlargeone：
"ThereisnotatraceofevidenceorawhisperofscandalagainstherbeforehervoluntarydeparturefromShelley。"
Trelawneysays：
"IwasassuredbytheevidenceofthefewfriendswhoknewbothShelleyandhiswife——Hookham，Hogg，Peacock，andoneoftheGodwins——thatHarrietwasperfectlyinnocentofalloffence。"
Whatexcusewasthereforrakingupaparceloffoulrumorsfrommaliciousanddiscreditedsourcesandflingingthematthisdeadgirl’shead？Herverydefencelessnessshouldhavebeenherprotection。Thefactthatallletterstoherorabouther，withalmosteveryscrapofherownwriting，hadbeendiligentlymislaid，leavinghercasedestituteofavoice，whileeverypen-strokewhichcouldhelpherhusband’ssidehadbeenasdiligentlypreserved，shouldhaveexcusedherfrombeingbroughttotrial。Herwitnesseshavealldisappeared，yetweseehersummonedinhergrave-clothestopleadforthelifeofhercharacter，withoutthehelpofanadvocate，beforeadisqualifiedjudgeandapackedjury。
HarrietShelleywroteherdistressedletteronthe7thofJuly。Onthe28thherhusbandranawaywithMaryGodwinandherpart-sisterClairetotheContinent。Hedesertedhiswifewhenherconfinementwasapproaching。SheborehimachildattheendofNovember，hismistressborehimanotheronesomethingovertwomonthslater。ThetruantswerebackinLondonbeforeeitheroftheseeventsoccurred。
Ononeoccasion，presently，Shelleywassopressedformoneytosupporthismistresswiththathewenttohiswifeandgotsomemoneyofhisthatwasinherhands——twentypounds。Yetthemistresswasnotmovedtogratitude；forlater，whenthewifewastroubledtomeetherengagements，themistressmakesthisentryinherdiary：
"Harrietsendshercreditorshere；nastywoman。Nowweshallhavetochangeourlodgings。"
Thedesertedwifeborethebitternessandobloquyofhersituationtwoyearsandaquarter；thenshegaveup，anddrownedherself。Amonthafterwardsthebodywasfoundinthewater。ThreeweekslaterShelleymarriedhismistress。
Imustherebeallowedtoitalicizearemarkofthebiographer’sconcerningHarrietShelley：
"ThatnoactofShelley’sduringthetwoyearswhichimmediatelyprecededherdeathtendedtocausetherashactwhichbroughtherlifetoitscloseseemscertain。"
Yetherhusbandhaddesertedherandherchildren，andwaslivingwithaconcubineallthattime！Whyshouldapersonattempttowritebiographywhenthesimplestfactshavenomeaningtohim？Thisbookislitteredwithascrassstupiditiesasthatone——deductionsbythepagewhichbearnodiscoverablekinshiptotheirpremises。
Thebiographerthrowsoffthatextraordinaryremarkwithoutanyperceptibledisturbancetohisserenity；forhefollowsitwithasentimentaljustificationofShelley’sconductwhichhasnotapangofconscienceinit，butissilkyandsmoothandundulatingandpious——
acake-walkwithallthecoloredbrethrenattheirbest。Theremaybepeoplewhocanreadthatpageandkeeptheirtemper，butitisdoubtful。
Shelley’slifehastheoneindelibleblotuponit，butisotherwiseworshipfullynobleandbeautiful。Itevenstandsoutindestructiblygraciousandlovelyfromtheruckofthesedisastrouspages，inspiteofthefactthattheyexposeandestablishhisresponsibilityforhisforsakenwife’spitifulfate——aresponsibilitywhichhehimselftacitlyadmitsinalettertoElizaWestbrook，whereinhereferstohistakingupwithMaryGodwinasanactwhichEliza"mightexcusablyregardasthecauseofhersister’sruin。"