Insofarastheeconomicalconditionofnationsturnsuponthestateofphysicalknowledge,itisasubjectforthephysicalsciences,andtheartsfoundedonthem。Butinsofarasthecausesaremoralorpsychological,dependentoninstitutionsandsocialrelations,orontheprinciplesofhumannature,theirinvestigationbelongsnottophysical,buttomoralandsocialscience,andistheobjectofwhatiscalledPoliticalEconomy。
Theproductionofwealth;theextractionoftheinstrumentsofhumansubsistenceandenjoymentfromthematerialsoftheglobe,isevidentlynotanarbitrarything。Ithasitsnecessaryconditions。Ofthese,somearephysical,dependingonthepropertiesofmatter,andontheamountofknowledgeofthosepropertiespossessedattheparticularplaceandtime。ThesePoliticalEconomydoesnotinvestigate,butassumes;referringforthegrounds,tophysicalscienceorcommonexperience。
Combiningwiththesefactsofoutwardnatureothertruthsrelatingtohumannature,itattemptstotracethesecondaryorderivativelaws,bywhichtheproductionofwealthisdetermined;
inwhichmustlietheexplanationofthediversitiesofrichesandpovertyinthepresentandpast,andthegroundofwhateverincreaseinwealthisreservedforthefuture。
UnlikethelawsofProduction,thoseofDistributionarepartlyofhumaninstitution:sincethemannerinwhichwealthisdistributedinanygivensociety,dependsonthestatutesorusagesthereinobtaining。Butthoughgovernmentsornationshavethepowerofdecidingwhatinstitutionsshallexist,theycannotarbitrarilydeterminehowthoseinstitutionsshallwork。Theconditionsonwhichthepowertheypossessoverthedistributionofwealthisdependent,andthemannerinwhichthedistributioniseffectedbythevariousmodesofconductwhichsocietymaythinkfittoadopt,areasmuchasubjectforscientificenquiryasanyofthephysicallawsofnature。
ThelawsofProductionandDistribution,andsomeofthepracticalconsequencesdeduciblefromthem,arethesubjectofthefollowingtreatise。
ThePrinciplesofPoliticalEconomy
byJohnStuartMill
Chapter1
OftheRequisitesofProduction
1。Therequisitesofproductionaretwo:labour,and
appropriatenaturalobjects。
Labouriseitherbodilyormental;or,toexpressthe
distinctionmorecomprehensively,eithermuscularornervous;and
itisnecessarytoincludeintheidea,notsolelytheexertion
itself,butfeelingsofadisagreeablekind,allbodily
inconvenienceormentalannoyance,connectedwiththeemployment
ofone’sthoughts,ormuscles,orboth,inaparticular
occupation。Oftheotherrequisite——appropriatenaturalobjects
——itistoberemarked,thatsomeobjectsexistorgrowup
spontaneously,ofakindsuitedtothesupplyofhumanwants。
Therearecavesandhollowtreescapableofaffordingshelter。
fruit,roots,wildhoney,andothernaturalproducts,onwhich
humanlifecanbesupported;butevenhereaconsiderable
quantityoflabourisgenerallyrequired,notforthepurposeof
creating,butoffindingandappropriatingthem。Inallbutthese
fewand(exceptintheverycommencementofhumansociety)
unimportantcases,theobjectssuppliedbynatureareonly
instrumentaltohumanwants,afterhavingundergonesomedegree
oftransformationbyhumanexertion。Eventhewildanimalsofthe
forestandofthesea,fromwhichthehuntingandfishingtribes
derivetheirsustenance——thoughthelabourofwhichtheyare
thesubjectischieflythatrequiredforappropriatingthem——
mustyet,beforetheyareusedasfood,bekilled,dividedinto
fragments,andsubjectedinalmostallcasestosomeculinary
process,whichareoperationsrequiringacertaindegreeofhuman
labour。Theamountoftransformationwhichnaturalsubstances
undergobeforebeingbroughtintotheshapeinwhichtheyare
directlyappliedtohumanuse,variesfromthisorastillless
degreeofalterationinthenatureandappearanceoftheobject,
toachangesototalthatnotraceisperceptibleoftheoriginal
shapeandstructure。Thereislittleresemblancebetweenapiece
ofamineralsubstancefoundintheearth,andaplough,anaxe,
orasaw。Thereislessresemblancebetweenporcelainandthe
decomposinggraniteitismade,orbetweensandmixedwith
sea—weed,andglass。Thedifferenceisgreaterstillbetweenthe
fleeceofasheep,orahandfulofcottonseeds,andawebof
muslinorbroadcloth;andthesheepandseedsthemselvesarenot
spontaneousgrowths,butresultsofpreviouslabourandcare。In
theseseveralcasestheultimateproductissoextremely
dissimilartothesubstancesuppliedbynature,thatinthe
customoflanguagenatureisrepresentedasonlyfurnishing
materials。
Nature,however,doesmorethansupplymaterials;shealso
suppliespowers。Thematteroftheglobeisnotaninert
recipientofformsandpropertiesimpressedbyhumanhands;it
hasactiveenergiesbywhichitco—operateswith,andmayevenbe
usedasasubstitutefor,labour。Intheearlyagespeople
convertedtheircornintoflourbypoundingitbetweentwo
stones;theynexthitonacontrivancewhichenabledthem,by
turningahandle,tomakeoneofthestonesrevolveuponthe
other;andthisprocess,alittleimproved,isstillthecommon
practiceoftheEast。Themuscularexertion,however,whichit
required,wasverysevereandexhausting,insomuchthatitwas
oftenselectedasapunishmentforslaveswhohadoffendedtheir
masters。Whenthetimecameatwhichthelabourandsufferingsof
slaveswerethoughtwortheconomizing,thegreaterpartofthis
bodilyexertionwasrenderedunnecessary,bycontrivingthatthe
upperstoneshouldbemadetorevolveuponthelower,notby
humanstrength,butbytheforceofthewindoroffallingwater。
Inthiscase,naturalagents,thewindorthegravitationofthe
water,aremadetodoaportionoftheworkpreviouslydoneby
labour。
2。Caseslikethis,inwhichacertainamountoflabourhas
beendispensedwith,itsworkbeingdevolveduponsomenatural
agent,areapttosuggestanerroneousnotionofthecomparative
functionsoflabourandnaturalpowers;asiftheco—operationof
thosepowerswithhumanindustrywerelimitedtothecasesin
whichtheyaremadetoperformwhatwouldotherwisebedoneby
labour;asif,inthecaseofthingsmade(asthephraseis)by
hand,natureonlyfurnishedpassivematerials。Thisisan
illusion。Thepowersofnatureareasactivelyoperativeinthe
onecaseasintheother。Aworkmantakesastalkoftheflaxor
hempplant,splitsitintoseparatefibres,twinestogether
severalofthesefibreswithhisfingers,aidedbyasimple
instrumentcalledaspindle;havingthusformedathread,helays
manysuchthreadssidebyside,andplacesothersimilarthreads
directlyacrossthem,sothateachpassesalternatelyoverand
underthosewhichareatrightanglestoit;thispartofthe
processbeingfacilitatedbyaninstrumentcalledashuttle。He
hasnowproducedawebofcloth,eitherlinenorsackcloth,
accordingtothematerial。Heissaidtohavedonethisbyhand,
nonaturalforcebeingsupposedtohaveactedinconcertwith
him。Butbywhatforceiseachstepofthisoperationrendered
possible,andtheweb,whenproduced,heldtogether?Bythe
tenacity,orforceofcohesion,ofthefibres:whichisoneof
theforcesinnature,andwhichwecanmeasureexactlyagainst
othermechanicalforces,andascertainhowmuchofanyofthemit
sufficestoneutralizeorcounterbalance。
Ifweexamineanyothercaseofwhatiscalledtheactionof
manuponnature,weshallfindinlikemannerthatthepowersof
nature,orinotherwordsthepropertiesofmatter,doallthe
work,whenonceobjectsareputintotherightposition。Thisone
operation,ofputtingthingsintofitplacesforbeingactedupon
bytheirowninternalforces,andbythoseresidinginother
naturalobjects,isallthatmandoes,orcando,withmatter。He
onlymovesonethingtoorfromanother。Hemovesaseedintothe
ground;andthenaturalforcesofvegetationproducein
successionaroot,astem,leaves,flowers,andfruit。Hemoves
anaxethroughatree,anditfallsbythenaturalforceof
gravitation;hemovesasawthroughit,inaparticularmanner,
andthephysicalpropertiesbywhichasoftersubstancegivesway
beforeaharder,makeitseparateintoplanks,whichhearranges
incertainpositions,withnailsdriventhroughthem,oradhesive
matterbetweenthem,andproducesatable,orahouse。Hemovesa
sparktofuel,anditignites,andbytheforcegeneratedin
combustionitcooksthefood,meltsorsoftenstheiron,converts
intobeerorsugarthemaltorcane—juice,whichhehas
previouslymovedtothespot。Hehasnoothermeansofactingon
matterthanbymovingit。Motion,andresistancetomotion,are
theonlythingswhichhismusclesareconstructedfor。By
muscularcontractionhecancreateapressureonanoutward
object,which,ifsufficientlypowerful,willsetitinmotion,
orifitbealreadymoving,willcheckormodifyoraltogether
arrestitsmotion,andhecandonomore。Butthisisenoughto
havegivenallthecommandwhichmankindhaveacquiredover
naturalforcesimmeasurablymorepowerfulthanthemselves;a
commandwhich,greatasitisalready,iswithoutdoubtdestined
tobecomeindefinitelygreater。Heexertsthispowereitherby
availinghimselfofnaturalforcesinexistence,orbyarranging
objectsinthosemixturesandcombinationsbywhichnatural
forcesaregenerated;aswhenbyputtingalightedmatchtofuel,
andwaterintoaboileroverit,hegeneratestheexpansiveforce
ofsteam,apowerwhichhasbeenmadesolargelyavailablefor
theattainmentofhumanpurposes。(1*)
Labour,then,inthephysicalworld,isalwaysandsolely
employedinputtingobjectsinmotion;thepropertiesofmatter,
thelawsofnature,dotherest。Theskillandingenuityofhuman
beingsarechieflyexercisedindiscoveringmovements,
practicablebytheirpowers,andcapableofbringingaboutthe
effectswhichtheydesire。But,whilemovementistheonlyeffect
whichmancanimmediatelyanddirectlyproducebyhismuscles,it
isnotnecessarythatheshouldproducedirectlybythemallthe
movementswhichherequires。Thefirstandmostobvious
substituteisthemuscularactionofcattle:bydegreesthe
powersofinanimatenaturearemadetoaidinthistoo,asby
makingthewind,orwater,thingsalreadyinmotion,communicate
apartoftheirmotiontothewheels,whichbeforethatinvention
weremadetorevolvebymuscularforce。Thisserviceisextorted
fromthepowersofwindandwaterbyasetofactions,consisting
liketheformerinmovingcertainobjectsintocertainpositions
inwhichtheyconstitutewhatistermedamachine;butthe
muscularactionnecessaryforthisisnotconstantlyrenewed,but
performedonceforall,andthereisonthewholeagreateconomy
oflabour。
3。Somewritershaveraisedthequestion,whethernature
givesmoreassistancetolabourinonekindofindustryorin
another;andhavesaidthatinsomeoccupationslabourdoesmost,
inothersnaturemost。Inthis,however,thereseemsmuch
confusionofideas。Thepartwhichnaturehasinanyworkofman,
isindefiniteandincommensurable。Itisimpossibletodecide
thatinanyonethingnaturedoesmorethaninanyother。One
cannotevensaythatlabourdoesless。Lesslabourmaybe
required;butifthatwhichisrequiredisabsolutely
indispensable,theresultisjustasmuchtheproductoflabour,
asofnature。Whentwoconditionsareequallynecessaryfor
producingtheeffectatall,itisunmeaningtosaythatsomuch
ofitisproducedbyoneandsomuchbytheother;itislike
attemptingtodecidewhichhalfofapairofscissorshasmostto
dointheactofcutting;orwhichofthefactors,fiveandsix,
contributesmosttotheproductionofthirty。Theformwhichthis
conceitusuallyassumes,isthatofsupposingthatnaturelends
moreassistancetohumanendeavoursinagriculture,thanin
manufactures。Thisnotion,heldbytheFrenchEconomistes,and
fromwhichAdamSmithwasnotfree,arosefromamisconceptionof
thenatureofrent。Therentoflandbeingapricepaidfora
naturalagency,andnosuchpricebeingpaidinmanufactures,
thesewritersimaginedthatsinceapricewaspaid,itwas
becausetherewasagreateramountofservicetobepaidfor。
whereasabetterconsiderationofthesubjectwouldhaveshown
thatthereasonwhytheuseoflandbearsapriceissimplythe
limitationofitsquantity,andthatifair,heat,electricity,
chemicalagencies,andtheotherpowersofnatureemployedby
manufacturers,weresparinglysupplied,andcould,likeland,be
engrossedandappropriated,arentcouldheexactedforthem
also。
4。Thisleadstoadistinctionwhichweshallfindtobeof
primaryimportance。Ofnaturalpowers,someareunlimited,others
limitedinquantity。Byanunlimitedquantityisofcoursenot
meantliterally,butpracticallyunlimited:aquantitybeyondthe
usewhichcaninany,oratleastinpresentcircumstances,be
madeofit。Landis,insomenewlysettledcountries,practically
unlimitedinquantity:thereismorethancanbeusedbythe
existingpopulationofthecountry,orbyanyaccessionlikelyto
bemadetoitforgenerationstocome。Buteventhere,land
favourablysituatedwithregardtomarketsormeansofcarriage,
isgenerallylimitedinquantity:thereisnotsomuchofitas
personswouldgladlyoccupyandcultivate,orotherwiseturnto
use。Inalloldcountries,landcapableofcultivation,landat
leastofanytolerablefertility,mustberankedamongagents
limitedinquantity。Water,forordinarypurposes,onthebanks
ofriversorlakes,mayberegardedasofunlimitedabundance;
butifrequiredforirrigation,itmayeventherebeinsufficient
tosupplyallwants,whileinplaceswhichdependfortheir
consumptiononcisternsortanks,oronwellswhicharenot
copious,orareliabletofail,watertakesitsplaceamong
thingsthequantityofwhichismoststrictlylimited。Where
wateritselfisplentiful,yetwaterpower,i。e。afallofwater
applicablebyitsmechanicalforcetotheserviceofindustry,
maybeexceedinglylimited,comparedwiththeusewhichwouldbe
madeofitifitweremoreabundant。Coal,metallicores,and
otherusefulsubstancesfoundintheearth,arestillmore
limitedthanland。Theyarenotonlystrictlylocalbut
exhaustible;though,atagivenplaceandtime,theymayexistin
muchgreaterabundancethanwouldbeappliedtopresentuseeven
iftheycouldbeobtainedgratis。Fisheries,inthesea,arein
mostcasesagiftofnaturepracticallyunlimitedinamount;but
theArcticwhalefisherieshavelongbeeninsufficientforthe
demandwhichexistsevenattheveryconsiderablepricenecessary
todefraythecostofappropriation:andtheimmenseextension
whichtheSouthernfisherieshaveinconsequenceassumed,is
tendingtoexhaustthemlikewise。Riverfisheriesareanatural
resourceofaverylimitedcharacter,andwouldberapidly
exhausted,ifallowedtobeusedbyeveryonewithoutrestraint。
Air,eventhatstateofitwhichwetermwind,may,inmost
situations,beobtainedinaquantitysufficientforevery
possibleuse;andsolikewise,ontheseacoastoronlarge
rivers,maywatercarriage:thoughthewharfageorharbour—room
applicabletotheserviceofthatmodeoftransportisinmany
situationsfarshortofwhatwouldbeusedifeasilyattainable。
Itwillbeseenhereafterhowmuchoftheeconomyofsociety
dependsonthelimitedquantityinwhichsomeofthemost
importantnaturalagentsexist,andmoreparticularlyland。For
thepresentIshallonlyremarkthatsolongasthequantityofa
naturalagentispracticallyunlimited,itcannot,unless
susceptibleofartificialmonopoly,bearanyvalueinthemarket,
sincenoonewillgiveanythingforwhatcanbeobtainedgratis。
Butassoonasalimitationbecomespracticallyoperative;as
soonasthereisnotsomuchofthethingtobehad,aswouldbe
appropriatedandusedifitcouldbeobtainedforasking;the
ownershiporuseofthenaturalagentacquiresanexchangeable
value。Whenmorewaterpoweriswantedinaparticulardistrict,
thantherearefallsofwatertosupplyit,personswillgivean
equivalentfortheuseofafallofwater。Whenthereismore
landwantedforcultivationthanaplacepossesses,orthanit
possessesofacertainqualityandcertainadvantagesof
situation,landofthatqualityandsituationmaybesoldfora
price,orletforanannualrent。Thissubjectwillhereafterbe
discussedatlength;butitisoftenusefultoanticipate,bya
briefsuggestion,principlesanddeductionswhichwehavenotyet
reachedtheplaceforexhibitingandillustratingfully。
NOTES:
1。Thisessentialandprimarylawofman’spowerovernaturewas,
Ibelieve,firstillustratedandmadeprominantasafundamental
principleofPoliticalEconomy,inthefirstchapterofMr。
Mill’sElements。
ThePrinciplesofPoliticalEconomy
byJohnStuartMill
Book1:Chapter2
OfLabourasanAgentofProduction
1。Thelabourwhichterminatesintheproductionofan
articlefittedforsomehumanuse,iseitheremployeddirectly
aboutthething,orinpreviousoperationsdestinedto
facilitate,perhapsessentialtothepossibilityof,the
subsequentones。Inmakingbread,forexample,thelabour
employedaboutthethingitselfisthatofthebaker;butthe
labourofthemiller,thoughemployeddirectlyintheproduction
notofbreadbutofflour,isequallypartoftheaggregatesum
oflabourbywhichthebreadisproduced;asisalsothelabour
ofthesowerandofthereaper。Somemaythinkthatallthese
personsoughttobeconsideredasemployingtheirlabourdirectly
aboutthething;thecorn,theflour,andthebreadbeingone
substanceinthreedifferentstates。Withoutdisputingaboutthis
questionofmerelanguage,thereisstilltheploughman,who
preparedthegroundfortheseed,andwhoselabournevercamein
contactwiththesubstanceinanyofitsstates;andthe
plough—maker,whoseshareintheresultwasstillmoreremote。
Allthesepersonsultimatelyderivetheremunerationoftheir
labourfromthebread,oritsprice:theplough—makerasmuchas
therest;forsinceploughsareofnouseexceptfortillingthe
soil,noonewouldmakeoruseploughsforanyotherreasonthan
becausetheincreasedreturns,therebyobtainedfromtheground,
affordedasourcefromwhichanadequateequivalentcouldbe
assignedforthelabouroftheplough—maker。Iftheproduceisto
beusedorconsumedintheformofbread,itisfromthebread
thatthisequivalentmustcome。Thebreadmustsufficeto
remuneratealltheselabourers,andseveralothers;suchasthe
carpentersandbricklayerswhoerectedthefarm—buildings;the
hedgersandditcherswhomadethefencesnecessaryforthe
protectionofthecrop;theminersandsmelterswhoextractedor
preparedtheironofwhichtheploughandotherinstrumentswere
made。These,however,andtheplough—maker,donotdependfor
theirremunerationuponthebreadmadefromtheproduceofa
singleharvest,butuponthatmadefromtheproduceofallthe
harvestswhicharesuccessivelygathereduntiltheplough,orthe
buildingsandfences,arewornout。Wemustaddyetanotherkind
oflabour;thatoftransportingtheproducefromtheplaceofits
productiontotheplaceofitsdestineduse:thelabourof
carryingthecorntomarket,andfrommarkettothemiller’s,the
flourfromthemiller’stothebaker’s,andthebreadfromthe
baker’stotheplaceofitsfinalconsumption。Thislabouris
sometimesveryconsiderable:flouristransportedtoEnglandfrom
beyondtheAtlantic,cornfromtheheartofRussia;andin
additiontothelabourersimmediatelyemployed,thewaggonersand
sailors,therearealsocostlyinstruments,suchasships,inthe
constructionofwhichmuchlabourhasbeenexpended:thatlabour,
however,notdependingforitswholeremunerationuponthebread,
butforapartonly;shipsbeingusually,duringthecourseof
theirexistence,employedinthetransportofmanydifferent
kindsofcommodities。
Toestimate,therefore,thelabourofwhichanygiven
commodityistheresult,isfarfromasimpleoperation。The
itemsinthecalculationareverynumerous—asitmayseemtosome
persons,infinitelysO;forif,asapartofthelabouremployed
inmakingbread,wecountthelabouroftheblacksmithwhomade
theplough,whynotalso(itmaybeasked)thelabourofmaking
thetoolsusedbytheblacksmith,andthetoolsusedinmaking
thosetools,andsobacktotheoriginofthings?Butafter
mountingoneortwostepsinthisascendingscale,wecomeintoa
regionoffactionstoominuteforcalculation。Suppose,for
instance,thatthesameploughwilllast,beforebeingwornout,
adozenyears。Onlyone—twelfthofthelabourofmakingthe
ploughmustbeplacedtotheaccountofeachyear’sharvest。A
twelfthpartofthelabourofmakingaploughisanappreciable
quantity。Butthesamesetoftools,perhaps,sufficetothe
plough—makerforforgingahundredploughs,whichserveduring
thetwelveyearsoftheirexistencetopreparethesoilofas
manydifferentfarms。Atwelve—hundredthpartofthelabourof
makinghistools,isasmuch,therefore,ashasbeenexpendedin
procuringoneyear’sharvestofasinglefarm:andwhenthis
fractioncomestobefurtherapportionedamongthevarioussacks
ofcornandloavesofbread,itisseenatoncethatsuch
quantitiesarenotworthtakingintotheaccountforany
practicalpurposeconnectedwiththecommodity。Itistruethat
ifthetool—makerhadnotlaboured,thecornandbreadnever
wouldhavebeenproduced;buttheywillnotbesoldatenthpart
ofafarthingdearerinconsiderationofhislabour。
2。Anotherofthemodesinwhichlabourisindirectlyor
remotelyinstrumentaltotheproductionofathing,requires
particularnotice:namely,whenitisemployedinproducing
subsistence,tomaintainthelabourerswhiletheyareengagedin
theproduction。Thispreviousemploymentoflabourisan
indispensableconditiontoeveryproductiveoperation,onany
otherthantheverysmallestscale。Exceptthelabourofthe
hunterandfisher,thereisscarcelyanykindoflabourtowhich
thereturnsareimmediate。Productiveoperationsrequiretobe
continuedacertaintime,beforetheirfruitsareobtained。
Unlessthelabourer,beforecommencinghiswork,possessesa
storeoffood,orcanobtainaccesstothestoresofsomeone
else,insufficientquantitytomaintainhimuntiltheproduction
iscompleted,hecanundertakenolabourbutsuchascanbe
carriedonatoddintervals,concurrentlywiththepursuitofhis
subsistence。Hecannotobtainfooditselfinanyabundance;for
everymodeofsoobtainingit,requiresthattherebealready
foodinstore。Agricultureonlybringsforthfoodafterthelapse
ofmonths;andthoughthelaboursoftheagriculturistarenot
necessarilycontinuousduringthewholeperiod,theymustoccupy
aconsiderablepartofit。Notonlyisagricultureimpossible
withoutfoodproducedinadvance,buttheremustbeaverygreat
quantityinadvancetoenableanyconsiderablecommunityto
supportitselfwhollybyagriculture。AcountrylikeEnglandor
Franceisonlyabletocarryontheagricultureofthepresent
year,becausethatofpastyearshasprovided,inthosecountries
orsomewhereelse,sufficientfoodtosupporttheiragricultural
populationuntilthenextharvest。Theyareonlyenabledto
producesomanyotherthingsbesidesfood,becausethefoodwhich
wasinstoreatthecloseofthelastharvestsufficesto
maintainnotonlytheagriculturallabourers,butalarge
industriouspopulationbesides。
Thelabouremployedinproducingthisstockofsubsistence,
formsagreatandimportantpartofthepastlabourwhichhas
beennecessarytoenablepresentlabourtobecarriedon。But
thereisadifference,requiringparticularnotice,betweenthis
andtheotherkindsofpreviousorpreparatorylabour。The
miller,thereaper,theploughman,theplough—maker,thewaggoner
andwaggon—maker,eventhesailorandship—builderwhenemployed,
derivetheirremunerationfromtheultimateproduct—thebread
madefromthecornonwhichtheyhaveseverallyoperated,or
suppliedtheinstrumentsforoperating。Thelabourthatproduced
thefoodwhichfedalltheselabourers,isasnecessarytothe
ultimateresult,thebreadofthepresentharvest,asanyof
thoseotherportionsoflabour;butisnot,likethem,
remuneratedfromit。Thatpreviouslabourhasreceivedits
remunerationfromthepreviousfood。Inordertoraiseany
product,thereareneededlabour,tools,andmaterials,andfood
tofeedthelabourers。Butthetoolsandmaterialsareofnouse
exceptforobtainingtheproduct,oratleastaretobeapplied
tonootheruse,andthelabouroftheirconstructioncanbe
remuneratedonlyfromtheproductwhenobtained。Thefood,onthe
contrary,isintrinsicallyuseful,andisappliedtothedirect
useoffeedinghumanbeings。Thelabourexpendedinproducingthe
food,andrecompensedbyit,needsnotberemuneratedoveragain
fromtheproduceofthesubsequentlabourwhichithasfed。Ifwe
supposethatthesamebodyoflabourerscarriedonamanufacture,
andgrewfoodtosustainthemselveswhiledoingit,theyhavehad
fortheirtroublethefoodandthemanufacturedarticle;butif
theyalsogrewthematerialandmadethetools,theyhavehad
nothingforthattroublebutthemanufacturedarticlealone。
Theclaimtoremunerationfoundedonthepossessionoffood,
availableforthemaintenanceoflabourers,isofanotherkind;
remunerationforabstinence,notforlabour。Ifapersonhasa
storeoffood,hehasitinhispowertoconsumeithimselfin
idleness,orinfeedingotherstoattendonhim,ortofightfor
him,ortosingordanceforhim。If,insteadofthesethings,he
givesittoproductivelabourerstosupportthemduringtheir
work,hecan,andnaturallywill,claimaremunerationfromthe
produce。Hewillnotbecontentwithsimplerepayment;ifhe
receivesmerelythat,heisonlyinthesamesituationasat
first,andhasderivednoadvantagefromdelayingtoapplyhis
savingstohisownbenefitorpleasure。Hewilllookforsome
equivalentforthisforbearance:hewillexpecthisadvanceof
foodtocomebacktohimwithanincrease,calledinthelanguage
ofbusiness,aprofit;andthehopeofthisprofitwillgenerally
havebeenapartoftheinducementwhichmadehimaccumulatea
stock,byeconomizinginhisownconsumption;or,atanyrate,
whichmadehimforegotheapplicationofit,whenaccumulated,to
hispersonaleaseorsatisfaction。Thefoodalsowhichmaintained
otherworkmenwhileproducingthetoolsormaterials,musthave
beenprovidedinadvancebysomeone,andhe,too,musthavehis
profitfromtheultimateproduct;butthereisthisdifference,
thatheretheultimateproducthastosupplynotonlytheprofit,
butalsotheremunerationofthelabour。Thetool—maker(say,for
instance,theploughmaker)doesnotindeedusuallywaitforhis
paymentuntiltheharvestisreaped;thefarmeradvancesitto
him,andstepsintohisplacebybecomingtheownerofthe
plough。Nevertheless,itisfromtheharvestthatthepaymentis
tocome;sincethefarmerwouldnotundertakethisoutlayunless
heexpectedthattheharvestwouldrepayhim,andwithaprofit
tooonthisfreshadvance;thatis,unlesstheharvestwould
yield,besidestheremunerationofthefarmlabourers(anda
profitforadvancingit),asufficientresiduetoremuneratethe
plough—maker’slabourers,givetheplough—makeraprofit,anda
profittothefarmeronboth。
3。Fromtheseconsiderationsitappears,thatinan
enumerationandclassificationofthekindsofindustrywhichare
intendedfortheindirectorremotefurtheranceofother
productivelabour,weneednotincludethelabourofproducing
subsistenceorothernecessariesoflifetobeconsumedby
productivelabourers;forthemainendandpurposeofthislabour
isthesubsistenceitself;andthoughthepossessionofastore
ofitenablesotherworktobedone,thisisbutanincidental
consequence。Theremainingmodesinwhichlabourisindirectly
instrumentaltoproduction,maybearrangedunderfiveheads。
First:Labouremployedinproducingmaterials,onwhich
industryistobeafterwardsemployed。Thisis,inmanycases,a
labourofmereappropriation;extractiveindustry,asithasbeen
aptlynamedbyM。Dunoyer。Thelabouroftheminer,forexample,
consistsofoperationsfordiggingoutoftheearthsubstances
convertiblebyindustryintovariousarticlesfittedforhuman
use。Extractiveindustry,however,isnotconfinedtothe
extractionofmaterials。Coal,forinstance,isemployed,not
onlyintheprocessofindustry,butindirectlywarminghuman
beings。Whensoused,itisnotamaterialofproduction,butis
itselftheultimateproduct。So,also,inthecaseofamineof
preciousstones。Thesearetosomesmallextentemployedinthe
productivearts,asdiamondsbytheglass—cutter,emeryand
corundumforpolishing,buttheirprincipaldestination,thatof
ornament,isadirectuse;thoughtheycommonlyrequire,before
beingsoused,someprocessofmanufacture,whichmayperhaps
warrantourregardingthemasmaterials。Metallicoresofall
sortsarematerialsmerely。
Underthehead,productionofmaterials,wemustincludethe
industryofthewood—cutter,whenemployedincuttingand
preparingtimberforbuilding,orwoodforthepurposesofthe
carpenter’soranyotherart。IntheforestsofAmerica,Norway,
Germany,thePyreneesandAlps,thissortoflabourislargely
employedontreesofspontaneousgrowth。Inothercases,wemust
addtothelabourofthewood—cutterthatoftheplanterand
cultivator。
Underthesameheadarealsocomprisedthelaboursofthe
agriculturistingrowingflax,hemp,cotton,feedingsilkworms,
risingfoodforcattle,producingbark,dye—stuffs,some
oleaginousplants,andmanyotherthingsonlyusefulbecause
requiredinotherdepartmentsofindustry。So,too,thelabourof
thehunter,asfarashisobjectisfursorfeathers;ofthe
shepherdandthecattle—breeder,inrespectofwool,hides,horn,
bristles,horse—hair,andthelike。Thethingsusedasmaterials
insomeprocessorotherofmanufactureareofamost
miscellaneouscharacter,drawnfromalmosteveryquarterofthe
animal,vegetable,andmineralkingdoms。Andbesidesthis,the
finishedproductsofmanybranchesofindustryarethematerials
ofothers。Thethreadproducedbythespinnerisappliedto
hardlyanyuseexceptasmaterialfortheweaver。Eventhe
productoftheloomischieflyusedasmaterialforthe
fabricatorsofarticlesofdressorfurniture,oroffurther
instrumentsofproductiveindustry,asinthecaseofthe
sailmaker。Thecurrierandtannerfindtheirwholeoccupationin
convertingrawmaterialintowhatmaybetermedprepared
material。Instrictnessofspeech,almostallfood,asitcomes
fromthehandsoftheagriculturist,isnothingmorethan
materialfortheoccupationofthebakerorthecook。
4。Thesecondkindofindirectlabouristhatemployedin
makingtoolsorimplementsfortheassistanceoflabour。Iuse
thesetermsintheirmostcomprehensivesense,embracingall
permanentinstrumentsorhelpstoproduction,fromaflintand
steelforstrikingalight,toasteamship,orthemostcomplex
apparatusofmanufacturingmachinery。Theremaybesome
hesitationwheretodrawthelinebetweenimplementsand
materials;andsomethingsusedinproduction(suchasfuel)
wouldscarcelyincommonlanguagebecalledbyeithername,
popularphraseologybeingshapedoutbyadifferentclassof
necessitiesfromthoseofscientificexposition。Toavoida
multiplicationofclassesanddenominationsansweringto
distinctionsofnoscientificimportance,politicaleconomists
generallyincludeallthingswhichareusedasimmediatemeansof
production(themeanswhicharenotimmediatewillbeconsidered
presently)eitherintheclassofimplementsorinthatof
materials。Perhapsthelineismostusuallyandmostconveniently
drawn,byconsideringasamaterialeveryinstrumentof
productionwhichcanonlybeusedonce,beingdestroyed(atleast
asaninstrumentforthepurposeinhand)byasingleemployment。
Thusfuel,onceburnt,cannotbeagainusedasfuel;whatcanbe
sousedisonlyanyportionwhichhasremainedunburntthefirst
time。Andnotonlyitcannotbeusedwithoutbeingconsumed,but
itisonlyusefulbybeingconsumed;forifnopartofthefuel
weredestroyed,noheatwouldbegenerated。Afleece,again,is
destroyedasafleecebybeingspunintothread;andthethread
cannotbeusedasthreadwhenwovenintocloth。Butanaxeisnot
destroyedasanaxebycuttingdownatree:itmaybeused
afterwardstocutdownahundredorathousandmore;andthough
deterioratedinsomesmalldegreebyeachuse,itdoesnotdoits
workbybeingdeteriorated,asthecoalandthefleecedotheirs
bybeingdestroyed;onthecontrary,itisthebetterinstrument
thebetteritresistsdeterioration。Therearesomethings,
rightlyclassedasmaterials,whichmaybeusedassuchasecond
andathirdtime,butnotwhiletheproducttowhichtheyat
firstcontributedremainsinexistence。Theironwhichformeda
tankorasetofpipesmaybemeltedtoformaploughora
steam—engine;thestoneswithwhichahousewasbuiltmaybeused
afteritispulleddown,tobuildanother。Butthiscannotbe
donewhiletheoriginalproductsubsists;theirfunctionas
materialsissuspended,untiltheexhaustionofthefirstuse。
Notsowiththethingsclassedasimplements;theymaybeused
repeatedlyforfreshwork,untilthetime,sometimesvery
distant,atwhichtheyarewornout,whiletheworkalreadydone
bythemmaysubsistunimpaired,andwhenitperishes,doessoby
itsownlaws,orbycasualtiesofitsown。(1*)
Theonlypracticaldifferenceofmuchimportancearisingfrom
thedistinctionbetweenmaterialsandimplements,isonewhich
hasattractedourattentioninanothercase。Sincematerialsare
destroyedassuchbybeingonceused,thewholeofthelabour
requiredfortheirproduction,aswellastheabstinenceofthe
personwhosuppliedthemeansforcarryingiton,mustbe
remuneratedfromthefruitsofthatsingleuse。Implements,on
thecontrary,beingsusceptibleofrepeatedemployment,thewhole
oftheproductswhichtheyareinstrumentalinbringinginto
existenceareafundwhichcanbedrawnupontoremuneratethe
labouroftheirconstruction,andtheabstinenceofthoseby
whoseaccumulationsthatlabourwassupported。Itisenoughif
eachproductcontributesafraction,commonlyaninsignificant
one,towardstheremunerationofthatlabourandabstinence,or
towardsindemnifyingtheimmediateproducerforadvancingthat
remunerationtothepersonwhoproducedthetools。
5。Thirdly:Besidesmaterialsforindustrytoemployitself
on,andimplementstoaidit,provisionmustbemadetoprevent
itsoperationsfrombeingdisturbed,anditsproductsinjured,
eitherbythedestroyingagenciesofnature,orbytheviolence
orrapacityofmen。Thisgivesrisetoanothermodeinwhich
labournotemployeddirectlyabouttheproductitself,is
instrumentaltoitsproduction;namely,whenemployedforthe
protectionofindustry。Suchistheobjectofallbuildingsfor
industrialpurposes;allmanufactories,warehouses,docks,
granaries,barns,farm—buildingsdevotedtocattle,ortothe
operationsofagriculturallabour。Iexcludethoseinwhichthe
labourerslive,orwhicharedestinedfortheirpersonal
accommodation:these,liketheirfood,supplyactualwants,and
mustbecountedintheremunerationoftheirlabour。Thereare
manymodesinwhichlabourisstillmoredirectlyappliedtothe
protectionofproductiveoperations。Theherdsmanhaslittle
otheroccupationthantoprotectthecattlefromharm:the
positiveagenciesconcernedintherealizationoftheproduct,go
onnearlyofthemselves。Ihavealreadymentionedthelabourof
thehedgerandditcher,ofthebuilderofwallsordykes。To
thesemustbeaddedthatofthesoldier,thepoliceman,andthe
judge。Thesefunctionariesarenotindeedemployedexclusivelyin
theprotectionofindustry,nordoestheirpaymentconstitute,to
theindividualproducer,apartoftheexpensesofproduction。
Buttheyarepaidfromthetaxes,whicharederivedfromthe
produceofindustry;andinanytolerablygovernedcountrythey
rendertoitsoperationsaservicefarmorethanequivalentto
thecost。Tosocietyatlargetheyarethereforepartofthe
expensesofproduction;andifthereturnstoproductionwerenot
sufficienttomaintaintheselabourersinadditiontoallthe
othersrequired,production,atleastinthatformandmanner,
couldnottakeplace。Besides,iftheprotectionwhichthe
governmentaffordstotheoperationsofindustrywerenot
afforded,theproducerswouldbeunderanecessityofeither
withdrawingalargeshareoftheirtimeandlabourfrom
production,toemployitindefence,orofengagingarmedmento
defendthem;allwhichlabour,inthatcase,mustbedirectly
remuneratedfromtheproduce;andthingswhichcouldnotpayfor
thisadditionallabour,wouldnotbeproduced。Underthepresent
arrangements,theproductpaysitsquotatowardsthesame
protection,andnotwithstandingthewasteandprodigality
incidenttogovernmentexpenditure,obtainsitofbetterquality
atamuchsmallercost。
6。Fourthly:Thereisaverygreatamountoflabouremployed,
notinbringingtheproductintoexistence,butinrenderingit,
wheninexistence,accessibletothoseforwhoseuseitis
intended。Manyimportantclassesoflabourersfindtheirsole
employmentinsomefunctionofthiskind。Thereisfirstthe
wholeclassofcarriers,bylandorwater。muleteers,waggoners,
bargemen,sailors,wharfmen,coalheavers,porters,railway
establishments,andthelike。Next,therearetheconstructorsof
alltheimplementsoftransport;ships,barges,carts,
locomotives,&c。,towhichmustbeaddedroads,canals,and
railways。Roadsaresometimesmadebythegovernment,andopened
gratuitouslytothepublic;butthelabourofmakingthemisnot
thelesspaidforfromtheproduce。Eachproducer,inpayinghis
quotaofthetaxesleviedgenerallyfortheconstructionof
roads,paysfortheuseofthosewhichconducetohis
convenience;andifmadewithanytolerablejudgment,they
increasethereturnstohisindustrybyfarmorethanan
equivalentamount。
Anothernumerousclassoflabourersemployedinrenderingthe
thingsproducedaccessibletotheirintendedconsumers,isthe
classofdealersandtraders,or,astheymaybetermed,
distributors。Therewouldbeagreatwasteoftimeandtrouble,
andaninconvenienceoftenamountingtoimpracticability,if
consumerscouldonlyobtainthearticlestheywantbytreating
directlywiththeproducers。Bothproducersandconsumersaretoo
muchscattered,andthelatteroftenattoogreatadistancefrom
theformer。Todiminishthislossoftimeandlabour,the
contrivanceoffairsandmarketswasearlyhadrecourseto,where
consumersandproducersmightperiodicallymeet,withoutany
intermediateagency;andthisplananswerstolerablywellfor
manyarticles,especiallyagriculturalproduce,agriculturists
havingatsomeseasonsacertainquantityofsparetimeontheir
hands。Buteveninthiscase,attendanceisoftenvery
troublesomeandinconvenienttobuyerswhohaveother
occupations,anddonotliveintheimmediatevicinity;while,
forallarticlestheproductionofwhichrequirescontinuous
attentionfromtheproducers,theseperiodicalmarketsmustbe
heldatsuchconsiderableintervals,andthewantsofthe
consumersmusteitherbeprovidedforsolongbeforehand,ormust
remainsolongunsupplied,thatevenbeforetheresourcesof
societyadmittedoftheestablishmentofshops,thesupplyof
thesewantsfelluniversallyintothehandsofitinerantdealers:
thepedlar,whomightappearonceamonth,beingpreferredtothe
fair,whichonlyreturnedonceortwiceayear。Incountry
districts,remotefromtownsorlargevillages,theindustryof
thepedlarisnotyetwhollysuperseded。Butadealerwhohasa
fixedabodeandfixedcustomersissomuchmoretobedepended
on,thatconsumerspreferresortingtohimifheisconveniently
accessible;anddealersthereforefindtheiradvantagein
establishingthemselvesineverylocalitywherethereare
sufficientconsumersnearathandtoaffordthemaremuneration。
Inmanycasestheproducersanddealersarethesamepersons,
atleastastotheownershipofthefundsandthecontrolofthe
operations。Thetailor,theshoemaker,thebaker,andmanyother
tradesmen,aretheproducersofthearticlestheydealin,sofar
asregardsthelaststageintheproduction。Thisunion,however,
ofthefunctionsofmanufacturerandretailerisonlyexpedient
whenthearticlecanadvantageouslybemadeatorneartheplace
convenientforretailingit,andis,besides,manufacturedand
soldinsmallparcels。Whenthingshavetobebroughtfroma
distance,thesamepersoncannoteffectuallysuperintendboththe
makingandtheretailingofthem;whentheyarebestandmost
cheaplymadeonalargescale,asinglemanufactoryrequiresso
manylocalchannelstocarryoffitssupply,thattheretailing
ismostconvenientlydelegatedtootheragency;andevenshoes
andcoats,whentheyaretobefurnishedinlargequantitiesat
once,asforthesupplyofaregimentorofaworkhouse,are
usuallyobtainednotdirectlyfromtheproducers,butfrom
intermediatedealers,whomakeittheirbusinesstoascertain
fromwhatproducerstheycanbeobtainedbestandcheapest。Even
whenthingsaredestinedtobeatlastsoldbyretail,
conveniencesooncreatesaclassofwholesaledealers。When
productsandtransactionshavemultipliedbeyondacertainpoint;
whenonemanufactorysuppliesmanyshops,andoneshophasoften
toobtaingoodsfrommanydifferentmanufactories,thelossof
timeandtroublebothtothemanufacturersandtotheretailers
bytreatingdirectlywithoneanothermakesitmoreconvenientto
themtotreatwithasmallernumberofgreatdealersor
merchants,whoonlybuytosellagain,collectinggoodsfromthe
variousproducersanddistributingthemtotheretailers,tobe
bythemfurtherdistributedamongtheconsumers。Ofthesevarious
elementsiscomposedtheDistributingClass,whoseagencyis
supplementarytothatoftheProducingClass:andtheproduceso
distributed,oritsprice,isthesourcefromwhichthe
distributorsareremuneratedfortheirexertions,andforthe
abstinencewhichenabledthemtoadvancethefundsneedfulfor
thebusinessofdistribution。
7。Wehavenowcompletedtheenumerationofthemodesin
whichlabouremployedonexternalnatureissubservientto
production。Butthereisyetanothermodeofemployinglabour,
whichconducesequally,thoughstillmoreremotely,tothatend:
thisis,labourofwhichthesubjectishumanbeings。Everyhuman
beinghasbeenbroughtupfrominfancyattheexpenseofmuch
labourtosomepersonorpersons,andifthislabour,orpartof
it,hadnotbeenbestowed,thechildwouldneverhaveattained
theageandstrengthwhichenablehimtobecomealabourerinhis
turn。Tothecommunityatlarge,thelabourandexpenseof
rearingitsinfantpopulationformapartoftheoutlaywhichis
aconditionofproduction,andwhichistobereplacedwith
increasefromthefutureproduceoftheirlabour。Bythe
individuals,thislabourandexpenseareusuallyincurredfrom
othermotivesthantoobtainsuchultimatereturn,and,formost
purposesofpoliticaleconomy,neednotbetakenintoaccountas
expensesofproduction。Butthetechnicalorindustrialeducation
ofthecommunity;thelabouremployedinlearningandinteaching
theartsofproduction,inacquiringandcommunicatingskillin
thosearts;thislabourisreally,andingeneralsolely,
undergoneforthesakeofthegreaterormorevaluableproduce
therebyattained,andinorderthataremuneration,equivalentor
morethanequivalent,maybereapedbythelearner,besidesan
adequateremunerationforthelabouroftheteacher,whena
teacherhasbeenemployed。
Asthelabourwhichconfersproductivepowers,whetherof
handorofhead,maybelookeduponaspartofthelabourby
whichsocietyaccomplishesitsproductiveoperations,orinother
words,aspartofwhattheproducecoststosociety,sotoomay
thelabouremployedinkeepingupproductivepowers;in
preventingthemfrombeingdestroyedorweakenedbyaccidentor
disease。Thelabourofaphysicianorsurgeon,whenmadeuseof
bypersonsengagedinindustry,mustberegardedintheeconomy
ofsocietyasasacrificeincurred,topreservefromperishingby
deathorinfirmitythatportionoftheproductiveresourcesof
societywhichisfixedinthelivesandbodilyormentalpowers
ofitsproductivemembers。Totheindividuals,indeed,thisforms
butapart,sometimesanimperceptiblepart,ofthemotivesthat
inducethemtosubmittomedicaltreatment:itisnotprincipally
fromeconomicalmotivesthatpersonshavealimbamputated,or
endeavourtobecuredofafever,thoughwhentheydoso,there
isgenerallysufficientinducementforitevenonthatscore
alone。Thisis,therefore,oneofthecasesoflabourandoutlay
which,thoughconducivetoproduction,yetnotbeingincurredfor
thatend,orforthesakeofthereturnsarisingfromit,areout
ofthesphereofmostofthegeneralpropositionswhichpolitical
economyhasoccasiontoassertrespectingproductivelabour:
though,whensocietyandnottheindividualsareconsidered,this
labourandoutlaymustberegardedaspartoftheadvanceby
whichsocietyeffectsitsproductiveoperations,andforwhichit
isindemnifiedbytheproduce。