"Youhaveamotiveforkillinghim,"saidFisher。
  Thedukecontinuedtostare,butheseemedunabletospeak。
  "Ihopeyouhadamotiveforkillinghim,"continuedFisher,mildly。"Yousee,it’sratheracurioussituation。
  Ifyouhaveamotiveformurdering,youprobablydidn’tmurder。Butifyouhadn’tanymotive,why,thenperhaps,youdid。"
  "Whatonearthareyoutalkingabout?"demandedtheduke,violently。
  "It’squitesimple,"saidFisher。"Whenyouwentacrosshewaseitheraliveordead。Ifhewasalive,itmightbeyouwhokilledhim,orwhyshouldyouhaveheldyourtongueabouthisdeath?Butifhewasdead,andyouhadareasonforkillinghim,youmighthaveheldyourtongueforfearofbeingaccused。"Thenafterasilenceheadded,abstractedly:"Cyprusisabeautifulplace,Ibelieve。Romanticsceneryandromanticpeople。Veryintoxicatingforayoungman。"
  Thedukesuddenlyclenchedhishandsandsaid,thickly,"Well,Ihadamotive。"
  "Thenyou’reallright,"saidFisher,holdingouthishandwithanairofhugerelief。"Iwasprettysureyouwouldn’treallydoit;youhadafrightwhenyousawitdone,aswasonlynatural。Likeabaddreamcometrue,wasn’tit?"
  Whilethiscuriousconversationwaspassing,Harkerhadgoneintothehouse,disregardingthedemonstrationsofthesulkynephew,andcamebackpresentlywithanewairofanimationandasheafofpapersinhishand。
  "I’vetelephonedforthepolice,"hesaid,stoppingtospeaktoFisher,"butIthinkI’vedonemostoftheirworkforthem。IbelieveI’vefoundoutthetruth。
  There’sapaperhere——"Hestopped,forFisherwaslookingathimwithasingularexpression;anditwasFisherwhospokenext:
  "Arethereanypapersthatarenotthere,I
  wonder?Imeanthatarenottherenow?"Afterapauseheadded:"Letushavethecardsonthetable。
  Whenyouwentthroughhispapersinsuchahurry,Harker,weren’tyoulookingforsomethingto——tomakesureitshouldn’tbefound?"
  Harkerdidnotturnaredhaironhishardhead,buthelookedattheotheroutofthecornersofhiseyes。
  "AndIsuppose,"wentonFisher,smoothly,"thatiswhyyou,too,toldusliesabouthavingfoundHookalive。Youknewtherewassomethingtoshowthatyoumighthavekilledhim,andyoudidn’tdaretellushewaskilled。But,believeme,it’smuchbettertobehonestnow。"
  Harker’shaggardfacesuddenlylitupasifwithinfernalflames。
  "Honest,"hecried,"it’snotsodamnedfineofyoufellowstobehonest。You’reallbornwithsilverspoonsinyourmouths,andthenyouswaggeraboutwitheverlastingvirtuebecauseyouhaven’tgototherpeople’sspoonsinyourpockets。ButIwasborninaPimlicolodginghouseandIhadtomakemyspoon,andthere’dbeplentytosayIonlyspoiledahornoranhonestman。Andifastrugglingmanstaggersabitoverthelineinhisyouth,inthelowerpartsofthelawwhichareprettydingy,anyhow,there’salwayssomeoldvampiretohangontohimallhislifeforit。"
  "GuatemalanGolcondas,wasn’tit?"saidFisher,sympathetically。
  Harkersuddenlyshuddered。Thenhesaid,"I
  believeyoumustknoweverything,likeGodAlmighty。"
  "Iknowtoomuch,"saidHorneFisher,"andallthewrongthings。"
  Theotherthreemenweredrawingnearertothem,butbeforetheycametoonear,Harkersaid,inavoicethathadrecoveredallitsfirmness:
  "Yes,Ididdestroyapaper,butIreallydidfindapaper,too;andIbelievethatitclearsusall。"
  "Verywell,"saidFisher,inalouderandmorecheerfultone;"letusallhavethebenefitofit。"
  "OntheverytopofSirIsaac’spapers,"explainedHarker,"therewasathreateningletterfromamannamedHugo。Itthreatenstokillourunfortunatefriendverymuchinthewaythathewasactuallykilled。Itisawildletter,fulloftaunts;youcanseeitforyourselves;butitmakesaparticularpointofpoorHook’shabitoffishingfromtheisland。Aboveall,themanprofessestobewritingfromaboat。And,sincewealonewentacrosstohim,"andhesmiledinaratheruglyfashion,"thecrimemusthavebeencommittedbyamanpassinginaboat。"
  "Why,dearme!"criedtheduke,withsomethingalmostamountingtoanimation。"Why,IrememberthemancalledHugoquitewell!HewasasortofbodyservantandbodyguardofSirIsaac。Yousee,SirIsaacwasinsomefearofassault。Hewas——hewasnotverypopularwithseveralpeople。Hugowasdischargedaftersomeroworother;butIrememberhimwell。
  HewasagreatbigHungarianfellowwithgreatmustachesthatstoodoutoneachsideofhisface。"
  AdooropenedinthedarknessofHaroldMarch’smemory,or,rather,oblivion,andshowedashininglandscape,likethatofalostdream。Itwasratherawaterscapethanalandscape,athingoffloodedmeadowsandlowtreesandthedarkarchwayofabridge。Andforoneinstanthesawagainthemanwithmustacheslikedarkhornsleapupontothebridgeanddisappear。
  "Goodheavens!"hecried。"Why,Imetthemurdererthismorning!"
  HorneFisherandHaroldMarchhadtheirdayontheriver,afterall,forthelittlegroupbrokeupwhenthepolicearrived。TheydeclaredthatthecoincidenceofMarch’sevidencehadclearedthewholecompany,andclinchedthecaseagainsttheflyingHugo。
  WhetherthatHungarianfugitivewouldeverbecaughtappearedtoHorneFishertobehighlydoubtful;norcanitbepretendedthathedisplayedanyverydemoniacdetectiveenergyinthematterasheleanedbackintheboatcushions,smoking,andwatchingtheswayingreedsslidepast。
  "Itwasaverygoodnotiontohopupontothebridge,"hesaid。"Anemptyboatmeansverylittle;hehasn’tbeenseentolandoneitherbank,andhe’swalkedoffthebridgewithoutwalkingontoit,sotospeak。He’sgottwenty—fourhours’start;hismustacheswilldisappear,andthenhewilldisappear。
  Ithinkthereiseveryhopeofhisescape。"
  "Hope?"repeatedMarch,andstoppedscullingforaninstant。
  "Yes,hope,"repeatedtheother。"Tobeginwith,I’mnotgoingtobeexactlyconsumedwithCorsicanrevengebecausesomebodyhaskilledHook。PerhapsyoumayguessbythistimewhatHookwas。A
  damnedblood—suckingblackmailerwasthatsimple,strenuous,self—madecaptainofindustry。Hehadsecretsagainstnearlyeverybody;oneagainstpooroldWestmorelandaboutanearlymarriageinCyprusthatmighthaveputtheduchessinaqueerposition;
  andoneagainstHarkeraboutsomeflutterwithhisclient’smoneywhenhewasayoungsolicitor。That’swhytheywenttopieceswhentheyfoundhimmurdered,ofcourse。Theyfeltasifthey’ddoneitinadream。ButIadmitIhaveanotherreasonfornotwantingourHungarianfriendactuallyhangedforthemurder。"
  "Andwhatisthat?"askedhisfriend。
  "Onlythathedidn’tcommitthemurder,"answeredFisher。
  HaroldMarchlaiddowntheoarsandlettheboatdriftforamoment。
  "Doyouknow,Iwashalfexpectingsomethinglikethat,"hesaid。"Itwasquiteirrational,butitwashangingaboutintheatmosphere,likethunderintheair。"
  "Onthecontrary,it’sfindingHugoguiltythat’sirrational,"repliedFisher。"Don’tyouseethatthey’recondemninghimfortheveryreasonforwhichtheyacquiteverybodyelse?HarkerandWestmorelandweresilentbecausetheyfoundhimmurdered,andknewtherewerepapersthatmadethemlooklikethemurderers。Well,sodidHugofindhimmurdered,andsodidHugoknowtherewasapaperthatwouldmakehimlooklikethemurderer。Hehadwrittenithimselfthedaybefore。"
  "Butinthatcase,"saidMarch,frowning,"atwhatsortofunearthlyhourinthemorningwasthemurderreallycommitted?ItwasbarelydaylightwhenImethimatthebridge,andthat’ssomewayabovetheisland。"
  "Theanswerisverysimple,"repliedFisher。"Thecrimewasnotcommittedinthemorning。Thecrimewasnotcommittedontheisland。"
  Marchstaredattheshiningwaterwithoutreplying,butFisherresumedlikeonewhohadbeenaskedaquestion:
  "Everyintelligentmurderinvolvestakingadvantageofsomeoneuncommonfeatureinacommonsituation。ThefeatureherewasthefancyofoldHookforbeingthefirstmanupeverymorning,hisfixedroutineasanangler,andhisannoyanceatbeingdisturbed。Themurdererstrangledhiminhisownhouseafterdinneronthenightbefore,carriedhiscorpse,withallhisfishingtackle,acrossthestreaminthedeadofnight,tiedhimtothetree,andlefthimthereunderthestars。Itwasadeadmanwhosatfishingthereallday。Thenthemurdererwentbacktothehouse,or,rather,tothegarage,andwentoffinhismotorcar。Themurdererdrovehisownmotorcar。"
  Fisherglancedathisfriend’sfaceandwenton。
  "Youlookhorrified,andthethingishorrible。Butotherthingsarehorrible,too。Ifsomeobscuremanhadbeenhag—riddenbyablackmailerandhadhisfamilyliferuined,youwouldn’tthinkthemurderofhispersecutorthemostinexcusableofmurders。Isitanyworsewhenawholegreatnationissetfreeaswellasafamily?BythiswarningtoSwedenweshallprobablypreventwarandnotprecipitateit,andsavemanythousandlivesrathermorevaluablethanthelifeofthatviper。Oh,I’mnottalkingsophistryorseriouslyjustifyingthething,buttheslaverythatheldhimandhiscountrywasathousandtimeslessjustifiable。IfI’dreallybeensharpIshouldhaveguesseditfromhissmooth,deadlysmilingatdinnerthatnight。DoyourememberthatsillytalkabouthowoldIsaaccouldalwaysplayhisfish?Inaprettyhellishsensehewasafisherofmen。"
  HaroldMarchtooktheoarsandbegantorowagain。
  "Iremember,"hesaid,"andabouthowabigfishmightbreakthelineandgetaway。"
  VI。THEHOLEINTHEWALL
  Twomen,theoneanarchitectandtheotheranarchaeologist,metonthestepsofthegreathouseatPrior’sPark;andtheirhost,LordBulmer,inhisbreezyway,thoughtitnaturaltointroducethem。Itmustbeconfessedthathewashazyaswellasbreezy,andhadnoveryclearconnectioninhismind,beyondthesensethatanarchitectandanarchaeologistbeginwiththesameseriesofletters。Theworldmustremaininareverentdoubtastowhetherhewould,onthesameprinciples,havepresentedadiplomatisttoadipsomaniacoraratiocinatortoaratcatcher。Hewasabig,fair,bull—neckedyoungman,aboundinginoutwardgestures,unconsciouslyflappinghisglovesandflourishinghisstick。
  "Youtwooughttohavesomethingtotalkabout,"
  hesaid,cheerfully。"Oldbuildingsandallthatsortofthing;thisisratheranoldbuilding,bytheway,thoughIsayitwhoshouldn’t。Imustaskyoutoexcusemeamoment;I’vegottogoandseeaboutthecardsforthisChristmasrompmysister’sarranging。Wehopetoseeyouallthere,ofcourse。Julietwantsittobeafancy—dressaffair——abbotsandcrusadersandallthat。
  Myancestors,Isuppose,afterall。"
  "Itrusttheabbotwasnotanancestor,"saidthearchaeologicalgentleman,withasmile。
  "Onlyasortofgreat—uncle,Iimagine,"answeredtheother,laughing;thenhisratherramblingeyerolledroundtheorderedlandscapeinfrontofthehouse;anartificialsheetofwaterornamentedwithanantiquatednymphinthecenterandsurroundedbyaparkoftalltreesnowgrayandblackandfrosty,foritwasinthedepthofaseverewinter。
  "It’sgettingjollycold,"hislordshipcontinued。"Mysisterhopesweshallhavesomeskatingaswellasdancing。"
  "Ifthecrusaderscomeinfullarmor,"saidtheother,"youmustbecarefulnottodrownyourancestors。"
  "Oh,there’snofearofthat,"answeredBulmer;
  "thispreciouslakeofoursisnottwofeetdeepanywhere。"Andwithoneofhisflourishinggestureshestuckhisstickintothewatertodemonstrateitsshallowness。Theycouldseetheshortendbentinthewater,sothatheseemedforamomenttoleanhislargeweightonabreakingstaff。
  "Theworstyoucanexpectistoseeanabbotsitdownrathersuddenly,"headded,turningaway。
  "Well,aurevoir;I’llletyouknowaboutitlater。"
  Thearchaeologistandthearchitectwereleftonthegreatstonestepssmilingateachother;
  butwhatevertheircommoninterests,theypresentedaconsiderablepersonalcontrast,andthefancifulmightevenhavefoundsomecontradictionineachconsideredindividually。Theformer,aMr。
  JamesHaddow,camefromadrowsydenintheInnsofCourt,fullofleatherandparchment,forthelawwashisprofessionandhistoryonlyhishobby;hewasindeed,amongotherthings,thesolicitorandagentofthePrior’sParkestate。Buthehimselfwasfarfromdrowsyandseemedremarkablywideawake,withshrewdandprominentblueeyes,andredhairbrushedasneatlyashisveryneatcostume。Thelatter,whosenamewasLeonardCrane,camestraightfromacrudeandalmostcockneyofficeofbuildersandhouseagentsintheneighboringsuburb,sunningitselfattheendofanewrowofjerry—builthouseswithplansinverybrightcolorsandnoticesinverylargeletters。Butaseriousobserver,atasecondglance,mighthaveseeninhiseyessomethingofthatshiningsleepthatiscalledvision;andhisyellowhair,whilenotaffectedlylong,wasunaffectedlyuntidy。
  Itwasamanifestifmelancholytruththatthearchitectwasanartist。Buttheartistictemperamentwasfarfromexplaininghim;therewassomethingelseabouthimthatwasnotdefinable,butwhichsomeevenfelttobedangerous。
  Despitehisdreaminess,hewouldsometimessurprisehisfriendswithartsandevensportsapartfromhisordinarylife,likememoriesofsomepreviousexistence。Onthisoccasion,nevertheless,hehastenedtodisclaimanyauthorityontheotherman’shobby。
  "Imustn’tappearonfalsepretences,"hesaid,withasmile。"Ihardlyevenknowwhatanarchaeologistis,exceptthataratherrustyremnantofGreeksuggeststhatheisamanwhostudiesoldthings。"
  "Yes,"repliedHaddow,grimly。"Anarchaeologistisamanwhostudiesoldthingsandfindstheyarenew。"
  Cranelookedathimsteadilyforamomentandthensmiledagain。
  "Dareonesuggest,"hesaid,"thatsomeofthethingswehavebeentalkingaboutareamongtheoldthingsthatturnoutnottobeold?"
  Hiscompanionalsowassilentforamoment,andthesmileonhisruggedfacewasfainterashereplied,quietly:
  "Thewallroundtheparkisreallyold。TheonegateinitisGothic,andIcannotfindanytraceofdestructionorrestoration。Butthehouseandtheestategenerally——welltheromanticideasreadintothesethingsareoftenratherrecentromances,thingsalmostlikefashionablenovels。Forinstance,theverynameofthisplace,Prior’sPark,makeseverybodythinkofitasamoonlitmediaevalabbey;I
  daresaythespiritualistsbythistimehavediscoveredtheghostofamonkthere。But,accordingtotheonlyauthoritativestudyofthematterIcanfind,theplacewassimplycalledPrior’sasanyruralplaceiscalledPodger’s。ItwasthehouseofaMr。Prior,afarmhouse,probably,thatstoodhereatsometimeorotherandwasalocallandmark。Oh,thereareagreatmanyexamplesofthesamething,hereandeverywhereelse。Thissuburbofoursusedtobeavillage,andbecausesomeofthepeopleslurredthenameandpronounceditHolliwell,manyaminorpoetindulgedinfanciesaboutaHolyWell,withspellsandfairiesandalltherestofit,fillingthesuburbandrawing—roomswiththeCeltictwilight。Whereasanyoneacquaintedwiththefactsknowsthat’Hollinwall’simplymeans’theholeinthewall,’andprobablyreferredtosomequitetrivialaccident。
  That’swhatImeanwhenIsaythatwedon’tsomuchfindoldthingsaswefindnewones。"
  Craneseemedtohavegrownsomewhatinattentivetothelittlelectureonantiquitiesandnovelties,andthecauseofhisrestlessnesswassoonapparent,andindeedapproaching。LordBulmer’ssister,JulietBray,wascomingslowlyacrossthelawn,accompaniedbyonegentlemanandfollowedbytwoothers。Theyoungarchitectwasintheillogicalconditionofmindinwhichhepreferredthreetoone。
  ThemanwalkingwiththeladywasnootherthantheeminentPrinceBorodino,whowasatleastasfamousasadistinguisheddiplomatistoughttobe,intheinterestsofwhatiscalledsecretdiplomacy。HehadbeenpayingaroundofvisitsatvariousEnglishcountryhouses,andexactlywhathewasdoingfordiplomacyatPrior’sParkwasasmuchasecretasanydiplomatistcoulddesire。Theobviousthingtosayofhisappearancewasthathewouldhavebeenextremelyhandsomeifhehadnotbeenentirelybald。
  But,indeed,thatwoulditselfbearatherbaldwayofputtingit。Fantasticasitsounds,itwouldfitthecasebettertosaythatpeoplewouldhavebeensurprisedtoseehairgrowingonhim;assurprisedasiftheyhadfoundhairgrowingonthebustofaRomanemperor。Histallfigurewasbuttonedupinatight—waistedfashionthatratheraccentuatedhispotentialbulk,andheworearedflowerinhisbuttonhole。Ofthetwomenwalkingbehindonewasalsobald,butinamorepartialandalsoamoreprematurefashion,forhisdroopingmustachewasstillyellow,andifhiseyesweresomewhatheavyitwaswithlanguorandnotwithage。ItwasHorneFisher,andhewastalkingaseasilyandidlyabouteverythingashealwaysdid。Hisalwaysdid。Hiscompanionwasamorestriking,andevenmorecompanionwasamorestriking,andevenmoresinister,figure,andhehadtheaddedimportanceofbeingLordBulmer’soldestandmostintimatefriend。
  HewasgenerallyknownwithaseveresimplicityasMr。Brain;butitwasunderstoodthathehadbeenajudgeandpoliceofficialinIndia,andthathehadenemies,whohadrepresentedhismeasuresagainstcrimeasthemselvesalmostcriminal。Hewasabrownskeletonofamanwithdark,deep,sunkeneyesandablackmustachethathidthemeaningofhismouth。Thoughhehadthelookofonewastedbysometropicaldisease,hismovementsweremuchmorealertthanthoseofhisloungingcompanion。
  "It’sallsettled,"announcedthelady,withgreatanimation,whentheycamewithinhailingdistance。
  "You’veallgottoputonmasqueradethingsandverylikelyskatesaswell,thoughtheprincesaystheydon’tgowithit;butwedon’tcareaboutthat。It’sfreezingalready,andwedon’toftengetsuchachanceinEngland。"
  "EveninIndiawedon’texactlyskatealltheyearround,"observedMr。Brain。
  "AndevenItalyisnotprimarilyassociatedwithice,"saidtheItalian。
  "Italyisprimarilyassociatedwithices,"remarkedMr。HorneFisher。"Imeanwithicecreammen。
  MostpeopleinthiscountryimaginethatItalyisentirelypopulatedwithicecreammenandorgangrinders。Therecertainlyarealotofthem;perhapsthey’reaninvadingarmyindisguise。"
  "Howdoyouknowtheyarenotthesecretemissariesofourdiplomacy?"askedtheprince,withaslightlyscornfulsmile。"Anarmyoforgangrindersmightpickuphints,andtheirmonkeysmightpickupallsortofthings。"
  "Theorgansareorganizedinfact,"saidtheflippantMr。Fisher。"Well,I’veknownitprettycoldbeforenowinItalyandeveninIndia,upontheHimalayanslopes。Theiceonourownlittleroundpondwillbequitecozybycomparison。"
  JulietBraywasanattractiveladywithdarkhairandeyebrowsanddancingeyes,andtherewasagenialityandevengenerosityinherratherimperiousways。Inmostmattersshecouldcommandherbrother,thoughthatnobleman,likemanyothermenofvagueideas,wasnotwithoutatouchofthebullywhenhewasatbay。Shecouldcertainlycommandherguests,eventotheextentofdeckingoutthemostrespectableandreluctantofthemwithhermediaevalmasquerade。Anditreallyseemedasifshecouldcommandtheelementsalso,likeawitch。Fortheweathersteadilyhardenedandsharpened;thatnighttheiceofthelake,glimmeringinthemoonlight,waslikeamarblefloor,andtheyhadbeguntodanceandskateonitbeforeitwasdark。
  Prior’sPark,or,moreproperly,thesurroundingdistrictofHolinwall,wasacountryseatthathadbecomeasuburb;havingoncehadonlyadependentvillageatitsdoors,itnowfoundoutsideallitsdoorsthesignalsoftheexpansionofLondon。Mr。Haddow,whowasengagedinhistoricalresearchesbothinthelibraryandthelocality,couldfindlittleassistanceinthelatter。Hehadalreadyrealized,fromthedocuments,thatPrior’sParkhadoriginallybeensomethinglikePrior’sFarm,namedaftersomelocalfigure,butthenewsocialconditionswereallagainsthistracingthestorybyitstraditions。Hadanyoftherealrusticsremained,hewouldprobablyhavefoundsomelingeringlegendofMr。Prior,howeverremotehemightbe。Butthenewnomadicpopulationofclerksandartisans,constantlyshiftingtheirhomesfromonesuburbtoanother,ortheirchildrenfromoneschooltoanother,couldhavenocorporatecontinuity。
  Theyhadallthatforgetfulnessofhistorythatgoeseverywherewiththeextensionofeducation。
  Nevertheless,whenhecameoutofthelibrarynextmorningandsawthewintrytreesstandingroundthefrozenpondlikeablackforest,hefelthemightwellhavebeenfarinthedepthsofthecountry。
  Theoldwallrunningroundtheparkkeptthatinclosureitselfstillentirelyruralandromantic,andonecouldeasilyimaginethatthedepthsofthatdarkforestfadedawayindefinitelyintodistantvalesandhills。Thegrayandblackandsilverofthewintrywoodwereallthemoresevereorsomberasacontrasttothecoloredcarnivalgroupsthatalreadystoodonandaroundthefrozenpool。Forthehousepartyhadalreadyflungthemselvesimpatientlyintofancydress,andthelawyer,withhisneatblacksuitandredhair,wastheonlymodernfigureamongthem。
  "Aren’tyougoingtodressup?"askedJuliet,indignantlyshakingathimahornedandtoweringblueheaddressofthefourteenthcenturywhichframedherfaceverybecomingly,fantasticasitwas。
  "EverybodyherehastobeintheMiddleAges。EvenMr。Brainhasputonasortofbrowndressinggownandsayshe’samonk;andMr。Fishergotholdofsomeoldpotatosacksinthekitchenandsewedthemtogether;he’ssupposedtobeamonk,too。Astotheprince,he’sperfectlyglorious,ingreatcrimsonrobesasacardinal。Helooksasifhecouldpoisoneverybody。Yousimplymustbesomething。"
  "Iwillbesomethinglaterintheday,"hereplied。
  "AtpresentIamnothingbutanantiquaryandanattorney。Ihavetoseeyourbrotherpresently,aboutsomelegalbusinessandalsosomelocalinvestigationsheaskedmetomake。ImustlookalittlelikeastewardwhenIgiveanaccountofmystewardship。"
  "Oh,butmybrotherhasdressedup!"criedthegirl。"Verymuchso。Noend,ifImaysayso。Whyhe’sbearingdownonyounowinallhisglory。"
  Thenoblelordwasindeedmarchingtowardtheminamagnificentsixteenth—centurycostumeofpurpleandgold,withagold—hiltedswordandaplumedcap,andmannerstomatch。Indeed,therewassomethingmorethanhisusualexpansivenessofbodilyactioninhisappearanceatthatmoment。Italmostseemed,sotospeak,thattheplumesonhishathadgonetohishead。Heflappedhisgreat,gold—linedcloaklikethewingsofafairykinginapantomime;heevendrewhisswordwithaflourishandwaveditaboutashedidhiswalkingstick。Inthelightofaftereventsthereseemedtobesomethingmonstrousandominousaboutthatexuberance,somethingofthespiritthatiscalledfey。Atthetimeitmerelycrossedafewpeople’smindsthathemightpossiblybedrunk。
  AshestrodetowardhissisterthefirstfigurehepassedwasthatofLeonardCrane,cladinLincolngreen,withthehornandbaldrickandswordappropriatetoRobinHood;forhewasstandingnearesttothelady,where,indeed,hemighthavebeenfoundduringadisproportionatepartofthetime。
  Hehaddisplayedoneofhisburiedtalentsinthematterofskating,andnowthattheskatingwasoverseemeddisposedtoprolongthepartnership。TheboisterousBulmerplayfullymadeapassathimwithhisdrawnsword,goingforwardwiththelungeintheproperfencingfashion,andmakingasomewhattoofamiliarShakespeareanquotationaboutarodentandaVenetiancoin。
  ProbablyinCranealsotherewasasubduedexcitementjustthen;anyhow,inoneflashhehaddrawnhisownswordandparried;andthensuddenly,tothesurpriseofeveryone,Bulmer’sweaponseemedtospringoutofhishandintotheairandrolledawayontheringingice。
  "Well,Inever!"saidthelady,asifwithjustifiableindignation。"Younevertoldmeyoucouldfence,too。"
  Bulmerputuphisswordwithanairratherbewilderedthanannoyed,whichincreasedtheimpressionofsomethingirresponsibleinhismoodatthemoment;thenheturnedratherabruptlytohislawyer,saying:
  "Wecansettleupabouttheestateafterdinner;
  I’vemissednearlyalltheskatingasitis,andIdoubtiftheicewillholdtillto—morrownight。IthinkIshallgetupearlyandhaveaspinbymyself。"
  "Youwon’tbedisturbedwithmycompany,"saidHorneFisher,inhiswearyfashion。"IfIhavetobeginthedaywithice,intheAmericanfashion,I
  preferitinsmallerquantities。ButnoearlyhoursformeinDecember。Theearlybirdcatchesthecold。"
  "Oh,Isha’n’tdieofcatchingacold,"answeredBulmer,andlaughed。
  Aconsiderablegroupoftheskatingpartyhadconsistedoftheguestsstayingatthehouse,andtheresthadtailedoffintwosandthreessometimebeforemostoftheguestsbegantoretireforthenight。Neighbors,alwaysinvitedtoPrior’sParkonsuchoccasions,wentbacktotheirownhousesinmotorsoronfoot;thelegalandarcheoologicalgentlemanhadreturnedtotheInnsofCourtbyalatetrain,togetapapercalledforduringhisconsultationwithhisclient;andmostoftheotherguestsweredriftingandlingeringatvariousstagesontheirwayuptobed。HorneFisher,asiftodeprivehimselfofanyexcuseforhisrefusalofearlyrising,hadbeenthefirsttoretiretohisroom;but,sleepyashelooked,hecouldnotsleep。Hehadpickedupfromatablethebookofantiquariantopography,inwhichHaddowhadfoundhisfirsthintsabouttheoriginofthelocalname,and,beingamanwithaquietandquaintcapacityforbeinginterestedinanything,hebegantoreaditsteadily,makingnotesnowandthenofdetailsonwhichhispreviousreadinglefthimwithacertaindoubtabouthispresentconclusions。Hisroomwastheonenearesttothelakeinthecenterofthewoods,andwasthereforethequietest,andnoneofthelastechoesoftheevening’sfestivitycouldreachhim。HehadfollowedcarefullytheargumentwhichestablishedthederivationfromMr。Prior’sfarmandtheholeinthewall,anddisposedofanyfashionablefancyaboutmonksandmagicwells,whenhebegantobeconsciousofanoiseaudibleinthefrozensilenceofthenight。Itwasnotaparticularlyloudnoise,butitseemedtoconsistofaseriesofthudsorheavyblows,suchasmightbestruckonawoodendoorbyamanseekingtoenter。Theywerefollowedbysomethinglikeafaintcreakorcrack,asiftheobstaclehadeitherbeenopenedorhadgivenway。
  Heopenedhisownbedroomdoorandlistened,butasheheardtalkandlaughteralloverthelowerfloors,hehadnoreasontofearthatasummonswouldbeneglectedorthehouseleftwithoutprotection。Hewenttohisopenwindow,lookingoutoverthefrozenpondandthemoonlitstatueinthemiddleoftheircircleofdarklingwoods,andlistenedagain。Butsilencehadreturnedtothatsilentplace,and,afterstraininghisearsforaconsiderabletime,hecouldhearnothingbutthesolitaryhootofadistantdepartingtrain。Thenheremindedhimselfhowmanynamelessnoisescanbeheardbythewakefulduringthemostordinarynight,andshrugginghisshoulders,wentwearilytobed。
  Heawokesuddenlyandsatupinbedwithhisearsfilled,aswiththunder,withthethrobbingechoesofarendingcry。Heremainedrigidforamoment,andthensprangoutofbed,throwingontheloosegownofsackinghehadwornallday。Hewentfirsttothewindow,whichwasopen,butcoveredwithathickcurtain,sothathisroomwasstillcompletelydark;butwhenhetossedthecurtainasideandputhisheadout,hesawthatagrayandsilverdaybreakhadalreadyappearedbehindtheblackwoodsthatsurroundedthelittlelake,andthatwasallthathedidsee。Thoughthesoundhadcertainlycomeinthroughtheopenwindowfromthisdirection,thewholescenewasstillandemptyunderthemorninglightasunderthemoonlight。
  Thenthelong,ratherlackadaisicalhandhehadlaidonawindowsillgrippedittighter,asiftomasteratremor,andhispeeringblueeyesgrewbleakwithfear。Itmayseemthathisemotionwasexaggeratedandneedless,consideringtheeffortofcommonsensebywhichhehadconqueredhisnervousnessaboutthenoiseonthepreviousnight。Butthathadbeenaverydifferentsortofnoise。Itmighthavebeenmadebyhalfahundredthings,fromthechoppingofwoodtothebreakingofbottles。Therewasonlyonethinginnaturefromwhichcouldcomethesoundthatechoedthroughthedarkhouseatdaybreak。Itwastheawfularticulatevoiceofman;anditwassomethingworse,forheknewwhatman。
  Heknewalsothatithadbeenashoutforhelp。Itseemedtohimthathehadheardtheveryword;buttheword,shortasitwas,hadbeenswallowedup,asifthemanhadbeenstifledorsnatchedawayevenashespoke。Onlythemockingreverberationsofitremainedeveninhismemory,buthehadnodoubtoftheoriginalvoice。Hehadnodoubtthatthegreatbull’svoiceofFrancisBray,BaronBulmer,hadbeenheardforthelasttimebetweenthedarknessandtheliftingdawn。
  Howlonghestoodthereheneverknew,buthewasstartledintolifebythefirstlivingthingthathesawstirringinthathalf—frozenlandscape。Alongthepathbesidethelake,andimmediatelyunderhiswindow,afigurewaswalkingslowlyandsoftly,butwithgreatcomposure——astatelyfigureinrobesofasplendidscarlet;itwastheItalianprince,stillinhiscardinal’scostume。Mostofthecompanyhadindeedlivedintheircostumesforthelastdayortwo,andFisherhimselfhadassumedhisfrockofsackingasaconvenientdressinggown;butthereseemed,nevertheless,somethingunusuallyfinishedandformal,inthewayofanearlybird,aboutthismagnificentredcockatoo。Itwasasiftheearlybirdhadbeenupallnight。
  "Whatisthematter?"hecalled,sharply,leaningoutofthewindow,andtheItalianturneduphisgreatyellowfacelikeamaskofbrass。
  "Wehadbetterdiscussitdownstairs,"saidPrinceBorodino。
  Fisherrandownstairs,andencounteredthegreat,red—robedfigureenteringthedoorwayandblockingtheentrancewithhisbulk。
  "Didyouhearthatcry?"demandedFisher。
  "IheardanoiseandIcameout,"answeredthediplomatist,andhisfacewastoodarkintheshadowforitsexpressiontoberead。
  "ItwasBulmer’svoice,"insistedFisher。"I’llswearitwasBulmer’svoice。"
  "Didyouknowhimwell?"askedtheother。
  Thequestionseemedirrelevant,thoughitwasnotillogical,andFishercouldonlyanswerina,randomfashionthatheknewLordBulmeronlyslightly。
  "Nobodyseemstohaveknownhimwell,"continuedtheItalian,inleveltones。"NobodyexceptthatmanBrain。BrainisratherolderthanBulmer,butIfancytheysharedagoodmanysecrets。"
  Fishermovedabruptly,asifwakingfromamomentarytrance,andsaid,inanewandmorevigorousvoice,"Butlookhere,hadn’twebettergetoutsideandseeifanythinghashappened。"
  "Theiceseemstobethawing,"saidtheother,almostwithindifference。
  Whentheyemergedfromthehouse,darkstainsandstarsinthegrayfieldoficedidindeedindicatethatthefrostwasbreakingup,astheirhosthadprophesiedthedaybefore,andtheverymemoryofyesterdaybroughtbackthemysteryofto—day。
  "Heknewtherewouldbeathaw,"observedtheprince。"Hewentoutskatingquiteearlyonpurpose。
  Didhecalloutbecausehelandedinthewater,doyouthink?"
  Fisherlookedpuzzled。"Bulmerwasthelastmantobellowlikethatbecausehegothisbootswet。Andthat’sallhecoulddohere;thewaterwouldhardlycomeuptothecalfofamanofhissize。Youcanseetheflatweedsonthefloorofthelake,asifitwerethroughathinpaneofglass。No,ifBulmerhadonlybrokentheicehewouldn’thavesaidmuchatthemoment,thoughpossiblyagooddealafterward。Weshouldhavefoundhimstampinganddamningupanddownthispath,andcallingforcleanboots。"
  "Letushopeweshallfindhimashappilyemployed,"remarkedthediplomatist。"Inthatcasethevoicemusthavecomeoutofthewood。"
  "I’llswearitdidn’tcomeoutofthehouse,"saidFisher;andthetwodisappearedtogetherintothetwilightofwintrytrees。
  Theplantationstooddarkagainstthefierycolorsofsunrise,ablackfringehavingthatfeatheryappearancewhichmakestreeswhentheyarebaretheveryreverseofrugged。Hoursandhoursafterward,whenthesamedense,butdelicate,marginwasdarkagainstthegreenishcolorsoppositethesunset,thesearchthusbegunatsunrisehadnotcometoanend。Bysuccessivestages,andtoslowlygatheringgroupsofthecompany,itbecameapparentthatthemostextraordinaryofallgapshadappearedintheparty;theguestscouldfindnotraceoftheirhostanywhere。Theservantsreportedthathisbedhadbeensleptinandhisskatesandhisfancycostumeweregone,asifhehadrisenearlyforthepurposehehadhimselfavowed。Butfromthetopofthehousetothebottom,fromthewallsroundtheparktothepondinthecenter,therewasnotraceofLordBulmer,deadoralive。HorneFisherrealizedthatachillingpremonitionhadalreadypreventedhimfromexpectingtofindthemanalive。Buthisbaldbrowwaswrinkledoveranentirelynewandunnaturalproblem,innotfindingthemanatall。
  HeconsideredthepossibilityofBulmerhavinggoneoffofhisownaccord,forsomereason;butafterfullyweighingithefinallydismissedit。Itwasinconsistentwiththeunmistakablevoiceheardatdaybreak,andwithmanyotherpracticalobstacles。
  Therewasonlyonegatewayintheancientandloftywallroundthesmallpark;thelodgekeeperkeptitlockedtilllateinthemorning,andthelodgekeeperhadseennoonepass。Fisherwasfairlysurethathehadbeforehimamathematicalprobleminaninclosedspace。Hisinstincthadbeenfromthefirstsoattunedtothetragedythatitwouldhavebeenalmostarelieftohimtofindthecorpse。Hewouldhavebeengrieved,butnothorrified,tocomeonthenobleman’sbodydanglingfromoneofhisowntreesasfromagibbet,orfloatinginhisownpoollikeapallidweed。Whathorrifiedhimwastofindnothing。
  Hesoonbecomeconsciousthathewasnotaloneeveninhismostindividualandisolatedexperiments。
  Heoftenfoundafigurefollowinghimlikehisshadow,insilentandalmostsecretclearingsintheplantationoroutlyingnooksandcornersoftheoldwall。Thedark—mustachedmouthwasasmuteasthedeepeyesweremobile,dartingincessantlyhitherandthither,butitwasclearthatBrainoftheIndianpolicehadtakenupthetraillikeanoldhunterafteratiger。
  Seeingthathewastheonlypersonalfriendofthevanishedman,thisseemednaturalenough,andFisherresolvedtodealfranklywithhim。
  "Thissilenceisratherasocialstrain,"hesaid。
  "MayIbreaktheicebytalkingabouttheweather?——which,bytheway,hasalreadybrokentheice。Iknowthatbreakingtheicemightbearathermelancholymetaphorinthiscase。"
  "Idon’tthinkso,"repliedBrain,shortly。"Idon’tfancytheicehadmuchtodowithit。Idon’tseehowitcould。"
  "Whatwouldyouproposedoing?"askedFisher。
  "Well,we’vesentfortheauthorities,ofcourse,butIhopetofindsomethingoutbeforetheycome,"
  repliedtheAnglo—Indian。"Ican’tsayIhavemuchhopefrompolicemethodsinthiscountry。Toomuchredtape,habeascorpusandthatsortofthing。Whatwewantistoseethatnobodybolts;thenearestwecouldgettoitwouldbetocollectthecompanyandcountthem,sotospeak。Nobody’sleftlately,exceptthatlawyerwhowaspokingaboutforantiquities。"
  "Oh,he’soutofit;heleftlastnight,"answeredtheother。"EighthoursafterBulmer’schauffeursawhislawyeroffbythetrainIheardBulmer’sownvoiceasplainasIhearyoursnow。"
  "Isupposeyoudon’tbelieveinspirits?"saidthemanfromIndia。Afterapauseheadded:"There’ssomebodyelseIshouldliketofind,beforewegoafterafellowwithanalibiintheInnerTemple。
  What’sbecomeofthatfellowingreen——thearchitectdressedupasaforester?Ihaven’tseemhimabout。"
  Mr。Brainmanagedtosecurehisassemblyofallthedistractedcompanybeforethearrivalofthepolice。Butwhenhefirstbegantocomentoncemoreontheyoungarchitect’sdelayinputtinginanappearance,hefoundhimselfinthepresenceofaminormystery,andapsychologicaldevelopmentofanentirelyunexpectedkind。
  JulietBrayhadconfrontedthecatastropheofherbrother’sdisappearancewithasomberstoicisminwhichtherewas,perhaps,moreparalysisthanpain;
  butwhentheotherquestioncametothesurfaceshewasbothagitatedandangry。
  "Wedon’twanttojumptoanyconclusionsaboutanybody,"Brainwassayinginhisstaccatostyle。"ButweshouldliketoknowalittlemoreaboutMr。Crane。
  Nobodyseemstoknowmuchabouthim,orwherehecomesfrom。AnditseemsasortofcoincidencethatyesterdayheactuallycrossedswordswithpoorBulmer,andcouldhavestuckhim,too,sinceheshowedhimselfthebetterswordsman。Ofcourse,thatmaybeanaccidentandcouldn’tpossiblybecalledacaseagainstanybody;butthenwehaven’tthemeanstomakearealcaseagainstanybody。Tillthepolicecomeweareonlyapackofveryamateursleuthhounds。"
  "AndIthinkyou’reapackofsnobs,"saidJuliet。
  "BecauseMr。Craneisageniuswho’smadehisownway,youtrytosuggesthe’samurdererwithoutdaringtosayso。Becauseheworeatoyswordandhappenedtoknowhowtouseit,youwantustobelieveheuseditlikeabloodthirstymaniacfornoreasonintheworld。Andbecausehecouldhavehitmybrotheranddidn’t,youdeducethathedid。That’sthesortofwayyouargue。Andasforhishavingdisappeared,you’rewronginthatasyouareineverythingelse,forherehecomes。"
  And,indeed,thegreenfigureofthefictitiousRobinHoodslowlydetacheditselffromthegraybackgroundofthetrees,andcametowardthemasshespoke。
  Heapproachedthegroupslowly,butwithcomposure;buthewasdecidedlypale,andtheeyesofBrainandFisherhadalreadytakeninonedetailofthegreen—cladfiguremoreclearlythanalltherest。
  Thehornstillswungfromhisbaldrick,buttheswordwasgone。
  Rathertothesurpriseofthecompany,Braindidnotfollowupthequestionthussuggested;but,whileretaininganairofleadingtheinquiry,hadalsoanappearanceofchangingthesubject。
  "Nowwe’reallassembled,"heobserved,quietly,"thereisaquestionIwanttoasktobeginwith。DidanybodyhereactuallyseeLordBulmerthismorning?"
  LeonardCraneturnedhispalefaceroundthecircleoffacestillhecametoJuliet’s;thenhecompressedhislipsalittleandsaid:
  "Yes,Isawhim。"
  "Washealiveandwell?"askedBrain,quickly。
  "Howwashedressed?"
  "Heappearedexceedinglywell,"repliedCrane,withacuriousintonation。"Hewasdressedashewasyesterday,inthatpurplecostumecopiedfromtheportraitofhisancestorinthesixteenthcentury。Hehadhisskatesinhishand。"
  "Andhisswordathisside,Isuppose,"addedthequestioner。"Whereisyourownsword,Mr。Crane?"
  "Ithrewitaway。"
  Inthesingularsilencethatensued,thetrainofthoughtinmanymindsbecameinvoluntarilyaseriesofcoloredpictures。
  Theyhadgrownusedtotheirfancifulgarmentslookingmoregayandgorgeousagainstthedarkgrayandstreakysilveroftheforest,sothatthemovingfiguresglowedlikestained—glasssaintswalking。Theeffecthadbeenmorefittingbecausesomanyofthemhadidlyparodiedpontificalormonasticdress。Butthemostarrestingattitudethatremainedintheirmemorieshadbeenanythingbutmerelymonastic;
  thatofthemomentwhenthefigureinbrightgreenandtheotherinvividviolethadforamomentmadeasilvercrossoftheircrossingswords。Evenwhenitwasajestithadbeensomethingofadrama;anditwasastrangeandsinisterthoughtthatinthegraydaybreakthesamefiguresinthesameposturemighthavebeenrepeatedasatragedy。
  "Didyouquarrelwithhim?"askedBrain,suddenly。
  "Yes,"repliedtheimmovablemaningreen。"Orhequarreledwithme。"
  "Whydidhequarrelwithyou?"askedtheinvestigator;andLeonardCranemadenoreply。
  HorneFisher,curiouslyenough,hadonlygivenhalfhisattentiontothiscrucialcross—examination。Hisheavy—liddedeyeshadlanguidlyfollowedthefigureofPrinceBorodino,whoatthisstagehadstrolledawaytowardthefringeofthewood;and,afterapause,asofmeditation,haddisappearedintothedarknessofthetrees。
  HewasrecalledfromhisirrelevancebythevoiceofJulietBray,whichrangoutwithanaltogethernewnoteofdecision:
  "Ifthatisthedifficulty,ithadbestbeclearedup。
  IamengagedtoMr。Crane,andwhenwetoldmybrotherhedidnotapproveofit;thatisall。"
  NeitherBrainnorFisherexhibitedanysurprise,buttheformeradded,quietly:
  "Except,Isuppose,thatheandyourbrotherwentoffintothewoodtodiscussit,whereMr。Cranemislaidhissword,nottomentionhiscompanion。"
  "AndmayIask,"inquiredCrane,withacertainflickerofmockerypassingoverhispallidfeatures,"whatIamsupposedtohavedonewitheitherofthem?LetusadoptthecheerfulthesisthatI
  amamurderer;ithasyettobeshownthatIamamagician。IfIranyourunfortunatefriendthroughthebody,whatdidIdowiththebody?DidIhaveitcarriedawaybysevenflyingdragons,orwasitmerelyatriflingmatterofturningitintoamilk—whitehind?"
  "Itisnooccasionforsneering,"saidtheAnglo—Indianjudge,withabruptauthority。"Itdoesn’tmakeitlookbetterforyouthatyoucanjokeabouttheloss。"
  Fisher’sdreamy,andevendreary,eyewasstillontheedgeofthewoodbehind,andhebecameconsciousofmassesofdarkred,likeastormysunsetcloud,glowingthroughthegraynetworkofthethintrees,andtheprinceinhiscardinal’srobesreemergedontothepathway。Brainhadhadhalfanotionthattheprincemighthavegonetolookforthelostrapier。Butwhenhereappearedhewascarryinginhishand,notasword,butanax。
  Theincongruitybetweenthemasqueradeandthemysteryhadcreatedacuriouspsychologicalatmosphere。Atfirsttheyhadallfelthorriblyashamedatbeingcaughtinthefoolishdisguisesofafestival,byaneventthathadonlytoomuchthecharacterofafuneral。Manyofthemwouldhavealreadygonebackanddressedinclothesthatweremorefunerealoratleastmoreformal。Butsomehowatthemomentthisseemedlikeasecondmasquerade,moreartificialandfrivolousthanthefirst。Andastheyreconciledthemselvestotheirridiculoustrappings,acurioussensationhadcomeoversomeofthem,notablyoverthemoresensitive,likeCraneandFisherandJuliet,butinsomedegreeovereverybodyexceptthepracticalMr。Brain。Itwasalmostasiftheyweretheghostsoftheirownancestorshauntingthatdarkwoodanddismallake,andplayingsomeoldpartthattheyonlyhalfremembered。Themovementsofthosecoloredfiguresseemedtomeansomethingthathadbeensettledlongbefore,likeasilentheraldry。Acts,attitudes,externalobjects,wereacceptedasanallegoryevenwithoutthekey;andtheyknewwhenacrisishadcome,whentheydidnotknowwhatitwas。
  Andsomehowtheyknewsubconsciouslythatthewholetalehadtakenanewandterribleturn,whentheysawtheprincestandinthegapofthegaunttrees,inhisrobesofangrycrimsonandwithhisloweringfaceofbronze,bearinginhishandanewshapeofdeath。Theycouldnothavenamedareason,butthetwoswordsseemedindeedtohavebecometoyswordsandthewholetaleofthembrokenandtossedawaylikeatoy。BorodinolookedliketheOldWorldheadsman,cladinterriblered,andcarryingtheaxfortheexecutionofthecriminal。AndthecriminalwasnotCrane。
  Mr。BrainoftheIndianpolicewasglaringatthenewobject,anditwasamomentortwobeforehespoke,harshlyandalmosthoarsely。
  "Whatareyoudoingwiththat?"heasked。"Seemstobeawoodman’schopper。"
  "Anaturalassociationofideas,"observedHorneFisher。"Ifyoumeetacatinawoodyouthinkit’sawildcat,thoughitmayhavejuststrolledfromthedrawing—roomsofa。Asamatteroffact,Ihappentoknowthatisnotthewoodman’schopper。It’sthekitchenchopper,ormeatax,orsomethinglikethat,thatsomebodyhasthrownawayinthewood。IsawitinthekitchenmyselfwhenIwasgettingthepotatosackswithwhichIreconstructedamediaevalhermit。"
  "Allthesame,itisnotwithoutinterest,"remarkedtheprince,holdingouttheinstrumenttoFisher,whotookitandexamineditcarefully。"Abutcher’scleaverthathasdonebutcher’swork。"
  "Itwascertainlytheinstrumentofthecrime,"
  assentedFisher,inalowvoice。
  Brainwasstaringatthedullbluegleamoftheaxheadwithfierceandfascinatedeyes。"Idon’tunderstandyou,"hesaid。"Thereisno——therearenomarksonit。"
  "Ithasshednoblood,"answeredFisher,"butforallthatithascommittedacrime。Thisisasnearasthecriminalcametothecrimewhenhecommittedit。"
  "Whatdoyoumean?"
  "Hewasnottherewhenhedidit,"explainedFisher。"It’sapoorsortofmurdererwhocan’tmurderpeoplewhenheisn’tthere。"
  "Youseemtobetalkingmerelyforthesakeofmystification,"saidBrain。"Ifyouhaveanypracticaladvicetogiveyoumightaswellmakeitintelligible。"
  "TheonlypracticaladviceIcansuggest,"saidFisher,thoughtfully,"isalittleresearchintolocaltopographyandnomenclature。TheysaythereusedtobeaMr。Prior,whohadafarminthisneighborhood。IthinksomedetailsaboutthedomesticlifeofthelateMr。Priorwouldthrowalightonthisterriblebusiness。"