amnotforlinkingourselvesbynewtreatieswiththequarrelsofEurope;enteringthatfieldofslaughtertopreservetheirbalance,orjoiningintheconfederacyofkingstowaragainsttheprinciplesofliberty。Iamforfreedomofreligion,&againstallmaneuvrestobringaboutalegalascendancyofonesectoveranother:forfreedomofthepress,&againstallviolationsoftheconstitutiontosilencebyforce¬byreasonthecomplaintsorcriticisms,justorunjust,ofourcitizensagainsttheconductoftheiragents。AndI
amforencouragingtheprogressofscienceinallit’sbranches;andnotforraisingahueandcryagainstthesacrednameofphilosophy;
forawingthehumanmindbystoriesofraw-head&bloodybonestoadistrustofitsownvision,&toreposeimplicitlyonthatofothers;
togobackwardsinsteadofforwardstolookforimprovement;tobelievethatgovernment,religion,morality,&everyothersciencewereinthehighestperfectioninagesofthedarkestignorance,andthatnothingcaneverbedevisedmoreperfectthanwhatwasestablishedbyourforefathers。TotheseIwilladd,thatIwasasincerewell-wishertothesuccessoftheFrenchrevolution,andstillwishitmayendintheestablishmentofafree&well-orderedrepublic;butIhavenotbeeninsensibleundertheatrociousdepredationstheyhavecommittedonourcommerce。Thefirstobjectofmyheartismyowncountry。Inthatisembarkedmyfamily,myfortune,&myownexistence。Ihavenotonefarthingofinterest,noronefibreofattachmentoutofit,norasinglemotiveofpreferenceofanyonenationtoanother,butinproportionastheyaremoreorlessfriendlytous。ButthoughdeeplyfeelingtheinjuriesofFrance,Ididnotthinkwarthesurestmeansofredressingthem。Ididbelieve,thatamissionsincerelydisposedtopreservepeace,wouldobtainforusapeaceable&honorablesettlement&retribution;andIappealtoyoutosay,whetherthismightnothavebeenobtained,ifeitherofyourcolleagueshadbeenofthesamesentimentwithyourself。
These,myfriend,aremyprinciples;theyareunquestionablytheprinciplesofthegreatbodyofourfellowcitizens,andIknowthereisnotoneofthemwhichisnotyoursalso。Intruth,weneverdifferedbutononeground,thefundingsystem;andas,fromthemomentofit’sbeingadoptedbytheconstitutedauthorities,Ibecamereligiouslyprincipledinthesacreddischargeofittotheuttermostfarthing,weareunitednowevenonthatsinglegroundofdifference。
Iturnnowtoyourinquiries。Theenclosedpaperwillansweroneofthem。Butyoualsoaskforsuchpoliticalinformationasmaybepossessedbyme,&interestingtoyourselfinregardtoyourembassy。Asaproofofmyentireconfidenceinyou,Ishallgiveitfully&candidly。WhenPinckney,Marshall,andDana,werenominatedtosettleourdifferenceswithFrance,itwassuspectedbymany,fromwhatwasunderstoodoftheirdispositions,thattheirmissionwouldnotresultinasettlementofdifferences,butwouldproducecircumstancestendingtowidenthebreach,andtoprovokeourcitizenstoconsenttoawarwiththatnation,&unionwithEngland。
Dana’sresignation&yourappointmentgavethefirstgleamofhopeofapeaceableissuetothemission。Foritwasbelievedthatyouweresincerelydisposedtoaccommodation;&itwasnotlongafteryourarrivalthere,beforesymptomswereobservedofthatdifferenceofviewswhichhadbeensuspectedtoexist。Inthemeantime,however,theaspectofourgovernmenttowardstheFrenchrepublichadbecomesoardent,thatthepeopleofAmericagenerallytookthealarm。Tothesouthward,theirapprehensionswereearlyexcited。IntheEasternStatesalso,theyatlengthbegantobreakout。Meetingswereheldinmanyofyourtowns,&addressestothegovernmentagreedoninoppositiontowar。Theexamplewasspreadinglikeawildfire。
Othermeetingswerecalledinotherplaces,&ageneralconcurrenceofsentimentagainsttheapparentinclinationsofthegovernmentwasimminent;when,mostcriticallyforthegovernment,thedespatchesofOctr22,preparedbyyourcolleagueMarshall,withaviewtotheirbeingmadepublic,droppedintotheirlaps。ItwastrulyaGod-sendtothem,&theymadethemostofit。Manythousandsofcopieswereprinted&dispersedgratis,atthepublicexpence;&thezealotsforwarco-operatedsoheartily,thattherewereinstancesofsingleindividualswhoprinted&dispersed10。or12,000copiesattheirownexpence。Theodiousnessofthecorruptionsupposedinthosepapersexcitedageneral&highindignationamongthepeople。Unexperiencedinsuchmaneuvres,theydidnotpermitthemselveseventosuspectthattheturpitudeofprivateswindlersmightmingleitselfunobserved,&giveit’sownhuetothecommunicationsoftheFrenchgovernment,ofwhoseparticipationtherewasneitherproofnorprobability。Itserved,however,foratime,thepurposeintended。
Thepeople,inmanyplaces,gavealoosetotheexpressionsoftheirwarmindignation,&oftheirhonestpreferenceofwartodishonor。
Thefeverwaslong&successfullykeptup,andinthemeantime,warmeasuresasardentlycrowded。Still,however,asitwasknownthatyourcolleagueswerecomingaway,andyourselftostay,thoughdisclaimingaseparatepowertoconcludeatreaty,itwashopedbytheloversofpeace,thataprojectoftreatywouldhavebeenprepared,adreferendum,onprincipleswhichwouldhavesatisfiedourcitizens,&overawedanybiasofthegovernmenttowardsadifferentpolicy。ButtheexpeditionoftheSophia,and,aswassupposed,thesuggestionsofthepersonchargedwithyourdespatches,&hisprobablemisrepresentationsoftherealwishesoftheAmericanpeople,preventedthesehopes。Theyhadthenonlytolookforwardtoyourreturnforsuchinformation,eitherthroughtheExecutive,orfromyourself,asmightpresenttoourviewtheothersideofthemedal。ThedespatchesofOct22,97,hadpresentedoneface。Thatinformation,toacertaindegree,isnowreceived,&thepublicwillseefromyourcorrespondencewithTaleyrand,thatFrance,asyoutestify,”wassincereandanxioustoobtainareconciliation,notwishingustobreaktheBritishtreaty,butonlytogiveherequivalentstipulations;andingeneralwasdisposedtoaliberaltreaty。”Andtheywilljudgewhethermr。Pickering’sreportshewsaninflexibledeterminationtobelievenodeclarationstheFrenchgovernmentcanmake,noranyopinionwhichyou,judgingonthespot&
fromactualview,cangiveoftheirsincerity,andtomeettheirdesignsofpeacewithoperationsofwar。Thealien&seditionactshavealreadyoperatedintheSouthaspowerfulsedativesoftheX。Y。
Z。inflammation。Inyourquarter,whereviolationsofprincipleareeitherlessregardedormoreconcealed,thedirecttaxislikelytohavethesameeffect,&toexciteinquiriesintotheobjectoftheenormousexpences&taxeswearebringingon。Andyourinformationsupervening,thatwemighthavealiberalaccommodationifwewould,therecanbelittledoubtofthereproductionofthatgeneralmovement,bythedespatchesofOct。22。Andtho’smallchecks&
stops,likeLogan’spretendedembassy,maybethrowninthewayfromtimetotime,&mayalittleretardit’smotion,yetthetideisalreadyturned,andwillsweepbeforeitallthefeebleobstaclesofart。TheunquestionablerepublicanismoftheAmericanmindwillbreakthroughthemistunderwhichithasbeenclouded,andwillobligeit’sagentstoreformtheprinciples&practicesoftheiradministration。
Yousupposethatyouhavebeenabusedbybothparties。Asfarashascometomyknowledge,youaremisinformed。Ihaveneverseenorheardasentenceofblameutteredagainstyoubytherepublicans;
unlessweweresotoconstruetheirwishesthatyouhadmoreboldlyco-operatedinaprojectofatreaty,andwouldmoreexplicitlystate,whethertherewasinyourcolleagesthatflexibility,whichpersonsearnestafterpeacewouldhavepractised?Whether,onthecontrary,theirdemeanorwasnotcold,reserved,anddistant,atleast,ifnotbackward?Andwhether,iftheyhadyieldedtothoseinformalconferenceswhichTaleyrandseemstohavecourted,theliberalaccommodationyousupposemightnothavebeeneffected,evenwiththeiragency?Yourfellow-citizensthinktheyhavearighttofullinformation,inacaseofsuchgreatconcerntothem。Itistheirsweatwhichistoearnalltheexpencesofthewar,andtheirbloodwhichistoflowinexpiationofthecausesofit。Itmaybeinyourpowertosavethemfromthesemiseriesbyfullcommunicationsandunrestraineddetails,postponingmotivesofdelicacytothoseofduty。Itrestsforyoutocomeforwardindependently;totakeyourstandonthehighgroundofyourowncharacter;todisregardcalumny,andtobeborneaboveitontheshouldersofyourgratefulfellowcitizens;ortosinkintothehumbleoblivion,towhichtheFederalistsself-calledhavesecretlycondemnedyou;andeventobehappyiftheywillindulgeyouwithoblivion,whiletheyhavebeamedonyourcolleaguesmeridiansplendor。Pardonme,mydearSir,ifmyexpressionsarestrong。Myfeelingsaresomuchmoreso,thatitiswithdifficultyIreducethemeventothetoneIuse。Ifyoudoubtthedispositionstowardsyou,lookintothepapers,onbothsides,forthetoastswhichweregiventhroughouttheStatesonthe4thofJuly。Youwillthereseewhoseheartswerewithyou,andwhosewereulceratedagainstyou。Indeed,assoonasitwasknownthatyouhadconsentedtostayinParis,therewasnomeasureobservedintheexecrationsofthewarparty。Theyopenlywishedyoumightbeguillotined,orsenttoCayenne,oranythingelse。Andtheseexpressionswerefinallystifledfromaprincipleofpolicyonly,&
topreventyoufrombeingurgedtoajustificationofyourself。Fromthisprinciplealoneproceedthesilenceandcoldrespecttheyobservetowardsyou。Still,theycannotpreventattimestheflamesburstingfromundertheembers,asmr。Pickering’sletters,report,&
conversationstestify,aswellastheindecentexpressionsrespectingyou,indulgedbysomeoftheminthedebateonthesedespatches。
Thesesufficientlyshowthatyouarenevermoretobehonoredortrustedbythem,andthattheyawaittocrushyouforever,onlytilltheycandoitwithoutdangertothemselves。
WhenIsatdowntoansweryourletter,buttwocoursespresentedthemselves,eithertosaynothingoreverything;forhalfconfidencesarenotinmycharacter。Icouldnothesitatewhichwasduetoyou。Ihaveunbosomedmyselffully;&itwillcertainlybehighlygratifyingifIreceivelikeconfidencefromyou。ForevenifwedifferinprinciplemorethanIbelievewedo,you&Iknowtoowellthetextureofthehumanmind,&theslipperinessofhumanreason,toconsiderdifferencesofopinionotherwisethandifferencesofformorfeature。Integrityofviewsmorethantheirsoundness,isthebasisofesteem。Ishallfollowyourdirectioninconveyingthisbyaprivatehand;tho’Iknownotasyetwhenoneworthyofconfidencewilloccur。Andmytrustinyouleavesmewithoutafearthatthisletter,meantasaconfidentialcommunicationofmyimpressions,willevergooutofyourhand,orbesufferedinanywisetocommitmyname。Indeed,besidestheaccidentswhichmighthappentoitevenunderyourcare,consideringtheaccidentofdeathtowhichyouareliable,Ithinkitsafesttoprayyou,afterreadingitasoftenasyouplease,todestroyatleastthe2d&3dleaves。The1stcontainsprinciplesonly,whichIfearnottoavow;butthe2d&
3dcontainfactsstatedforyourinformation,andwhich,thoughsacredlyconformabletomyfirmbelief,yetwouldbegallingtosome,&exposemetoilliberalattacks。Ithereforerepeatmyprayertoburnthe2d&3dleaves。Anddidweeverexpecttoseetheday,when,breathingnothingbutsentimentsoflovetoourcountry&it’sfreedom&happiness,ourcorrespondencemustbeassecretasifwewerehatchingit’sdestruction!Adieu,myfriend,andacceptmysincere&affectionatesalutations。Ineednotaddmysignature。”THESPIRITOF1776”
_ToThomasLomax_
_Monticello,Mar。12,1799_
DEARSIR,——YourwelcomefavoroflastmonthcametomyhandsinPhiladelphia。Solongatimehaselapsedsincewehavebeenseparatedbyevents,thatitwaslikealetterfromthedead,andrecalledtomymemoryverydearrecollections。Mysubsequentjourneythroughlifehasofferednothingwhich,incomparisonwiththose,isnotcheerless&dreary。Itisarichcomfortsometimestolookbackonthem。
Itakethelibertyofenclosingalettertomr。Baylor,open,becauseIsolicityourperusalofit。Itwill,atthesametime,furnishtheapologyformynotansweringyoufromPhiladelphia。YouaskforanycommunicationImaybeabletomake,whichmayadministercomforttoyou。Icangivethatwhichissolid。Thespiritof1776
isnotdead。Ithasonlybeenslumbering。ThebodyoftheAmericanpeopleissubstantiallyrepublican。Buttheirvirtuousfeelingshavebeenplayedonbysomefactwithmorefiction;theyhavebeenthedupesofartfulman;oeuvres,&madeforamomenttobewillinginstrumentsinforgingchainsforthemselves。Buttime&truthhavedissipatedthedelusion,&openedtheireyes。TheyseenowthatFrancehassincerelywishedpeace,&theirseducershavewishedwar,aswellfortheloaves&fisheswhichariseoutofwarexpences,asforthechanceofchangingtheconstitution,whilethepeopleshouldhavetimetocontemplatenothingbuttheleviesofmenandmoney。