Ithinktheinvitationwillbeaccepted,bysomesectsfromcandidintentions,andbyothersfromjealousyandrivalship。Andbybringingthesectstogether,andmixingthemwiththemassofotherstudents,weshallsoftentheirasperities,liberalizeandneutralizetheirprejudices,andmakethegeneralreligionareligionofpeace,reason,andmorality。
Thetimeofopeningouruniversityisstillasuncertainasever。Allthepavilions,boardinghouses,anddormitoriesaredone。
Nothingisnowwantingbutthecentralbuildingforalibraryandothergeneralpurposes。Forthiswehavenofunds,andthelastlegislaturerefusedallaid。Wehavebetterhopesofthenext。Butallisuncertain。Ihaveheardwithregretofdisturbancesonthepartofthestudentsinyourseminary。ThearticleofdisciplineisthemostdifficultinAmericaneducation。Prematureideasofindependence,toolittlerepressedbyparents,begetaspiritofinsubordination,whichisthegreatobstacletosciencewithus,andaprincipalcauseofitsdecaysincetherevolution。Ilooktoitwithdismayinourinstitution,asabreakerahead,whichIamfarfrombeingconfidentweshallbeabletoweather。Theadvanceofage,andtardypaceofthepublicpatronage,mayprobablysparemethepainofwitnessingconsequences。
Isaluteyouwithconstantfriendshipandrespect。
CALVINANDCOSMOLOGY
_ToJohnAdams_
_Monticello,April11,1823_
DEARSIR,——Thewishesexpressed,inyourlastfavor,thatI
maycontinueinlifeandhealthuntilIbecomeaCalvinist,atleastinhisexclamationof`_monDieu!_jusqueaquand’!wouldmakemeimmortal。IcanneverjoinCalvininaddressing_hisgod。_HewasindeedanAtheist,whichIcanneverbe;orratherhisreligionwasDaemonism。Ifevermanworshippedafalsegod,hedid。Thebeingdescribedinhis5。pointsisnottheGodwhomyouandIacknolegeandadore,theCreatorandbenevolentgovernoroftheworld;butadaemonofmalignantspirit。Itwouldbemorepardonabletobelieveinnogodatall,thantoblasphemehimbytheatrociousattributesofCalvin。IndeedIthinkthateveryChristiansectgivesagreathandletoAtheismbytheirgeneraldogmathat,withoutarevelation,therewouldnotbesufficientproofofthebeingofagod。NowonesixthofmankindonlyaresupposedtobeChristians:theotherfivesixthsthen,whodonotbelieveintheJewishandChristianrevelation,arewithoutaknolegeoftheexistenceofagod!ThisgivescompleatlyagaindecausetothedisciplesofOcellus,Timaeus,Spinosa,DiderotandD’Holbach。Theargumentwhichtheyrestonastriumphantandunanswerableisthat,ineveryhypothesisofCosmogonyyoumustadmitaneternalpre-existenceofsomething;
andaccordingtotheruleofsoundphilosophy,youarenevertoemploytwoprinciplestosolveadifficultywhenonewillsuffice。
Theysaythenthatitismoresimpletobelieveatonceintheeternalpre-existenceoftheworld,asitisnowgoingon,andmayforevergoonbytheprincipleofreproductionwhichweseeandwitness,thantobelieveintheeternalpre-existenceofanulteriorcause,orCreatoroftheworld,abeingwhomweseenot,andknownot,ofwhoseformsubstanceandmodeorplaceofexistence,orofactionnosenseinformsus,nopowerofthemindenablesustodelineateorcomprehend。OnthecontraryIholdwithoutappealtorevelationthatwhenwetakeaviewoftheUniverse,init’spartsgeneralorparticular,itisimpossibleforthehumanmindnottopercieveandfeelaconvictionofdesign,consummateskill,andindefinitepowerineveryatomofit’scomposition。Themovementsoftheheavenlybodies,soexactlyheldintheircoursebythebalanceofcentrifugalandcentripetalforces,thestructureofourearthitself,withit’sdistributionoflands,watersandatmosphere,animalandvegetablebodies,examinedinalltheirminutestparticles,insectsmereatomsoflife,yetasperfectlyorganisedasmanormammoth,themineralsubstances,theirgenerationanduses,itisimpossible,Isay,forthehumanmindnottobelievethatthereis,inallthis,design,causeandeffect,uptoanultimatecause,afabricatorofallthingsfrommatterandmotion,theirpreserverandregulatorwhilepermittedtoexistintheirpresentforms,andtheirregeneratorintonewandotherforms。Wesee,too,evidentproofsofthenecessityofasuperintendingpowertomaintaintheUniverseinit’scourseandorder。Stars,wellknown,havedisappeared,newoneshavecomeintoview,comets,intheirincalculablecourses,mayrunfoulofsunsandplanetsandrequirerenovationunderotherlaws;
certainracesofanimalsarebecomeextinct;and,weretherenorestoringpower,allexistencesmightextinguishsuccessively,onebyone,untilallshouldbereducedtoashapelesschaos。SoirresistiblearetheseevidencesofanintelligentandpowerfulAgentthat,oftheinfinitenumbersofmenwhohaveexistedthro’alltime,theyhavebelieved,intheproportionofamillionatleasttoUnit,inthehypothesisofaneternalpre-existenceofacreator,ratherthaninthatofaself-existentUniverse。Surelythisunanimoussentimentrendersthismoreprobablethanthatofthefewintheotherhypothesis。SomeearlyChristiansindeedhavebelievedinthecoeternalpre-existanceofboththeCreatorandtheworld,withoutchangingtheirrelationofcauseandeffect。ThatthiswastheopinionofSt。Thomas,weareinformedbyCardinalToleto,inthesewords`Deusabaeternofuitjamomnipotens,sicutcumproduxitmundum。Abaeternopotuitproduceremundum——Sisolabaeternoesset,lumenabaeternoesset;etsipes,similitervestigium。Atlumenetvestigiumeffectussuntefficientissolisetpedis;potuitergocumcausaaeternaeffectuscoaeternaesse。CujussententiaeestS。ThomasTheologorumprimus’CardinalToleta。
Ofthenatureofthisbeingweknownothing。Jesustellsusthat`Godisaspirit。’4。John24。butwithoutdefiningwhataspiritis{pneymaoTheos}。Downtothe3d。centuryweknowthatitwasstilldeemedmaterial;butofalightersubtlermatterthanourgrossbodies。SosaysOrigen。`Deusigitur,cuianimasimilisest,juxtaOriginem,reaptecorporalisest;sedgraviorumtantumrationecorporumincorporeus。’ThesearethewordsofHuetinhiscommentaryonOrigen。Origenhimselfsays`appelatio{asomaton}apudnostrosscriptoresestinusitataetincognita。’SoalsoTertullian`quisautemnegabitDeumessecorpus,etsideusspiritus?Spiritusetiamcorporissuigeneris,insuaeffigie。’Tertullian。Thesetwofatherswereofthe3d。century。Calvin’scharacterofthissupremebeingseemschieflycopiedfromthatoftheJews。Butthereformationoftheseblasphemousattributes,andsubstitutionofthosemoreworthy,pureandsublime,seemstohavebeenthechiefobjectofJesusinhisdiscourcestotheJews:andhisdoctrineoftheCosmogonyoftheworldisveryclearlylaiddowninthe3firstversesofthe1st。
chapterofJohn,inthesewords,`{enarcheenologos,kaiologosenprostonTheonkaiTheosenologos。`otosenenarcheprostonTheon。Pantadeaytoegeneto,kaichorisaytoegenetoodeen,ogegonen}。Whichtrulytranslatedmeans`inthebeginningGodexisted,andreasonormindwaswithGod,andthatmindwasGod。
ThiswasinthebeginningwithGod。Allthingswerecreatedbyit,andwithoutitwasmadenotonethingwhichwasmade’。Yetthistext,soplainlydeclaringthedoctrineofJesusthattheworldwascreatedbythesupreme,intelligentbeing,hasbeenpervertedbymodernChristianstobuildupasecondpersonoftheirtritheismbyamistranslationoftheword{logos}。Oneofit’slegitimatemeaningsindeedis`aword。’But,inthatsense,itmakesanunmeaningjargon:
whiletheothermeaning`reason’,equallylegitimate,explainsrationallytheeternalpreexistenceofGod,andhiscreationoftheworld。Knowinghowincomprehensibleitwasthat`aword,’themereactionorarticulationofthevoiceandorgansofspeechcouldcreateaworld,theyundertaketomakeofthisarticulationasecondpreexistingbeing,andascribetohim,andnottoGod,thecreationoftheuniverse。TheAtheisthereplumeshimselfontheuselessnessofsuchaGod,andthesimplerhypothesisofaself-existentuniverse。ThetruthisthatthegreatestenemiestothedoctrinesofJesusarethosecallingthemselvestheexpositorsofthem,whohavepervertedthemforthestructureofasystemoffancyabsolutelyincomprehensible,andwithoutanyfoundationinhisgenuinewords。
AndthedaywillcomewhenthemysticalgenerationofJesus,bythesupremebeingashisfatherinthewombofavirginwillbeclassedwiththefableofthegenerationofMinervainthebrainofJupiter。
ButwemayhopethatthedawnofreasonandfreedomofthoughtintheseUnitedStateswilldoawaywithallthisartificialscaffolding,andrestoretoustheprimitiveandgenuinedoctrinesofthisthemostveneratedreformerofhumanerrors。
SomuchforyourquotationofCalvin’s`mondieu!jusqu’aquand’inwhich,whenaddressedtotheGodofJesus,andourGod,I
joinyoucordially,andawaithistimeandwillwithmorereadinessthanreluctance。Maywemeetthereagain,inCongress,withourantientColleagues,andrecievewiththemthesealofapprobation`Welldone,goodandfaithfulservants。’
THESUPREMECOURTANDTHECONSTITUTION
_ToJusticeWilliamJohnson_
_Monticello,June12,1823_
DEARSIR,——Ourcorrespondenceisofthataccommodatingcharacter,whichadmitsofsuspensionattheconvenienceofeitherparty,withoutinconveniencetotheother。HencethistardyacknowledgmentofyourfavorofAprilthe11th。Ilearnfromthatwithgreatpleasure,thatyouhaveresolvedoncontinuingyourhistoryofparties。Ouropponentsarefaraheadofusinpreparationsforplacingtheircausefavorablybeforeposterity。YetIhopeevenfromsomeofthemtheescapeofprecioustruths,inangryexplosionsoreffusionsofvanity,whichwillbetraythegenuinemonarchismoftheirprinciples。Theydonotthemselvesbelievewhattheyendeavortoinculcate,thatwewereanoppositionparty,notonprinciple,butmerelyseekingforoffice。Thefactis,thatattheformationofourgovernment,manyhadformedtheirpoliticalopinionsonEuropeanwritingsandpractices,believingtheexperienceofoldcountries,andespeciallyofEngland,abusiveasitwas,tobeasaferguidethanmeretheory。ThedoctrinesofEuropewere,thatmeninnumerousassociationscannotberestrainedwithinthelimitsoforderandjustice,butbyforcesphysicalandmoral,wieldedoverthembyauthoritiesindependentoftheirwill。Hencetheirorganizationofkings,hereditarynobles,andpriests。Stillfurthertoconstrainthebruteforceofthepeople,theydeemitnecessarytokeepthemdownbyhardlabor,povertyandignorance,andtotakefromthem,asfrombees,somuchoftheirearnings,asthatunremittinglaborshallbenecessarytoobtainasufficientsurplusbarelytosustainascantyandmiserablelife。Andtheseearningstheyapplytomaintaintheirprivilegedordersinsplendorandidleness,tofascinatetheeyesofthepeople,andexciteinthemanhumbleadorationandsubmission,astoanorderofsuperiorbeings。
Althoughfewamongushadgonealltheselengthsofopinion,yetmanyhadadvanced,somemore,someless,ontheway。Andintheconventionwhichformedourgovernment,theyendeavoredtodrawthecordsofpowerastightastheycouldobtainthem,tolessenthedependenceofthegeneralfunctionariesontheirconstituents,tosubjecttothemthoseoftheStates,andtoweakentheirmeansofmaintainingthesteadyequilibriumwhichthemajorityoftheconventionhaddeemedsalutaryforbothbranches,generalandlocal。
Torecover,therefore,inpracticethepowerswhichthenationhadrefused,andtowarptotheirownwishesthoseactuallygiven,wasthesteadyobjectofthefederalparty。Ours,onthecontrary,wastomaintainthewillofthemajorityoftheconvention,andofthepeoplethemselves。Webelieved,withthem,thatmanwasarationalanimal,endowedbynaturewithrights,andwithaninnatesenseofjustice;andthathecouldberestrainedfromwrongandprotectedinrightbymoderatepowers,confidedtopersonsofhisownchoice,andheldtotheirdutiesbydependenceonhisownwill。Webelievedthatthecomplicatedorganizationofkings,nobles,andpriests,wasnotthewisestnorbesttoeffectthehappinessofassociatedman;thatwisdomandvirtuewerenothereditary,thatthetrappingsofsuchamachinery,consumedbytheirexpense,thoseearningsofindustry,theyweremeanttoprotect,and,bytheinequalitiestheyproduced,exposedlibertytosufferance。Webelievedthatmen,enjoyingineaseandsecuritythefullfruitsoftheirownindustry,enlistedbyalltheirinterestsonthesideoflawandorder,habituatedtothinkforthemselves,andtofollowtheirreasonastheirguide,wouldbemoreeasilyandsafelygoverned,thanwithmindsnourishedinerror,andvitiatedanddebased,asinEurope,byignorance,indigenceandoppression。Thecherishmentofthepeoplethenwasourprinciple,thefearanddistrustofthem,thatoftheotherparty。Composed,aswewere,ofthelandedandlaboringinterestsofthecountry,wecouldnotbelessanxiousforagovernmentoflawandorderthanweretheinhabitantsofthecities,thestrongholdsoffederalism。Andwhetheroureffortstosavetheprinciplesandformofourconstitutionhavenotbeensalutary,letthepresentrepublicanfreedom,orderandprosperityofourcountrydetermine。Historymaydistorttruth,andwilldistortitforatime,bythesuperioreffortsatjustificationofthosewhoareconsciousofneedingitmost。Norwilltheopeningscenesofourpresentgovernmentbeseenintheirtrueaspect,untilthelettersoftheday,nowheldinprivatehoards,shallbebrokenupandlaidopentopublicview。