……Often,atSaint—Cloud,hekeepsthecounselorsofstatefromnineo’clockinthemorninguntilfiveintheevening,withfifteenminutes’intermission,andseemsnomorefatiguedatthecloseofthesessionthanwhenitbegan。"Duringthenightsessions"manyofthememberssuccumbthroughweariness,whiletheMinisterofWarfallsasleep";hegivesthemashakeandwakesthemup,"Come,come,citizens,letusbestirourselves,itisonlytwoo’clockandwemustearnthemoneytheFrenchpeoplepayus。"ConsulorEmperor,[50]"hedemandsofeachministeranaccountofthesmallestdetails:Itisnotraretoseethemleavingthecouncilroomovercomewithfatigue,duetothelonginterrogatoriestowhichhehassubjectedthem;heappearsnottohavenoticed,andtalksabouttheday’sworksimplyasarelaxationwhichhasscarcelygivenhismindexercise。"Andwhatisworse,"itoftenhappensthatonreturninghometheyfindadozenofhislettersrequiringimmediateresponse,forwhichthewholenightscarcelysuffices。"Thequantityoffactsheisabletoretainandstoreaway,thequantityofideasheelaboratesandproduces,seemstosurpasshumancapacity,andthisinsatiable,inexhaustible,unmovablebrainthuskeepsonworkinguninterruptedlyforthirtyyears。Throughanotherresultofthesamementalorganization,Napoleon’sbrainisneverunproductive;that’stodayourgreatdanger。—Duringthepastthreehundredyearswehavemoreandmorelostsightoftheexactanddirectmeaningofthings。Subjecttotheconstraintsofaconservative,complex,andextendededucationalsystemwestudy*thesymbolsofobjectsratherthanontheobjectsthemselves;
*insteadofthegrounditself,amapofit;
*insteadofanimalsstrugglingforexistence,[51]nomenclaturesandclassifications,or,atbest,stuffedspecimensdisplayedinamuseum;
*insteadofpersonswhofeelandact,statistics,codes,histories,literatures,andphilosophies;
inshort,printedwords。Evenworse,abstractterms,whichfromcenturytocenturyhavebecomemoreabstractandthereforefurtherremovedfromexperience,moredifficulttounderstand,lessadaptableandmoredeceptive,especiallyinallthatrelatestohumanlifeandsociety。Here,duetothegrowthofgovernment,tothemultiplicationofservices,totheentanglementofinterests,theobject,indefinitelyenlargedandcomplex,noweludesourgrasp。Ourvague,incomplete,incorrectideaofitbadlycorrespondswithit,ordoesnotcorrespondatall。Inninemindsoutoften,orperhapsninety—
nineoutofahundred,itisbutlittlemorethanaword。Theothers,iftheydesiresomesignificantindicationofwhatsocietyactuallyisbeyondtheteachingsofbooks,requiretenorfifteenyearsofcloseobservationandstudytore—thinkthephraseswithwhichthesehavefilledtheirmemory,tointerpretthemanew,tomakecleartheirmeaning,togetatandverifytheirsense,tosubstituteforthemoreorlessemptyandindefinitetermthefullnessandprecisionofapersonalimpression。WehaveseenhowideasofSociety,State,Government,Sovereignty,Rights,Liberty,themostimportantofallideas,were,atthecloseoftheeighteenthcentury,curtailedandfalsified;how,inmostminds,simpleverbalreasoningcombinedthemtogetherindogmasandaxioms;whatanoffspringthesemetaphysicalsimulacragavebirthto,howmanylifelessandgrotesqueabortions,howmanymonstrousanddestructivechimeras。ThereisnoplaceforanyofthesefancifuldreamsinthemindofBonaparte;theycannotariseinit,norfindaccesstoit;hisaversiontotheunsubstantialphantomsofpoliticalabstractionextendsbeyonddisdain,eventodisgust。[52]Thatwhichwasthencalledideology,ishisparticularbugbear;heloathesitnotalonethroughcalculation,butstillmorethroughaninstinctivedemandforwhatisreal,asapracticalmanandstatesman,alwayskeepinginmind,likethegreatCatherine,"thatheisoperating,notonpaper,butonthehumanhide,whichisticklish。"
Everyideaentertainedbyhimhaditsorigininhispersonalobservation,andheusedhisownpersonalobservationstocontrolthem。
Ifbooksareusefultohimitistosuggestquestions,whichheneveranswersbutthroughhisownexperience。Hehasreadonlyalittle,andhastily;[53]hisclassicaleducationisrudimentary;inthewayofLatin,heremainedinthelowerclass。TheinstructionhegotattheMilitaryAcademyaswellasatBriennewasbelowmediocrity,while,afterBrienne,itisstatedthat"forthelanguagesandbelles—
lettres,hehadnotaste。"Nexttothis,theliteratureofeleganceandrefinement,thephilosophyoftheclosetanddrawing—room,withwhichhiscontemporariesareimbued,glidedoverhisintellectasoverahardrock。Nonebutmathematicaltruthsandpositivenotionsaboutgeographyandhistoryfoundtheirwayintohismindanddeeplyimpressedit。Everythingelse,aswithhispredecessorsofthefifteenthcentury,comestohimthroughtheoriginal,directactionofhisfacultiesincontactwithmenandthings,throughhispromptandsuretact,hisindefatigableandminuteattention,hisindefinitelyrepeatedandrectifieddivinationsduringlonghoursofsolitudeandsilence。Practice,andnotspeculation,isthesourceofhisinstruction,thesameaswithamechanicbroughtupamongstmachinery。
"ThereisnothingrelatingtowarfarethatIcannotmakemyself。Ifnobodyknowshowtomakegunpowder,Ido。Icanconstructgun—
carriages。Ifcannonmustbecast,Iwillseethatitisdoneproperly。Iftacticaldetailsmustbetaught,Iwillteachthem。"[54]
Thisiswhyheiscompetentrightfromthebeginning,generalintheartillery,major—general,diplomatist,financierandadministratorofallkinds。Thankstothisfertileapprenticeship,beginningwiththeConsulate,heshowsofficialsandveteranministerswhosendintheirreportstohimwhattodo。
"Iamamoreexperiencedadministratorthanthey,[55]whenonehasbeenobligedtoextractfromhisbrainsthewaysandmeanswithwhichtofeed,maintain,control,andmovewiththesamespiritandwilltwoorthreehundredthousandmen,alongdistancefromtheircountry,onehassoondiscoveredthesecretsofadministration。"
Ineachofthehumanmachineshebuildsandmanipulates,heperceivesrightawayalltheparts,eachinitsproperplaceandfunction,themotors,thetransmissions,thewheels,thecompositeaction,thespeedwhichensues,thefinalresult,thecompleteeffect,thenetproduct。
Neverishecontentwithasuperficialandsummaryinspection;hepenetratesintoobscurecornersandtothelowestdepths"throughthetechnicalprecisionofhisquestions,"withthelucidityofaspecialist,andinthisway,borrowinganexpressionfromthephilosophers,withhimtheconceptshouldbeadequatetoitspurpose。[56]
Hencehiseagernessfordetails,fortheseformthebodyandsubstanceoftheconcept;thehandthathasnotgraspedthese,orletsthemgo,retainsonlytheshell,anenvelope。Withrespecttothesehiscuriosityis"insatiable。"[57]Ineachministerialdepartmentheknowsmorethantheministers,andineachbureauheknowsasmuchastheclerks。"Onhistable[58]liereportsofthepositionsofhisforcesonlandandonwater。Hehasfurnishedtheplansofthese,andfreshonesareissuedeverymonth";suchisthedailyreadinghelikesbest。
"Ihavemyreportsonpositionsalwaysathand;mymemoryforanAlexandrineisnotgood,butIneverforgetasyllableofmyreportsonpositions。Ishallfindtheminmyroomthisevening,andIshallnotgotobeduntilIhavereadthem。"
Healwaysknows"hisposition"onlandandatseabetterthanisknownintheWarandNavydepartments;bettereventhanhisstaff—officersthenumber,size,andqualitiesofhisshipsinoroutofport,thepresentandfuturestateofvesselsunderconstruction,thecompositionandstrengthoftheircrews,theformation,organization,staffofofficers,material,stations,andenlistments,pastandtocome,ofeacharmycorpsandofeachregiment。Itisthesameinthefinancialanddiplomaticservices,ineverybranchoftheadministration,laicorecclesiastical,inthephysicalorderandinthemoralorder。Histopographicalmemoryandhisgeographicalconceptionofcountries,places,ground,andobstaclesculminateinaninwardvisionwhichheevokesatwill,andwhich,yearsafterwards,revivesasfreshasonthefirstday。Hiscalculationofdistances,marches,andmaneuversissorigidamathematicaloperationthat,frequently,atadistanceoftwoorfourhundredleagues,[59]hismilitaryforesight,calculatedtwoorfourmonthsahead,turnsoutcorrect,almostonthedaynamed,andpreciselyonthespotdesignated。[60]Addtothisoneotherfaculty,andtherarestofall。
For,ifthingsturnoutasheforesawtheywould,itisbecause,aswithgreatchess—players,hehasaccuratelymeasurednotalonethemechanicalmovesofthepieces,butthecharacterandtalentofhisadversary,"soundedhisdraftofwater,"anddivinedhisprobablemistakes。Hehasaddedthecalculationofphysicalquantitiesandprobabilitiestothecalculationofmoralquantitiesandprobabilities,thusshowinghimselfasgreatapsychologistasheisanaccomplishedstrategist。Infact,noonehassurpassedhimintheartofjudgingtheconditionandmotivesofanindividualorofagroupofpeople,therealmotives,permanentortemporary,whichdriveorcurbmeningeneralorthisorthatmaninparticular,theincentivestobeemployed,thekindanddegreeofpressuretobeemployed。Thiscentralfacultyrulesalltheothers,andintheartofmasteringManhisgeniusisfoundsupreme。
III。HisacuteUnderstandingofOthers。
Hispsychologicalfacultyandwayofgettingatthethoughtandfeelingofothers。—Hisself—analysis。—Howheimaginesageneralsituationbyselectingaparticularcase,imaginingtheinvisibleinteriorbydeductingfromthevisibleexterior。—Originalityandsuperiorityofhisstyleanddiscourse。—Hisadaptationofthesetohishearersandtocircumstances。—Hisnotationandcalculationofserviceablemotives。
Nofacultyismorepreciousforapoliticalengineer;fortheforcesheactsuponareneverotherthanhumanpassions。Buthow,exceptthroughdivination,canthesepassions,whichgrowoutofthedeepestsentiments,bereached?How,savebyconjecture,canforcesbeestimatedwhichseemtodefyallmeasurement?Onthisdarkanduncertainground,whereonehastogropeone’sway,Napoleonmoveswithalmostabsolutecertainty;hemovespromptly。Firstofall,hestudieshimself;indeed,tofindone’swayintoanother’ssoulrequires,preliminarily,thatoneshoulddivedeepintoone’sown。[61]
"Ihavealwaysdelightedinanalysis,"saidhe,oneday,"andshouldI
everfallseriouslyinloveIwouldtakemysentimenttopieces。WhyandHowaresuchimportantquestionsonecannotputthemtoone’sselftoooften。"
"Itiscertain,"writesanobserver,"thathe,ofallmen,istheonewhohasmostmeditatedonthewhywhichcontrolshumanactions。"
Hismethod,thatoftheexperimentalsciences,consistsintestingeveryhypothesisordeductionbysomepositivefact,observedbyhimunderdefiniteconditions;aphysicalforcebeingascertainedandaccuratelymeasuredthroughthedeviationofaneedle,orthroughtheriseandfallofafluid,thisorthatinvisiblemoralforcecanlikewisebeascertainedandapproximatelymeasuredthroughsomeemotionalsign,somedecisivemanifestation,consistingofacertainword,tone,orgesture。Itisthesewords,tones,andgestureswhichhedwellson;hedetectsinwardsentimentsbytheoutwardexpression;
hefigurestohimselftheinternalbytheexternal,bysomefacialappearance,sometellingattitude,somebriefandtopicalscene,bysuchspecimenandshortcuts,sowellchosenanddetailedthattheyprovideasummaryoftheinnumerableseriesofanalogouscases。Inthisway,thevague,fleetingobjectissuddenlyarrested,broughttobear,andthengaugedandweighed,likesomeimpalpablegascollectedandkeptinagraduatedtransparentglasstube。—Accordingly,attheCouncilofState,whiletheothers,eitherjuristsoradministrators,seeabstractions,articlesofthelawandprecedents,heseespeopleastheyare—theFrenchman,theItalian,theGerman;thatofthepeasant,theworkman,thebourgeois,thenoble,thereturnedémigré,[62]thesoldier,theofficerandthefunctionary—everywheretheindividualmanasheis,themanwhoplows,manufactures,fights,marries,bringsforthchildren,toils,enjoyshimself,anddies。—
Nothingismorestrikingthanthecontrastbetweenthedull,graveargumentsadvancedbythewiseofficialeditor,andNapoleon’sownwordscaughtonthewing,atthemoment,vibratingandteemingwithillustrationsandimagery。[63]Aproposofdivorce,theprincipleofwhichhewishestomaintain:
"Consult,now,nationalmannersandcustoms。Adulteryisnophenomenon;itiscommonenough—uneaffairedecanapé……Theremustbesomecurbonwomenwhocommitadulteryfortrinkets,poetry,Apollo,andthemuses,etc。"
Butifdivorcebeallowedforincompatibilityoftemperyouunderminemarriage;thefragilityofthebondwillbeapparentthemomenttheobligationiscontracted;
"itisjustasifamansaidtohimself,’IamgoingtomarryuntilI
feeldifferent。’"
Nullityofmarriagemustnotbetoooftenallowed;onceamarriageismadeitisaseriousmattertoundoit。
"Supposethat,inmarryingmycousinjustarrivedfromtheIndies,I
wedanadventuress。Shebearsmechildren,andIthendiscoversheisnotmycousin—isthatmarriagevalid?Doesnotpublicmoralitydemandthatitshouldbesoconsidered?Therehasbeenamutualexchangeofhearts,oftranspiration。"
Ontherightofchildrentobesupportedandfedalthoughofage,hesays:
"Willyouallowafathertodriveagirloffifteenoutofhishouse?
Afatherworth60,000francsayearmightsaytohisson,’Youarestoutandfat;goandturnplowman。’Thechildrenofarichfather,orofoneingoodcircumstances,arealwaysentitledtothepaternalporridge。Strikeouttheirrighttobefed,andyoucompelchildrentomurdertheirparents。"
Astoadoption:
"Youregardthisaslaw—makersandnotasstatesmen。Itisnotacivilcontractnorajudicialcontract。Theanalysis(ofthejurist)
leadstoviciousresults。Manisgovernedbyimaginationonly;
withoutimaginationheisabrute。Itisnotforfivecentsaday,simplytodistinguishhimself,thatamanconsentstobekilled;ifyouwanttoelectrifyhimtouchhisheart。Anotary,whoispaidafeeoftwelvefrancsforhisservices,cannotdothat。Itrequiressomeotherprocess,alegislativeact。Adoption,whatisthat?Animitationbywhichsocietytriestocounterfeitnature。Itisanewkindofsacrament……Societyordainsthatthebonesandbloodofonebeingshallbechangedintothebonesandbloodofanother。Itisthegreatestofalllegalacts。Itgivesthesentimentsofasontoonewhoneverhadthem,andreciprocallythoseofaparent。Whereoughtthistooriginate?Fromonhigh,likeaclapofthunder!"
Allhisexpressionsarebrightflashesoneafteranother。[64]Nobody,sinceVoltaireandGaliani,haslaunchedforthsuchaprofusionofthem;onsociety,laws,government,FranceandtheFrench,somepenetrateandexplain,likethoseofMontesquieu,asifwithaflashoflightening。Hedoesnothammerthemoutlaboriously,buttheyburstforth,theoutpouringsofhisintellect,itsnatural,involuntary,constantaction。Andwhataddstotheirvalueisthat,outsideofcouncilsandprivateconversations,heabstainsfromthem,employingthemonlyintheserviceofthought;atothertimeshesubordinatesthemtotheendhehasinview,whichisalwaystheirpracticaleffect。Ordinarily,hewritesandspeaksinadifferentlanguage,inalanguagesuitedtohisaudience;hedispenseswiththeoddities,theirregularimprovisationsandimagination,theoutburstsofgeniusandinspiration。Heretainsandusesmerelythosewhichareintendedtoimpressthepersonagewhomhewishestodazzlewithagreatideaofhimself,suchasPiusVII。,ortheEmperorAlexander。
Inthiscase,hisconversationaltoneisthatofacaressing,expansive,amiablefamiliarity;heisthenbeforethefootlights,andwhenheactshecanplayallparts,tragedyorcomedy,withthesamelifeandspiritwhetherhefulminates,insinuates,orevenaffectssimplicity。Whenheiswithhisgenerals,ministers,andprincipalperformers,hefallsbackontheconcise,positive,technicalbusinessstyle;anyotherwouldbeharmful。Thekeenmindonlyrevealsitselfthroughthebrevityandimperiousstrengthandrudenessoftheaccent。
Forhisarmiesandthecommonrunofmen,hehashisproclamationsandbulletins,thatistosay,sonorousphrasescomposedforeffect,astatementoffactspurposelysimplifiedandfalsified,[65]inshort,anexcellenteffervescentwine,goodforexcitingenthusiasm,andanequallyexcellentnarcoticformaintainingcredulity,[66]asortofpopularmixturetobedistributedjustatthepropertime,andwhoseingredientsaresowellproportionedthatthepublicdrinksitwithdelight,andbecomesatonceintoxicated。—Hisstyleoneveryoccasion,whetheraffectedorspontaneous,showshiswonderfulknowledgeofthemassesandofindividuals;exceptintwoorthreecases,ononeexalteddomain,ofwhichhealwaysremainsignorant,hehaseverhitthemark,applyingtheappropriatelever,givingjustthepush,weight,anddegreeofimpulsionwhichbestaccomplisheshispurpose。Aseriesofbrief,accuratememoranda,correcteddaily,enableshimtoframeforhimselfasortofpsychologicaltabletwhereonhenotesdownandsumsup,inalmostnumericalvaluation,thementalandmoraldispositions,characters,faculties,passions,andaptitudes,thestrongorweakpoints,oftheinnumerablehumanbeings,nearorremote,onwhomheoperates。
IV。HisWonderfulMemory。
HisThreeAtlases。—Theirscaleandcompleteness。
Letustryforamomenttoshowtherangeandcontentsofthisintellect;wemayhavetogobacktoCaesartohisequal;but,forlackofdocuments,wehavenothingofCaesarbutgeneralfeatures—asummaryoutline。OfNapoleonwehave,besidestheperfectoutline,thefeaturesindetail。Readhiscorrespondence,daybyday,thenchapterbychapter;[67]forexample,in1806,afterthebattleofAusterlitz,or,stillbetter,in1809,afterhisreturnfromSpain,uptothepeaceofVienna;whateverourtechnicalshortcomingsmaybe,weshallfindthathismind,initscomprehensivenessandamplitude,largelysurpassesallknownorevencredibleproportions。
Hehasmentallywithinhimthreeprincipalatlases,alwaysathand,eachcomposedof"abouttwentynote—books,"eachdistinctandeachregularlypostedup。—
1。Thefirstoneismilitary,formingavastcollectionoftopographicalchartsasminuteasthoseofangeneralstaff,withdetailedplansofeverystronghold,alsospecificindicationsandthelocaldistributionofallforcesonseaandonland—crews,regiments,batteries,arsenals,storehouses,presentandfutureresourcesinsuppliesofmen,horses,vehicles,arms,munitions,food,andclothing。
2。Thesecond,whichiscivil,resemblestheheavy,thickvolumespublishedeveryyear,inwhichwenowreadthestateofthebudget,andcomprehend,first,theinnumerableitemsofordinaryandextraordinaryreceiptandexpenditure,internaltaxes,foreigncontributions,theproductsofthedomainsinFranceandoutofFrance,thefiscalservices,pensions,publicworks,andtherest;
next,alladministrativestatistics,thehierarchyoffunctionsandoffunctionaries,senators,deputies,ministers,prefects,bishops,professors,judges,andthoseundertheirorders,eachwhereheresides,withhisrank,jurisdiction,andsalary。
3。Thethirdisavastbiographicalandmoraldictionary,inwhich,asinthepigeon—holesoftheChiefofPolice,eachnotablepersonageandlocalgroup,eachprofessionalorsocialbody,andeveneachpopulation,hasitslabel,alongwithabriefnoteonitssituation,needs,andantecedents,and,therefore,itsdemonstratedcharacter,eventualdisposition,andprobableconduct。Eachlabel,card,orstripofpaperhasitssummary;allthesepartialsummaries,methodicallyclassified,terminateintotals,andthetotalsofthethreeatlases,combinedtogether,thusfurnishtheirpossessorwithanestimateofhisdisposableforces。
Now,in1809,howeverfulltheseatlases,theyareclearlyimprintedonNapoleon’smindheknowsnotonlythetotalandthepartialsummaries,butalsotheslightestdetails;hereadsthemreadilyandateveryhour;hecomprehendsinamass,andinallparticulars,thevariousnationshegovernsdirectly,orthroughsomeoneelse;thatistosay,60,000,000men,thedifferentcountrieshehasconqueredoroverrun,consistingof70,000squareleagues[68]。Atfirst,FranceincreasedbytheadditionofBelgiumandPiedmont;nextSpain,fromwhichheisjustreturned,andwherehehasplacedhisbrotherJoseph;
southernItaly,where,afterJoseph,hehasplacedMurat;centralItaly,whereheoccupiesRome;northernItaly,whereEugèneishisdelegate;DalmatiaandIstria,whichhehasjoinedtohisempire;
Austria,whichheinvadesforthesecondtime;theConfederationoftheRhine,whichhehasmadeandwhichhedirects;WestphaliaandHolland,wherehisbrothersareonlyhislieutenants;Prussia,whichhehassubduedandmutilatedandwhichheoppresses,andthestrongholdsofwhichhestillretains;and,addalastmentaltableau,thatwhichrepresentsthenorthernseas,theAtlanticandtheMediterranean,allthefleetsofthecontinentatseaandinportfromDantzictoFlessingenandBayonne,fromCadiztoToulonandGa?ta,fromTarentumtoVenice,Corfu,andConstantinople。[69]—Onthepsychologicalandmoralatlas,besidesaprimitivegapwhichhewillneverfillup,becausethisisacharacteristictrait,therearesomeestimateswhicharewrong,especiallywithregardtothePopeandtoCatholicconscience。InlikemannerheratestheenergyofnationalsentimentinSpainandGermanytoolow。HeratestoohighhisownprestigeinFranceandinthecountriesannexedtoher,thebalanceofconfidenceandzealonwhichhemayrely。Buttheseerrorsarerathertheproductofhiswillthanofhisintelligence,herecognizesthematintervals;ifhehasillusionsitisbecausehefabricatesthem;
lefttohimselfhisgoodsensewouldrestinfallible,itisonlyhispassionswhichblurredthelucidityofhisintellect。—Astotheothertwoatlases,thetopographicalandthemilitary,theyareascompleteandasexactasever;Nomatterhowmuchtherealitiestheycontainwillswellanddailybecomeevermorecomplex,theycontinuetocorrespondtoitintheirfullnessandprecision,traitfortrait。
V。HisImaginationanditsExcesses。
Hisconstructiveimagination。—Hisprojectsanddreams。—
Manifestationofthemasterfacultyanditsexcesses。
Butthismultitudeofinformationandobservationsformonlythesmallestportionofthementalpopulationswarminginthisimmensebrain;for,onhisideaofthereal,germinateandswarmhisconceptsofthepossible;withouttheseconceptstherewouldbenowaytohandleandtransformthings,andthathedidhandleandtransformthemweallknow。Beforeacting,hehasdecidedonhisplan,andifthisplanisadopted,itisoneamongseveralothers,[70]afterexamining,comparing,andgivingitthepreference;hehasaccordinglythoughtoveralltheothers。Behindeachcombinationadoptedbyhimwedetectthosehehasrejected;therearedozensofthembehindeachofhisdecisions,eachmaneuvereffected,eachtreatysigned,eachdecreepromulgated,eachorderissued,andIventuretosay,behindalmosteveryimprovisedactionorwordspoken。Forcalculationentersintoeverythinghedoes,evenintohisapparentexpansiveness,alsointohisoutburstswheninearnest;ifhegiveswaytothese,itisonpurpose,foreseeingtheeffect,withaviewtointimidateortodazzle。Heturnseverythinginothersaswellasinhimselftoaccount—hispassion,hisvehemence,hisweaknesses,histalkativeness,heexploitsitallfortheadvancementoftheedificeheisconstructing。[71]Certainlyamonghisdiversefaculties,howevergreat,thatoftheconstructiveimaginationisthemostpowerful。Attheverybeginningwefeelitsheatandboilingintensitybeneaththecoolnessandrigidityofhistechnicalandpositiveinstructions。
"WhenIplanabattle,"saidhetoRoederer,"nomanismorespinelessthanIam。Ioverexaggeratetomyselfallthedangersandalltheevilsthatarepossibleunderthecircumstances。Iaminastateoftrulypainfulagitation。Butthisdoesnotpreventmefromappearingquitecomposedtopeoplearoundme;Iamlikeawomangivingbirthtoachild。[72]
Passionately,inthethroesofthecreator,heisthusabsorbedwithhiscomingcreation;healreadyanticipatesandenjoyslivinginhisimaginaryedifice。"General,"saidMadamedeClermont—Tonnerretohim,oneday,"youarebuildingbehindascaffoldingwhichyouwilltakedownwhenyouhavedonewithit。""Yes,Madame,that’sit,"
repliedBonaparte;"youareright。Iamalwayslivingtwoyearsinadvance。"[73]Hisresponsecamewith"incrediblevivacity,"asifasuddeninspiration,thatofasoulstirredinitsinnermostfiber。—
Hereaswell,thepower,thespeed,fertility,play,andabundanceofhisthoughtseemunlimited。Whathehasaccomplishedisastonishing,butwhathehasundertakenismoreso;andwhateverhemayhaveundertakenisfarsurpassedbywhathehasimagined。Howevervigoroushispracticalfaculty,hispoeticalfacultyisstronger;itiseventoovigorousforastatesman;itsgrandeurisexaggeratedintoenormity,anditsenormitydegeneratesintomadness。InItaly,afterthe18thofFructidor,hesaidtoBourrienne:
"Europeisamolehill;neverhavetherebeengreatempiresandgreatrevolutions,exceptintheOrient,withits600,000,000
inhabitants。"[74]
ThefollowingyearatSaint—Jeand’Acre,ontheeveofthelastassault,headded"IfIsucceedIshallfindinthetownthepasha’streasureandarmsfor300,000men。IstirupandarmallSyria……ImarchonDamascusandAleppo;asIadvanceinthecountrymyarmywillincreasewiththediscontented。Iproclaimtothepeopletheabolitionofslavery,andofthetyrannicalgovernmentofthepashas。IreachConstantinoplewitharmedmasses。IoverthrowtheTurkishEmpire;I
foundintheEastanewandgrandempire,whichfixesmyplacewithposterity,andperhapsIreturntoParisbythewayofAdrianople,orbyVienna,afterhavingannihilatedthehouseofAustria。"[75]
Becomeconsul,andthenemperor,heoftenreferredtothishappyperiod,when,"ridoftherestraintsofatroublesomecivilization,"
hecouldimagineatwillandconstructatpleasure。[76]
"Icreatedareligion;IsawmyselfontheroadtoAsia,mountedonanelephant,withaturbanonmyhead,andinmyhandanewKoran,whichIcomposedtosuitmyself。"
ConfinedtoEurope,hethinks,after1804,thathewillreorganizeCharlemagne’sempire。
"TheFrenchEmpirewillbecomethemothercountryofothersovereignties……ImeanthateverykinginEuropeshallbuildagrandpalaceatParisforhisownuse;onthecoronationoftheEmperoroftheFrenchthesekingswillcomeandoccupyit;theywillgracethisimposingceremonywiththeirpresence,andhonoritwiththeirsalutations。"[77]ThePopewillcome;hecametothefirstone;
hemustnecessarilyreturntoParis,andfixhimselftherepermanently。WherecouldtheHolySeebebetteroffthaninthenewcapitalofChristianity,underNapoleon,heirtoCharlemagne,andtemporalsovereignoftheSovereignPontiff?Throughthetemporaltheemperorwillcontrolthespiritual,[78]andthroughthePope,consciences。"
InNovember,1811,unusuallyexcited,hesaystoDePradt:
"InfiveyearsIshallbemasteroftheworld;onlyRussiawillremain,butIwillcrushher。[79]……PariswillextendouttoSt。Cloud。"
TorenderParisthephysicalcapitalofEuropeis,throughhisownconfession,"oneofhisconstantdreams。"
"Attimes,"hesays,[80]"Iwouldliketoseeheracityoftwo,three,fourmillionsofinhabitants,somethingfabulous,colossal,unknowndowntoourday,anditspublicestablishmentsadequatetoitspopulation……Archimedesproposedtolifttheworldifhecouldbeallowedtoplacehislever;formyself,IwouldhavechangeditwhereverIcouldhavebeenallowedtoexercisemyenergy,perseverance,andbudgets。"
Atallevents,hebelievesso;forhoweverloftyandbadlysupportedthenextstoryofhisstructuremaybe,hehasalwaysreadyanewstory,loftierandmoreunsteady,toputaboveit。Afewmonthsbeforelaunchinghimself,withallEuropeathisback,againstRussia,hesaidtoNarbonne:[81]
"Afterall,mydearsir,thislongroadistheroadtoIndia。
AlexanderstartedasfaroffasMoscowtoreachtheGanges;thishasoccurredtomesinceSt。Jeand’Acre……ToreachEnglandto—
dayIneedtheextremityofEurope,fromwhichtotakeAsiaintherear……SupposeMoscowtaken,Russiasubdued,theczarreconciled,ordeadthroughsomecourtconspiracy,perhapsanotheranddependentthrone,andtellmewhetheritisnotpossibleforaFrencharmy,withitsauxiliaries,settingoutfromTiflis,togetasfarastheGanges,whereitneedsonlyathrustoftheFrenchswordtobringdownthewholeofthatgrandcommercialscaffoldingthroughoutIndia。
Itwouldbethemostgiganticexpedition,Iadmit,butpracticableinthenineteenthcentury。ThroughitFrance,atonestroke,wouldsecuretheindependenceoftheWestandthefreedomoftheseas。"
Whileutteringthishiseyesshonewithstrangebrilliancy,andheaccumulatessubjects,weighingobstacles,means,andchances:theinspirationisunderfullheadway,andhegiveshimselfuptoit。Themasterfacultyfindsitselfsuddenlyfree,andittakesflight;theartist,[82]lockedupinpolitics,hasescapedfromhissheath;heiscreatingoutoftheidealandtheimpossible。Wetakehimforwhatheis,aposthumousbrotherofDanteandMichaelAngelo。Intheclearoutlinesofhisvision,intheintensity,coherency,andinwardlogicofhisdreams,intheprofundityofhismeditations,inthesuperhumangrandeurofhisconceptions,heis,indeed,theirfellowandtheirequal。Hisgeniusisofthesamestatureandthesamestructure;heisoneofthethreesovereignmindsoftheItalianRenaissance。Only,whilethefirsttwooperatedonpaperandonmarble,thelatteroperatesonthelivingbeing,onthesensitiveandsufferingfleshofhumanity。
_
Notes:
[1]ReformsintroducedbyNapoleonafterhiscoupd’état9Nov。1799。
(SR。)
[2]Themainauthorityis,ofcourse,the"correspondancedel’EmpereurNapoléonI。,"inthirty—two—volumes。Thiscorrespondance,"
unfortunately,isstillincomplete,while,afterthesixthvolume,itmustnotbeforgottenthatmuchofithasbeenpurposelystrickenout。
"Ingeneral,"saytheeditors(XVI。,p。4),"wehavebeengovernedsimplybythisplainrule,thatwewererequiredtopublishonlywhattheEmperorhimselfwouldhavegiventothepublichadhesurvivedhimself,and,anticipatingtheverdictoftime,exposedtoposterityhisownpersonalityandsystem。"—Thesavantwhohasthemostcarefullyexaminedthiscorrespondence,entireintheFrencharchives,estimatesthatitcomprisesabout80,000pieces,ofwhich30,000havebeenpublishedinthecollectionreferredto;passagesin20,000oftheothershavebeenstrickenoutonaccountofpreviouspublication,andabout30,000more,throughconsiderationsofproprietyorpolicy。
Forexample,butlittlemorethanone—halfofthelettersfromNapoleontoBigotdePréameneuonecclesiasticalmattershavebeenpublished;manyoftheseomittedletters,allimportantandcharacteristic,maybefoundin"L’égliseromaineetlePremierEmpire,"byM。d’Haussonville。Theabove—mentionedsavantestimatesthenumberofimportantlettersnotyetpublishedat2,000。
[3]"MémorialdeSainteHéléne,"byLasCasas(May29,1816)。———"InCorsica,Paoli,onahorsebackexcursion,explainedthepositionstohim,theplaceswherelibertyfoundresistanceortriumphed。
EstimatingthecharacterofNapoleonbywhathesawofitthroughpersonalobservation,Paolisaidtohim,"Oh,Napoleon,thereisnothingmoderninyou,youbelongwhollytoPlutarch!"——Antonomarchi,"Mémoires,"Oct。25,1819。Thesameaccount,slightlydifferent,istheregiven:"Oh。Napoleon,"saidPaolitome,"youdonotbelongtothiscentury;youtalklikeoneofPlutarch’scharacters。Courage,youwilltakeflightyet!"
[4]DeSégur,"HistoireetMémoires,"I。,150。(NarrativebyPontécoulant,memberofthecommitteeinthewar,June,1795。)"Boissyd’AnglastoldhimthathehadseentheeveningbeforealittleItalian,pale,slender,andpuny,butsingularlyaudaciousinhisviewsandinthevigorofhisexpressions。—Thenextday,BonapartecallsonPontécou1ant,"Attituderigidthroughamorbidpride,poorexterior,longvisage,hollowandbronzed……Heisjustfromthearmyandtalkslikeonewhoknowswhatheistalkingabout。"
[5]Coston,"BiographiedespremièresannéesdeNapoléonBuonaparte,"
2vols。(1840),passim。—Yung,"BonaparteetsonTemps,"I。,300,302。(Piècesgénéalogiques。)—KingJoseph,"Mémoires,"I。,109,111。
(OnthevariousbranchesanddistinguishedmenoftheBonapartefamily。)—MiotdeMelito,"Mémoires,"II。,30。(DocumentsontheBonapartefamily,collectedonthespotbytheauthorin1801。)
[6]"Mémorial,"May6,1816。—MiotdeMelito,II。,30。(OntheBonapartesofSanMiniato):"ThelastoffshootofthisbranchwasacanonthenstilllivinginthissametownofSanMiniato,andvisitedbyBonaparteintheyearIV,whenhecametoFlorence。"
[7]"Correspondancedel’EmpereurNapoléonI。"(LetterofBonaparte,Sept。29,1797,inrelationtoItaly):"ApeopleatbottominimicaltotheFrenchthroughtheprejudices,character,andcustomsofcenturies。"
[8]MiotdeMelito,I。,126,(1796):"Florence,fortwocenturiesandahalf,hadlostthatantiqueenergywhich,inthestormytimesoftheRepublic,distinguishedthiscity。Indolencewasthedominantspiritofallclasses……AlmosteverywhereIsawonlymenlulledtorestbythecharmsofthemostexquisiteclimate,occupiedsolelywiththedetailsofamonotonousexistence,andtranquillyvegetatingunderitsbeneficentsky。"—(OnMilan,in1796,cf。Stendhal,introductiontothe"ChartreusedeParme。")
[9]"MiotdeMelito,I。,131:"HavingjustleftoneofthemostcivilizedcitiesinItaly,itwasnotwithoutsomeemotionthatI
foundmyselfsuddenlytransportedtoacountry(Corsica)which,initssavageaspect,itsruggedmountains,anditsinhabitantsuniformlydressedincoarsebrowncloth,contrastedsostronglywiththerichandsmilinglandscapeofTuscany,andwiththecomfort,Ishouldalmostsayelegance,ofcostumewornbythehappycultivatorsofthatfertilesoil。"
[10]MiotdeMelito,II。,30:"OfanotveryimportantfamilyofSartène。"—II。,143。(OnthecantonofSartèneandtheVendettasof1796)。—Coston,I。,4:"ThefamilyofMadameLaetitia,sprungfromthecountsofCotalto,cameoriginallyfromItaly。"
[11]Hisfather,CharlesBonaparte,weakandevenfrivolous,"toofondofpleasuretocareabouthischildren,"andtoseetohisaffairs,tolerablylearnedandanindifferentheadofafamily,diedattheageofthirty—nineofacancerinthestomach,whichseemstobetheonlybequesthemadetohissonNapoleon。—Hismother,onthecontrary,serious,authoritative,thetrueheadofafamily,was,saidNapoleon,"hardinheraffectionsshepunishedandrewardedwithoutdistinction,goodorbad;shemadeusallfeelit。"—Onbecomingheadofthehousehold,"shewastooparsimonious—evenridiculouslyso。
Thiswasduetoexcessofforesightonherpart;shehadknownwant,andherterriblesufferingswereneveroutofhermind……
Paolihadtriedpersuasionwithherbeforeresortingtoforce……Madamerepliedheroically,asaCorneliawouldhavedone……
From12to15,000peasantspoureddownfromthemountainsofAjaccio;
ourhousewaspillagedandburnt,ourvinesdestroyed,andourflocks……Inotherrespects,thiswoman,fromwhomitwouldhavebeensodifficulttoextractfivefrancs,wouldhavegivenupeverythingtosecuremyreturnfromElba,andafterWaterloosheofferedmeallshepossessedtorestoremyaffairs。"("Mémorial,"May29,1816,and"Mémoiresd’Antonomarchi,"Nov。18,1819。—OntheideasandwaysofBonaparte’smother,readher"Conversation"in"JournaletMémoires,"vol。IV。,byStanislasGirardin。)Duchessed’Abrantès,"
Mémoires,"II。,318,369。"Avariciousoutofallreasonexceptonafewgraveoccasions……Noknowledgewhateveroftheusagesofsociety……veryignorant,notaloneofourliterature,butofherown。"—Stendhal,"ViedeNapoleon":"ThecharacterofhersonistobeexplainedbytheperfectlyItaliancharacterofMadameLaetitia。"
[12]TheFrenchconquestiseffectedbyarmedforcebetweenJuly30,1768,andMay22,1769。TheBonapartefamilysubmittedMay23,1769,andNapoleonwasbornonthefollowing15thofAugust。
[13]Antonomarchi,"Mémoires,"October4,1819。"Mémorial,"May29,1816。
[14]MiotdeMelito,II。,33:"ThedayIarrivedatBocognanotwomenlosttheirlivesthroughprivatevengeance。Abouteightyearsbeforethisoneoftheinhabitantsofthecantonhadkilledaneighbor,thefatheroftwochildren……Onreachingtheageofsixteenorseventeenyearsthesechildrenleftthecountryinordertodogthestepsofthemurderer,whokeptonthewatch,notdaringtogofarfromhisvillage……Findinghimplayingcardsunderatree,theyfiredatandkilledhim,andbesidesthisaccidentallyshotanothermanwhowasasleepafewpacesoff。Therelativesonbothsidespronouncedtheactjustifiableandaccordingtorule。"Ibid。,I。,143:"OnreachingBastiafromAjacciothetwoprincipalfamiliesoftheplace,thePeraldiandtheVisuldi,firedateachother,indisputingoverthehonorofentertainingme。
[15]Bourrienne,"Mémoires,"I。,18,19。
[16]DeSégur,"HistoireetMémoires,"I,,74。
[17]Yung,I。,195。(LetterofBonapartetoPaoli,June12,1789);
I。,250(LetterofBonapartetoButtafuoco,January231790)。
[18]Yung,I。,107(LetterofNapoleontohisfather,Sept。12,1784);I。,163(LetterofNapoleontoAbbéRaynal,July,1786);I。,197(LetterofNapoleontoPaoli,June12,1789)。ThethreelettersonthehistoryofCorsicaarededicatedtoAbbéRaynalinaletterofJune24,1790,andmaybefoundinYung,I。,434。
[19]Readespeciallyhisessay"OntheTruthsandSentimentsmostimportanttoinculcateonMenfortheirWelfare"(asubjectproposedbytheAcademyofLyonsin1790)。Someboldmendrivenbygenius……Perfectiongrowsoutofreasonasfruitoutofatree……
Reason’seyesguardmanfromtheprecipiceofthepassions……
ThespectacleofthestrengthofvirtuewaswhattheLacedaemoniansprincipallyfelt……Mustmenthenbeluckyinthemeansbywhichtheyareledontohappiness?……Myrights(toproperty)arerenewedalongwithmytranspiration,circulateinmyblood,arewrittenonmynerves,onmyheart……Proclaimtotherich—yourwealthisyourmisfortune,withdrawnwithinthelatitudeofyoursenses……Lettheenemiesofnatureatthyvoicekeepsilenceandswallowtheirrabidserpents’tongues……
Thewretchedshunthesocietyofmen,thetapestryofgayetyturnstomourning……Such,gentlemen,aretheSentimentswhich,inanimalrelations,mankindshouldhavetaughtitforitswelfare。"
[20]Yung,I。,252(LettertoButtafuoco)。"Drippingwiththebloodofhisbrethren,sulliedbyeveryspeciesofcrime,hepresentshimselfwithconfidenceunderhisvestofageneral,thesolerewardofhiscriminalities。"—I。,192(LettertotheCorsicanIntendant,April2,1879)。"Cultivationiswhatruinsus"—Seevariousmanuscriptletters,copiedbyYung,forinnumerableandgrossmistakesinFrench。—MiotdeMelito,I。,84(July,1796)。"Hespokecurtlyand,atthistime,veryincorrectly。"—MadamedeRémusat,I。,104。
"Whateverlanguagehespokeitneverseemedfamiliartohim;heappearedtoforcehimselfinexpressinghisideas。"—NotesparleComteChaptal(unpublished),councillorofstateandafterwardsministeroftheinteriorundertheConsulate:"Atthistime,Bonapartedidnotblushattheslightknowledgeofadministrativedetailswhichhepossessed;heaskedagoodmanyquestionsanddemandeddefinitionsandthemeaningofthecommonestwordsinuse。Asitveryoftenhappenedwithhimnottoclearlycomprehendwordswhichheheardforthefirsttime,healwaysrepeatedtheseafterwardsasheunderstoodthem;forexample,heconstantlyusedsectionforsession,armisticeforamnesty,fulminatingpointforculminatingpoint,rentesvoyagèresfor’rentesviagères,’etc。"
[21]DeSégur,I。,174
[22]Cf。the"Mémoires"ofMarshalMarmont,I。,15,fortheordinarysentimentsoftheyoungnobility。"In1792Ihadasentimentforthepersonoftheking,difficulttodefine,ofwhichIrecoveredthetrace,andtosomeextentthepower,twenty—twoyearslater;asentimentofdevotionalmostreligiousincharacter,aninnaterespectasifduetoabeingofasuperiororder。ThewordKingthenpossessedamagic,aforce,whichnothinghadchangedinpureandhonestbreasts……Thisreligionofroyaltystillexistedinthemassofthenation,,andespeciallyamongstthewell—born,who,sufficientlyremotefrompower,wereratherstruckwithitsbrilliancythanwithitsimperfections……Thislovebecameasortofworship。"
[23]Bourrienne,"Mémoires,’I。27。—Ségur,I。445。In1795,atParis,Bonaparte,beingoutofmilitaryemployment,entersuponseveralcommercialspeculations,amongstwhichisabookstore,whichdoesnotsucceed。(StatedbySebastianiandmanyothers。)
[24]"Mémorial,"Aug。3,1816。
[25]Bourrienne,I。,171。(Originaltextofthe"SouperdeBeaucaire。")
[26]Yung,II。,430,431。(WordsofCharlotteRobespierre。)Bonaparteasasouvenirofhisacquaintancewithher,grantedherapension,undertheconsulate,of3600francs。—Ibid。(LetterofTilly,chargéd’affairesatGenoa,toBuchot,commissionerofforeignaffairs。)Cf。inthe"Mémorial,"Napoleon’sfavorablejudgmentofRobespierre。
[27]Yung,II。,455。(LetterfromBonapartetoTilly,Aug。7,1794。)Ibid。,III。,120。(MemoirsofLucien。)"BarrastakescareofJosephine’sdowry,whichisthecommandofthearmyinItaly。"Ibid。,II。,477。(Gradingofgeneralofficers,notesbySchéreronBonaparte。)"Heknowsallaboutartillery,butisrathertooambitious,andtoointriguingforpromotion。"
[28]DeSégur,I。,162。—LaFayette,"Mémoires,"II。,215。
"Mémorial"(notedictatedbyNapoleon)。Hestatesthereasonsforandagainst,andadds,speakingofhimself:"Thesesentiments,twenty—fiveyearsofage,confidenceinhisstrength,hisdestiny,determinedhim。"Bourrienne,I。,51:"Itiscertainthathehasalwaysbemoanedthatday;hehasoftensaidtomethathewouldgiveyearsofhislifetoeffacethatpageofhishistory。"
[29]"Mémorial,"I。,Sept6,1815。"ItisonlyafterLodithattheideacametomethatImight,afterall,becomeadecisiveactoronourpoliticalstage。Thenthefirstsparkofloftyambitiongleamedout。"OnhisaimandconductintheItaliancampaignofSybel,"Histoiredel’EuropependantlaRévolutionFran?aise"(Dosquettranslation),vol。IV。,booksII。andIII。,especiallypp。182,199,334,335,406,420,475,489。
[30]Yung,III。,213。(LetterofM。deSucy,August4,1797。)
[31]Ibid。,III。,214。(Reportofd’EntraiguestoM。deMowikinoff,Sept。,1797。)"IftherewasanykinginFrancewhichwasnothimself,hewouldliketohavebeenhiscreator,withhisrightsattheendofhissword,thisswordnevertobepartedwith,sothathemightplungeitintheking’sbosomifheeverceasedtobesubmissivetohim。"—
MiotdeMelito,I。,154。(BonapartetoMontebello,beforeMiotandMelzi,June,1797。)Ibid,I。,184。(BonapartetoMiot,Nov。18,1797,atTurin。)
[32]D’Haussonville,"L’égliseRomaineetlaPremierEmpire,"I。,405。
(WordsofM。Cacault,signeroftheTreatyofTolentino,andFrenchSecretaryofLegationatRome,atthecommencementofnegotiationsfortheConcordat。)M。Cacautsaysthatheusedthisexpression,"AfterthescenesofTolentinoandofLeghorn,andthefrightofManfredini,andMatéithreatened,andsomanyothervivacities。"
[33]MadamedeSta?l,"ConsidérationssurlaRévolutionFran?aise,"
3rdpart,ch。XXVI。,and4thpart,ch。XVIII。
[34]PortraitofBonaparteinthe"CabinetdesEtampes,""drawnbyGuérin,engravedbyFiesinger,depositedintheNationalLibrary,Vendémiaire29,yearVII。"
[35]MadamedeRémusat,"Mémoires,"I。,104。—MiotdeMelito,I。,84。
[36]MadamedeSta?l,"Considerations,"etc。,3rdpart,ch。XXV。—
MadamedeRémusat,II。,77。
[37]Stendhal,"MémoiressurNapoléon,"narrationofAdmiralDecrès。
—Samenarrationinthe"Mémorial。"
[38]DeSégur,I。,193。
[39]Roederer,"Oeuvrescomplétes,"II。,560。(ConversationswithGeneralLasallein1809,andLasalle’sjudgmentonthedébutsofNapoleon)。
[40]AnotherinstanceofthiscommandinginfluenceisfoundinthecaseofGeneralVandamme,anoldrevolutionarysoldierstillmorebrutalandenergeticthanAugereau。In1815,VandammesaidtoMarshald’Ornano,oneday,onascendingthestaircaseoftheTuileriestogether:"Mydearfellow,thatdevilofaman(speakingoftheEmperor)fascinatesmeinawayIcannotaccountfor。I,whodon’tfeareitherGodorthedevil,whenIapproachhimItremblelikeachild。Hewouldmakemedashthroughtheeyeofaneedleintothefire!"("LeGénéralVandamme,"byduCasse,II。,385)。
[41]Roederer,III。,356。(Napoleonhimselfsays,February11,1809):
"I,military!Iamso,becauseIwasbornso;itismyhabit,myveryexistence。WhereverIhavebeenIhavealwayshadcommand。I
commandedattwenty—three,atthesiegeofToulon;IcommandedatParisinVendémiaire;IwonoverthesoldiersinItalythemomentI
presentedmyself。Iwasbornforthat。"
[42]Observethevariousfeaturesofthesamementalandmoralstructureamongdifferentmembersofthefamily。(Speakingofhisbrothersandsistersinthe"Memorial"Napoleonsays):"Whatfamilyasnumerouspresentssuchasplendidgroup?"—"Souvenirs",byPASQUIER
(Etienne—Dennis,duc),chancelierdeFrance。inVIvolumes,LibrariePlon,Paris1893。Vol。I。p。400。(Thisauthor,ayoungmagistrateunderLouisXVI。,ahighfunctionaryundertheEmpire,animportantpoliticalpersonageundertherestorationandtheJulymonarchy,isprobablythebestinformedandmostjudiciousofeye—witnessesduringthefirsthalfofourcentury。):"Theirvicesandvirtuessurpassordinaryproportionsandhaveaphysiognomyoftheirown。Butwhatespeciallydistinguishesthemisastubbornwill,andinflexibleresolution……Allpossessedtheinstinctoftheirgreatness。"
Theyreadilyaccepted"thehighestpositions;theyevengottobelievingthattheirelevationwasinevitable……NothingintheincrediblegoodfortuneofJosephastonishedhim;ofteninJanuary,1814,IheardhimsayoverandoveragainthatifhisbrotherhadnotmeddledwithhisaffairsafterthesecondentryintoMadrid,hewouldstillbeonthethroneofSpain。AstodeterminedobstinacywehaveonlytorefertotheresignationofLouis,theretirementofLucien,andtheresistancesofFesch;theyalonecouldstemthewillofNapoleonandsometimesbreakalancewithhim。—Passion,sensuality,thehabitofconsideringthemselvesoutsideofrules,andself—confidencecombinedwithtalent,superaboundamongthewomen,asinthefifteenthcentury。Elisa,inTuscany,hadavigorousbrain,washighspiritedandagenuinesovereign,notwithstandingthedisordersofherprivatelife,inwhichevenappearanceswerenotsufficientlymaintained。"CarolineatNaples,"withoutbeingmorescrupulousthanhersisters,"betterobservedtheproprieties;noneoftheotherssomuchresembledtheEmperor;"withher,alltastessuccumbedtoambition";itwasshewhoadvisedandprevaileduponherhusband,Murat,todesertNapoleonin1814。AstoPauline,themostbeautifulwomanofherepoch,"nowife,sincethatoftheEmperorClaude,surpassedherintheuseshedaredmakeofhercharms;nothingcouldstopher,notevenamaladyattributedtothestrainofthislife—styleandforwhichwehavesooftenseenherborneinalitter。"
—Jerome,"inspiteoftheuncommonboldnessofhisdebaucheries,maintainedhisascendancyoverhiswifetothelast。"—Onthe"pressingeffortsandattempts"ofJosephonMariaLouisein1814,ChancelierPasquier,afterSavary’spapersandtheevidenceofM。deSaint—Aignan,givesextraordinarydetails。—"MessouvenirssurNapoléon,346,bythecountChaptal:"Everymemberofthisnumerousfamily(Jér?me,Louis,Joseph,theBonapartesisters)mountedthronesasiftheyhadrecoveredsomuchproperty。"
[43]Burkhardt,"DieRenaissanceinItalien,"passim。—Stendhal,"HistoiredelapeintureenItalie"(introduction),and"Rome,Naples,etFlorence,"passim。—"NotesparleComteChaptal":Whenthesenotesarepublished,manydetailswillbefoundintheminsupportofthejudgmentexpressedinthisandthefollowingchapters。ThepsychologyofNapoleonasheregivenislargelyconfirmedbythem。
[44]Roederer,III,380(1802)。
[45]NapoleonusestheFrenchwordjustwhichmeansbothfair,justifiable,pertinent,correct,andinmusictrue。
[46]"Mémorial。"
[47]DePradt,"Histoiredel’Ambassadedanslagrande—duchédeVarsovieen1812,"preface,p。X,and5。
[48]Roederer,III。,544(February24,1809)。Cf。Meneval,"NapoléonetMarie—Louise,souvenirshistoriques,"I。,210—213。
[49]PeletdelaLozère,"OpinionsdeNapoléonauconseild’état,"
p。8。—Roederer,III。,380。
[50]Mollien,"Mémoires,"I。,379;II。,230。—Roederer,III。,434。"Heisattheheadofallthings。Hegoverns,administrates,negotiates,workseighteenhoursaday,withtheclearestandbestorganizedhead;
hehasgovernedmoreinthreeyearsthankingsinahundredyears。"—
Lavalette,"Mémoires,"II。,75。(ThewordsofNapoleon’ssecretaryonNapoleon’slaborinParis,afterLeipsic)"Heretiresateleven,butgetsupatthreeo’clockinthemorning,anduntiltheeveningthereisnotamomenthedoesnotdevotetowork。Itistimethisstopped,forhewillbeusedup,andmyselfbeforeheis。"—Gaudin,DucdeGa?te,"Mémoires,"III。(supplement),p。75。Accountofaneveninginwhich,fromeighto’clocktothreeinthemorning,NapoleonexamineswithGaudinhisgeneralbudget,duringsevenconsecutivehours,withoutstoppingaminute。—SirNeilCampbell,"NapoléonatFontainebleauandatElbe,"p。243。"JournaldeSirNeilCampbella’
l’iled’Elbe":Ineversawanyman,inanystationinlife,sopersonallyactiveandsopersistentinhisactivity。Heseemstotakepleasureinperpetualmotionandinseeingthosewhoaccompanyhimcompletelytiredout,whichfrequentlyhappenedinmycasewhenI
accompaniedhim……Yesterday,afterhavingbeenonhislegsfromeightinthemorningtothreeintheafternoon,visitingthefrigatesandtransports,eventogoingdowntothelowercompartmentsamongthehorses,herodeonhorsebackforthreehours,and,asheafterwardssaidtome,toresthimself。"
[51]Thestarting—pointofthegreatdiscoveriesofDarwinisthephysical,detaileddescriptionhemadeinhisstudyofanimalsandplants,asliving;duringthewholecourseoflife,throughsomanydifficultiesandsubjecttoafiercecompetition。Thisstudyiswhollylackingintheordinaryzoologistorbotanist,whosemindisbusyonlywithanatomicalpreparationsorcollectionsofplants。Ineveryscience,thedifficultyliesindescribinginanutshell,usingsignificantexamples,therealobject,justasitexistsbeforeus,anditstruehistory。ClaudeBernardonedayremarkedtome,"Weshallknowphysiologywhenweareabletofollowstepbystepamoleculeofcarbonorazoteinthebodyofadog,giveitshistory,anddescribeitspassagefromitsentrancetoitsexit。"
[52]Thibaudeau,"MémoiressurleConsulat,"204。(Aproposofthetribunate):"Theyconsistofadozenorfifteenmetaphysicianswhooughttobeflungintothewater;theycrawlallovermelikevermin。
[53]MadamedeRémusat,I。,115:"Heisreallyignorant,havingreadverylittleandalwayshastily。"—Stendhal,"MémoiressurNapoleon":
"Hiseducationwasverydefective……Heknewnothingofthegreatprinciplesdiscoveredwithinthepastonehundredyears,"andjustthosewhichconcernmanorsociety。"Forexample,hehadnotreadMontesquieuasthiswriteroughttoberead,thatistosay,inawaytoacceptordecidedlyrejecteachofthethirty—onebooksofthe’Espritdeslois。’HehadnotthusreadBayle’sDictionarynortheEssayontheWealthofNationsbyAdamSmith。ThisignoranceoftheEmperor’swasnotperceptibleinconversation,andfirst,becauseheledinconversation,andnextbecausewithItalianfinessenoquestionputbyhim,orcarelesssuppositionthrownout,everbetrayedthatignorance。"—Bourrienne。I。,19,21:AtBrienne,"unfortunatelyforus,themonkstowhomtheeducationofyouthwasconfidedknewnothing,andweretoopoortopaygoodforeignteachers……Itisinconceivablehowanycapablemanevergraduatedfromthiseducationalinstitution。"—Yung,I。,125(NotesmadebyhimonBonaparte,whenhelefttheMilitaryAcademy):"Veryfondoftheabstractsciences,indifferenttoothers,wellgroundedinmathematicsandgeography。"
[54]Roederer,III。,544(March6,1809),26,563(Jan。23,1811,andNov。12,1813)。
[55]Mollien,I。,348(ashorttimebeforetheruptureofthepeaceofAmiens),III。,16:"ItwasattheendofJanuary,1809,thathewantedafullreportofthefinancialsituationonthe31stofDecember,1808……Thisreportwastobereadyintwodays。"—III。,34:"A
completebalancesheetofthepublictreasuryforthefirstsixmonthsof1812wasunderNapoleon’seyesatWitebsk,the11thofAugust,elevendaysafterthecloseofthesefirstsixmonths。Whatistrulywonderfulis,thatamidstsomanydifferentoccupationsandpreoccupations……hecouldpreservesuchanaccuraterunoftheproceedingsandmethodsoftheadministrativebranchesaboutwhichhewantedtoknowatanymoment。Nobodyhadanyexcusefornotansweringhim,foreachwasquestionedinhisownterms;itisthatsingularaptitudeoftheheadoftheState,andthetechnicalprecisionofhisquestions,whichaloneexplainshowhecouldmaintainsucharemarkableensembleinanadministrativesystemofwhichthesmallestthreadscenteredinhimself。"
[56]200yearsafterthedeathofNapoleonSirAlfredAyerthuswritesin"LANGUAGE,TRUTHANDLOGIC":’Actually,weshallseethattheonlytesttowhichaformofscientificprocedurewhichsatisfiesthenecessaryconditionofself—consistencyissubject,isthetestofitssuccessinpractice。Weareentitledtohavefaithinourprocedurejustsolongasitdoestheworkitisdesignedtodo—thatis,enablesustopredictfutureexperience,andsotocontrolourenvironment。"
AndonthePurposeofInquiry:
’Thetraditionaldisputesofphilosophersare,forthemostpart,asunwarrantedastheyareunfruitful。Thesurestwaytoendthemistoestablishbeyondquestionwhatshouldbethepurposeandthemethodofphilosophicalinquiry。’(SR。)
[57]AnexpressionofMollien。
[58]Meneval,I。,210,213。—Roederer,III。,537,545(FebruaryandMarch,1889):WordsofNapoleon:"Atthismomentitwasnearlymidnight。"—Ibid。,IV。,55(November,1809)。ReadtheadmirableexaminationofRoedererbyNapoleonontheKingdomofNaples。Hisqueriesformavastsystematicandconcisenetwork,embracingtheentiresubject,leavingnophysicalormoraldata,nousefulcircumstancenotseizedupon。—Ségur,II。,231:M。DeSégur,orderedtoinspecteverypartofthecoast—line,hadsentinhisreport:"’I
haveseenyourreports,’saidtheFirstConsultome,’andtheyareexact。Nevertheless,youforgotatOstentwocannonoutofthefour。’
—Andhepointedouttheplace,’aroadwaybehindthetown。’Iwentoutoverwhelmedwithastonishmentthatamongthousandsofcannondistributedamongthemountedbatteriesorlightartilleryonthecoast,twopiecesshouldnothaveescapedhisrecollection。"—
"Correspondance,"lettertoKingJoseph,August6,1806:"Theadmirableconditionofmyarmiesisduetothis,thatIgiveattentiontothemeverydayforanhourortwo,and,whenthemonthlyreportscomein,tothestateofmytroopsandfleets,allformingabouttwentylargevolumes。Ileaveeveryotheroccupationtoreadthemoverindetail,toseewhatdifferencethereisbetweenonemonthandanother。Itakemorepleasureinreadingthosethananyyounggirldoesinanovel。"—CadetdeGassicourt,"VoyageenAutriche"(1809)。
OnhisreviewsatSchoenbrunnandhisverificationofthecontentsofapontoon—wagon,takenasanexample。
[59]OneancientFrenchleagueequalsapp。4km。(SR。)
[60]Bourrienne,II。,116;IV。,238:"Hehadnotagoodmemoryforpropernames,words,anddates,butitwasprodigiousforfactsandlocalities。Irememberthat,onthewayfromParistoToulon,hecalledmyattentiontotenplacessuitableforgivingbattle……Itwasasouvenirofhisyouthfultravels,andhedescribedtomethelayoftheground,designatingthepositionshewouldhavetakenevenbeforewewereonthespot。"March17,1800,puncturingacardwithapin,heshowsBourriennetheplacewhereheintendstobeatMélas,atSanJuliano。"FourmonthsafterthisIfoundmyselfatSanJulianowithhisportfolioanddispatches,and,thatveryevening,atTorre—di—Gafolo,aleagueoff,Iwrotethebulletinofthebattleunderhisdictation"(ofMarengo)。—DeSégur,II。,30(NarrativeofM。DarutoM。DeSégurAug。13,1805,attheheadquartersofLaManche,NapoleondictatestoM。DaruthecompleteplanofthecampaignagainstAustria):"Orderofmarches,theirduration,placesofconvergenceormeetingofthecolumns,attacksinfullforce,thevariousmovementsandmistakesoftheenemy,all,inthisrapiddictation,wasforeseentwomonthsbeforehandandatadistanceoftwohundredleagues……Thebattle—field,thevictories,andeventheverydaysonwhichweweretoenterMunichandViennawerethenannouncedandwrittendownasitallturnedout……DarusawtheseoraclesfulfilledonthedesignateddaysuptoourentryintoMunich;iftherewereanydifferencesoftimeandnotofresultsbetweenMunichandVienna,theywereallinourfavor。"—M。deLaVallette,"Mémoires,"II。,p。35。(Hewaspostmaster—general):"ItoftenhappenedtomethatIwasnotascertainashewasofdistancesandofmanydetailsinmyadministrationonwhichhewasabletosetmestraight。"—OnreturningfromthecampatBologna,Napoleonencountersasquadofsoldierswhohadgotlost,askswhatregimenttheybelongto,calculatesthedaytheyleft,theroadtheytook,whatdistancetheyshouldhavemarched。andthentellsthem,"Youwillfindyourbattalionatsuchahaltingplace。"—Atthistime,"thearmynumbered200,000men。"
[61]MadamedeRémusat,I。,103,268。
[62]Thibaudeau,p。25,I(ontheJacobinsurvivors):"Theyarenothingbutcommonartisans,painters,etc。,withlivelyimaginations,alittlebetterinstructedthanthepeople,livingamongstthepeopleandexercisinginfluenceoverthem。"—MadamedeRémusat,I。,271(ontheroyalistparty):"Itisveryeasytodeceivethatpartybecauseitsstarting—pointisnotwhatitis,butwhatitwouldliketohave。"
—I。,337:"TheBourbonswillneverseeanythingexceptthroughtheOeildeBoeuf。"—Thibaudeau,p。46:"Insurrectionsandemigrationsareskindiseases;terrorismisaninternalmalady。"Ibid。,75:"Whatnowkeepsthespiritofthearmyupistheideasoldiershavethattheyoccupytheplacesofformernobles。"
[63]Thibaudeau,pp。419to452。(Bothtextsaregiveninseparatecolumns。)Andpassim,forinstance,p。84,thefollowingportrayalofthedecadalsystemofworshipundertheRepublic:"Itwasimaginedthatcitizenscouldbegottogetherinchurches,tofreezewithcoldandhear,read,andstudylaws,inwhichtherewasalreadybutlittlefunforthosewhoexecutedthem。"Anotherexampleofthewayinwhichhisideasexpressedthemselvesthroughimagery(PeletdelaLozère,p。
242):"IamnotsatisfiedwiththecustomsregulationsontheAlps。
Theyshownolife。Wedon’theartherattleofcrownpiecespouringintothepublictreasury。"ToappreciatethevividnessofNapoleon’sexpressionsandthoughtthereadermustconsult,especially,thefiveorsixlongconversations,notedontheveryeveningofthedaytheyoccurredbyRoederer;thetwoorthreeconversationslikewisenotedbyMiotdeMelito;thescenesnarratedbyBeugnot;thenotesofPeletdelaLozèreandbyStanislasdeGirardin,andnearlytheentirevolumebyThibaudeau。
[64]PeletdelaLozère,63,64。(OnthephysiologicaldifferencesbetweentheEnglishandtheFrench。)—MadamedeRémusat,I。,273,392:"You,Frenchmen,arenotinearnestaboutanything,except,perhaps,equality,andevenhereyouwouldgladlygivethisupifyouweresureofbeingtheforemost……Thehopeofadvancementintheworldshouldbecherishedbyeverybody……KeepyourvanityalwaysaliveTheseverityoftherepublicangovernmentwouldhaveworriedyoutodeath。WhatstartedtheRevolution?Vanity。Whatwillendit?Vanity,again。Libertyismerelyapretext。"—III。,153
"Libertyisthecravingofasmallandprivilegedclassbynature,withfacultiessuperiortothecommonrunofmen;thisclass,therefore,maybeputunderrestraintwithimpunity;equality,onthecontrary,catchesthemultitude。"—Thibaudeau,99:"WhatdoIcarefortheopinionsandcackleofthedrawing—room?Ineverheedit。I
payattentiononlytowhatrudepeasantssay。"Hisestimatesofcertainsituationsaremasterpiecesofpicturesqueconcision。"WhydidIstopandsignthepreliminariesofLeoben?BecauseIplayedvingt—et—unandwassatisfiedwithtwenty。"Hisinsightinto(dramatic)characteristhatofthemostsagaciouscritic。"The’Mahomet’ofVoltaireisneitheraprophetnoranArab,onlyanimpostorgraduatedoutoftheécolePolytechnique。"—"MadamedeGenlistriestodefinevirtueasifshewerethediscovererofit。"—
(OnMadamedeSta?l):"Thiswomanteachespeopletothinkwhonevertooktoit,orhaveforgottenhow。"—(OnChateaubriand,oneofwhoserelationshadjustbeenshot):"HewillwriteafewpatheticpagesandreadthemaloudinthefaubourgSaint—Germain;prettywomenwillshedtears,andthatwillconsolehim。"—(OnAbbéDelille):"Heiswitinitsdotage。"—(OnPasquierandMolé):"Imakethemostofone,andmadetheother。"—MadamedeRémusat,II。,389,391,394,399,402;III。,67。
[65]Bourrienne,II。,281,342:"Itpainedmetowriteofficialstatementsunderhisdictation,ofwhicheachwasanimposture。"Healwaysanswered:"Mydearsir,youareasimpleton—youunderstandnothing!"—MadamedeRémusat,II。,205,209。
[66]Seeespeciallythecampaignbulletinsfor1807,soinsultingtothekingandqueenofPrussia,but,owingtothatfact,sowellcalculatedtoexcitethecontemptuouslaughterandjeersofthesoldiers。
[67]In"LaCorrespondancedeNapoleon,"publishedinthirty—twovolumes,thelettersarearrangedunderdates。—Inhis’"CorrespondanceavecEugène,vice—roid’Italie,"theyarearrangedunderchapters;alsowithJoseph,KingofNaplesandafterwardsKingofSpain。Itiseasytoselectotherchaptersnotlessinstructive:
oneonforeignaffairs(letterstoM。deChampagny,MdeTalleyrand,andM。deBassano);anotheronthefinances(letterstoM。GaudinandtoM。Mollien);anotheronthenavy(letterstoAdmiralDecrès);
anotheronmilitaryadministration(letterstoGeneralClarke);
anotherontheaffairsoftheChurch(letterstoM。PortalisandtoM。
BigotdePréameneu);anotheronthePolice(letterstoFouché),etc。
—Finally,bydividinganddistributinghislettersaccordingastheyrelatetothisorthatgrandenterprise,especiallytothisorthatmilitarycampaign,athirdclassificationcouldbemade。—Inthiswaywecanformaconceptofthevastnessofhispositiveknowledge,alsoofthescopeofhisintellectandtalents。Cf。especiallythefollowingletterstoPrinceEugène,JuneII,1806(onthesuppliesandexpensesoftheItalianarmy);June1stand18th,1806(ontheoccupationofDalmatia,andonthemilitarysituation,offensiveanddefensive)。ToGen。Dejean,April28,1806(onthewarsupplies);
June27,1806(onthefortificationsofPeschiera)July20,1806(onthefortificationsofWeselandofJuliers)。—"MessouvenirssurNapoleon",p。353bytheCountChaptal:"Oneday,theEmperorsaidtomethathewouldliketoorganizeamilitaryschoolatFontainebleau;
hethenexplainedtometheprincipalfeaturesoftheestablishment,andorderedmetodrawupthenecessaryarticlesandbringthemtohimthenextday。Iworkedallnightandtheywerereadyattheappointedhour。Hereadthemoverandpronouncedthemcorrect,butnotcomplete。Hebademetakeaseatandthendictatedtomefortwoorthreehoursaplanwhichconsistedoffivehundredandseventeenarticles。Nothingmoreperfect,inmyopinion,everissuedfromaman’sbrain。—Atanothertime,theEmpressJosephinewastotakethewatersatAix—la—Chapelle,andtheEmperorsummonedme。’TheEmpress,’saidhe,’istoleaveto—morrowmorning。Sheisagood—
natured,easy—goingwomanandmusthaveherrouteandbehaviormarkedoutforher。Writeitdown。’Hethendictatedinstructionstomeontwenty—onelargesheetsofpaper,inwhicheverythingshewastosayandtodowasdesignated,eventhequestionsandrepliesshewastomaketotheauthoritiesontheway。"