NowandthenIamaskedasto“whatbooksastatesmanshouldread。”
andmyansweris,poetryandnovels——includingshortstoriesundertheheadofnovels。Idon’tmeanthatheshouldreadonlynovelsandmodernpoetry。IfhecannotalsoenjoytheHebrewprophetsandtheGreekdramatists,heshouldbesorry。Heoughttoreadinterestingbooksonhistoryandgovernment,andbooksofscienceandphilosophy;
andreallygoodbooksonthesesubjectsareasenthrallingasanyfictioneverwritteninproseorverse。GibbonandMacaulay,Herodotus,ThucydidesandTacitus,theHeimskringla,Froissart,JoinvilleandVillehardouin,ParkmanandMahan,MommsenandRanke——
why!therearescoresandscoresofsolidhistories,thebestintheworld,whichareasabsorbingasthebestofallthenovels,andofaspermanentvalue。ThesamethingistrueofDarwinandHuxleyandCarlyleandEmerson,andpartsofKant,andofvolumeslikeSutherland’s“GrowthoftheMoralInstinct。”orActon’sEssaysandLounsbury’sstudies——hereagainIamnottryingtoclassbookstogether,ormeasureonebyanother,orenumerateoneinathousandofthoseworthreading,butjusttoindicatethatanymanorwomanofsomeintelligenceandsomecultivationcaninsomelineorotherofseriousthought,scientificorhistoricalorphilosophicaloreconomicorgovernmental,findanynumberofbookswhicharecharmingtoread,andwhichinadditiongivethatforwhichhisorhersoulhungers。I
donotforaminutemeanthatthestatesmanoughtnottoreadagreatmanydifferentbooksofthischaracter,justaseveryoneelseshouldreadthem。But,inthefinalevent,thestatesman,andthepublicist,andthereformer,andtheagitatorfornewthings,andtheupholderofwhatisgoodinoldthings,allneedmorethananythingelsetoknowhumannature,toknowtheneedsofthehumansoul;andtheywillfindthisnatureandtheseneedssetforthasnowhereelsebythegreatimaginativewriters,whetherofproseorofpoetry。
Theroomforchoiceissolimitlessthattomyminditseemsabsurdtotrytomakecatalogueswhichshallbesupposedtoappealtoallthebestthinkers。ThisiswhyIhavenosympathywhateverwithwritinglistsoftheOneHundredBestBooks,ortheFive-FootLibrary。Itisallrightforamantoamusehimselfbycomposingalistofahundredverygoodbooks;andifheistogooffforayearorsowherehecannotgetmanybooks,itisanexcellentthingtochooseafive-footlibraryofparticularbookswhichinthatparticularyearandonthatparticulartriphewouldliketoread。Butthereisnosuchthingasahundredbooksthatarebestforallmen,orforthemajorityofmen,orforonemanatalltimes;andthereisnosuchthingasafive-footlibrarywhichwillsatisfytheneedsofevenoneparticularmanondifferentoccasionsextendingoveranumberofyears。MiltonisbestforonemoodandPopeforanother。BecauseamanlikesWhitmanorBrowningorLowellheshouldnotfeelhimselfdebarredfromTennysonorKiplingorKornerorHeineortheBardoftheDimbovitza。Tolstoy’snovelsaregoodatonetimeandthoseofSienkiewiczatanother;andheisfortunatewhocanrelish“Salammbo“and“TomBrown“andthe“TwoAdmirals“and“QuentinDurward“and“ArtemusWard“andthe“IngoldsbyLegends“and“Pickwick“and“VanityFair。”Why,therearehundredsofbookslikethese,eachoneofwhich,ifreallyread,reallyassimilated,bythepersontowhomithappenstoappeal,willenablethatpersonquiteunconsciouslytofurnishhimselfwithmuchammunitionwhichhewillfindofuseinthebattleoflife。
Abookmustbeinterestingtotheparticularreaderatthatparticulartime。Buttherearetensofthousandsofinterestingbooks,andsomeofthemaresealedtosomemenandsomearesealedtoothers;andsomestirthesoulatsomegivenpointofaman’slifeandyetconveynomessageatothertimes。Thereader,thebooklover,mustmeethisownneedswithoutpayingtoomuchattentiontowhathisneighborssaythoseneedsshouldbe。Hemustnothypocriticallypretendtolikewhathedoesnotlike。Yetatthesametimehemustavoidthatmostunpleasantofalltheindicationsofpuffed-upvanitywhichconsistsintreatingmereindividual,andperhapsunfortunate,idiosyncrasyasamatterofpride。IhappentobedevotedtoMacbeth,whereasIveryseldomreadHamletthoughIlikepartsofit。NowIamhumblyandsincerelyconsciousthatthisisademeritinmeandnotinHamlet;
andyetitwouldnotdomeanygoodtopretendthatIlikeHamletasmuchasMacbethwhen,asamatteroffact,Idon’t。Iamveryfondofsimpleepicsandofballadpoetry,fromtheNibelungenliedandtheRolandsongthrough“ChevyChase“and“PatrickSpens“and“TwaCorbies“toScott’spoemsandLongfellow’s“SagaofKingOlaf“and“Othere。”Ontheotherhand,Idon’tcaretoreaddramasasarule;I
cannotreadthemwithenjoymentunlesstheyappealtomeverystrongly。TheymustalmostbeAEschylusorEuripides,GoetheorMoliere,inorderthatImaynotfeelafterfinishingthemasenseofvirtuousprideinhavingachievedatask。NowIwouldbethefirsttodenythateventhemostdelightfuloldEnglishballadshouldbeputonaparwithanyoneofscoresofdramaticworksbyauthorswhomIhavenotmentioned;Iknowthateachofthesedramatistshaswrittenwhatisofmoreworththantheballad;only,Ienjoytheballad,andI
don’tenjoythedrama;andthereforetheballadisbetterforme,andthisfactisnotalteredbytheotherfactthatmyownshortcomingsaretoblameinthematter。IstillreadanumberofScott’snovelsoverandoveragain,whereasifIfinishanythingbyMissAustenI
haveafeelingthatdutyperformedisarainbowtothesoul。Butotherbookloverswhoareveryclosekintome,andwhosetasteIknowtobebetterthanmine,readMissAustenallthetime——and,moreover,theyareverykind,andneverpitymeintoooffensiveamannerfornotreadinghermyself。
Asidefromthemastersofliterature,thereareallkindsofbookswhichonepersonwillfinddelightful,andwhichhecertainlyoughtnottosurrenderjustbecausenobodyelseisabletofindasmuchinthebelovedvolume。Thereisonourbook-shelvesalittlepre-
Victoriannovelortalecalled“TheSemi-AttachedCouple。”Itistoldwithmuchhumor;itisastoryofgentlefolkwhoarereallygentlefolk;andtomeitisaltogetherdelightful。ButoutsidethemembersofmyownfamilyIhavenevermetahumanbeingwhohadevenheardofit,andIdon’tsupposeIevershallmeetone。IoftenenjoyastorybysomelivingauthorsomuchthatIwritetotellhimso——ortotellherso;andatleasthalfthetimeIregretmyaction,becauseitencouragesthewritertobelievethatthepublicsharesmyviews,andhethenfindsthatthepublicdoesn’t。
Booksareallverywellintheirway,andwelovethematSagamoreHill;butchildrenarebetterthanbooks。SagamoreHillisoneofthreeneighboringhousesinwhichsmallcousinsspentveryhappyyearsofchildhood。Inthethreehousestherewereatonetimesixteenofthesesmallcousins,alltold,andoncewerangedtheminorderofsizeandtooktheirphotograph。Therearemanykindsofsuccessinlifeworthhaving。Itisexceedinglyinterestingandattractivetobeasuccessfulbusinessman,orrailroadman,orfarmer,orasuccessfullawyerordoctor;orawriter,oraPresident,oraranchman,orthecolonelofafightingregiment,ortokillgrizzlybearsandlions。
Butforunflagginginterestandenjoyment,ahouseholdofchildren,ifthingsgoreasonablywell,certainlymakesallotherformsofsuccessandachievementlosetheirimportancebycomparison。Itmaybetruethathetravelsfarthestwhotravelsalone;butthegoalthusreachedisnotworthreaching。Andasforalifedeliberatelydevotedtopleasureasanend——why,thegreatesthappinessisthehappinessthatcomesasaby-productofstrivingtodowhatmustbedone,eventhoughsorrowismetinthedoing。Thereisabitofhomelyphilosophy,quotedbySquireBillWidener,ofWidener’sValley,Virginia,whichsumsupone’sdutyinlife:“Dowhatyoucan,withwhatyou’vegot,whereyouare。”
Thecountryistheplaceforchildren,andifnotthecountry,acitysmallenoughsothatonecangetoutintothecountry。Whenourownchildrenwerelittle,wewereforseveralwintersinWashington,andeachSundayafternoonthewholefamilyspentinRockCreekPark,whichwasthenveryrealcountryindeed。Iwoulddragoneofthechildren’swagons;andwhentheverysmallestpairsoffeetgrewtiredoftrudgingbravelyafterus,orofracingonrapturoussidetripsafterflowersandothertreasures,theownerswouldclamberintothewagon。
Oneofthesewagons,bytheway,agorgeousredone,had“Express“
paintedonitingiltletters,andwasknowntotheyoungerchildrenasthe“’spress“wagon。Theyevidentlyassociatedthecolorwiththeterm。OncewhilewewereatSagamoresomethinghappenedtothecherished“’spress“wagontothedistressofthechildren,andespeciallyofthechildwhoownedit。TheirmotherandIwerejuststartingforadriveinthebuggy,andwepromisedthebereavedownerthatwewouldvisitastoreweknewinEastNorwich,avillageafewmilesaway,andbringbackanother“’spress“wagon。Whenwereachedthestore,wefoundtoourdismaythatthewagonwhichwehadseenhadbeensold。Wecouldnotbeartoreturnwithoutthepromisedgift,forweknewthatthebrainsofsmallpersonsaremuchpuzzledwhentheireldersseemtobreakpromises。Fortunately,wesawinthestoreadelightfullittlebright-redchairandbright-redtable,andthesewebroughthomeandhandedsolemnlyovertotheexpectantrecipient,explainingthatasthereunfortunatelywasnota“’spress“wagonwehadbroughthimbacka“’spress“chairand“’spress“table。Itworkedbeautifully!The“’spress“chairandtablewerereceivedwithsuchrapturethatwehadtogetduplicatesfortheothersmallmemberofthefamilywhowastheparticularcronyoftheproprietorofthenewtreasures。
WhentheirmotherandIreturnedfromarow,wewouldoftenseethechildrenwaitingforus,runninglikesand-spidersalongthebeach。
Theyalwayslikedtoswimincompanywithagrown-upofbuoyanttemperamentandinventivemind,andthefloatofferedlimitlessopportunitiesforenjoymentwhilebathing。Alldutifulparentsknowthegameof“stage-coach“;eachchildisgivenaname,suchasthewhip,thenighleader,theoffwheeler,theoldladypassenger,and,underpenaltyofpayingaforfeit,mustgetupandturnroundwhenthegrown-up,whoisimprovisingathrillingstory,mentionsthatparticularobject;andwhentheword“stage-coach“ismentioned,everybodyhastogetupandturnround。Well,weusedtoplaystage-
coachonthefloatwhileinswimming,andinsteadoftamelygettingupandturninground,thechildwhoseturnitwashadtoplungeoverboard。WhenImentioned“stage-coach。”thewaterfairlyfoamedwithvigorouslykickinglittlelegs;andthentherewasalwaysamomentofinterestwhileIcounted,soastobesurethatthenumberofheadsthatcameupcorrespondedwiththenumberofchildrenwhohadgonedown。
Nomanorwomanwilleverforgetthetimewhensomechildliessickofadiseasethatthreatensitslife。Moreover,muchlessserioussicknessisunpleasantenoughatthetime。Lookingback,however,thereareelementsofcomedyincertainofthelessseriouscases。I
wellrememberonesuchinstancewhichoccurredwhenwewerelivinginWashington,inasmallhouse,withbarelyenoughroomforeverybodywhenallthechinkswerefilled。Measlesdescendedonthehousehold。
Intheefforttokeepthechildrenthatwerewellandthosethatweresickapart,theirmotherandIhadtocampoutinimprovisedfashion。
Whentheeldestsmallboywasgettingwell,andhadrecoveredhisspirits,Isleptonasofabesidehisbed——thesofabeingsoshortthatmyfeetprojectedoveranyhow。Oneafternoonthesmallboywasgivenatoyorganbyasympatheticfriend。NextmorningearlyIwaswakedtofindthesmallboyveryvivaciousandrequestingastory。
Havingdrowsilytoldthestory,Isaid,“Now,father’stoldyouastory,soyouamuseyourselfandletfathergotosleep“;towhichthesmallboyrespondedmostvirtuously,“Yes,fatherwillgotosleepandI’llplaytheorgan。”whichhedid,atadistanceoftwofeetfrommyhead。Laterhissister,whohadjustcomedownwiththemeasles,wasputintothesameroom。Thesmallboywasconvalescing,andwasengagedinplayingonthefloorwithsometinships,togetherwithtwoorthreepasteboardmonitorsandramsofmyownmanufacture。HewasgivingavividrenderingofFarragutatMobileBay,frommemoriesofhowIhadtoldthestory。Mypasteboardramsandmonitorswerefascinating——ifanavalarchitectmaybeallowedtopraisehisownwork——andaspropertytheywereequallydividedbetweenthelittlegirlandthesmallboy。Thelittlegirllookedonwithalertsuspicionfromthebed,forshewasnotyetconvalescentenoughtobealloweddownonthefloor。Thesmallboywasbusilyrecitingthephasesofthefight,whichnowapproacheditsclimax,andthelittlegirlevidentlysuspectedthathermonitorwasdestinedtoplaythepartofvictim。
Littleboy。“Andthentheysteamedbangintothemonitor。”
Littlegirl。“Brother,don’tyousinkmymonitor!”
Littleboywithoutheeding,andhurryingtowardtheclimax。“Andthetorpedowentatthemonitor!”
Littlegirl。“Mymonitorisnottosink!”