Lookatthisimpression,whereyougetbothtyresclear。
  Theoneisasdeepastheother。Thatcanonlymeanthattherideristhrowinghisweightontothehandle—bar,asamandoeswhenheissprinting。ByJove!hehashadafall。"
  Therewasabroad,irregularsmudgecoveringsomeyardsofthetrack。Thentherewereafewfootmarks,andthetyrereappearedoncemore。
  "Aside—slip,"Isuggested。
  Holmesheldupacrumpledbranchoffloweringgorse。TomyhorrorIperceivedthattheyellowblossomswerealldabbledwithcrimson。Onthepath,too,andamongtheheatherweredarkstainsofclottedblood。
  "Bad!"saidHolmes。"Bad!Standclear,Watson!Notanunnecessaryfootstep!WhatdoIreadhere?Hefellwounded,hestoodup,heremounted,heproceeded。Butthereisnoothertrack。Cattleonthissidepath。Hewassurelynotgoredbyabull?Impossible!ButIseenotracesofanyoneelse。Wemustpushon,Watson。Surelywithstainsaswellasthetracktoguideushecannotescapeusnow。"
  Oursearchwasnotaverylongone。Thetracksofthetyrebegantocurvefantasticallyuponthewetandshiningpath。
  Suddenly,asIlookedahead,thegleamofmetalcaughtmyeyefromamidthethickgorsebushes。Outofthemwedraggedabicycle,Palmer—tyred,onepedalbent,andthewholefrontofithorriblysmearedandslobberedwithblood。Ontheothersideofthebushesashoewasprojecting。Weranround,andtherelaytheunfortunaterider。Hewasatallman,fullbearded,withspectacles,oneglassofwhichhadbeenknockedout。Thecauseofhisdeathwasafrightfulblowuponthehead,whichhadcrushedinpartofhisskull。Thathecouldhavegoneonafterreceivingsuchaninjurysaidmuchforthevitalityandcourageoftheman。Heworeshoes,butnosocks,andhisopencoatdisclosedanight—shirtbeneathit。ItwasundoubtedlytheGermanmaster。
  Holmesturnedthebodyoverreverently,andexamineditwithgreatattention。Hethensatindeepthoughtforatime,andI
  couldseebyhisruffledbrowthatthisgrimdiscoveryhadnot,inhisopinion,advancedusmuchinourinquiry。
  "Itisalittledifficulttoknowwhattodo,Watson,"saidhe,atlast。"Myowninclinationsaretopushthisinquiryon,forwehavealreadylostsomuchtimethatwecannotaffordtowasteanotherhour。Ontheotherhand,weareboundtoinformthepoliceofthediscovery,andtoseethatthispoorfellow’sbodyislookedafter。"
  "Icouldtakeanoteback。"
  "ButIneedyourcompanyandassistance。Waitabit!
  Thereisafellowcuttingpeatupyonder。Bringhimoverhere,andhewillguidethepolice。"
  Ibroughtthepeasantacross,andHolmesdispatchedthefrightenedmanwithanotetoDr。Huxtable。
  "Now,Watson,"saidhe,"wehavepickeduptwocluesthismorning。
  OneisthebicyclewiththePalmertyre,andweseewhatthathasledto。TheotheristhebicyclewiththepatchedDunlop。
  Beforewestarttoinvestigatethat,letustrytorealizewhatweDOknowsoastomakethemostofit,andtoseparatetheessentialfromtheaccidental。"
  "FirstofallIwishtoimpressuponyouthattheboycertainlyleftofhisownfreewill。Hegotdownfromhiswindowandhewentoff,eitheraloneorwithsomeone。Thatissure。"
  Iassented。
  "Well,now,letusturntothisunfortunateGermanmaster。
  Theboywasfullydressedwhenhefled。Therefore,heforesawwhathewoulddo。ButtheGermanwentwithouthissocks。
  Hecertainlyactedonveryshortnotice。"
  "Undoubtedly。"
  "Whydidhego?Because,fromhisbedroomwindow,hesawtheflightoftheboy。Becausehewishedtoovertakehimandbringhimback。Heseizedhisbicycle,pursuedthelad,andinpursuinghimmethisdeath。"
  "Soitwouldseem。"
  "NowIcometothecriticalpartofmyargument。Thenaturalactionofamaninpursuingalittleboywouldbetorunafterhim。
  Hewouldknowthathecouldovertakehim。ButtheGermandoesnotdoso。Heturnstohisbicycle。Iamtoldthathewasanexcellentcyclist。Hewouldnotdothisifhedidnotseethattheboyhadsomeswiftmeansofescape。"
  "Theotherbicycle。"
  "Letuscontinueourreconstruction。Hemeetshisdeathfivemilesfromtheschool——notbyabullet,markyou,whichevenaladmightconceivablydischarge,butbyasavageblowdealtbyavigorousarm。Thelad,then,HADacompanioninhisflight。
  Andtheflightwasaswiftone,sinceittookfivemilesbeforeanexpertcyclistcouldovertakethem。Yetwesurveythegroundroundthesceneofthetragedy。Whatdowefind?Afewcattletracks,nothingmore。Itookawidesweepround,andthereisnopathwithinfiftyyards。Anothercyclistcouldhavehadnothingtodowiththeactualmurder。Norwerethereanyhumanfootmarks。"
  "Holmes,"Icried,"thisisimpossible。"
  "Admirable!"hesaid。"Amostilluminatingremark。
  ItISimpossibleasIstateit,andthereforeImustinsomerespecthavestateditwrong。Yetyousawforyourself。
  Canyousuggestanyfallacy?"
  "Hecouldnothavefracturedhisskullinafall?"
  "Inamorass,Watson?"
  "Iamatmywit’send。"
  "Tut,tut;wehavesolvedsomeworseproblems。Atleastwehaveplentyofmaterial,ifwecanonlyuseit。Come,then,and,havingexhaustedthePalmer,letusseewhattheDunlopwiththepatchedcoverhastoofferus。"
  Wepickedupthetrackandfolloweditonwardsforsomedistance;
  butsoonthemoorroseintoalong,heather—tuftedcurve,andweleftthewatercoursebehindus。Nofurtherhelpfromtrackscouldbehopedfor。AtthespotwherewesawthelastoftheDunloptyreitmightequallyhaveledtoHoldernesseHall,thestatelytowersofwhichrosesomemilestoourleft,ortoalow,greyvillagewhichlayinfrontofus,andmarkedthepositionoftheChesterfieldhighroad。
  Asweapproachedtheforbiddingandsqualidinn,withthesignofagame—cockabovethedoor,Holmesgaveasuddengroanandclutchedmebytheshouldertosavehimselffromfalling。
  Hehadhadoneofthoseviolentstrainsoftheanklewhichleaveamanhelpless。Withdifficultyhelimpeduptothedoor,whereasquat,dark,elderlymanwassmokingablackclaypipe。
  "Howareyou,Mr。ReubenHayes?"saidHolmes。
  "Whoareyou,andhowdoyougetmynamesopat?"thecountrymananswered,withasuspiciousflashofapairofcunningeyes。
  "Well,it’sprintedontheboardaboveyourhead。It’seasytoseeamanwhoismasterofhisownhouse。Isupposeyouhaven’tsuchathingasacarriageinyourstables?"
  "No;Ihavenot。"
  "Icanhardlyputmyfoottotheground。"
  "Don’tputittotheground。"
  "ButIcan’twalk。"
  "Well,then,hop。"
  Mr。ReubenHayes’smannerwasfarfromgracious,butHolmestookitwithadmirablegood—humour。
  "Lookhere,myman,"saidhe。"Thisisreallyratheranawkwardfixforme。Idon’tmindhowIgeton。"
  "NeitherdoI,"saidthemoroselandlord。
  "Thematterisveryimportant。Iwouldofferyouasovereignfortheuseofabicycle。"
  Thelandlordprickeduphisears。
  "Wheredoyouwanttogo?"
  "ToHoldernesseHall。"
  "PalsoftheDook,Isuppose?"saidthelandlord,surveyingourmud—stainedgarmentswithironicaleyes。
  Holmeslaughedgood—naturedly。
  "He’llbegladtoseeus,anyhow。"
  "Why?"
  "Becausewebringhimnewsofhislostson。"
  Thelandlordgaveaveryvisiblestart。
  "What,you’reonhistrack?"
  "HehasbeenheardofinLiverpool。Theyexpecttogethimeveryhour。"
  Againaswiftchangepassedovertheheavy,unshavenface。
  Hismannerwassuddenlygenial。
  "I’velessreasontowishtheDookwellthanmostmen,"saidhe,"forIwashisheadcoachmanonce,andcruelbadhetreatedme。
  Itwashimthatsackedmewithoutacharacteronthewordofalyingcorn—chandler。ButI’mgladtohearthattheyounglordwasheardofinLiverpool,andI’llhelpyoutotakethenewstotheHall。"
  "Thankyou,"saidHolmes。"We’llhavesomefoodfirst。
  Thenyoucanbringroundthebicycle。"
  "Ihaven’tgotabicycle。"
  Holmesheldupasovereign。
  "Itellyou,man,thatIhaven’tgotone。I’llletyouhavetwohorsesasfarastheHall。"
  "Well,well,"saidHolmes,"we’lltalkaboutitwhenwe’vehadsomethingtoeat。"
  Whenwewereleftaloneinthestone—flaggedkitchenitwasastonishinghowrapidlythatsprainedanklerecovered。Itwasnearlynightfall,andwehadeatennothingsinceearlymorning,sothatwespentsometimeoverourmeal。Holmeswaslostinthought,andonceortwicehewalkedovertothewindowandstaredearnestlyout。Itopenedontoasqualidcourtyard。
  Inthefarcornerwasasmithy,whereagrimyladwasatwork。
  Ontheothersidewerethestables。Holmeshadsatdownagainafteroneoftheseexcursions,whenhesuddenlysprangoutofhischairwithaloudexclamation。
  "ByHeaven,Watson,IbelievethatI’vegotit!"hecried。
  "Yes,yes,itmustbeso。Watson,doyourememberseeinganycow—tracksto—day?"
  "Yes,several。"
  "Where?"
  "Well,everywhere。Theywereatthemorass,andagainonthepath,andagainnearwherepoorHeideggermethisdeath。"
  "Exactly。Well,now,Watson,howmanycowsdidyouseeonthemoor?"
  "Idon’trememberseeingany。"
  "Strange,Watson,thatweshouldseetracksallalongourline,butneveracowonthewholemoor;verystrange,Watson,eh?"
  "Yes,itisstrange。"
  "Now,Watson,makeaneffort;throwyourmindback!
  Canyouseethosetracksuponthepath?"
  "Yes,Ican。"
  "Canyourecallthatthetracksweresometimeslikethat,Watson"——hearrangedanumberofbread—crumbsinthisfashion——:::::——"andsometimeslikethis"——:。:。:。:。——
  "andoccasionallylikethis"——。`。`。`。"Canyourememberthat?"
  "No,Icannot。"
  "ButIcan。Icouldsweartoit。However,wewillgobackatourleisureandverifyit。WhatablindbeetleIhavebeennottodrawmyconclusion!"
  "Andwhatisyourconclusion?"
  "Onlythatitisaremarkablecowwhichwalks,canters,andgallops。
  ByGeorge,Watson,itwasnobrainofacountrypublicanthatthoughtoutsuchablindasthat!Thecoastseemstobeclear,saveforthatladinthesmithy。Letusslipoutandseewhatwecansee。"
  Thereweretworough—haired,unkempthorsesinthetumble—downstable。Holmesraisedthehindlegofoneofthemandlaughedaloud。
  "Oldshoes,butnewlyshod——oldshoes,butnewnails。Thiscasedeservestobeaclassic。Letusgoacrosstothesmithy。"
  Theladcontinuedhisworkwithoutregardingus。IsawHolmes’seyedartingtorightandleftamongthelitterofironandwoodwhichwasscatteredaboutthefloor。Suddenly,however,weheardastepbehindus,andtherewasthelandlord,hisheavyeyebrowsdrawnoverhissavageeyes,hisswarthyfeaturesconvulsedwithpassion。Heheldashort,metal—headedstickinhishand,andheadvancedinsomenacingafashionthatIwasrightgladtofeeltherevolverinmypocket。
  "Youinfernalspies!"themancried。"Whatareyoudoingthere?"
  "Why,Mr。ReubenHayes,"saidHolmes,coolly,"onemightthinkthatyouwereafraidofourfindingsomethingout。"
  Themanmasteredhimselfwithaviolenteffort,andhisgrimmouthloosenedintoafalselaugh,whichwasmoremenacingthanhisfrown。
  "You’rewelcometoallyoucanfindoutinmysmithy,"saidhe。
  "Butlookhere,mister,Idon’tcareforfolkpokingaboutmyplacewithoutmyleave,sothesooneryoupayyourscoreandgetoutofthisthebetterIshallbepleased。"
  "Allright,Mr。Hayes——noharmmeant,"saidHolmes。
  "Wehavebeenhavingalookatyourhorses,butIthinkI’llwalkafterall。It’snotfar,Ibelieve。"
  "NotmorethantwomilestotheHallgates。That’stheroadtotheleft。"Hewatcheduswithsulleneyesuntilwehadlefthispremises。
  Wedidnotgoveryfaralongtheroad,forHolmesstoppedtheinstantthatthecurvehidusfromthelandlord’sview。
  "Wewerewarm,asthechildrensay,atthatinn,"saidhe。
  "IseemtogrowcoldereverystepthatItakeawayfromit。
  No,no;Ican’tpossiblyleaveit。"
  "Iamconvinced,"saidI,"thatthisReubenHayesknowsallaboutit。Amoreself—evidentvillainIneversaw。"
  "Oh!heimpressedyouinthatway,didhe?Therearethehorses,thereisthesmithy。Yes,itisaninterestingplace,thisFightingCock。Ithinkweshallhaveanotherlookatitinanunobtrusiveway。"
  Along,slopinghillside,dottedwithgreylimestoneboulders,stretchedbehindus。Wehadturnedofftheroad,andweremakingourwayupthehill,when,lookinginthedirectionofHoldernesseHall,Isawacyclistcomingswiftlyalong。
  "Getdown,Watson!"criedHolmes,withaheavyhanduponmyshoulder。Wehadhardlysunkfromviewwhenthemanflewpastusontheroad。AmidarollingcloudofdustIcaughtaglimpseofapale,agitatedface——afacewithhorrorineverylineament,themouthopen,theeyesstaringwildlyinfront。
  ItwaslikesomestrangecaricatureofthedapperJamesWilderwhomwehadseenthenightbefore。
  "TheDuke’ssecretary!"criedHolmes。"Come,Watson,letusseewhathedoes。"
  Wescrambledfromrocktorockuntilinafewmomentswehadmadeourwaytoapointfromwhichwecouldseethefrontdooroftheinn。Wilder’sbicyclewasleaningagainstthewallbesideit。Noonewasmovingaboutthehouse,norcouldwecatchaglimpseofanyfacesatthewindows。SlowlythetwilightcreptdownasthesunsankbehindthehightowersofHoldernesseHall。Theninthegloomwesawthetwoside—lampsofatraplightupinthestableyardoftheinn,andshortlyafterwardsheardtherattleofhoofs,asitwheeledoutintotheroadandtoreoffatafuriouspaceinthedirectionofChesterfield。
  "Whatdoyoumakeofthat,Watson?"Holmeswhispered。
  "Itlookslikeaflight。"
  "Asinglemaninadog—cart,sofarasIcouldsee。Well,itcertainlywasnotMr。JamesWilder,forthereheisatthedoor。"
  Aredsquareoflighthadsprungoutofthedarkness。Inthemiddleofitwastheblackfigureofthesecretary,hisheadadvanced,peeringoutintothenight。Itwasevidentthathewasexpectingsomeone。Thenatlasttherewerestepsintheroad,asecondfigurewasvisibleforaninstantagainstthelight,thedoorshut,andallwasblackoncemore。Fiveminuteslateralampwaslitinaroomuponthefirstfloor。
  "ItseemstobeacuriousclassofcustomthatisdonebytheFightingCock,"saidHolmes。
  "Thebarisontheotherside。"
  "Quiteso。Thesearewhatonemaycalltheprivateguests。
  Now,whatintheworldisMr。JamesWilderdoinginthatdenatthishourofnight,andwhoisthecompanionwhocomestomeethimthere?Come,Watson,wemustreallytakeariskandtrytoinvestigatethisalittlemoreclosely。"
  Togetherwestoledowntotheroadandcreptacrosstothedooroftheinn。Thebicyclestillleanedagainstthewall。
  Holmesstruckamatchandheldittothebackwheel,andI
  heardhimchuckleasthelightfelluponapatchedDunloptyre。
  Upaboveuswasthelightedwindow。
  "Imusthaveapeepthroughthat,Watson。Ifyoubendyourbackandsupportyourselfuponthewall,IthinkthatIcanmanage。"
  Aninstantlaterhisfeetwereonmyshoulders。
  Buthewashardlyupbeforehewasdownagain。
  "Come,myfriend,"saidhe,"ourday’sworkhasbeenquitelongenough。Ithinkthatwehavegatheredallthatwecan。It’salongwalktotheschool,andthesoonerwegetstartedthebetter。"
  Hehardlyopenedhislipsduringthatwearytrudgeacrossthemoor,norwouldheentertheschoolwhenhereachedit,butwentontoMackletonStation,whencehecouldsendsometelegrams。
  LateatnightIheardhimconsolingDr。Huxtable,prostratedbythetragedyofhismaster’sdeath,andlaterstillheenteredmyroomasalertandvigorousashehadbeenwhenhestartedinthemorning。
  "Allgoeswell,myfriend,"saidhe。"Ipromisethatbeforeto—morroweveningweshallhavereachedthesolutionofthemystery。"
  Ateleveno’clocknextmorningmyfriendandIwerewalkingupthefamousyewavenueofHoldernesseHall。WewereusheredthroughthemagnificentElizabethandoorwayandintohisGrace’sstudy。TherewefoundMr。JamesWilder,demureandcourtly,butwithsometraceofthatwildterrorofthenightbeforestilllurkinginhisfurtiveeyesandinhistwitchingfeatures。
  "YouhavecometoseehisGrace?Iamsorry;butthefactisthattheDukeisfarfromwell。Hehasbeenverymuchupsetbythetragicnews。WereceivedatelegramfromDr。Huxtableyesterdayafternoon,whichtoldusofyourdiscovery。"
  "ImustseetheDuke,Mr。Wilder。"
  "Butheisinhisroom。"
  "ThenImustgotohisroom。"
  "Ibelieveheisinhisbed。"
  "Iwillseehimthere。"
  Holmes’scoldandinexorablemannershowedthesecretarythatitwasuselesstoarguewithhim。
  "Verygood,Mr。Holmes;Iwilltellhimthatyouarehere。"
  Afterhalfanhour’sdelaythegreatnoblemanappeared。
  Hisfacewasmorecadaverousthanever,hisshouldershadrounded,andheseemedtometobeanaltogetheroldermanthanhehadbeenthemorningbefore。Hegreeteduswithastatelycourtesyandseatedhimselfathisdesk,hisredbeardstreamingdownontothetable。
  "Well,Mr。Holmes?"saidhe。
  Butmyfriend’seyeswerefixeduponthesecretary,whostoodbyhismaster’schair。
  "Ithink,yourGrace,thatIcouldspeakmorefreelyinMr。Wilder’sabsence。"
  ThemanturnedashadepalerandcastamalignantglanceatHolmes。
  "IfyourGracewishes————"
  "Yes,yes;youhadbettergo。Now,Mr。Holmes,whathaveyoutosay?"
  Myfriendwaiteduntilthedoorhadclosedbehindtheretreatingsecretary。
  "Thefactis,yourGrace,"saidhe,"thatmycolleague,Dr。Watson,andmyselfhadanassurancefromDr。Huxtablethatarewardhadbeenofferedinthiscase。Ishouldliketohavethisconfirmedfromyourownlips。"
  "Certainly,Mr。Holmes。"
  "Itamounted,ifIamcorrectlyinformed,tofivethousandpoundstoanyonewhowilltellyouwhereyoursonis?"
  "Exactly。"
  "Andanotherthousandtothemanwhowillnamethepersonorpersonswhokeephimincustody?"
  "Exactly。"
  "Underthelatterheadingisincluded,nodoubt,notonlythosewhomayhavetakenhimaway,butalsothosewhoconspiretokeephiminhispresentposition?"
  "Yes,yes,"criedtheDuke,impatiently。"Ifyoudoyourworkwell,Mr。SherlockHolmes,youwillhavenoreasontocomplainofniggardlytreatment。"
  Myfriendrubbedhisthinhandstogetherwithanappearanceofaviditywhichwasasurprisetome,whoknewhisfrugaltastes。
  "IfancythatIseeyourGrace’scheque—bookuponthetable,"
  saidhe。"Ishouldbegladifyouwouldmakemeoutachequeforsixthousandpounds。Itwouldbeaswell,perhaps,foryoutocrossit。TheCapitalandCountiesBank,OxfordStreetbranch,aremyagents。"
  HisGracesatverysternanduprightinhischair,andlookedstonilyatmyfriend。
  "Isthisajoke,Mr。Holmes?Itishardlyasubjectforpleasantry。"
  "Notatall,yourGrace。Iwasnevermoreearnestinmylife。"
  "Whatdoyoumean,then?"
  "ImeanthatIhaveearnedthereward。Iknowwhereyoursonis,andIknowsome,atleast,ofthosewhoareholdinghim。"
  TheDuke’sbeardhadturnedmoreaggressivelyredthaneveragainsthisghastlywhiteface。
  "Whereishe?"hegasped。
  "Heis,orwaslastnight,attheFightingCockInn,abouttwomilesfromyourparkgate。"
  TheDukefellbackinhischair。
  "Andwhomdoyouaccuse?"
  SherlockHolmes’sanswerwasanastoundingone。HesteppedswiftlyforwardandtouchedtheDukeupontheshoulder。
  "IaccuseYOU,"saidhe。"Andnow,yourGrace,I’lltroubleyouforthatcheque。"
  NevershallIforgettheDuke’sappearanceashesprangupandclawedwithhishandslikeonewhoissinkingintoanabyss。
  Then,withanextraordinaryeffortofaristocraticself—command,hesatdownandsankhisfaceinhishands。Itwassomeminutesbeforehespoke。
  "Howmuchdoyouknow?"heaskedatlast,withoutraisinghishead。
  "Isawyoutogetherlastnight。"
  "Doesanyoneelsebesidesyourfriendknow?"
  "Ihavespokentonoone。"
  TheDuketookapeninhisquiveringfingersandopenedhischeque—book。
  "Ishallbeasgoodasmyword,Mr。Holmes。Iamabouttowriteyourcheque,howeverunwelcometheinformationwhichyouhavegainedmaybetome。WhentheofferwasfirstmadeIlittlethoughttheturnwhicheventsmighttake。Butyouandyourfriendaremenofdiscretion,Mr。Holmes?"
  "IhardlyunderstandyourGrace。"
  "Imustputitplainly,Mr。Holmes。Ifonlyyoutwoknowofthisincident,thereisnoreasonwhyitshouldgoanyfarther。
  IthinktwelvethousandpoundsisthesumthatIoweyou,isitnot?"
  ButHolmessmiledandshookhishead。
  "Ifear,yourGrace,thatmatterscanhardlybearrangedsoeasily。
  Thereisthedeathofthisschoolmastertobeaccountedfor。"
  "ButJamesknewnothingofthat。Youcannotholdhimresponsibleforthat。Itwastheworkofthisbrutalruffianwhomhehadthemisfortunetoemploy。"
  "Imusttaketheview,yourGrace,thatwhenamanembarksuponacrimeheismorallyguiltyofanyothercrimewhichmayspringfromit。"
  "Morally,Mr。Holmes。Nodoubtyouareright。Butsurelynotintheeyesofthelaw。Amancannotbecondemnedforamurderatwhichhewasnotpresent,andwhichheloathesandabhorsasmuchasyoudo。Theinstantthatheheardofithemadeacompleteconfessiontome,sofilledwashewithhorrorandremorse。Helostnotanhourinbreakingentirelywiththemurderer。Oh,Mr。Holmes,youmustsavehim——youmustsavehim!Itellyouthatyoumustsavehim!"TheDukehaddroppedthelastattemptatself—command,andwaspacingtheroomwithaconvulsedfaceandwithhisclenchedhandsravingintheair。
  Atlasthemasteredhimselfandsatdownoncemoreathisdesk。
  "Iappreciateyourconductincomingherebeforeyouspoketoanyoneelse,"saidhe。"Atleast,wemaytakecounselhowfarwecanminimizethishideousscandal。"