EnglandhasmisrepresentedtoallEuropethisgroundofthewar。Shehascalleditanewpretension,setupsincetherepealofherordersofcouncil。Sheknowstherehasneverbeenamomentofsuspensionofourreclamationsagainstit,fromGeneralWashington’stimeinclusive,tothepresentday:andthatitisdistinctlystatedinourdeclarationofwar,asoneofitsprincipalcauses。Shehaspretendedwehaveenteredintothewartoestablishtheprincipleof`freebottoms,freegoods,’ortoprotectherseamenagainstherownrightoverthem。Wecontendforneitherofthese。ShepretendswearepartialtoFrance;thatwehaveobservedafraudulentandunfaithfulneutralitybetweenherandherenemy。Sheknowsthistobefalse,andthatiftherehasbeenanyinequalityinourproceedingstowardsthebelligerents,ithasbeeninherfavor。Herministersareinpossessionoffullproofsofthis。Ouracceptingatonce,andsincerely,themediationofthevirtuousAlexander,theirgreatestfriend,andthemostaggravatedenemyofBuonaparte,sufficientlyproveswhetherwehavepartialitiesonthesideofherenemy。Isincerelypraythatthismediationmayproduceajustpeace。Itwillprovethattheimmortalcharacter,whichhasfirststoppedbywarthecareerofthedestroyerofmankind,isthefriendofpeace,ofjustice,ofhumanhappiness,andthepatronofunoffendingandinjurednations。Heistoohonestandimpartialtocountenancepropositionsofpeacederogatorytothefreedomoftheseas。
ShallIapologisetoyou,mydearMadam,forthislongpoliticalletter?Butyoursjustifiesthesubject,andmyfeelingsmustpleadfortheunreservedexpressionofthem;andtheyhavebeenthelessreserved,asbeingfromaprivatecitizen,retiredfromallconnectionwiththegovernmentofhiscountry,andwhoseideas,expressedwithoutcommunicationwithanyone,areneitherknown,norimputabletothem。
Thedangersoftheseaarenowsogreat,andthepossibilitiesofinterceptionbyseaandlandsuch,thatIshallsubscribenonametothisletter。Youwillknowfromwhomitcomes,byitsreferencetothedateoftimeandplaceofyours,aswellasbyitssubjectinanswertothat。Thisomissionmustnotlesseninyourviewtheassurancesofmygreatesteem,ofmysinceresympathiesforthesharewhichyoubearintheafflictionsofyourcountry,andthedeprivationstowhichalawlesswillhassubjectedyou。Inreturn,youenjoythedignifiedsatisfactionofhavingmetthem,ratherthanbeyokedwiththeabject,tohiscar;andthat,inwithdrawingfromoppression,youhavefollowedthevirtuousexampleofafather,whosenamewilleverbedeartoyourcountryandtomankind。Withmyprayersthatyoumayberestoredtoit,thatyoumayseeitre-establishedinthattemperateportionoflibertywhichdoesnotinfereitheranarchyorlicentiousness,inthathighdegreeofprosperitywhichwouldbetheconsequenceofsuchagovernment,inthat,inshort,whichtheconstitutionof1789wouldhaveinsuredit,ifwisdomcouldhavestayedatthatpointthefervidbutimprudentzealofmen,whodidnotknowthecharacteroftheirowncountrymen,andthatyoumaylongliveinhealthandhappinessunderit,andleavetotheworldawelleducatedandvirtuousrepresentativeanddescendantofyourhonoredfather,istheardentprayerofthesincereandrespectfulfriendwhowritesthisletter。
LIGHTANDLIBERTYANDTHEPARTIES
_ToJohnAdams_
_Monticello,June15,1813_
DEARSIR——Iwroteyoualetteronthe27th。ofMay,whichprobablywouldreachyouaboutthe3d。inst。andonthe9th。I
recievedyoursofthe29th。ofMay。OfLindsay’sMemoirsIhadneverbeforeheard,andscarcelyindeedofhimself。Itcouldnotthereforebutbeunexpectedthattwolettersofmineshouldhaveanythingtodowithhislife。Thenameofhiseditorwasnewtome,andcertainlypresentsitself,forthefirsttime,underunfavorablecircumstances。Religion,Isuppose,isthescopeofhisbook:andthatawriteronthatsubjectshouldusherhimselftotheworldintheveryactofthegrossestabuseofconfidence,bypublishingprivateletterswhichpassedbetweentwofriends,withnoviewstotheireverbeingmadepublic,isaninstanceofinconsistency,aswellasofinfidelityofwhichIwouldratherbethevictimthantheauthor。ByyourkindquotationofthedatesofmytwolettersIhavebeenenabledtoturntothem。Theyhadcompleatlyevanishedfrommymemory。Thelastisonthesubjectofreligion,andbyit’spublicationwillgratifythepriesthoodwithnewoccasionofrepeatingtheirComminationsagainstme。Theywishittobebelievedthathecanhavenoreligionwhoadvocatesit’sfreedom。ThiswasnotthedoctrineofPriestley,andIhonoredhimfortheexampleofliberalityhesettohisorder。Thefirstletterispolitical。Itrecallstoourrecollectionthegloomytransactionsofthetimes,thedoctrinestheywitnessed,andthesensibilitiestheyexcited。Itwasaconfidentialcommunicationofreflectionsonthesefromonefriendtoanother,depositedinhisbosom,andnevermeanttotroublethepublicmind。Whetherthecharacterofthetimesisjustlyportrayedornot,posteritywilldecide。Butononefeatureofthemtheycanneverdecide,thesensationsexcitedinfreeyetfirmminds,bytheterrorismoftheday。Nonecanconcievewhodidnotwitnessthem,andtheywerefeltbyonepartyonly。Thisletterexhibitstheirsideofthemedal。TheFederalistsnodoubthavepresentedtheother,intheirprivatecorrespondences,aswellasopenaction。Ifthesecorrespondenciesshouldeverbelaidopentothepubliceye,theywillprobablybefoundnotmodelsofcomitytowardstheiradversaries。Thereadersofmylettershouldbecautionednottoconfineit’sviewtothiscountryalone。Englandandit’salarmistswereequallyunderconsideration。Stilllessmusttheyconsideritaslookingpersonallytowardsyou。Youhappenindeedtobequotedbecauseyouhappenedtoexpress,morepithilythanhadbeendonebythemselves,oneofthemottosoftheparty。ThiswasinyouranswertotheaddressoftheyoungmenofPhiladelphia。[SeeSelectionofpatrioticaddresses。pa。198。]Oneofthequestionsyouknowonwhichourpartiestookdifferentsides,wasontheimprovabilityofthehumanmind,inscience,inethics,ingovernmentetc。Thosewhoadvocatedreformationofinstitutions,paripassu,withtheprogressofscience,maintainedthatnodefinitelimitscouldbeassignedtothatprogress。Theenemiesofreform,ontheotherhand,deniedimprovement,andadvocatedsteadyadherencetotheprinciples,practicesandinstitutionsofourfathers,whichtheyrepresentedastheconsummationofwisdom,andakmeofexcellence,beyondwhichthehumanmindcouldneveradvance。Altho’inthepassageofyouransweralludedto,youexpresslydisclaimthewishtoinfluencethefreedomofenquiry,youpredictthatthatwillproducenothingmoreworthyoftransmissiontoposterity,thantheprinciples,institutions,andsystemsofeducationrecievedfromtheirancestors。Idonotconsiderthisasyourdeliberateopinion。Youpossess,yourself,toomuchscience,nottoseehowmuchisstillaheadofyou,unexplainedandunexplored。Yourownconsciousnessmustplaceyouasfarbeforeourancestors,asintherearofourposterity。Iconsideritasanexpressionlenttotheprejudicesofyourfriends;andaltho’I
happenedtociteitfromyou,thewholelettershewsIhadthemonlyinview。Intruth,mydearSir,wewerefarfromconsideringyouastheauthorofallthemeasuresweblamed。Theywereplacedundertheprotectionofyourname,butweweresatisfiedtheywantedmuchofyourapprobation。Weascribedthemtotheirrealauthors,thePickerings,theWolcotts,theTracys,theSedgwicks,etidgenusomne[”andalloftheirkind”],withwhomwesupposedyouinastateofDuresse。Iwellrememberaconversationwithyou,inthemorningofthedayonwhichyounominatedtotheSenateasubstituteforPickering,inwhichyouexpressedajustimpatienceunder`thelegacyofSecretarieswhichGen。Washingtonhadleftyou’andwhomyouseemedthereforetoconsiderasunderpublicprotection。Manyotherincidentsshewedhowdifferentlyyouwouldhaveactedwithlessimpassionedadvisers;andsubsequenteventshaveprovedthatyourmindswerenottogether。Youwoulddomegreatinjusticethereforebytakingtoyourselfwhatwasintendedformenwhowerethenyoursecret,astheyarenowyouropenenemies。Shouldyouwriteonthesubject,asyoupropose,Iamsureweshallseeyouplaceyourselffartherfromthemthanfromus。
Astomyself,Ishalltakenopartinanydiscussions。IleaveotherstojudgeofwhatIhavedone,andtogivemeexactlythatplacewhichtheyshallthinkIhaveoccupied。Marshallhaswrittenlibelsononeside;others,Isuppose,willbewrittenontheotherside;andtheworldwillsiftboth,andseparatethetruthaswellastheycan。Ishouldseewithreluctancethepassionsofthatdayrekindledinthis,whilesomanyoftheactorsareliving,andallaretoonearthescenenottoparticipateinsympathieswiththem。
Aboutfacts,youandIcannotdiffer;becausetruthisourmutualguide。Andifanyopinionsyoumayexpressshouldbedifferentfrommine,IshallrecievethemwiththeliberalityandindulgencewhichI
askformyown,andstillcherishwithwarmththesentimentsofaffectionaterespectofwhichIcanwithsomuchtruthtenderyoutheassurance。
DEBT,TAXES,BANKS,ANDPAPER
_ToJohnWaylesEppes_
_Monticello,June24,1813_
DEARSIR,——Thisletterwillbeonpoliticsonly。ForalthoughIdonotoftenpermitmyselftothinkonthatsubject,itsometimesobtrudesitself,andsuggestsideaswhichIamtemptedtopursue。Someoftheserelatingtothebusinessoffinance,Iwillhazardtoyou,asbeingattheheadofthatcommittee,butintendedforyourselfindividually,orsuchasyoutrust,butcertainlynotforamixedcommittee。
Itisawiseruleandshouldbefundamentalinagovernmentdisposedtocherishitscredit,andatthesametimetorestraintheuseofitwithinthelimitsofitsfaculties,”nevertoborrowadollarwithoutlayingataxinthesameinstantforpayingtheinterestannually,andtheprincipalwithinagiventerm;andtoconsiderthattaxaspledgedtothecreditorsonthepublicfaith。”
Onsuchapledgeasthis,sacredlyobserved,agovernmentmayalwayscommand,ona_reasonableinterest_,allthelendablemoneyoftheircitizens,whilethenecessityofanequivalenttaxisasalutarywarningtothemandtheirconstituentsagainstoppressions,bankruptcy,anditsinevitableconsequence,revolution。Butthetermofredemptionmustbemoderate,andatanyratewithinthelimitsoftheirrightfulpowers。Butwhatlimits,itwillbeasked,doesthisprescribetotheirpowers?Whatistohinderthemfromcreatingaperpetualdebt?Thelawsofnature,Ianswer。Theearthbelongstotheliving,nottothedead。Thewillandthepowerofmanexpirewithhislife,bynature’slaw。Somesocietiesgiveitanartificialcontinuance,fortheencouragementofindustry;somerefuseit,asouraboriginalneighbors,whomwecallbarbarians。Thegenerationsofmenmaybeconsideredasbodiesorcorporations。Eachgenerationhastheusufructoftheearthduringtheperiodofitscontinuance。
Whenitceasestoexist,theusufructpassesontothesucceedinggeneration,freeandunincumbered,andsoon,successively,fromonegenerationtoanotherforever。Wemayconsidereachgenerationasadistinctnation,witharight,bythewillofitsmajority,tobindthemselves,butnonetobindthesucceedinggeneration,morethantheinhabitantsofanothercountry。Orthecasemaybelikenedtotheordinaryoneofatenantforlife,whomayhypothecatethelandforhisdebts,duringthecontinuanceofhisusufruct;butathisdeath,thereversionerwhoisalsoforlifeonlyreceivesitexoneratedfromallburthen。Theperiodofageneration,orthetermofitslife,isdeterminedbythelawsofmortality,which,varyingalittleonlyindifferentclimates,offerageneralaverage,tobefoundbyobservation。Iturn,forinstance,toBuffon’stables,oftwenty-threethousandninehundredandninety-fourdeaths,andtheagesatwhichtheyhappened,andIfindthatofthenumbersofallageslivingatonemoment,halfwillbedeadintwenty-fouryearsandeightmonths。Butleavingoutminors,whohavenotthepowerofself-governmentoftheadultsoftwenty-oneyearsofagelivingatonemoment,amajorityofwhomactforthesociety,onehalfwillbedeadineighteenyearsandeightmonths。Atnineteenyearsthenfromthedateofacontract,themajorityofthecontractorsaredead,andtheircontractwiththem。Letthisgeneraltheorybeappliedtoaparticularcase。SupposetheannualbirthsoftheStateofNewYorktobetwenty-threethousandninehundredandninety-four,thewholenumberofitsinhabitants,accordingtoBuffon,willbesixhundredandseventeenthousandsevenhundredandthree,ofallages。Ofthesetherewouldconstantlybetwohundredandsixty-ninethousandtwohundredandeighty-sixminors,andthreehundredandforty-eightthousandfourhundredandseventeenadults,ofwhichlast,onehundredandseventy-fourthousandtwohundredandninewillbeamajority。Supposethatmajority,onthefirstdayoftheyear1794,hadborrowedasumofmoneyequaltothefee-simplevalueoftheState,andtohaveconsumeditineating,drinkingandmakingmerryintheirday;or,ifyourplease,inquarrellingandfightingwiththeirunoffendingneighbors。Withineighteenyearsandeightmonths,onehalfoftheadultcitizensweredead。Tillthen,beingthemajority,theymightrightfullylevytheinterestoftheirdebtannuallyonthemselvesandtheirfellow-revellers,orfellow-champions。Butatthatperiod,sayatthismoment,anewmajorityhavecomeintoplace,intheirownright,andnotundertherights,theconditions,orlawsoftheir